Dignity in death for people who face suffering the reports writing in The Sunday Times Scotland news paper 9 cross party M S P's highlighted the case of Jeff Whaley an 80 year old with motor neuron disease who recently ended his life or to Dignitas facility in Switzerland in a letter the politicians claim the Tate percent of people in Scotland support a change in the law they wrote We understand there are issues around how to develop a safe and robust law the concerns that the role of palliative care would diminish but with a considered debate we can craft a law that addresses this and draws on the experience of other countries previous attempts to change the law on assisted dying in Scotland have failed the a mess P.S. Now hope to have a formal consultation on assisted suicide towards the end of this Parliament firefighters are still at the scene of a blaze answer church building in Glasgow they were called to greet George Street in the city's west end just after 3 o'clock this morning it's understood a 3 storey building was being converted into flights 6 fine engines were sent to the scene but there are no reports of casualties the husband of the jailed a British charity worker at NASA N.Z. Gary Radcliffe answer levered a Mother's Day card to the Iranian embassy in an effort to highlight talk continuing detention she denies plotting against the Iranian government unless the news know the sport with Thomas Duncan Thanks Julian Celtic have extended their lead at the top of the Premiership to 13 points after beating rivals Rangers 21 and a thrilling Darby at Celtic Park odds on Edouard gave the horse the lead and Rangers then had Alfred O'Meara last sent off for an elbow on Scott Brown but the equalized in the 2nd half through Ryan Kent's only for James Forrest to net the winner for Celtic 4 minutes from time much to the relief of his manager Neil Lennon and I'm delighted it's one the remit was before the game and we've come away with a fantastic one against a very good range of surgery motivated said and then you are mostly thrilled with the 3 points and would extend the lead of the top on a time to ask any more of the players again. At the moment well Lennon also said Rangers should have finished the game with 9 men after dying can't escape punishment for a shove to the face of Scott Brown after the Celtic captain stopped him from achieving the ball to restart the game Rangers manager Steven Gerrard believes Brown himself should have been punished for provoke provoking Rangers players while Rangers details on how they sent off after the final whistle for his part in a scuffle between both teams elsewhere in the English Premier League it's goalless at half time between Cardiff City and Chelsea the title chasing Liverpool play Tottenham later and engulf Stephen Gallacher One the Indian Open by a short to earn his 4th European Tour title despite a quadruple bogey on the 7th hole of his final round the Scot hold 5 back mine birdies to finish on one under par for the day and 9 under overall more sport coming up on sport signed with Jeff Webster after this bullet and now it's back to Joe in for a look at the weather Thank you Thomas in most parts of this often in with some spells of brightness and some sunshine a scattering of showers the will affect the Western on the Northern Isles temperatures will peak on to 10 Celsius with some light winds and the sea evening and tonight Central and Eastern parts will have a dry and chilly night with some frost in places clear spells in the West for the time but close with a few spots of rain to lose tonight of minus 2 to 4 degrees and that's the latest B.B.C. Radio Scotland nice. To be a. Force and so you don't see that try to do that for the week you would think of all the action from all the biggest games. Sports from B.B.C. B. Deal Scotland Hello and welcome back to the final 2 hours of Sunday Sport signed with Geoff Webster between 0 and 5 Athol rugby Super Saturday ended up in disappointment for board Edinburgh and Glasgow Warriors on the European stage set up a T.V. Feel someone searching. For Change points in the circuit as a final shot in the semifinal. I don't know how good it could have prepared to kill I don't want to just drop a kid so close but I wanted to be 56 points to talk to 7 o'clock think it's a good 1st thought of the book the finals without the services of boycott all those Chinese cut over the course taught us that this week too much football is good the stuff to do even your head talks about her battle back from injury and her disappointment of missing out on the recent curling World Championships it was a tough few weeks out the line if I said it was just stuck a now I'm a lot some pain like I took a lot from I think it kind of built me as a characters well and as I say we turned out we lost the Scottish final and that's all we did as a team and the decision that was made a 100 percent agree with that decision and then we dealt with those maybe some questions there and we hear from a school which he's had to wait 5 years to get his medal from the Winter Olympics as part of the British bobsled team I was expecting the kind of mixed emotions of finally receive it fairly recently here's the box at the moment this just looking before still. Think. This is great news plenty to keep us talking between now and 5 sports and sports on B.B.C. Radio go. After the phonetic nature of the Old Firm game earlier we're going to relax the piece a bit no finer exponents of strolling through our Sunday afternoon 100 a few make Donald's sportswriter who joins us no Hugh what kind of week if you had a good good weekend. Very disappointed with the rugby yesterday not Scholtz why I don't expect. It to wind you know I really didn't. Disappoint to be that we played particular footy then because of the oil and by the really good show and just didn't come up with that well I should say we build it as super Saturday as Edinburgh I'm Glasgow. Took on Monster and Saddam's sons and their respective quarterfinal ties and rugby's European Champions Cup for Edinburgh it was a case of close but not close enough even though they needed just one score going into stoppage time. In the Champions Cup All the action from all the biggest gave. Media scum. Bag and eyes ring if you were backing Edinburgh yesterday well they are joining us now we are former wires and Scotland proper Ryan Grant a former Edinburgh and Scotland international Kris Patterson who was part of our team at money fell just today and also with us Mike Duncan former Scotland winger best known for his time at West of Scotland Chris if I can come to you 1st listening back there to that was just stoppage time or part of stoppage time yesterday I mean there was still a belief for me with the gap only 4 points and I tried needed that they came so close to me here that. I mean the I think Paul did a wonderful job there because we were. Never really move that was I think it was between the $210.00 metre lights so who knows what would have been like if it had been you know carbon on the field towards a month so that means that the fans or afternoon was exceptional Peter Lorre not only to stop it but with their talk. Actually that told the discipline not to give away a penalty you know it was a 4 point difference so. We kicked a ball but it was a given the opportunity to kick different territory and try to launch against us to hold up the support to be called tackles or you know sent back to ground Gilchrist made oh no one of 2 caddies 5 American dastardly in fact that all afternoon but the my how excited you got it was actually really really comfortable to faint from start and it was a defense that basically was a store that afternoon one that won the match for them it was a thrilling game Chris and we thought it would be but tactically and the way it played out as we said would be attritional would be a bruising contest was that. Did you get we expected I think we did yeah but I think we saw that Ed Brooke go talk to Toure monster who famed for the brutality and physical it admittedly not to the levels and the last but the 18 months of couple years and then the were up when they were one of their Champions Cup but they still have that physicality about them and it brought matched up more than 4 balls to the game. As critical said afterwards and it does come down to key moments in those 23 key moments that I don't ever like to see and that's because it's so that you know bad loser completely stripped the medal L.O.L. Things went for months that I know it sounds plucky loser but you know even overthrow from the lead up to the fighting trifle key sales want to get well finished and well created in the end the start of it was that it was monsters line it was a pure thoughts and oversaw you know Edinburgh. Other vile title but in all the months a number of things went for it it just bugs towards button hole we things that I'd like you sales to correct up for the 1st try as you say just a. Quick thinking Absolutely but it's much easier to think quickly when the ball gets in your hand just at Meijer as of course was gone for the penalty so it's not as if you have to search for the ball to take it so so I'll think that when I get to. The different last of the discipline of sense how to look back Piers humans. On the type are needed moved towards him as a silly one and that was the platform that really believed the months were able to kick to the people I tried to launch for that try so very of course I do think but didn't get the right but the big moments probably need a little bit more discipline and certainly a lot more concentration right and this was monsters 18th appearance in the quarterfinals Edinburgh's 3rd is this just a case of the teams that get there more often will eventually do better than the stage because they have the experience of what to do needs to moments. You know I agree with Chris you know months there probably haven't been. There used to be but for some reason in European games the you know they can. Suck the rugby game with with you know exceptional defense and and do the small things well and discipline is one of those things that I think wants to do very well yes the beef is after some use whether it was in attack or defense and then probably just an. That kind of composure gets them over the line I guess am in these big European games that they seem to be able to come up trumps even when they're the form perhaps isn't what used to be I think is really interested in a little you know as disciplines of arena as a huge talking point. Pete for you know deal a for the Like a moment like of this one is just something that you can you can quote something as a unit that you can teach or. Something I don't know or you know it just seems an awful cough is it something that you can you can tell on somebody I think I think you can definitely put an emphasis on it. I don't know when when I came back to the Warriors It was you know the penalty count was addressed enough that every game and you know the focus of go of the team to get that down to single figures you know and it makes a huge difference I don't know Greg tones and is obviously a big advocate for for that as well and you see the teams that do when the teams give away the least amount of Yankees but then there's moments where you know it's down to the man and it's a hot headed decision or a silly decision that you know you're seen as you've done it you're like. You but then says this where you've had to it was even him perhaps behalf D.C.T. People in your own dressing room you know you've got a club. We can't afford us know how to regulate a president who is not I think there was you know there's always. You know without naming names. Saying you know a prop for instance another hall I tell you Heaven forbid you know that this maybe is good over ball or something like that and wants to keep going for them and you know sees it there and it's easy to take but we've given away a few penalties in the referee's horning you slap him on the back I mean we've all seen the classic Get your hands off the ball that is the and you just want to slap in the face. So there's there's there's instances where you know. You're trying to be more disciplined and then someone will do something silly and you'll lose your temper or summon. A sports isn't it yeah it's going to happen I mean Matt don't get much on yesterday what did you make of the overall they were but I didn't just say we don't like seeing plucky losers but they had their moments and they were they could have perhaps oh God certainly did and it would be wrong to Kemah pull the mistakes in the editors and they were killing time discipline Oh gosh. Yes And and it does as Ryan said it's how momentary lack of concentration and you pay a huge price for that but overall I thought I didn't really stayed with the task very well this is not the monster of all but it's still a decent side there's no such thing as a bad month that. We really they really didn't make the most of the opportunities they had when they had them and I think. Really at the end the last 15 minutes should have been Edinburgh's game they should have been able to close the down time and they got a bit panicky bit nervy made mistakes and else try was a gift to almost because we left that space open forum Well this was the reaction of their head coach Richard Cockrell it's a good camera people from both sides and it was going to come down to fine Arjun's and we were right well we're so desperately disappointed. But very proud of the performance and it's something that we've got to build on you know it's not a lot to lose I want to win. But I don't think the team could have given any more try. 131010 minutes to go did you think if we see this or we can see this oh it's already expecting some kind of late for what I said once or to produce our now you think you can win the game because we played really well we tactics were good we play probably more. Than they did. You know so like tackling our turn we retaliate or whatever that looks like I'm not sure it's a reverse penalty they overthrow the law and now the ball bounces their way and they end up scoring from the the ensuing play so it's those 4 and 4 margins and that we had opportunities in the 1st off to take maybe take points but you know I kickers weren't comfortable so it's the corners where opportunities this fall and fall and margins are so look I mean you guys watched it it was one hell of a battle wasn't it and they were great saw it and you know we're talking about a real completing in Europe quarter finals against big teams. Look at their reaction about beating us it says everything about the respect that we've got so we're getting there but it's yeah I'm pretty cheesed off that we we didn't get the result with us last is there anything more you could have done you say players gave you everything you know look it's a game it's a good it's a sport you know things happen referees decision the bounce of a ball things go against you you have opportunities you take and don't take the same with them we have some massive moments you know the scrum penalty Well I don't think the Edinburgh players could have given an ounce more today I thought D'Arcy was great at fullback he did some great things I thought we know that phase of play at the end you know we're battling battling at the death to try and win the game and it says a lot about what we're doing here. And I hate the sort of you know you have to go through the pain before you get to the you know the good bits at the end I'm just talking about actually that they've been quarterfinals you this is your 3rd Yeah I know but it still hurts because. It wasn't as if they were much better than us and we hung in there we were as good as them today you know and we're talking about when as you know when we've both got all our players available both teams we are as good as monster who are one hell of a team and consistently very very good so we should take some pride in that but. Yeah. Plucky loses not really nothing at all. Richard Clarke you losers I mean that's that's no good see it affected your I mean the of pride with your team but the fact that you came up short is that's that's of no worth to you as a basket of one disc you owe you a 100 percent and we've got to learn to do that part of learning it you know it doesn't always just go your way does it and you know you get to a procession you end up in semifinal and fall you win your log you've got to have a bit of luck and you'll be very good so. It's good building blocks for us so I'm not going to throw all of it why people want to be negative about a solution today I don't care what those people have to study because actually what we're doing here is really good and we've got some great players who are working really hard work great stuff this is a proper a big club that is now competing in on the big stage and if we can play like that in the next 3 games hopefully we'll be in playoffs in the process what do you think they learned you know when they when they're when everything dies down what you think they'll have learned from today I think in the big moments you have to take your chances you have to be composed you can't give a silly penalty where you can't be a few feet on the goal on and they approach the ball all the. Little bit and you have to learn and you only learn it by doing it and there's no you know there's no easy way of learning it months or about some 3 days in Europe you know. Cause a lot of. You know we were talking earlier about the season 2000 when less than one it you know the semifinal to the crossbar and then the post it went over to beat scholars and then they'll back nick the ball astern his hands to us to win the game at the end so it's a bit of luck and you got to be a very good team and you got a bit of both I think we're a very good team I think we were probably a little bit unlucky today I mean you guys watched it was one game in rugby wasn't really nobody's going away disappointed pretty different top of rugby to so the next time you might see on T.V. This afternoon but very very proud of Edinburgh as a as a club we deserve a huge amount of credit. But now we have to get better and we got to get a Scarlets next week next week and have a similar performance and we're going to get all stay and have a better performance and. They want to test this again you have been if you miss out in Europe next season of year you nightmarish because you've had a whale of a time this is yeah we've just got to be to we've got to keep developing as a team now 2 years ago. we start this project we want to be more consistent this year we've dropped off a little bit and we've just got a keep developing no teen develops room where we of come from in 2 years to be the best in europe all the burst in the pro 14 it takes to on we're building oh we have a plan every year were got to get better and we got to start a join of up together would leak to europe and and be out of to to to complete on 2 fronts and do it better you know we were a good team we don't sing great things we just need to do it better and as well as months that i'm lentz the and all those big teams in europe and finally richard when you go to rejoin the players in the dressing room are afterwards what what do you see it on tonight it world done be proud of you performance but we have to learn a we have to wouldn't neck start and let's get prepared for next week in we get i'm appear and we're going to eat and enjoy each of the stop me rob is meant to be fun the games dan we couldn't of given any more i don't think so there's nothing to be embarrassed or ashamed of in fact a really thin on i'm very proud of how we plight that structured cocked all there are with you mean donald and myself this afternoon we have rang grant matt duncan and crist