Vimarsana.com

Transcripts For HLN 20091203

• Source: archive.org
welcome back to "prime news" on hln. continuing our conversation concerning tiger woods, the scandal that's ensued in his life. we're taking your calls, 1-877-tell-hln is the phone number. issue number one here, we see pictures of tiger with his wife, elin. two kids involved here. two young children. we wonder what's going on with the family. how do you repair this. we had hoped counseling is going on. and there's been a lot of reports about prenuptial agreement, whether there was one, what could be happening now with that. joining us again to talk about that, neil hersh, celebrity divorce attorney, high-powered clients. as you look at this, and we're speculating somewhat here, neil. do you think anything's going down on that front? or do you think it's all about counseling and reestablishing, rebuilding a marriage? >> you know, i think that the first thing that the couple is thinking about is rebuilding their marriage. the impact on their children. what the media is doing. how they get over all of that. i certainly don't think that money is the topic of conversation right now. it may be in the future. but you could rest assured from my perspective that first you have to mend the relationship to see if you even get to the point where you start talking about staying together and what that entails. and that may mean changing the prenuptial agreement. it may mean not changing it. but you don't even have to address that if this marriage can survive this juggernaut of publicity and all of the storm that has rained down on this young family. so that's the first priority, i'm sure, for the family, that they're addressing. >> neal, in your experience, as you have dealt, again, with big-named, high-powered clients, has that been an issue for you, you have a marriage, a crisis hits like this, where does prenuptial agreement even fit into that? is it, like you're saying, down the line in your experience? >> well, look, anytime you have a prenuptial agreement, there's somebody who's getting less and somebody who has more. it's not always a crisis that precip tats re-looking at a prenuptial agreement, and renegotiating. that is not uncommon. so you can expect that when something of this nature occurs, if the marriage survives, tiger will either offer to do something for her by way of changing the prenuptial, or just giving her an outright gift of something. she may demand it to stay in the marriage. there may be, that is, some financial discussions. it is not uncommon. and it isn't something that everybody has to worry about and say, oh, my god. it happens all the time. and it happens in situations where there isn't a crisis, where you're married a period of years and someone says, i want to be a little bit more generous than i was when we first signed the prenuptial agreement. so this kind of renegotiation is not something to be shocked about, or unexpected. >> got you. let's bring back carlos diaz with "extra." carlos, first question with neal concerned tiger and elin, any chances of rebuilding this marriage. are sources telling you anything about what's going on with them? are they on lockdown right now, counseling going on? >> anybody that's talking about tiger woods and why he hasn't come on camera with a statement, keep this in mind. if tiger woods goes on camera right now and there's anything still wrong with his face as far as cuts or bruises, that is the image they will play over and over and over again. i'm one of the people who think it is smart for tiger woods to stay behind the scenes. if that image of tiger with any cuts or bruises on his face right now, that will last a lifetime. we're not used to seeing tiger with anything but that pristine smile at any kind of tournament. i think that's a smart move there. and a report about an hour ago is that not only was tiger woods and his wife elin there or thanksgiving night going into friday morning when this all took place with the crash, also elin's mom and tiger woods' mom were also at the house when all this went down. >> let's -- we're getting brand-new sound from a neighbor who ended up calling 911. here he is talking to police about what he saw when he came onto the scene. >> is he in the street or was he still -- >> he was in the street. >> so he was on the sidewalk. who else was there with him? >> his wife. >> and her name is elin? >> elin. >> was he conscious, unconscious? >> at that point he was snoring. >> he was snoring? >> he was actually snoring. >> did she say anything to you? >> no. i mean, at this point she was actually very quiet, just kind of in shock. just kind of sitting there. she wasn't very verbal. >> okay. again, that was jarius adams. a couple of things that stand out there, carlos, number one, that tiger was snoring in the aftermath of this. that's according to a man who came onto the scene. elin seemed quiet and shocked. let's talk about the snoring first off. florida highway patrol and people that they've talked to, alcohol was not smelled. i believe jarius adams said that. snoring? any thoughts on that, carlos? >> that's very unusual. one of the texts that tiger allegedly sent to jaimee grubbs, he kind of mentions taking an ambien in one of the texts that he had sent her. as she said to "us weekly." but the big thing that you have to look at here is, they said he was slipping in and out of consciousness. but this is the first we're hearing of tiger snoring. and to say that, that he's laying on the street and he's bloodied and bruised and snoring, that throws a whole other question mark in this whole equation. >> let's take a call, guys. michael's with us in ohio. michael, go ahead. hey, michael, you with us? >> caller: yeah, i'm here. >> go ahead. you're up. >> caller: my question was, why does it even matter if he -- tiger himself has to apologize to the public? i mean, that's a family affair. when this whole thing happened. his wife and his family is all i think he should apologize to. i mean, he doesn't owe the public anything. >> you know, that's an interesting point. in his statement, carlos, you can back me up on this, he apologized to his family first. but at the end he apologized to his supporters. when you look at tiger woods, and i think that's what saddens everybody, carlos, we had hoped he was as good a man and husband and father as he was a golfer. this screams otherwise, right? >> he has made a majority of his money with endorsements, and with off-the-course activities. it would be different if woods was a billionaire from what he made off the golf course. you can't say pay me for this public image i'm putting forth, and when it begins to crumble, you have to leave me alone. you cannot choose when you are a celebrity. >> apologize and that's it, have your people fight that fight for you. we don't want excuses at this point. >> great point. >> carlos, always good having you on. i'm sure we're not finished with this one. appreciate it. neal, you as well. thank you for your expertise. coming up, a dangerous child molester shackled, bound in a wheelchair, yet he overpowers two armed guards, takes their guns. now he is on the loose. eeeee this reward is in conjunction for the information leading to the arrest of arcade comeaux jr. he's an escaped prisoner. very violent. and he took two guards by gunpoint. >> that reward at $25,000. hopefully that amount of money will loosen some lips and we'll find out where this dangerous criminal might be. we'll take your calls, 1-877-tell-hln. we have our experts standing by. i want to go back to john moriarty, texas inspector general. john, i think a lot of people have questions on how he could end up in a wheelchair in the first place. what was the diagnosis where -- that he would need one? >> well, you know, that's all a part of the investigation that's going on. obviously he had some medical issues. and as you know, they fluctuate, and doctors make decisions, and decisions change. but, you know, it's a -- usually i'm on the other side of the coin investigating medical neglect issues. so there's fine lines there that you've got to deal with with people in custody. >> he is still on the loose. let's bring back michelle sigona, investigative reporter. michelle, let's talk about this guy's violent criminal history. a repeat child sex offender. he's a predator. the worst of the worst here. his life of crime started, what, 1979? >> back in 1979. i do have to say michelle lyons with the detective department of criminal justice did a good job of outlining that. it starts at 1979 and brings us all the way from child rape. we have aggravated rape of a child. indecency of a child. aggravated sex assault. you have that incident in 1979 that you just mentioned a few moments ago, about where he pinned his wife in the middle of the visiting area and stabbed her repeatedly in the chest with a metal object. and then also stabbed another man that stepped out to help. this guy is dangerous. he has two semiautomatic weapons with him, along with a 12-gauge shotgun that he took from the two officers. investigators on the ground are doing an awesome job. they are working around the clock to try to locate him. we are so grateful for that. we thank you, mike, for having to put the word out there. >> we have to, with a guy like this, and the folks in houston on edge with a guy like this on the loose. john moriarty, 1999 is when he stabbed his wife. what happened with him in jail after that, john? what kind of security was around him? >> well, he was placed in the highest level of security in the prison. and my office prosecuted him for that assault. and he got two life sentences. >> okay. again, it's unthinkable that this guy's out there. john, what's the next move right now? as far as, you know, because we said it, let's go back to where we began, catching him's number one. >> that's correct. and we need the public's help, obviously, to keep calling in and giving us good tips on where we might get him. and again, this is a 24/7 operation with over 100 marshals, state police officers, houston police, baytown, everyone in the whole houston metropolitan area in law enforcement is just exerting every effort possible. >> guys, thanks again. michelle, john. we appreciate it. and we hope you find him, and find him very soon. thanks again. coming up, following up on this story. a dying man at an emergency room, philadelphia hospital waiting room, he is robbed. there's a couple of frongts to hit. that is one. and also, did he get the care that he needed that could have saved his life. we're going to talk to this victim's son. that's coming up. we'll take your calls as well, 1-877-tell-hln. welcome back. we're revisiting this story. and it's a sad one. a dying man is robbed during the final moments of his life. there he is, joaquin rivera. described as a great man. this happened at a philadelphia hospital. cops say shortly after joaquin rivera lost consciousness, two men and women in the emergency room took his watch then took off. the 63-year-old, a popular high school counselor, local musician, and the loss is hitting the latino community hard. let's give that a listen. >> i want him to be remembered for what he did to the -- to preserve the puerto rican culture in philadelphia. that was his idea, that every kid born knew his roots. >> friends, family, the community demanding answers now on this one. today we are joined by the victim's son, joaquin rivera jr. joaquin, thanks for being with us. our condolences to you. i'm sure you're still in shock that your father's gone. how are you holding up at this point? >> just trying to do the best i can. me and my family, we're trying to get through this the best we can. i mean, it's hard. >> yeah. i'm sure. especially around the holidays, thanksgiving. it's got to be so frustrating. your dad was just 63. >> yes. do you believe he's alive today if he gets the proper care he needed? >> i hon stly do. i believe if he was just treated, if he was just checked out when he was there, i believe he would have been alive. they had an opportunity to save him. >> it would seem. let me go over some of the details for our viewers, joaquin. and crest me if i go astray. the way we understand it, your father lives close to the hospital, so walked there himself. and had pretty much classic symptoms of possibly a heart attack. pain in his left arm. pain radiating to his abdomen. then he's told to sit down. and 11 minutes later is when he had a heart attack and died, and he was robbed after that. and he wasn't seen or attended to for another hour after that. is that the way you understand the story? and if so, what is the hospital telling you now about all of that? >> as far as what you said him dying 11 minutes while waiting there, i don't know exactly when he died. >> okay. >> i don't know about that. all i know is that when he was there, he made him sit there for an hour. an hour and 19 minutes. before -- well, after he was dead, he was robbed by the two men. and as far as the hospital goes, they haven't contacted us in any way, shape or form. >> nothing from the -- let me read their statement. this is a statement from aria health. due to the pending criminal investigation, and citing patient kfld shalt, aria health is unable to regard to any circumstances surrounding this death. it offers its condolences to the patient's family. aria officials are conducting an intensive internal investigation into this event and coordinating their efforts with law enforcement. have they reached out to you and offered condolences to you? >> no. just that public statement. that's all we've received. no phone calls, no letters, nothing. >> nothing at this point. does your father have any health issues? did he have a health problem that was existing that you knew of? >> not that i know of. because my father always kept me in the dark about that type of thing. as far as his health, he never talked to me about that. >> how did you find out, joaquin? the shocking news? >> i had received a phone call from my mother telling me to rush to the hospital. and i was asking her why. she said, please, just hurry up. and i hurried up to the hospital. when i got to the emergency room, that's when my mother told me. >> again, you guys must just be devastated. and as you mentioned, must be salt in a deep wound to know that your father had his watch taken from him. that's unbelievable, isn't it? >> they're not human. i don't see how you can do that to a man. >> what's your next move here? you have every right to demand answers here. >> i mean, right now, me and my family, we want to take this week and dedicate it to him. we want to worry about giving him a proper burial that he deserves. we're not worried about anything right now except for giving him the respect and -- just making sure we dedicate his life and honor his death. that's all we can do right now. we're not thinking about anything else but making sure he has a proper burial. making sure he goes the way he would want to go. >> and celebrate his life. before we let you go, can you tell us about your dad? it seems from the little snippets we've seen, there he is singing. tell us about the man. >> he was an amazing man. i can honestly say i'm not a quarter of the man he is. he was a great man. he was willing to help anybody. it didn't matter who you were. if the call was good, he was there for you. he had a love for people. he had a love for life. and that was taken away from him. >> and your father was taken from you. joaquin rivera jr., again, our thoughts and prayers are with you. thank you again. >> thank you. >> celebrate your father's life. thank you so much for taking time. >> you're welcome. >> i want to bring in my colleague, vinnie politan, host "in session." also an attorney. as we look at this, and there's an investigation ongoing. what should this family do? number one is to celebrate their father's life, give a proper burial. but what's the next step? could they possibly have a case against this hospital? >> oh, absolutely. absolutely. you know, you take a step back, it takes a family a while. but when it's time, and you want to get answers. and, you know, when you get a lawyer and you get a civil lawsuit, in a case like this, a lot of times it has nothing to do with the money. it has to do with responsibility. it has to do with getting the answers that you want. getting the answers that you deserve. unfortunately, mike, in the society we live in, in corporate america the way it is, they're not going to get someone from the hospital to call them. because anything they say can be some sort of admission that we did something wrong here. so i wouldn't expect to get that phone call. but the bottom line is, they're entitled to those answers. and that's why we have civil courts for. and that's why we have lawyers that do that type of work. >> vinnie, we see this, you and i see this, and this doesn't happen again, right? >> that's the other part of it. people talk about our civil system of justice. people getting money. the reason that lawsuits exist and the reason why people have to pay damages is, all of a sudden now the people that are responsible for this, they wake up and say, hey, what did we do wrong here. we can't let this happen again. let's change the way we do what we do. and that's the great value that this country has, for plaintiffs' lawyers. i know politicians like to rail on them, but they do a lot of good, because it's a checks and balances on the way people are treated in our society. >> this man was not treated well in his final moments of life. now why and how it all took place, that's what we want to find out. good talking to you, vinnie. one of tiger woods' alleged mistresses schedules a news conference. we think she's going to tell her story. then it's abruptly canceled. why? what was she going to say? i'm going to bring in my colleague jane velez-mitchell to talk about it. welcome back to "prime news" on hln. again today we thought we would finally hear from one of tiger woods' alleged mistresses. she's the first one linked to the golf star. we're talking about rachel uchitel. she denied the affair in a lengthy interview with the "new york post." her attorney, gloria allred called a press conference today. then it was canceled. i want to bring in jane velez-mitchell, host of "issues" with jane velez-mitchell, coming your way at the top of the hour. also with us, carlos diaz, correspondent for "extra." also a former sports journalist who has covered tiger for a long time. jane, unforeseen circumstances? what do you make of that? >> i don't know what to make of this. but tmz is reporting that rachel and tiger spoke last night. now, this is straight from tmz. gloria allred has never canceled a news conference in her career. sources tell us rachel and tiger have been communicating as recently as last night. now, it goes on and on. certainly we don't know, we weren't on the phone conversation, but you have to take into account that when you have an attorney like gloria allred, that gives you leverage. that is as vinnie politan so aptly put it, a bargaining chip. the question is, were they on the phone bargaining? and if so, did they reach some kind of understanding and agreement? and if so, what did she get out of it? i do not have the answers. but i think we can all sort of do the math. >> yeah. exactly. let's bring in carlos diaz on this. carlos, in your reporting on this, and as you've looked at this case, and rachel uchitel and tiger woods, what more do you know about their involvement? if they had a relationship or not? >> well, i mean, that's the thing. tmz also reporting that rachel uchitel was paid, basically her air fair was paid to australia by tiger woods' organization. and, you know, it's not up for dispute that tiger woods and rachel uchitel stayed in the same hotel while she was in australia. you know, what's happened a world away, when people are flying in to half a world away, that is some pretty damning evidence right there. >> yeah. >> you know, just one of those things where, you know, the fallout on tiger woods in the last week has been unbelievable and undeniable. and i don't think we've ever seen an athlete that has been on top so high fall so low so quickly. >> i think that's where -- carlos, you and i talked about this. that's where the disappointment lies. fans, supporters thought he was different. that he was not only the greatest golfer in the world, but he was a pretty good guy as well. a good man, a good husband, a good father. we like that complete role model. and yet this, and how it's unfolded, says otherwise. >> i actually don't like that complete role model. because i don't think it's realistic. nobody's perfect. i have found time after time, in fact i wrote "secrets can be murder" when you put an image of perfection before the world, then it makes the toxic secrets that lie behind that perfection seem all the more shocking. so i think it's a cautionary tale about the dangers of trying to appear too darn perfect. show some of your character defects to the world, and it will make the fall a little less sharp when the big kahoona comes down the pike. >> but these are major defects. i don't think it's wrong for us to want that in the sense that tiger woods, i mean, he's such a ground-breaker, not only in golf, but all the barriers he has broken, and to whom much is given, much is expected. i don't think it's a bad thing that we hoped better expected. i don't think it is a bad thing we hoped better for him. >> one thing you have to understand and this is undeniable. tiger woods is the only athlete that afternoon routes for. if you are a derek jeter fan, people in boston hate jeter. people in la don't like garnet. tiger woods is everyone's hero. this is the first time that tiger woods has had to put up with anyone making fun of him or saying bad things. >> i think you are proving my point. when you put privacy above all else you are setting yourself up for a fall. you need to give the impression that you are human and you could make a mistake so that when you do make the mistake, you don't take such a nose dive. >> it will be interesting to see what has to happen before golf fans turn from him in a sense. like you said, he is pretty much universally liked and adored as far as not only golf fans but people from all walks of life. i think it will depend on how many more women come forward and what details come out. guys, we got run. jane, we will be watching "issues" tonight 7 eastern. pleasure. see you.