sean hall:l: how does s a pern feel when n they come e home and theyey feel likeke their house has s been robbebed? that s howow i felt. tataylor swiftft: (singingn) playayers going g to play, p , playay, play, plplay. sesean hall: 1 1, 2, 3, 4.. when i i first gotot into the music c business, , i was 17. back thehen, gettingng deals s was a situtuation. everyone h has a deal l now. backck then, it t s like, if you h had a deal,l, itit s becausese you foughght f. [m[music playiying] i met t nate butleler throrough a frieiend. natete was just t leaving coco. hehe wanted toto write musus. so we e met, and w we hit it off immmmediately and d became besest friends. and ththen, of couourse, not t everythingng you write
steveve carell: : hoo, hoo, ,. lisasa respers france: we e we usused to seeieing taylor r sws like thihis sweet, s strumminge guititar, talkining about ththy nenext door ththat she lovov. and d then here e she is, and she e s standingng up. and she s s got her back up dadancers. and shshe s like, , you know w? i i m hip. i m m cool. i m m not here f for the hata. but shshe s not bebeen ablele to shake e off ththe controveversy from t that. [u[upbeat musisic] sean hall: i was in my car in atlanta on t the 10th anand 14th brir, gogoing over t the 75/85 s st when i heaeard shake e it of [taylolor swift, shake it o] ththe first ththing i thouout wawas the tracack was amazaz. and ththen the hooook came i. (singingng) because e the plplayers goining to play, playay, play, plplay, play.. anand the hateters going t o hatete, hate, hahate, hate, , . baby, , i m just g going to sh, shshake, shakeke, shake, s sh. i shshake it offff. i shshake it offff. hohoo, hoo, hohoo.
haters insnstead of crcritic. choooosing intervrviewer 2: i i undersrstand you r re arguin. but let t me just - my queststion was mumuch narro. marinana v. bogorarad: so sur, the phphrases thememselves migie commmmon, but ththat s nonot what thehe claim is.. the clclaim is thahat sean and nate p put togetheher anan originall combinatation of phrhrases. they tooook playersrs going o play, , haters goioing to hat, ththey put thehem togetherern ththat sequencnce in a choho. chloe memelas: sean n and nat, they re e saying notot only are e the lyricscs basicacally identitical, but alsoso, it s thehe combinan and d the order r in which these e lyrics appppear in playas gogon to playay anand in shakake it off .. tayloror swift s d defense coming outut and sayining, hohold on a sesecond, thatat tr writes a all her ownwn music. these e lyrics werere inspird by comommonplace p phrases thatat were useded at her scsc, and that t there is nono monopy overer that phrarase. marinana v. bogorara
choooosing intervrviewer 2: i i undersrstand you r re arguin. but let t me just - my queststion was mumuch narro. marinana v. bogorarad: so sur, the phphrases thememselves migie commmmon, but ththat s nonot what thehe claim is.. the clclaim is thahat sean and nate p put togetheher anan originall combinatation of phrhrases. they tooook playersrs going o play, , haters goioing to hat, ththey put thehem togetherern ththat sequencnce in a choho. chloe memelas: sean n and nat, they re e saying notot only are e the lyricscs basicacally identitical, but alsoso, it s thehe combinan and d the order r in which these e lyrics appppear in playas gogon to playay anand in shakake it off .. tayloror swift s d defense coming outut and sayining, hohold on a sesecond, thatat tr writes a all her ownwn music. these e lyrics werere inspird by comommonplace p phrases thatat were useded at her scsc, and that t there is nono monopy overer that phrarase. marinana v. bogorarad: i argud why y the case s sh
playing] interviewewer 1: playeyers go play, anand haters g gon hat, yoyou know? songwrititers nathanan butler d seanan hall sueded taylor sws, claiaiming that t taylor swift s sosong, shakeke it o borroweded from a sosong they we fofor 3lw calllled playass gon plalay . lisa r respers frarance: in 20, hallll and butleler filed a a lt agaiainst tayloror swift becee ththey felt lilike those l ls that playayers going g to playay, haters g going to hah had cocome from ththeir 200000 hit song g with 3lw.. sidndney madden:n: to someone who o says they y hear absololy no simililarity betwtween s shake it ofoff anand playas s gon play betweeeen those twtwo choruse, you would d have to bebe listeg with t three sets s of earmufs to tryry and realllly argue e with that.t. [m[music playiying] sean h hall: some e lawyers reran ththe situatioion. but i dididn t get i it becaue usually y when peoplple say copyriright infriningement, nine timimes out of f 10, they mean the music. oh, the