Last Week in the Federal Circuit (January 25-29): Year 1993

Last Week in the Federal Circuit (January 25-29): Year 1993 and LTE Technology | Morrison & Foerster LLP - Federal Circuitry


Panel:  Judges Dyk, Plager, and Moore, with Judge Dyk writing the opinion
You should read this case if:  you have a matter involving standard-essential patents and license agreements that include later-developed or acquired intellectual property.  
Our case this week features the standard-essential power players of quarantine: cell phones and tablets.  If you’re wondering how your trusted devices fared, please do read on. 
Evolved owns a standard-essential patent (SEP) covering 4G/LTE technology for mobile devices.  In 2015, Evolved sued several mobile device manufacturers for infringement based on their use of Qualcomm chipsets to make multi-mode, or LTE, mobile devices.
But here’s the catch.  The patent’s original owner, LGE, had granted a license to Qualcomm back in 1993.  This license agreement barred patent infringement claims against Qualcomm and its customers for use of LGE patents that are technically or commercially necessary to make, sell, or use a “Subscriber Unit.”  The (multi-) million dollar question, then, is whether defendants’ accused products are “subscriber units” under the 1993 LGE-Qualcomm license.  The district court said “yes.”  As a result, it granted defendants summary judgment of noninfringement based on the license agreement and the doctrine of patent exhaustion. 

Related Keywords

, Morrison Foerster Llp , G Code Division Multiple Access , Holaplex Inc , Qualcomm , Morrison Foerster , Loreal United States Inc , Federal Circuit , L Oreal United States , Evolved Wireless , Judges Dyk , Judge Dyk , Code Division Multiple Access , மோரிசன் போஎர்ஸ்தேற் ல்ப் , க் குறியீடு பிரிவு பல நுழைவு , ஓலப்ளேக்ஷ இன்க் , குவால்காம் , மோரிசன் போஎர்ஸ்தேற் , லோரல் ஒன்றுபட்டது மாநிலங்களில் இன்க் , கூட்டாட்சியின் சுற்று , ல் ஒறேல் ஒன்றுபட்டது மாநிலங்களில் , பரிணாமம் வயர்லெஸ் , நீதிபதிகள் டய்க் , நீதிபதி டய்க் , குறியீடு பிரிவு பல நுழைவு ,

© 2025 Vimarsana