by Scott Spanbauer and Harry McCracken
(IDG)
-- After months of waiting, an endless cycle of beta versions and "release
candidates," ongoing legal wrangling, and inescapable hype, it all boils
down to a simple question: Does upgrading to Windows 98 make sense?
The question may be simple, but it's not easy to answer. If Windows 95
was a great leap forward, Win 98 is a series of baby steps. No single
feature of this $90 (street price) upgrade screams "buy me," and many
improvements are available as free downloads or in recent Win 95 versions.
Ultimately, the new operating system's fate will be decided in court.
Moreover, industrial-strength Windows NT 5.0 waits in the wings. It will
incorporate most of Win 98's new features and should be more secure, stable,
and manageable. With NT 5.0 due early next year, many users (especially
corporate types) may wait before upgrading.
To determine whether Windows 98 is really safe for human consumption,
PC World's testing team spent countless hours installing and using the
latest release candidates on a range of PCs, from 66-MHz 486 systems to
300-MHz Pentium IIs. The version we tested was very close to final code,
though it didn't have every last tweak in place. Still, our informal testing
shows the new operating system to be about as fast and at least as stable
overall as Windows 95 (next month we'll publish final test results based
on shipping code of the new operating system). Our conclusion: Windows
98 improves on its predecessor in ways that many users will appreciate.
But it's not for everyone.