middle here, concurred with the decision that mr. snyder ought to lose. the other two, joined in an opinion throwing the case out on first amendment grounds. all judge shed said was i agree the case should get thrown out. i would throw it ought because there is no intentional infliction claim. the other two judges did not join in that decision that s not the basis on which it s going to the supreme court. bill: they didn t dissent. they don t need to he was concurring with the result. bill: the fact that shed said that team did k. debate the appropriateness he is a nut. do you want me to explain his point to you. bill: no, i don t. you throw him under the bus and you dent want to hear the defense. bill: i throw him under the bus because that s he wrote. i don t want to hear some rationalization of what he wrote. the reason he is saying it may not have been intentional infliction of emotional distress for this westboro baptist church people to go outside of that funeral
bill: time for pinheads and patriots. before the opening game in boston the red sox got a pep talk from a 5-year-old. tonight we are the greatest baseball team in the world. you were born to be baseball players. every one of ya. and you were meant to be here tonight. this is your time. their time is done, it s over! bill: little josh is a patriot and will probably be joining the marines soon. on the pinhead front we come minuted jane fonda for promoting physical fitness. sadly jane cannot stay out of pinhead realm. when i came back from north vietnam there was a quarter of an inch of media about it in
bill: back of the book segment tonight. the culture warriors, i think it s fair to stay criticize people right now president obama and sarah palin. harry reid added to the palin circus yesterday. i was going to give a few remarks on the people who were here a week ago saturday but i couldn t write it all on my hand. [ laughter ] [ applause ] you betcha. bill: here now, the culture warriors fox news analyst margaret hoover and fox & friends co-anchor gretchen carlson. i was going to say something mocking reid. no. i m a bigger man. here is my question. reid mocks palin, palin mocks reid. opposite ends of the spectrum. when a male politician mock as
responded saying your objection is too late. all right? so the court then asked for a response. the other side argued still they are out of time. and mr. snyder s lawyer never contested that he never came back and said i m not late. bill: all we know is sean summers told us he didn t file late and the court has never stated. that s fine. he says he wasn t late. the other side says he was late. the rule i have to tell you was not clear. i called the court to ask them what they say. they don t answer these types of questions. bill: they don t answer. now, when it goes to the supreme court in october, all right? coulter is saying. this is the only thing that you and coulter agree on that it s really a close call. that the supreme court is going to have to judge freeman of speech claims against the damage that this group does consistently, westboro, which would be able to be proven. right. bill: can you prove that they do damage to people who are grieving, military families. so,
bill: impact something ment tonight as we reported last week senator john mccain is now asking president obama to put the national guard on the mexican border. this after arizona rancher was murdered apparently by an illegal alien. well so, far mr. obama resisted putting the military on the border. joining us now is charles krauthammer. we disagree on, this charles, but let s hear your opinion first. why no military for you? because the reason you use the military is if we had satellite information that the mexican army is massing at the texas frontier and planning to retake the alamo. in that case i would recommend using the military. in our country in our tradition we don t use the military for internal policing. if you want to stop illegal immigration, you don t have to use the military. you build a fence. it s not complicated.