Change My Mind: Butter's Better When It's Not Refrigerated [POLL]
I'm sorry, but if you're keeping your butter in the fridge, you're doing it wrong. When it comes to butter, I use just as much as Paula Dean on her cooking shows, so the stick of butter doesn't exactly last long to begin with. Yes, I leave one stick of butter out on the counter (or in a cupboard) at room temperature, while the remaining sticks sit in the fridge. So I'm not that much of a monster when it comes to keeping my butter safe. I don't enjoy ripping up my piece of toast or slice of bread with rock-hard butter and that's simply my prerogative.
Source: fun107.com