Page 708 - Instruction News Today

Courtroom when you return. during deliberations, jurors must communicate about the case only with one another and only when all jurors are present in the jury room. you are not to communicate with any person outside the jury about this case. until you have reached a verdict, you must not talk about this case in person or through the telephone, writing, or electronic communication such as a blog, twitter, e-mail, text message or any other means. do not contact anyone to assist you during delibera...

Instruction. >> thats an error by not instructing this jury properly on the law. >> you continually disagree with this court every time i make a ruling. if i have made a mistake in this case, you will appeal. this is my ruling on this issue. >> reporter: but it was this moment after a hearing late into the night that will forever be cemented in trial watchers minds. >> im not physically able to keep up this pace at this moment. its 10:00 at night. we started this morning. every day. weekends, de...

The law. you get a jury instruction, take a look at the jury instruction. a witnesss attitude in giving testimony is absolutely irrelevant -- i mean, is relevant. whether don west wasnt asking for a curative instruction is beyond me because what he told that jury is not the state of the law. that is absolutely not what the jury instruction reads. you can absolutely take a look at her attitude, demeanor, like any other witness and if you feel that theres a problem with that, you can discount or y...

State that started out at the beginning. i think thats crucial in the assessment of a jury. at the same time, the prosecution didnt address how do you deal with the reasonableness of the offense. i think the jury instructions are kind of confusing on the question of self-defense and manslaughter. i thought a better job could have been done. >> with that said, does it concern you that those instructions that you view as confusing in your experience, will that complicate a verdict? >> i think so. ...

Is the instruction at the very, very end, a little sneak peek into this where she will say to them, you must look at the law. you must not look at your passion or anything like that, you must look at the law, and we are counting on you to make a wise decision which i think was interesting. i havent seen that many times before. >> i havent seen it in a jury charge before. >> its always i know, folly to try to figure out how to read the tea leaves of what jurors are thinking. however we have a lit...

Category one they are known as lesser included offenses. in a case of second-degree murder, there is one necessarily included category one and thats manslaughter. if either side asks for it, the judge has to give it. this is no alarming deal in court. this is nothing that required research or any surprise, trick or anything else. it was automatic. the lawyers knew it from the very first day they got in this case, or they told have and im sure they did. i know these lawyers. >> so some people tha...

Uncommon for a judge. something that was on display again today, as she clashed with defense attorney don west over jury instructions. >> i am not giving that instruction. and you can -- >> by not instructing the law of this jury properly on the law -- >> you continually disagree with this court every time i make a ruling. if i have made a mistake in this case, you will appeal. this is my ruling on this issue. >> reporter: but it was this moment after a hearing late into the night that will fore...

>> the felony alleged is child abuse. obviously, the information alleges that the defendant shot and killed the victim, that the victim was under the age of 18. and child abuse must be, according to the third degree felony murder, instruction defined. >> reporter: the defense attorney was outraged. >> oh, my god. just when i thought this case couldnt get anymore bizarre. >> reporter: the debate brought more testy exchanges between west and judge debra nelson. >> i understand. ive already ruled a...

Defense lawyers and she remembers him and she is angry. that back and forth was so weirdly personal. >> you are talking about -- >> you want to listen? >> you got it? >> lets roll the flip out. >> the state is seeking this instruction as part of a larger scheme, another trick that the state is seeking. >> i dont want to hear the word trick anymore with regards to the arguments, please. >> i understand i have already ruled and you have -- you continually disagree with this court every time i make...

Deadly force if he reasonable bring believes that such force is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to himself. the danger facing george zimmerman need not have been actual, based upon appearance, george zimmerman must have actually believed that the danger was real. >> karen desoto, apply that standard to this case. >> well, you know, the whole idea of reasonableness in this case is really what this hinges in. the defense spent a large amount of time in their closing talkin...