I was so confused. I didnt think it was real. In the rarefied world of the Ivy League, he was the total package. Star student. Gifted athlete. Wildly popular. Hes one of the nicest guys ever. Know it could understand how a Weekend Visit to his parents house. Ended in gunfire. Who was already dead . My husband. Charlie said he was going to kill my mom. I had to do it. A brave son protecting his mom. Was a true . He is seated behind a desk. It seems to be execution. Was as Campus Hero a coldhearted killer . The defendant sent an email to his Fraternity Brother saying it showtime. Was the truth different . One of the things that was a question as was charlie covering for Someone Else . A trial where nothing went by the book. Three of the jurors were crying really hard. We are turning around and getting emotional. He was becoming unhinged. Welcome to dateline. Charlie tan was an Ivy Leaguer with a bright future, but then, Charlies Dad was killed in the Home And Everything changed. Police were being told one story but the evidence was telling them another. There were also three 911 calls. Did one of them pulled a clue that would unlock what really happened on that wintry night . Here is Dennis Murphy with house of secrets. Cayuga, thats Cayuga Lake in ithaca, new york, and its where youll find one of the most prestigious universities in the nation. Cornell. The Ivy League big red. More than 13,000 Undergrads Working towards degrees, filled with good fortune taken a place in medicine, the law, the arts. Theres No Doubt a Cornell Education can be a goldplated entrance to adult life. Only the best need apply. Students like Charlie Tan. He was so kind his High School Classmates featured him in a video, random acts of kindness. Giving gives to complete strangers. The greatest of great kids. Charlie was a son of Chinese Immigrants who became mr. Everything. Scholar, athlete, class president. The guy with the Cool Friends and in ballantyne opened up her parents summerlike house To Charlie enter other teenaged pals. He was such a nice guy. Happy and energetic. The kind of guy who tells jokes . Everybody knows him. The Room Lights up and the starts telling a funny story. You would think Charlie Tan was another Ivy League overachiever poised for takeoff and great things to come. Thats not this story. Its about the Charlie Tan, keeper of secrets and quite possibly something much worse. Before all that, charlie was as deserving a kid is ever got in Ivy League acceptance letter. He was excited when he got admitted. He was so excited. He was super happy. In the fall of 2013, Charlie Tan left his parents home near rochester, new york, drove the hours to cornell. Is no chapter in a life filled with early achievements. He pledged a fraternity. He was a big enough for the Football Team so at 165 pounds, he was to directorate toward what they called a sprint Football Team. I met Charlie First Day freshman year. I had got my locker and he was one of the first people i met. The quarterback rob. One of the most encouraging team players we have. Leader by example and through his words. Robin charlie became not just teammates but great friends. Hes one of the most generous and selfless people ive ever met. He impressed his teammates and his coach. Good football player. Quiet. Always has a smile and never late. Always a hard worker. Go back to the house in the Rochester Suburbs Charlie grew up in his teenaged years. A place called pittsford, new york. Newspaper reporter knows it well. Its a nice community. Big long and nice cars . Big houses. A lot of executives from Kodak And Xerox and lawyers. Charlie was the younger two boys. His parents Jim And Jean born in china lived in canada before moving charlie and his brother to upstate new york. His dad ran a Tech Business that thrived. The home radiated uppermiddle class comfort. His friend had been there on occasion. I went over. I didnt Know Esperance well. I talked to his mom a couple of times but didnt have much conversation. Little was known about his parents and charlie didnt offer details if someone asked. If he had secrets, sorrows, they werent for the outside world to know about. He is very good at keeping his emotions and ski i have no situation of what the homelike was life. Other than 911 dispatchers and a few town officers, the wider community, friends of Charlie Tan knew nothing about the whispers of Domestic Violence on coach side lane. He is a stoic individual. The record is sealed but it is safe to say that Tan House was known to authorities. Go back to cornell. The winter of 2015 and charlie is a sophomore. On a chilly thursday morning, he stopped in to visit his Football Coach. There is a softer side to the coach that drills and his kids know he will always be there for them. Hour rule, if you need somebody to talk to, we are here. It was charlie who needed a shoulder. I said how are you doing . He said good but I Cant make weightlifting on friday. I said whats the problem . He said he needed to go home. Charlie seemed emotional. I asked if he wanted to talk . He declined. He said he had to get home. It was not spring break. Classes were in session for charlie started the drive to pittsford 100 miles away. The coach didnt know the Charlie Tans life as a student at cornell would soon be over. We didnt worry about charlie. He has his act together and knows what hes doing. Only Charlie Tan was not okay. It snowed that night. A blanket covering the home were something awful was about to happen. Why did charlie need to rush him . The first sign of trouble came from a Friends Mom who called 911. Coming up. He didnt give us a lot of details. Can distort things. And something serious may be behind those itchy eyes. Up to 50 of people with graves could develop a different condition called thyroid eye disease, which should be treated by a different doctor. See an expert. Find a ted Eye Specialist at isitted. Com nexium 24hr prevents Heartburn Acid before it begins. Get Allday And Allnight Heartburn Acid prevention with just one pill a day. Choose acid prevention. Choose nexium. Progress. Choose acid prevention. Moving in a positive direction. We all want our lives to do that. Why is progress also in our name . Weve always believed insurance should do more. Thats why weve gifted over A Thousand vehicles to veterans , funded Housing Programs for families in need and why were working to make roads safer. Youre doing good. And housing more fair. For us, thats real progress. Stay ahead of your moderatetosevere eczema. And show off clearer skin and less itch with dupixent, the 1 prescribed biologic by dermatologists and allergists, that helps heal your skin from within. Serious allergic reactions can occur that can be severe. Tell your doctor about new or worsening Eye Problems such as Eye Pain or vision changes including blurred vision, Joint Aches and pain, or a parasitic infection. Dont change or stop asthma medicines without talking to your doctor. Ask your Eczema Specialist about dupixent. [ ] your skin is everchanging, take care of it with gold bonds healing formulations of 7 moisturizers and 3 vitamins. For all your skins, gold bond. Protect against rsv with arexvy. Arexvy is a vaccine used to prevent lower Respiratory Disease from rsv in people 60 years and older. Arexvy does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients. Those with weakened Immune Systems may have a lower response to the vaccine. The most common Side Effects are Injection Site pain, fatigue, muscle pain, headache, and joint pain. Arexvy is Number One in Rsv Vaccine shots. Rsv . Make it arexvy. Choose advil liquigels for faster, stronger and longerlasting relief than tylenol rapid release gels. Because advil Targets Pain at the source of inflammation. So for faster pain relief, advil the pain away. Oooh this is our night shingles doesnt care. But shingrix protects. Only shingrix is proven over 90 effective. Shingrix is a vaccine used to prevent shingles in adults 50 years and older. Shingrix does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients or to a previous dose. An increased risk of Guillainbarre Syndrome was observed after getting shingrix. Fainting can also happen. The most common Side Effects are pain, redness, and swelling at the Injection Site, muscle pain, tiredness, headache, shivering, fever, and upset stomach. Ask your Doctor Or Pharmacist about shingrix today. When Charlie Tan when Charlie Tan left cornell and made the 100 Mile Trip Home on a thursday morning, as Football Coach knew he had been upset. I asked him to call me when he got home so i know he was okay. That evening, charlie spent time at an old Friends House where he seemed deeply despond, sad, possibly depressed. Not the charlie he had known since childhood. After charlie left, the friend and his mother was so concerned , they called 911. Was charlie suicidal . He didnt give us a lot of details. Im worried he might do something at his house. I dont know if anything is gonna happen but i cannot take a chance. We will have Summit Go to the house. A deputy did that. Spot charlie told the deputy he was upset over some things. He had come home to talk to people and he was working out some things and he would be okay. It was late Thursday Night. Almost the weekend. Charlie did not go back to school Friday Morning and come monday, he was not a practice. There wasnt much i could do anyway other than text him and he did not respond. Then, it was monday night. Something awful. What is the address of the emergency . The caller confused the dispatcher. My name is Jean Tan. I heard an argument in my I Cant understand anything you are saying . It was charlies mother. To somebody in the house of a gun . The garbled story was coming into focus. Shots fired. The Man Of The House was dead. Who was already dead . My husband. Are you in a safe spot . Yes, i am. We need you to wait outside the house for the officers safety. The detective was soon on route to coach side lane. Only a Garbled Account from the 911 call. Who had shot home . Hes trying to protect me. Your son was trying to protect you . It looked like domestic murder. Something that just occurred. On arrival, the first deputies Cy Young Man who would turn out to be 19yearold Charlie Tan standing in the driveway with his mother. They are outside the house. Its a Safety Thing for the deputies. The people come out. They asked who else is in the house . The deputies for the sum tell a story that sounded like selfdefense. He had to shoot, he said, to save his mother. He used a shotgun. Charlie said my dad is in there. He is dead. I had to do it. He was going to hurt my mom. He feels his mother is in jeopardy . Yes. The deputies but the Son And Mother and a patrol car. They asked where the shotgun was. There was mention it was in the garage. After securing the weapon, they made their way into the home. In the second floor, they found the victim. The father is behind the desk . He is behind the desk in the Shotgun Shells are all there. The detective would learn more about Jim Tan, father, husband and businessman. He owned his own company. They lived in canada and then moved to the united states some years earlier. Successful executive . It seems. Was he also an abusive husband . The detective looked around as Crime Scene techs processed the shotgun killing upstairs. He came upon, to appear at Domestic Violence court. Justifiable homicide made some sense. The detective was no rookie. His investigation into Charlie Tan and what happened inside the home was just getting started. One of the investigators found what appeared to be newly taken passport photos. Along with a list of prominent local Defense Attorneys. That is interesting. The story is i had to do it but you are not taking it at face value. Correct. A discovery in jim Tans Computer Trigger suspicions. S. Deputies canvassed the neighborhood but No One had heard the Gunshot Blast that killed Jim Tan. This Homicide Wasnt a whodunit. The son admitted moments after deputies arrived that he had been the shooter. He had to do it, he said, to protect his mom. Selfdefense is something we will listen to. We wanted to speak to him to determine that. The same Night Charlie and his mother were taken to the station to tell their stories. Were you able to get a statement from The Sun . His lawyer would not allow us to speak with him. His lawyer was already on scene . Without the cooperation of the participants, the detectives were on their own. It turns out a large piece of evidence was waiting to be found in their very office. Ever purport from the house on coach side lane. Two weeks before the shooting, Police Records show the wife placed another 911 call. Yes, hi. My name is Jean Tan and my husband beats me up. I need your protection. He choked me. I am so scared. Please help. Hes coming. No. No. Please come. The dispatcher heard what sounded like an ongoing fight between husband and wife. Hello . Sorry. No. No. Sorry. My wife was probably upset at me. Shes upset at you . He is choking me. A deputy was sent to the house and noticed Jean Tan was clearly rattled. Reporter of the democratic and chronicle newspaper. They found jean was upset. She had red marks on her neck. There wasnt enough there to charge Jim Tan with a crying. Incident over. That night. He tried to kill me but nothing even makes it into the paperwork . History of abuse it appeared. If that were the case, charlie told No One at cornell university. On campus, the Coach Hadnt heard from charlie in days and now his phone rings. Campus police called me and asked me to come to his fraternity house, which i did. They wanted me to know that Charlies Father had been killed. It was rugged. We got a bunch of players in the fraternity, and everybody was upset. Charlie tan admitting he shot his father to death. I think it was Disbelief And Shock that this occurs. We had a Team Meeting about it but immediately after, there was so much support for him, and everyone was amazed by the support. There was no debate. The entire Frat And Team had charlies back. Were not just a spring Football Team but everybody on campus he knew well was showing support for him. Everyone was trying to help him and asked if there was anything we could do for him. To his friends at home there was shock too. And yet, the heartbreaking story of Charlie Tan protecting his mom by any means necessary made some weird sense. Was, after all, the kid i was trying hard to help. People talk about him being selfless. He lives to help other people. Yeah. Anna had a hard time wrapping her head around charlie doing anything violent. He did things no ordinary teenager did. My mom went through cancer and he was always there. He brought her gifts and he was always there supporting anybody. Anna would be there supporting charlie during this difficult time. Neither she nor anyone else couldve guessed where the investigation was heading next. The detective who examined the scene that night was wondering if there was more to the story. It was obvious right away that something was off with a Working Theory of the crime. A heat of passion, selfdefense homicide. We were there for hours searching every bit. One of the things noticed by one of the investigators is the Dried Blood all over. Dried blood . The Time Line and the story demanded a closer look. Its getting your attention that, hang on, there might be more. Lets make sure we are on the right path. There were other observations that set the Time Line back. In jim Tans Desk Computer where he had been working when he was killed, there were unopened emails going back before the weekend. Jim is trading employees emails and at some point after that, he clearly stops using his computer. Hes no longer sending or opening. As detectives poked around the office, how many days prior was the last Email Check . Four. That was big for me. He ran his own company with employees and activity. Going back four days which put the shooting to Thursday Night that charlie came home from cornell and he four day old Crime Scene would explain what had been obvious to the seasoned detectives. The odor of decomposition was very strong. The detec