Page 3 - Standing Issue News Today

Для контролю якості медпослуг може бути створено спеціальний держорган - Ляшко 1 хв читати Для контролю якості надання медичних послуг клінік, які отримують бюджетне фінансування, може бути створений спеціальний держорган, повідомив міністр охорони здоровя Віктор Л�...

When justice barrett came for confirmation the democrats surrounded her with giant pictures of people who would lose their healthcare because they said she was put on the court specifically to vote in this case and to strike down the aca a. some of us went on the air and said look, thats just not true, this case is exceptionally unlikely to overturn the aca. it was a very technical case dealing with severability, there was a standing issue and some of us said its almost -- i mean, its not within...

Center right. is this something that indicates the court will rule more moderately than expected, or is this a mirage at this point, this reading? >> yeah, i think i wouldnt take too much from this ruling, that its based on process and the restraint weve seen from chief justice roberts in the past. in fact, it is the kind of thing that is a mrafs worth enemy to be struck down on a standing issue. something that is used in challenges by the aclu or people in personal injury lawsuits. some may see...

The cases are being hung up on the question of standing, on who gets to do the challenge. so the second circuit case was dismissed and now one of two things will happen. it will go back to begin the discovery process, which will be fascinating. i would do anything to get to help in that where theyll find out whos spending what money in different hotels and restaurants. that discovery process would be fascinating. or the white house could stall and take it up to the full second circuit, which see...

Are these cases proving so hard to prove? >> they arent being hard to prove. we arent even getting to that point. the cases are being hung up on the question of standing, on who gets to do the challenge. so the second circuit case was dismissed and now one of two things will happen. it will go back to begin the discovery process, which will be fascinating. i would do anything to get to help in that where theyll find out whos spending what money in different hotels and restaurants. that discovery...

Or upholds, rather, a challenge to a map, a congressional map that was -- that was the argument racially motivated? >> this case has been up to the supreme court before. its gone back down. its up again. the core issue is whether or not republicans had the standing, the ability to bring the case in the first place. so this standing issue is what the court ruled on today and did not go to this issue of whether or not there was racial gerrymandering. the reason why you pointed out correctly, racia...

Problem. even the conservatives on the court said there was a problem with standing of these republicans. because once democrats took over the governorship and the attorney general, there was a switch on what and who should be able to bring cases regarding this issue. the standing issue is the crux of it for right now. im sure theyre going to figure out a way to get back to the same question again when they have the parties involved. >> stick around. were watching the court. theres a lot to die ...

In effect says they havent found evidence of a wrong here based on legislation. is that right? >> not really. the standing issue says you have to have some proof when you bring a case in federal of showing that you have individual and particularized hathe court o address that. >> understood. okay. michael moore, we appreciate it. it is early here as we read -- as we read through this long statement. we have our jessica schneider, she is up at the supreme court, she has been delving into this. je...

>> but shouldnt those snaerten have known when he said, oh day one its beginning to be easy were going to repeal -- shouldnt the senators say oh this is a warning because he doesnt understand how this process works. >> yeah, he didnt realize how hard this was going to be. healthcare is a long standing issue, former house speaker john bayer tried to worn us a couple months ago when he said its just not going to happen. its not entirely the presidents fall by the naive they has not worn off as to ...

Does here. i do want to get to key point. >> we would like to get to answer to the question. because it speaks to its standing issue if the order says muslims could not be admit would anything have standing to challenge that? >> it would be by u.s. citizen with connection with someone seeking entry. this is far cry from that -- >> is there a purpose standing, is there an why i purpose for your argument that we shouldnt recognize this lawsuit by the states and we should wait for an individual to ...