Caledonia chief speaks out, says evidence planting 'completely untrue' Caledonia's police chief defends officer in traffic stop The Caledonia police chief is speaking out after one of his officers was accused of planting evidence during a traffic stop. CALEDONIA, Wis. - The Caledonia police chief is speaking out after one of his officers was accused of planting evidence during a traffic stop. A 16-second video taken by a passenger in the vehicle went viral. But the police chief said the accusations are false – and he has video to prove it. "It was completely untrue," said Caledonia Police Chief Chris Botsch.