Library. God bless america. [inaudible conversations] [inaudible] good afternoon. I will be moderating this panel for you a good afternoon i will be moderating the panel today to give a critique to the war on terror per gram a professor at the Naval Academy teaching courses on American Foreign policy and International Affairs and i have two guests today although it may not appear that way. [laughter] one is urgently on his way. [laughter] the one we are missing currently is james who is a correspondent with the New York Times and a person who has provided a lot of the american response to the september 11th attacks he is a great person to be with us provided he were with us. He is on his way from the National Airport and should be here in about 50 minutes. I will introduce him before he arrives one the first Pulitzer Prize for reporting about 911. Totally appropriate and he won his second writing about the Bush Administration wiretap as part of the National Security response to 911 and