Competent opinions. Information marathon with mykola veresny saturday 17 10, sunday 18 15. Events, events that are happening right now and affect our lives. Of course, the news feed reports on them, but few know what is happening. It is necessary to understand. Antin borkovskii and invited experts soberly assess events, analyze them, and model them ours every saturday at 13 10 with a repeat on sunday at 10 10. Studio zahid with Anton Borkovsky at espresso. Well, now oleg hrybachuk, former head of president viktor yushchenkos secretariat, former vice Prime Minister for european integration of ukraine, and cofounder of the chesna movement will work on the air of the tv channel. Glory to ukraine, mr. Oleg, congratulations. Glory to heroes. Extremely. A serious earthquake in the president s office, a number of leading specialists, in different positions, with different biographies, different histories of relations with volodymyr zelenskyi, were removed from their positions, this matter was preceded by the resignation of the secretary of the National Security and Defense Council of ukraine oleksiy danilov, well, some explanations were given in connection with the transfer to a more, so to speak, suitable position, well. The head of the Diplomatic Mission in moldova, well, actually, i do not perceive it as some kind of tsunami at all, it is Something Like a light spring breeze, trofimov, well, these are the people who led Volodymyr Oleksandrovich under the white hands to the pedestals of all olympians, so when it happened, it was in the era before yermakovsk, and before yermakov era it is ended a long time ago, and that is why i agree with those. Who say, not without reason, that in fact , with these decisions, yermak, like the cuckoo that laid, that is, yermak in the form of an egg, which at one time got to bank street, hatched and threw away all the others , here it is also important to understand that the heads of the president , they are of two categories, those who believe that they simply have to ensure his work, do not get in there. In front of the public, in front of the cameras, but do so that the president has the maximum a wellthoughtout policy so that he is aware of what is happening, to provide him with versatile, multivector access to information, and there are others who believe that they are not the first, but also not the second, so the others, they always have, and it is very interesting, for example, i had three deputies, my viktor bologas successor, there were already 11 or more of them, but yermak also has a dozen of them there now, maybe more, and therefore, when these deputies are replaced, it means that it is definitely not zelenskys decision, because zelensky is quick, not most likely, but i know for sure that only yermamak communicates with the president , and apart from yermak, no one, especially some of his deputies, there are a dozen of them, they have nothing to do with bohdan, and most likely, zelensky trusted him the most as a friend. Therefore, issues such as contacts with oligarchs are discussed by everyone, i. E. Some very sensitive, intimate for president zelenskyi, the intimate issue in quotation marks was decided by the shefir, but the shefir left after that attempt, about which they probably already forgot about him, and in fact, i think , this could not have been yermaks decision, but it should have been shefirs and zelenskyis mutual decision, because well, this function simply disappeared during the war, but all these personnel reshuffles in. They, i am sure, were initiated and controlled by yermak, and this is a very harmful structure for president zelenskyi, because he was, yes and remains in monopoly. Yarmak from the point of view of who he meets, what information he receives, who can have access to him to zelenskyi, and among other things, this also explains the situation with the secretary of the National Security council, because in the constitution of ukraine, the National Security council is the body, the only body that is mentioned in the institute of the president , because there is no office, secretariat, administration of the president , nothing is said about it there, and the National Security council is really the body that. The president , the president who believes in a collegial decision that wants to make policy, hear all the arguments there, this is the body that allows the president to gather at the highest level members of the government, politicians and anyone, really, whom the president considers important and influential, and therefore those president s who are inclined to collegial decisions, and we there were very few of them, they could use the National Security council for. A better National Security council was constructed then by volodymyr horbulin, and i worked with him, i tried to return that council format, but it is important to understand that the decisions of the National Security council come into effect by president ial decree of ukraine, and if egos begin to be measured there, the head of the secretariat or the head of the president S Administration and the secretary of the National Security and Defense Council, the secretary of the National Security and Defense Council always loses, because there were a number of examples when there were even some decisions there. Formally approved at the security council, and this is it a large round table, there are many people who speak, someone takes minutes, well, somewhere there something is written as in the Verkhovna Rada, but the final document is issued by the president ial office, the president ial office, the president ial administration, and therefore at some point, probably danilov has this happened because danilov went a little independent, not a little, but seriously into independent swimming, he was no longer interested there, he started working as a newsmaker. There and it was a matter of time, and it is obvious that on this, on this basis, he had problems with yurmak, because danilov most likely did not agree with his public statements there for the last six months and could be another source of influence on the president that yermak did not like, i think that this and besides that danilov was simply already there and he was fed up there to be, it was visible, mr. Oleg, i would like to ask you, that is, the departure of shefir, the departure of trofimov . This means that the president ial communication with various, so to speak, certain directions will be somewhat narrowed, because the shefir is also a private direction, trofimov was responsible for that other regional policy, yes, if yermak has, i dont know, i think there are 10 or how many deputies, well, that means that none of these deputies, i insist on this, really have nothing there does not affect, he cannot in. Go oneonone to a meeting with the president and convey his point of view to the president , the fair stands firmly there, that is, the structure of the office, where there are a dozen or more deputies, she says that the head of this service, he does not delegate anything to anyone, its just like that, its such a labyrinth, you know, a variety of different positions, people are responsible for something, but they submit all documents and all proposals to the head of the office, and he already. If he deems it necessary, he can give access to the body only in his presence there, or support one or the other idea, because if you delegate, well, there should be one or two deputies, and these deputies should really work, you should meet every day, as we did with all the heads of divisions, and discuss the agenda, this is definitely not the case at the bank now, and therefore i share the point of view of those people who say that this is actually a strengthening or. Such a reservation of the monopoly of the head of yermaks office on access to the president , well , there is nothing new here, we already had such people, we had tabachnik, we had him there medvedchuk, they all ended badly in the end, and both those people and those president s around whom such a monopoly was created, because this monopoly can be called differently, you can call it a bubble, you can call it a bunker, when you really lose contact with the outside world , and when you is delegated by the president to. A lot, and the opportunity to check the quality of your analytics or, well, there is no one who can act as an alternative to some, well, i dont know, to critics or to offer some other options, and therefore this this this this this harmful formula, it, well look at the degradation of putin, there is far to go, any president who freezes or ferments in the same environment, in the same place, he inevitably intellectually. Politically degrades, or begins to make, so to speak, certain transformations, well, in particular, we remember, was bohdan, there is no bohdan and so on, there may be some kind of broader front. I dont know any changes, maybe consolidation, so we have a rate, we have an office, we have a National Security and Defense Council, and maybe there will be some, i dont know, synergy. The second thing that worries me is the feeling that in our country, the key body, the Verkhovna Rada of ukraine, is somehow selfresetting itself, or is being reset to zero with the help of someones will, so here is the rating, a sociological agency did a study, evidence of a drop in trust in the parliament, and at the same time we understand that there is. A decrease in trust and to of the president , that is, during the war, a decrease in trust is not good, it is a certain danger and we remember very well how important functions the parliament has always been able to perform, our viewers or listeners, many of them will not agree, because well , they dont like our deputies, they call them viewers, call them whatever you want, because as for deputies, we havent seen a single broadcast of the meeting of the president s office there. Right, and we dont know much there about how the government works, maybe theyll show a few minutes of opening there cabinet, and the Prime Minister will say something, but we see a lot of stories, because the deputies have their own telegram channels, they conduct their own communications, there are just some public scandals, a lot of attention, and this attention is mostly positive for parliament, although i confirm that the entire turbulent history of ukraine in the most threatening times, when it seemed that our ship is now. Ukraine will simply crash on the reefs, it was the parliament that acted as the navigator who led between these reefs, i recently met a deputy i know there, and the main question, i i say that what oppresses you there the most, he says that it is the impossibility of actually going abroad, because it sounds very humiliating, a lot of deputies are really in order to implement their projects, i will not describe this project very much, but the project is absolutely normal, man. He is working on a project for ukraine, he needs to do it somewhere in the baltics or in warsaw, and then go to brussels somewhere, and he says that it is very humiliating, you have to stand in line there for six months to the speaker, to explain, and you will be released if you go to a conditional meeting in warsaw, and then you still go to brussels, then you will have to explain the reports there, because it is being investigated by the border guards, that is, this factor, which has already been talked about, turns out to be. For many unconscious deputies, because what do you influence then, well, you obviously dont influence the government, because the president s office already does it all there, you re not, you dont have a broadcast, you cant have any informational influence there, because the marathon there has a clear list of whom invite someone no, and as a result, many deputies simply do not see any sense in the fact that they are deputies, well, those who came to earn cannot earn, because there is someone to earn without them, they are simply. Wiped off, you can only earn , if you give the lions share to the main center of power there, and this is not the parliament, this is the president s office, that is, you have some schemes to interfere, this is also, this is also an amateur, and if you want to change something in the country, then you perfectly understand that you no one calls you anything, and zelenskys meeting with deputies, and thats already a lot of people confirmed that it was the president s monologue, and the deputies could not insert their 5 kopecks there, that is, the obvious crisis is such a thing. Plus they dont see their future, usually, if you are a deputy, well, every politician wants to see their political future, well, not everyone, but many who want to see their political future, here they dont see it, they definitely understand that most of them have none the lists will not get there, it is not known what will happen with the elections, in a word, they are demoralized, they do not influence the government, they do not influence the voters, they should or should do whatever they want they will say, or crawl there on your knees. So that, on the one hand, the parliament was not a serious competitive center, i dont know, but on the other hand, it was an Insurance Center that could sometimes perform lightning rod missions, that is, we understand, there are unpopular decisions, collective responsibility, it is very often, you know smears this particular responsibility and, here we understand that a certain, i dont know, conscious or unconscious campaign of discrediting is going on, respectively. Maybe it smells of one or the other electoral moments, although we understand that the constitution says no, it is the same thing that is wanted and it stings, so it is obvious that let us remind ourselves that this is the first time we have a parliament in which the president had a single majority as a political force, we have never had this during the years of independence, and it is not the first time, the traditionally propresident ial force, after a few years of the president being in. In office, it starts to rain, and the closer to the elections, the less influential it is, and it is already there competition for who will be the next president ial power, and here there are problems, because it is already clear. That the servant of the people as a brand has already served its purpose, it has no chance of repeating its success there, and for bankova street, on the one hand , i would really like to see some, well, young blood come, for example, if people started coming to the parliament from the list, it would be guaranteed, in a normal political force, it would be guaranteed. But those people who are in the team, who are there, well, who share the ideology of the conditional party, but we know that for sure a third of the deputies are the current servants of the people, those who compiled those lists never thought in their lives that these people would get into the parliament, so there are a lot of completely random people, and you can afford the quality of those who are even lower there, because you just had to fill in there 40050 or how many 300 people to give, and there was a lot of writing, so its not a cut either. And and accordingly, none of the president s, this is also not news, each of the president s did not want to have a strong parliament, well, each of the president s was annoyed by the parliament, they tried to control it, somehow to coexist, but it is a very difficult story, and there is shmyhal, and someone else may come instead of shmygal, or what do you think, are these premature talks about replacing the head of the government, well, first of all, he is already a record holder, a Prime Minister. Secondly, from those rumors out there, and this is what i believe, i believe that irmak sees himself as the Prime Minister at night, well, because he understands how much it is possible to follow zelensky a little to control everything everywhere, and such type of heads of secretariats, like yermak, baloga, tabachnyk, medvedchuk, all of them they had this vision that after, they understood that you can be in this position forever, for them it was a dream to become the Prime Minister. In my opinion, none of the heads of the administration became Prime Minister, but perhaps in the current conditions, yermak has such a dream, that is , such legalization would not be very beneficial to yermak, because then he would have to be really responsible for something, but now he is not for which he is not responsible, well, you havent seen him take responsibility for anything, some there, he, he, he is not responsible, there is no Job Description for him, we dont know, for what can you ask him, journalists write about the fact that he is such a personnel man, who is tall. He puts his friends on bread trade winds, but it will not end in anything, so whether it will be good for the country or whether it will change something, i do not know, well , because this will most likely lead to an inevitable conflict with zelenskyi, and again from the point of view of management, management will not improve, because i do not imagine yermak, but a collegial head of the cabinet of ministers, who will be there to listen, where they will have some meetings, to talk. Some things, listening to opponents, i. E. Cooperating with the parliament, it is very difficult with those individuals, look, but why exactly these changes took place right now in the spring, yes, that is, they could have happened, i dont know, three months ago, they could have been postponed for a couple of months, but it went, such a process started and it went quite quickly, although i say, i repeat, nothing portends the possibility or prospect of the same parliamentary elections, well, the meeting of the president you already mentioned. With his faction, yes, well, she could be different, i dont know, warmer, more promising, that is, it would be possible to somehow show the great prospects of individual Political Development and so on, no, quite, quite, i would say so, it was tough, tough, and they could just the president had to give the deputies the opportunity to