information now, and we think we have another suspect. reporter: another suspect. a new name altogether. based on information from an eyewitness who may have seen annie kasprzak the night she was killed and knew who killed her. coming up is this how annie was murdered? and is this the man who murdered her? what if i told you she s dead? i didn t do it. the latest innovation from xfinity
is? reporter: it was a message from chris. the cops might come back to your house. i need you to tell them that annie got a bloody nose so i don t get blamed. he told me about the he said something about the bloody nose. that i actually don t remember seeing. i remember hearing it though. reporter: lab results eventually did show annie s blood was on chris shoes. detectives questioned him about it during a second interview. okay. it would have just been one drop? yeah. reporter: but then his story began to change. where did it drip on your shoe? there was a little bit on the shoelace and then there was a little bit right here. okay. so those are two separate drops you could see? yeah. reporter: in fact, the lab found more than just those two spots of blood. they found several. but, studying the case file, jaclyn noticed that the lab didn t test every spot to see if it belonged to annie. they also hadn t tested the bottom of chris shoes. so what do you do? we
in the balance, justice for annie, now dead for a year and a half. she strongly suspected chris bagshaw knew more than he was telling. again and noticed something interesting chris said about his shoes. she had a bloody nose last time i hung out with her, and we were sitting right next to each other, and she did drip it on my shoes. do you remember where on the shoe? it was on my shoe laces. i m not sure which shoe it is. when was that? about five days ago maybe, me and my friend spencer were hanging out, and she just came over. reporter: spencer, the guy from that cell phone video. remember, jaclyn had seen him coming into the station in the days following annie s murder. she had a gut feeling back then that he was hiding something and detectives at the time asked for his phone. do you have an idea why we took your phone? for call logs? well, no, that s part of the reason. but there was a message on there that we re kind of interested in. do you know what that messag
annie, certainly. initially, we were thinking, no, that s not possible. there s no way. reporter: but then, a detail sergeant carpenter shared with salt lake city s nbc affiliate ksl tv. there was a shoe found at the crime scene, and there was one on the body. reporter: a red shoe. the same kind james had bought annie for valentine s day just weeks earlier. veronica and james tried to stay calm. we called the police. and we said, hey, our daughter s missing. i think logically i was going, they re just going to rule it out. i just need them to rule it out. reporter: but they couldn t rule it out. after i called the police, i called my parents to come and pick up our boys. and i just started sobbing. reporter: police soon determined the 20-something asian victim was really 15-year-old annie kasprzak. she had been killed by blunt force trauma to the head. veronica and james had thought the rapid pinging of annie s phone meant she was driving away.
annie kasprzak had been brutally murdered and dumped into the jordan river. we kept asking, are you sure it wasn t an accident? the idea that somebody else could do that to her was just even now, it s hard to imagine that that s even possible. reporter: and now draper police were working hard to catch her killer. we re trying to actively locate suspects in this case, any witnesses, so we can actually bring this case to a conclusion for the parents. reporter: and within a week of annie s murder, they found that witness. her name was joanna, and she had been picked up on a fraud charge by neighboring west jordan pd. during her interview, she started telling detectives about a young girl she had seen a week