Send us a tweet cspanwj. Or go to facebook. Or send an email. The phone lines are open. Take a look at the exchange between donald trump and john kasich on immigration. Mp we have to stop ilLegal Immigration, it is hurting us from every standpoint and causing tremendous difficulty with respect to drugs and what it does to our inner cities and it is such an unbelievable moment because the courts have not been ruling in our favor. It was a 21 decision, a terrific thing that happened. We are a country of laws. We need borders. We will have a wall and the wall will be built. The wall will be successful at if you think walls do not work, ask israel. The wall works. Properly done. Can you just send 5 Million People back with no effect on the economy . We are a country of laws. We either have a country or we do not have a country. We are a country of laws. , they willo go out come back, and hopefully they get back but we have no choice if we are going to run our country properly and going to be a country. We need to control our borders just like people have to control who goes in and out of their house. If people think we are going to ship 11 Million People who are lawabiding, in this country and somehow pick them up and ship them out of mexico, think about the families and the children. The answer is, if they have been lawabiding, they pay a penalty, they get to stay and we protect the wall, anybody else comes over, they go back. For the 11 Million People, we know you cannot pick them up and ship them across the border. It is a silly argument. It makes no sense. your lucky in ohio you struck oil. [laughter] dwight eisenhower, a good , heident, people like him moved 1 million and a half Illegal Immigrants out of this country beyond the border. He moved them again and they came back. He did not like it, move them way south and they never came back. [laughter] dwight eisenhower. You do not get nicer or friendlier, they moved a million and a half people out. We have no choice. We have no choice. Kasich in ohio we have grown 347,000 jobs, unemployment is half of what it was and our fracking industry may have contributed 20,000 but if mr. Trump understood the real jobs come in the downstream, that is where we will get our jobs. Ohio is diversified. Thing, they do not think when it comes to the truth. I am suggesting we cannot ship 11 Million People out of this country, children would be terrified and it will not work. P undelete i have built an Unbelievable Company with billions and billions of dollars, i do not have to hear from this man. Host a lengthy exchange between donald trump and john kasich on immigration. The debate continued with the other candidates. Marco rubio who was part of the gang of eight who came up with a comprehensive Immigration Reform proposal that passed in the senate, some noting that marco rubio was out of that exchange and that debate over immigration. David in virginia, a democrat, what did you think . Ele thin gru running for president in the republican ranks. Gentleman. P is no the way he spoke to ms. Fiorina, big things he said about i have more funny money than you mr. K6 so i do not have to listen to you, things that are beyond the bend. Any sensible politician. That is not politics. I would like to see him say that to Vladimir Putin. Host he would say that is right, he is not a politician. Guest he still has to act like one when he meets with people with other politicians and other leaders around the world. Host you do not find him president ial . Guest absolutely not. Job. Ush does not want the case forch made a good himself. Like the gentleman from texas i cannot remember his name. Host senator ted cruz. Guest he is another one that is beyond the pale. Host why do you say jeb bush does not want it . Guest his attitude, the way he acts. I do not think he wants to be president. He feels like it is a Family Tradition that he has to uphold. Brothersshore up his the policy decisions and mistakes that were made during his brothers administration. Host that was david, a democrat. N virginia i want to hear from a publicans, eight candidates were on the debate, the smallest amount, what do you think . An independent in flushing, new york. Guest good morning. I followed both debates. What is clear [indiscernible] know what personality will matter. Fiorina and carly the rest of the guys are no different. Host what do you like about Carly Fiorina and in carson . Guest ben carson is calm. Americans want someone who they trust. Ben carson has that. He might not be politically correct. Like muslims cannot be president. These might hurt him. Carly fiorina is the woman for me. She is in business, she knows how to handle money and her personality is good. Donald trump insulted her and she was calm. Know if republicans go with these two personalities they have a chance. Jeb bush should step down. He does not have it. He should step down and let the other guys. Democrats should learn from a publicans republicans. [indiscernible] host lets hear from a republican. Tennessee. Play whatould like to ted cruz said about immigration. That we should have ilLegal Immigration and the rule of law Legal Immigration and the ruled law. And wepeople come in love refugees come in. Cruz said about other subjects and marco rubio as well. Had a lot ofrina good sense to say on taxes and balancing our budget and getting zero budget or we can cut certain things. I would appreciate if you would play what ted cruz said. Guest thats where we will go in host that is where we will go to next. How jeb bush and ted cruz responded to the immigration question. 12 million Illegal Immigrants, to send them back, 500,000 a month is not possible. It is not embracing american values. It would tear communities apart and send the signal that we are not the kind of country i know america is. Having this conversation send a powerful signal, they are doing high fives in the Clinton Campaign when they hear this. Thats the problem with this. We have to win the presidency and that is by practical plans. We need to allow people to earn legal status where they pay a fine and work and do not commit crime and learn english. They earn legal status, that is the proper path. People online trying to come in to the country, very unfair to those who want to come have gone, they through the process and are waiting, very unfair to them. Ted cruz when the Mainstream Media covers immigration they do not see it as an economic issues. For millions of americans watching this, it is a personal economic issue. I will say the politics of it would be different if a bunch of lawyers and bankers were crossing the rio grande. Or if a bunch of people with journalism degrees were driving down the wages in the press. [laughter] [applause] then we would see stories about the economic calamity that is the falling our nation. [laughter] couldose who believe we people should come to the country legally, we are tired of being told we are antiimmigrant. Host ted cruz on the immigration question last night. Jeb bush said the hillary Clinton Campaign is doing highfives when they hear donald trump talking about another republican candidate talking about immigration. A spokesperson for the hillary of Clinton Campaign said they were doing highfives. A philadelphia democrat, mark. Wast watching that debate tough. The one thing that strikes me about the republicans is none of them want to raise the moment which i find hard to believe. Second of all, they spent so much time talking about Vladimir Putin and isis. I went to the drugstore yesterday that cost 10 a pill. Medicare and they will not pay for it. My supplemental plan is saying i should use generic but the generic does not work. I am spending about 700 a month on healthrelated insurance premiums and medicine, over half my Social Security check. I do not hear anything about this. L . I care about isi do i care about Vladimir Putin when i can barely afford my medication . Host the breakdown on how much time they spent on different issues, taxes, deficit, budget, the debt took up most of the time at 26 minutes and National Security and Foreign Policy came in second at 18 minutes. Bank bailouts, 15 minutes on that topic. Immigration, over six minutes. Medicare, under five. Trade, the same on the discretion of trade and the trade promotion authority. On obamacare, over four minutes. The economy got four minutes. Minuteswage under four to income inequality, two minutes because rand paul talked about it. Your thoughts on the fourth gop debate posted by foxbusiness and the wall street journal did republicans we want to hear from you. Democrats, 2027488000. What did you make of the eight candidates republicans, 2027488001. Also the debate at 7 00 p. M. Eastern time would be for other candidates. Marilyn, you are up. Guest it was refreshing to see professional journalism last night, fox did it well, asking substantive questions. To every democrat, i am independent, that is independent is a code word for democrat. Obama rules like a king. Take all your illegals, over 21 million, take them in your backyards and you pay for this. This country did not ask for this. We want to take america back and make it great again. Not to embrace socialism and communism, this was forced upon us just Like Health Care was shut down our throats. We want common sense laws in place. Another tactic the democrats pulled was lets call their bluff. Host about executive orders by the president on immigration, take a look at the Washington Post front page. President obama is looking for the high court to help them. Justices will rule on immigration actions after the latest legal setback. Said it wouldtion ask the Supreme Court to rule next year on the president s plan to allow millions of undocumented immigrants to remain at work in the United States without fear of deportation. A ruling which could open political debate in the president ial election. After setback for obama in court there is a new urgency among the white house officials and advocates to start enrolling immigrants before the president leaves office in january of 2017. The latest on that. What are your thoughts on the debate last night . Debtspent far more time on than they did immigration. And the economy. What are your thoughts . Huntington beach, california, a democrat, jerry. Guest i did not know you changed your name. It was scary, the debate. It does not add up. Keepnot see how they can come up with these things, they will cut taxes, increase military spending, and magically balance the budget. They need ae reality check. There is something wrong with this whole idea. If i had to pick a worse statement, it came from Carly Fiorina, she said that the United States when the United States is wrong, the rest of the world is strong and when the United States is weak, the rest of the country is weak. What evidence does she have . Thank you not answer questions. It was a mess. Guest host who presented the greatest challenge to Hillary Clinton or Bernie Sanders . Depending on who gets the nomination. Guest probably none of them but the only two that were rational or rand paul and ben carson. The rest were hysterical. It was crazy. It was amazing. Guest an independent in new york. You are on the air. Debate andtched the i think the republicans are clowns. There was one thing jeb bush said that i agree with. That was his remark on immigration that you just played. It sounds remarkably like obamas executive orders on immigration, pay a fine, the resid pathway to citizenship, we do not do for you. Deport you. Plan. Exactly like obamas host james, a republican, what did you make of the debate . Guest it was a good debate. Overall, everybody did a reasonable job. John kasich went over the top. I do not think bush did well. Rand paul did a good job as he always does and more attention needs to begin to him. Ive had several holders called me pulling stations call and they eliminate rand paul out of the questions. They give me choices of jeb bush carson,d trump or ben they would not put rand paul in there so his polling numbers have to be low. The question was, who would i vote for for president in the republican primary . They gave me those choices without giving me the choice of other people. Rand paul was not in their. I said he was a good choice because he stands up for liberty. In my opinion, he would like to give us out of some of these wars we do not need to be in. Last night, they asked a question i have not seen shown on the morning show about us having a nofly zone and he said, if we do that, we will encounter russian planes that we would be shooting down, that would cause a war with russia. His stance on Foreign Affairs are better and make more common sense that what some of the others do. So many of them that are warmongers and the war missing he had to argue with rubio with, i thought he was correct. Marco rubio cannot handle his own credit card, much less United Statescredit card. I would like to see more rand paul and people giving him a chance to explain his point of view. We are missing an opportunity. The last thing most people want is rand paul to be the president of United States over the big businesses do not want him. Host let me show our viewers that exchange between marco rubio from florida and rand paul from kentucky. This is their money, it is refundable, not just if the taxes i guess the government but refundable against the payroll tax. Everyone pays payroll tax. This is their money. This is not our money. If you invest that money in the piece of equipment, in a business, you get to write it off your taxes but if you invested in your children, in the future of america and strengthening your family, we will not recognize that in our taxes, the family is the most important institution. I know that rand paul is an isolationist, i am not. The world is a stronger and better place when United States is the Strongest Military power in the world. Host that exchange between the two senators over military issues. While they were preparing for last nights debate, the senate was voting on the Defense Authorization bill. In the new york times, making it harder to close guantanamo. The military measure which passed in a 913 vote includes provision that if the transfer of prisoners to the United States oil, which has been a core component of the administrations plan to shut the prison. Mr. Obama had vetoed a publishing Previous Mission a new version was approved by the house last week. Overwhelming bipartisan support. The bill bans bringing guantanamo detainees for to the United States for prosecution or detention. It tightens restrictions on transferring detainees to other countries. 913. Ill approved six senators did not vote, senator ted cruz, Lindsey Graham , senator heller, rand paul, marco rubio, and senator david who washo was vitter in his home state for a debate last night. The president says he will approve this measure. Approvede yesterday an 80 billion spending bill for veterans programs and military Construction Projects to be adopted this year here and we will talk more about Veterans Issues coming up on todays washington journal. We are spending the first part of the program talking about last night gop debate. James and South Carolina a democrat from maryland. Guest good morning. This is very divisive to the Republican Party when you have so many horses in a race. There are so many horses in this race did that is not uniting the party. Host who should get out . Guest who should get out . Some should eliminate themselves. They do not belong there. Host tell us who. Guest that is not my place on cspan when so many people can hear it as to say who should get out. Some people want to hear themselves talk. Immigration or the lack of it, i do not know if this was brought up but i see them all the time, shopping and Grocery Stores, they come here and they do not speaking but i do not want to learning which. They bring learn english. They bring their children here so their children can be born here and it is costing us a fortune. Host how do you know all that i seeing them in the Grocery Store . Guest i see them all the time and they stand there, i do not speak english. They bring their children. Guest bellevue, nebraska, bob, independent. Guest it is great to listen to republicans talk about immigration. It is great to have them deal with problems with immigration. In the 1950s, people from mexico were very poor like now and many of them came to the United States and work in the United States and then returned to mexico every year. This continued militarization of the border. This is becoming more difficult so people do not go home, they stay here. The other ongoing issues you have host we are listening. Guest the other issues are the issues that the White Working Class has competing with people. You think a person from x go with a sixth grade education was a better worker than a