live coverage here on msnbc of tonight s presidential debate between president joe biden and former president donald trump. we said it would be a debate unlike any other. it certainly was that in this first ever ly was that in thi came out of the s gate with firsa t ever go unexpectedly weak voice. voice that at times made it hard to discern. the campaign said it was the result of a cold. he did seem to falter several times early on in terms of trying to speak in a way that could be heard in in terms of speaking to time as the red lights, flashing red lights came on to stop him as the rules of the debate indicated two minute and one minute segments. this is a live shot we ve got right here. president biden and first lady jill biden walking out on stage. this is at a watch party in atlanta. you might ve noticed at the very end of the debate, as soon as the moderators said good night, boom, lost the shop. we did not get to see president biden s wife, the first lady, or anyone e