PTAB's secondary considerations analysis in an IPR Final Written Decision
Appellant Yita sought inter parts review of two patents sharing a specification, both of which are directed to the vehicle floor tray. In one IPR, the Board determined that claims of one patent, the 186 patent were not unpatentable for obviousness.
Kohler Co Appellee Macneil Final Written Decisions Federal Circuit Intelligent Bio Systems Patent Owner Response Macneil
Source: natlawreview.com