Complaint: Firefighter shot man 6 times after fight over 'basketball' By Kasey Chronis and FOX6 News Digital Team Published Firefighter shot man 6 times after fight over basketball, prosecutors say Prosecutors say Caesar Fuentes and Andra Nicholson, Jr. were at a Third Ward club when they got into an argument over who had the better high school basketball team. MILWAUKEE - A Hales Corners firefighter fatally shot Andra Nicholson, Jr., 25, in an alley in Milwaukee's Third Ward Sunday, Dec. 6 after an argument about sports, prosecutors said in a criminal complaint obtained by FOX6 News Sunday, Dec. 13. Caesar Fuentes, 23, faces one count of first-degree reckless homicide, use of a dangerous weapon.