📰 Commerce News
Page 1615 - Commerce News Today
Fast, Ad-Free News Updates
Stay updated with breaking news from Commerce. Real-time updates on events, politics, business and more.
March 27, 2012
Than constitutionality. >> i couldnt agree more with that. they can deal with a policy across the street in the congress, which is where it should be dealt with. what were talking about today in this very significant argument going on behind me right now has to do with the constitutionality with this law. and i along with 28 of my colleagues feel very strongly that this is not a constitutional law for the reasons youve already reported on. the massive over reach of power, not only into the comme...
March 27, 2012
At the court. you hear all these conspiracy theories. my favorite is theres going to be two opinions. roberts can write an opinion that says this law stinks, this is a dangerous, you go up to the line but i cant rule it out. >> you have to jump with the commerce clause. clearly, where you are compelling, conservative jurists would say you are engaging instead of a big commerce case law saying if you are going to have a barbecue restaurant off the interstate in birmingham, alabama, you have to se...
March 27, 2012
Its massacquerading tax increa. would you have challenged it? >> i would have challenged it politically in the arena of congress, but legally it would have been much more difficult for us. theyre trying to pass this thing. at the time a tax was politically infeasible for them. now it is constitutionally pragmatic for them to argue that it is a tax, but its not a tax, and theyre trying to rush it into the commerce authority, and its simply not constitutional. >> i want you to react to something. ...
March 27, 2012
Than most had ever have the chance to be here at the supreme court today. another important argument, probably the most important of paul clements career. that is something he acknowledges, martha. martha: what an incredible amount of experience he has in that arena. he seems like he has a very good argument like he believes. why are the support is of this law so confident it will be upheld in there? >> reporter: one thing they point to a number of lower courts upheld the mandate. they say a lot...
March 27, 2012
Clothing. yes, we all need these things, and yes, the fewer people that purchase them, the more its going to cost for the rest of us. that doesnt give congress automatically the authority to regulate that area of human behavior. very, very telling, and exceedingly sharp questioning. and in the case of justice scalia and ginsburg, from one justice to the other, as opposed to from one justice to the lawyer. jon: you say that the commerce clause initially was brought into being in part to govern fe...
March 27, 2012
He said, well, perhaps we can say the health care market really is different. that that is the limiting principle here. that the government can do this, can require everyone to buy health insurance, and that wont necessarily mean a broader power to buy anything else. thats clearly the thing that he is tossing around in his mind. some of the justices made it quite clear that they dont buy that argument. what the opponents of this law say is that under the commerce clause power, congress can only ...
March 27, 2012
Forward and make your indicate. >> greta: tomorrow the mandate. theyll have argument whether the mandate is constitutional tor not. its going to be attacked or supported on so many grounds. weve got a commerce clause issue. is this interstate commerce. supporters say absolutely. theyre not compelling someone into activity. theyre regulating activity. folks against it say if you force me to buy something, where do you draw the line? can you force me, youve heard the example again and again to eat...
March 27, 2012
Youve had constituents ask you this, how do you fix this part of it? >> as far as the medicaid portion? >> yeah. how do you deal with the fact that everybody is going to use the health care system? >> well, first off, the government made its argument over there in court today that this is a health care market. my concern is not with what will ultimately happen if everyone falls into that market. if you can define it as a health care market, then the government can regulate anyone who breathes, w...
March 27, 2012
People in to regulate them because everyone is in the health care market already. i dont think that satisfied the conservative members of the court. heres an odd point, both side agree you could require people to buy insurance when they show up at the doctors office or when they show up at the emergency room to get care. they both agree on that. they both said the government could do that because if youre seeking to get health care services, the congress can regulate how you pay for it. what the...
March 27, 2012
♪ spread a little joy... theres two hours of argument, and he has an hour. [ female announcer ] fresh milk and real cream. and his argument centers around thats what makes philadelphia. ♪ so spread a little... the fact that everyone the [ female announcer ] and thats what makes the moment we enjoy it, a little richer. governments argument goes is ♪ going to need health insurance real belgian chocolate at some point in his or her whipped with philadelphia cream cheese. life. and all that th...