Transcripts For WPVI Nightline 20160929

Ring. A romantic yankee fan getting down on one knee, then all fours. Going viral when he loses the diamond Engagement Ring in the stands. There he is, hes scratching his head. But first the nightline 5. Many sleep aids have Pain Medicine. But zyquil is different. Why would you take a Pain Medicine when all you want is good sleep . Zyquil thats not for pain, just for sleep. Think your heartburn pill works fast . Take the zantac it challenge. Zantac works in as little as 30 minutes. Nexium can take 24 hours. When heartburn strikes take zantac for faster relief than nexium or your money back. Number one in just 60 seconds. Good evening. Thanks for joining us. The dramatic verdict in the mysterious murder case of a 12yearold boy. The College Soccer coach accused of strangling his exgirlfriends son. The judges announcement rocked the childs family and divided a small new york town. Tonight the defendant speaks out telling a very different story than the prosecution. So whos telling the truth . Heres abcs Elizabeth Vargas. Reporter its judgment day in a case thats prompted National Headlines and divided a community. Nearly five years after the brutal murder of Young Garrett philips. And after three weeks of trial, the accused, 42yearold soccer star turned coach, nick hillary, is about to hear his fate. It is the judgment of this court that as to the charge of murder in the Second Degree reporter 2011, a rainy afternoon in potsdam, new york. 12yearold Garrett Phillips is heading home from school. Tell me about his personality. Just seemed like he was 100 miles an hour all the time. Soccer, lacrosse, hockey, football. Wow, allaround athlete. Yes. Reporter until recently, tandy and nick had been a couple, even living together, which raised eyebrows in the small town. Do you feel like you stuck out . Oh, yeah, most definitely. You know, sometimes youre the only one of color in the grocery stores. Reporter that day in 2011, across the hall from tandys apartment, College Students sean hall and marisa vogel hear something. I said, did you hear that . We were both convinced we had heard either no, or ow, and then definitely a help. I knew it was one of the children right away. It sounded urgent. Reporter marisa goes to investigate, knocks on the door. It was completely quiet until i heard a click of a lock. It was instant goosebumps. Potsdam police. I thought i heard screaming. Like no, and help a couple of times. Reporter when police finally get inside, Garrett Phillips is lying on the floor of his mothers bedroom. Initially my officers, they were focused on saving garretts life at that point in time. They didnt know who they had or what they had. They called for medical intervention immediately. Thats when the Emergency Response began. Reporter he is rushed to the hospital. And then the shocking autopsy. Rug burns on garretts legs. Suspicious marks on his face and neck. The cause of death, suffocation and strangulation. 12yearold Garrett Philips was murdered. Did police ask you who would want to harm your son . Yes. I was like, everybody liked garrett, no one ever had a problem with garrett. And then it was like, oh, there was one person. Just one . Just one. Who was it . Nick. Nick hillary . Yes. Reporter tandy says nick and garrett didnt get along. She told me that garrett had come there and said, i hate nick, i dont want to live here with him anymore. Reporter two days after the murder, the police ask hillary to visit the station. Hillary says police held him against his will all day. Why do you think theres this depth of fervor to get you . Because they think i have crossed the line of being a black man, honestly. You think its all about race . It is. I sincerely think its all about race. Reporter after three days of searching the crime scene, authorities can find no evidence linking nick hillary to garretts murder. We didnt get any evidence from the items that were tested by the Forensic Center in albany. No dna, no hairs, no fibers . Right. Really nothing . Reporter they do find four sets of fingerprints on this window. None of them belong to nick hillary. And it was the only way out for the killer. He appears to have jumped from that window, a daunting leap. Oh, wow, that is pretty far down. Around 20 feet from the windowsill down to the ground. Reporter police had suspected hillary from the start. They secretly filmed him pacing the sidelines of a soccer game as he coached. Capturing evidence of what they say appears to be a limp. You didnt jump out a window and injure your ankle trying to escape . No, i did not. I absolutely have nothing to do with the death of Garrett Philips. Reporter nick hillary is eventually indicted for murder. Prosecutors say a possible motive, perhaps the hope that with her son gone, tandy might come back to hillary. Or fury at the child who caused the breakup. With ten jurors already selected for trial, nick hillarys defense team suddenly asks for a bench trial, choosing to put his fate in the hands of one man, judge felix katina. His lawyers smartly felt, we dont want to take the chance of putting this in the hands of a jury. The many names that have been labelled on this defendant are, the innocent man, the wrongfully accused reporter five years after the murder, nick hillarys trial begins. I want you to label him for exactly what he is, the murderer of a helpless 12yearold boy. Nick hillary did not kill Garrett Phillips. Reporter the prosecutions case is based largely on a few moments of Security Camera video. That video shows Garrett Phillips skateboarding past nick hillarys parked car at the potsdam high school. Moments after garrett passes, nick pulls out. Did you see garrett skateboard by . No, i didnt. Obviously surveillance tape shows that he did, to go home. Exactly, exactly. Thats a pretty extraordinary convince den. Very much so. Given what happens. Yes. Reporter hillary claims he went straight home. But watch carefully. Instead of turning right to go straight home, hillary turns left. Prosecutors say hes following garrett on his way to commit murder. Why would you turn left . When i made a left, my intentions were to get to the office. And i quickly realize i need to make provisions for my daughter at home. Reporter but thats not what his defense attorney argues during the trial. He says hillary turned left to visit his assistant coach. The inference you can draw from nick making the left turn is that he was going to ann fieldings house. This case was primarily based on surveillance video, potential motive, and his own arguably inconsistent statements. Theres no hard evidence. Like dna, fingerprints. Reporter in closing arguments the defense team repeats the phrase reasonable doubt 25 times. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Reasonable doubt. Reasonable doubt. Reporter questions the motive. You kill the poor kid with the hope the motor will come running back into your arms . It makes absolutely no sense. Reporter hours ago, judge katina with the decision. It is the judgment of this court that as to the charge of murder in the Second Degree, as charged in the indictment, the defendant, oril nick ras hillary, is found not guilty. Reporter nick hillary acquitted and free to go. Nick hillary is an innocent man. This legal team is not oblivious to the fact that theres a family that even after five years still grieves. Reporter a final verdict, but a town still divided and still looking for justice. For a young boy whose life was cut short. For nightline, im Elizabeth Vargas in potsdam, new york. Our thanks to elizabeth. Catch the first interview with nick hillary postverdict and an inside look at the crime scene. Tune into 20 20 this friday. Up next, the revolution canceled. Bernie sanders explains why hes now a schill for hill. And the biggest error in the game happened in the stands. The botched wedding proposal with a happy ending. I struggle with bipolar depression, and its tough. It leaves me feeling sad and empty. It makes it hard to be there for the people i love. So i talked to my doctor and she prescribed latuda. There are many forms of depression. Latuda is fda approved to treat bipolar depression which is different from other types of depression. In clinical studies, onceaday latuda was proven effective for many people with bipolar depression. Latuda is not for everyone. Call your doctor about unusual mood changes, behaviors, or suicidal thoughts. Antidepressants can increase these in children, teens, and young adults. Elderly dementia patients on latuda have an increased risk of death or stroke. Call your doctor about fever, stiff muscles and confusion, as these may be signs of a lifethreatening reaction, or if you have uncontrollable muscle movements, as these may be permanent. High blood sugar has been seen with latuda and medicines like it, and in extreme cases can lead to coma or death. Other risks include decreased white blood cells, which can be fatal, dizziness on standing, seizures, increased cholesterol, weight or prolactin, trouble swallowing and impaired judgment. Avoid grapefruit and grapefruit juice. Use caution before driving or operating machinery. Being there for the people i love means i get to be a part of lifes little moments. And that means so much to me. Ask your doctor if oncedaily latuda is right for you. Pay as little as a 15 copay. Visit latuda. Com. With another new flavor you never saw coming. Grilled, glazed korean bbq shrimp. And try as much as you want of flavors like new parmesan peppercorn shrimp. Just come in before it ends. Try align probiotic. Looking for balance in your digestive system . For a nonstop, sweet treat goodness, hold on to your tiara kind of day. Live 24 7. With 24 7 digestive support. Try align, the 1 ge recommended probiotic. When pat toomey went to wasworking for wall street. Toomeys plan would risk Social Security on the stock market, lining bankers pockets with fees from our benefits that. Could total billions, even if the market crashes, and seniors lose everything. Katie mcginty is working for us. A mother of three, and ninth of ten kids, mcginty knows what matters. Shell fight for equal pay, affordable college, and. Shell always protect Social Security. Dscc is responsible for the content of this advertising. We need not remind you Bernie Sanders spent the president ial primaries building a revolution, battling Hillary Clinton, suggesting she was unqualified, bad for trade, and in the pocket of wall street. So why is he campaigning so passionately with her now . Heres abcs david wright. Reporter today in New Hampshire, a special guest out on the campaign trail. Senator Bernie Sanders reporter senator Bernie Sanders, who put up such a fierce fight for the democratic nomination. Today hit the stump alongside his old rival. It is imperative that we elect Hillary Clinton as our next president. Isnt this one of the strangest elections youve ever seen . Reporter after that long and bitter primary, they may seem 94 like frenemies than friends. But the truth is especially in states like New Hampshire, clinton needs sanders voters. Clinton has yet to convince many diehard Bernie Sanders fans, fully half of them dont think shes honest. If i think that bernie has a chance with my vote of becoming our next president , then he will get my vote. Otherwise my vote will go to dr. Jill stein. Reporter the republicans have their own set of problems, not least the effort to explain trumps performance at mondays debate. I think my strongest asset, maybe my far, is my temperament. Reporter one highlevel trump adviser pushed back on the notion the candidate didnt prepare adequately, noting his failures were more a lack of execution than preparation. The conaccepts seconsensus seem growing inside the Trump Campaign it was not his best night. The democrats arent counting their chickens just yet. One of their concerns, supporters of the vermont senator who gave clinton such a run for her money. Its clear the Bernie Sanders candidacy created a permanent problem for Hillary Clinton. She is not winning millennial voters in anything like the same numbers that barack obama did. Bernie sanders is now out on the trail. If he can convince those young people who went for him to go for her, that will make an enormous difference in november. Happy to be spending a few more nights at home . Reporter today we caught up with sanders in New Hampshire as he tries to convince his voters to come over to clinton. Senator, weve met any number of people for whom even at this stage its bernie or bust. Whats your message . My message is that people have got to get beyond personality. And theyve got to take a hard look at the issues that impact the lives of middleclass and workingclass people. Hillary clintons positions are far, far, far superior to donald trump. Do you see this choice in november as a choice of the lesser of two evils . No, i really dont. Secretary clinton and i disagree on a lot of issues. That was what we campaigned on for a year. So im not going to deny that for a second. But i think if you look at her proposals, issue by issue, a number of them are very progressive. But you talked about this as a political revolution. And you brought a whole lot of people into the process who otherwise wouldnt have cared. Now many of them are saying, you know what im going to sit this one out, or im going for a thirdparty candidate whos more aligned with my values. How can you blame them . Im not here to blame anybody. Everybody has the right to vote for whomever they want. All i can say is, donald trump must not be elected president and i intend to do everything i personally can to make sure that does not happen, and that means im going to campaign very hard for clinton, not only here in New Hampshire but all across this country. Reporter its a problem clinton faces in several of the key battlegrounds. Not just New Hampshire. The polls in those states showing her slightly ahead. But too close for comfort. Millennials overwhelmingly supported sanders in the primaries. Partly because of his progressive message. The nation based on social justice, economic justice, Racial Justice reporter partly because of his antiestablishment views. It is time for a political revolution. Reporter millennials are a huge group, if you can get them out to the polls. Roughly 30 of the electorate. In 2012, under25s accounted for a slightly bigger share than latinos. But now that their favorite candidate is out, its not clear clinton will be an acceptable second choice. If it came down to it tomorrow i dont even know who i would vote for. I will probably end up voting for clinton. I mean the lesser of two evils . Exactly, yeah. Are you going to vote . Yeah. Bernie sanders is urging his people to vote for hillary. Does that carry any weight with you . No, not really. Its very hard to transfer votes. Endorsements dont really work very much these days. But Bernie Sanders does have a very loyal cadre of young supporters. And perhaps they will listen to him, who knows. Reporter its not so much these young voters are struggling to choose between clinton and trump. For many the dilemma is more like clinton or none of the above. Maybe a thirdparty candidate. Or maybe just sit this one out. Thats why Michelle Obama was out today wooing young voters in pennsylvania. And if you vote for someone other than hillary, or if you dont vote at all, then you are helping to elect hillarys opponent. Reporter here in New Hampshire, the scenario that keeps democrats like state party chair Raymond Buckley up at night is what happened to al gore in 2000. Is that your nightmare scenario this year . The nightmare of 2000 haunts every one of us every day. For just a few thousand votes, al gore would have been elected president. You believe if he had spent more time in New Hampshire, he wouldnt have had to worry about florida . Absolutely. Reporter the theory goes that a few thousand votes for ralph nader cost gore New Hampshires four electoral votes. If hed won those four votes, the florida recount might never have been an issue. The question now, if those sanders voters sit this one out, could it happen again to Hillary Clinton . If she were to lose, does any part of you worry you would go down at the ralph nader of 2016 . No, i dont think so. The logical corollary is we should not have competitive elections, that we should apoint somebody to run, and anybody runs against them would be responsible. I think more people think my candidacy made her a stronger candidate against trump. Reporter even so, Bernie Sanders plans to be out on the trail in the battleground states. No longer his own man. Now hes with her. Im david wright for nightline in durham, New Hampshire. Our thanks to david. With 40 days to the election, stay on top of all the political news. Download the abc news app and get Live Streaming of breaking news from the campaign trail, dat bates, even election night. Think of it as your political magic button. Next, a hopeless romantic at Yankee Stadium dropped the ball during a public proposal. Before staging an unforgettable comeback. [ on the road again, by Willie Nelson ] on the road again [ rear alert sounds ] [ music stops ] just cant wait to get on the road again [ front assist sounds ] [ music stops ] [ girl laughs ] on the road again like a band of gypsies we go down the highway [ beetle horn honks ] no matter which passat you choose, you get more standard features, for less than you expected. Hurry in and lease the 2017 passat s for just 199 a month. Dont let the food you eat during the day haunt you at night. Nexium 24hr. Shuts down your stomachs active acid pumps. To stop the burn of frequent heartburn. All day and night. Have we seen them before . Banish the burn with nexium 24hr. This clean was like pow. Ything well . It felt like i had just gone to the dentist. It just kind of like, wiped everything clean. My teeth are glowing. They look great. They are so white. Crest hd 6x cleaning. 6x whitening. And at two weeks, superior sensitivity relief to the leading sensitivity toothpaste. I actually really like the two steps crest hd step 1 cleans, step 2 whitens. Its the whole package. No ones done this. Crest healthy, beautiful smiles for life. Trust number one doctor recommended dulcolax constipated . Use dulcolax tablets for gentle overnight relief suppositories for relief in minutes and stool softeners for comfortable relief of hard stools. Dulcolax, designed for dependable relief i think my strongest asset, maybe by far, is my temperament. Id like to punch him in the face, ill tell you. I would bomb the [bleep] out of em. I could stand in the middle of 5th avenue and shoot somebody and i wouldnt lose any voters, okay . And you can tell them to go [bleep] themselves. Get him out of here get him out of here get the hell out of here priorities usa action is responsible for the content of this advertising. It was the Marriage Proposal at Yankee Stadium that went foul for a moment when the groom to be lost the Engagement Ring. All of Yankee Stadium, it seems, was waiting for him to pop the question. But then they literally cant find the ring. A major league curveball. The crowd jumping in to help. After what seems like forever yeah a diamond in the cuff. Andrew fox told mlbs field goal live he googled yankees wedding proposal to surprise his girlfriend heather. I didnt know what to think. I felt really bad. The couple, who met online, going viral. The twitterverse dubbing it ringgate. Fans writing, never propose at stadiums. And, nightmare scenario with a happy ending. As for a wedding date . I havent thought about that yet. I just knew i wanted her to be my wife. Reporter a come from behind victory for a couple of good sports. For the record, the yankees won. Thanks for watching abc news. As always were online at abcnews. Com and our Nightline Facebook page. Good night, america. Go yankees. Hey, everybody. I hope your ready for some excitement because when youre playing for a million dollars, drama kind of comes with the territory. This is who wants to be a millionaire. [dramatic music] hey, everybody, welcome to the show. Are you guys ready to play millionaire today . All right, as a starving artist who is very passionate about her work, our first contestant says this money is absolutely lifechanging. From atlanta, georgia, please welcome sarah jones. Hey, sarah. Hi. How are you doing . Good, how are you . Good to see you. Come on over. I love that you are an artist, but the operative word is starving artist. Yes, yes. So you are grinding it out for this passion of yours. Yes, yes. So this money really could be lifechanging. It could be, could be. Can we make a deal right here . Okay. If you win a million dollars, will you do a lifesize portrait of me . Absolutely. Lets shake on it. I will do it. A deal, all right. I will do it. Well, let me tell you what youre up against. Okay. Its going to go right over the mantle, itll be beautiful. 14 questions, the money values growing from 500 all the way up to that 1 million. Every question you answer correctly moves you one step closer to that top prize. Remember, at any time,