Extra-strength acetaminophen recall warns of liver damage risk Some extra-strength acetaminophen, a pain reliever sold under various brand names, has been recalled because the bottles weren’t labeled properly. According to the recall notice from A-S Medication Solutions, LLM, the lack of the required OTC Drug Facts label may lead to some consumers taking the pain reliever without awareness of the potentially harmful effects. Acetaminophen is a common pain reliever that can be purchased over the counter at drug stores, grocery stores, and many other places. As with many drugs, taking acetaminophen improperly may result in adverse reactions — taking too much, for example, can result in liver damage.