a tip at a restaurant? it reportedly happened at this houston, texas, restaurant. the manager of la fisherman, as brian says, sounds french, locked a party inside and called police when a woman and her five friends didn t leave the 17% gratuity required of parties of five or more. well, the group claims the restaurant s staff didn t deserve the tip. so who is right legally? let s ask fox news senior judicial analyst judge andrew napolitano. if you can concentrate because we ve had show girls, we ve had tanning women and brian s commentary. this nutty president of spirit airlines. so now we re on to this. the people did not want to pay the tip, they say the service was horrible! it does say on the menu it s required. do they have to pay it? well, there is no specific court ruling on this because the concept of adding automatic tips is relatively new and as far as i know and as far as research could determine, it hasn t been challenged so the restaurant would say it wasn t really a