it hurts anyone but the super rich and has a complexity level that i don t think joe quite realizes. what would you say to constituents in toledo about how 9-9-9 would affect them? first of all, i think 9-9-9 would not encourage investment in the usa, but out sourcing. we have to have a tax code to make goods in america and grow goods in america and ship them elsewhere. i think that the bill that the proposal that you are talking about would increase taxes on the middle class. we have been trying to relieve that tax burden and also on the working class and poor. i think that s where we need to increase consumer spending. they said marcie, bring me customers. they need people who are earning money and buy goods to move the economy forward. what he is talking about is a