Im tyler mathisen. On wall street, it was the first threeday win streak for stocks this year. But we begin tonight with the battle between Silicon Valley and the federal government. Apple will fight a court order to help the fbi unlock an iphone used by one of the San Bernardino shooters. The decision sets up a legal showdown between the Worlds Largest publicly traded company and federal Law Enforcement. One side citing privacy, the other national security. Eamon javers has more on this escalating confrontation. Reporter a dramatic standoff today between the fbi and apple. The fbi wants access to the cell phone of one of the shooters in the San Bernardino terrorist attack back in december. They say they simply cant get into that phone. They want Apple Computers help and theyve gotten a court order from a judge that would order apple to do that. Heres what the order says. The judge saying that the Apple Computer engineers have to come up with some kind of system or software that would bypass or disable the iphones auto erase function so the phone wont delete itself when the fbi tries to get in there. It would eble the fbi to have access to that phone, either through a device port, through bluetooth, through wifi or some other way to get into the phone, and also that the Apple Software engineers would have to ensure that that particular phones software wont delay the fbi as they try to use whats called brut force to crack into that phone, that is, dialing up random numbers on the passcode in order to just guess by pure chance what the password is to that phone. The fbi thinking if they can do that at computer speed, they can simply enter in millions of passwords until they get the right one and get access to the information on that phone, which they say is crucial to their investigation. Meanwhile, tim cook at apple saying that that company is going to resist this court order. Heres what he had to say yesterday, saying, opposing this order is not something we take lightly. We feel we must speak up in the face of what we see as an overreach by the u. S. Government. We are challenging the fbis demand with the deepest respect for american democracy and a love for our country. And guys, not at all clear here where this goes from here, but apple has a number of days now to respond to this court order. Failing that, we could see this go up to the court of appeals, and ultimately, this is the kind of case that could be heard before the supreme court. Back to you. We have two guests now with opposing views on this battle between apple and the federal government. Susan land yao is professor of Cyber Security policy and supports apple, and ron hosco is former assistant director at the fbi and now president of the Law EnforcementLegal Defense fund. He says the governments request is narrow and reasonable. Susan, let me start with you. There is a big issue here. A lot of people may not even realize how secure their phones are at this particular time, but now they realize that. And the issue with apple has to do with one phone. The doj says they just want that one phone. Why is it such an issue when its only that one device . Because in order to do this, apple has to write a piece of software that while it is targeted at that one phone, can be reused, as long as one has apples, whats called signin key, in order to use it on other phones, and then it becomes very dangerous, because apples signin key now becomes the target, for example, for nation states to go after, because that would unlock other peoples phones. And given the way we use our phones, thats exceedingly dangerous, including for national security. Ron will take the other side of this. Why do you think tim cook is wrong . Well, i think this order that was issued in california is very narrow. We are talking about a phone that the fbi is in lawful possession of after this horrific terrorist incident, that the county has consented to a search of because it was the countys phone possessed by a terrorist. And what the order requires and expects is that apple take reasonable steps to develop the tools to get in there. That doesnt necessarily equate with the fbi driving away with the tools. What the fbi wants is the data from the phone, which is potentially evidence of a crime, evidence of a broader conspiracy. So, ron, could all of this be done in apples offices . They just unlock that phone, get the data that the fbi needs, provide the fbi with that data without giving them the whole backdoor process to the way that they actually were able to get the data from the phone . That is my understanding of the order. The order does not contemplate the fbi being handed over the encryption or the decryption tools or software that could act upon other phones. This is much more narrow. What the fbi is looking for, reasonably and responsibly, is the data. But this does lead us into the broader conversation. Mmhmm. Sadly here, the terrorist attack is over. And where the fbi wants to be is in front of a terrorist attack the next time so it can defeat it. Susan, play out for me this scenario that i sense you are you fear in response to what appears to be a Reasonable Court order to go after a device that was owned by a terrorist murderer. Play it out. Why should we, the users of cell phones, be worried that apple would have the ability to unlock a phone that is now not unlockable. Right. So, ten years ago, before the iphone what we had was a situation where corporate data was accessed through blackberrys, which were quite secure. But as soon as the iphone was developed and then the android, apps became really important and people started carrying iphones and androids and then started using them at work. Now we have byod, bring your own device. So, while somebody working in the department of defense or in the Defense Industrial base of lockheed martha imartin or mart marietta or one of those companies, those people carry two phones, one for work, one for their own personal information. But almost everybody else carries just one phone, and that phone not only has their family photos and their mail with their spouse, but it also has access to work, and it sometimes has Work Information on it. And those phones then become very interesting to nation states, whether theyre a lawyer, an employee at ford, an employee at some other u. S. Company. The information there is really important. If apple makes creates software that enables it to unlock a single device, that software will enable it to unlock other devices, and then that software and apples signin key become a real target for other nation states, and we make ourselves less secure. Are you concerned, susan, that this also sets a precedent . Again, what if its just as narrow and reasonable, as ron suggests it may be, and we are only talking about one phone that could be unlocked, again, at apple without the fbi really having access to the process of unlocking . Is your concern that this then would open a precedent, though, for requests to come from another country, perhaps . Im absolutely concerned that, you know, a businessperson, a u. S. Businessperson is traveling in russia, is traveling in china, is traveling in many other countries in the world, and the governments there go to apple and they say we know you know how to unlock the phone, do it. It could be a u. S. Businessperson, a german, a french person, a brit. The point is that we are only as secure as the device is secure, and thats where the risk is. Were also at risk because the software can be stolen. It would be nice to say apple has amazing security, but we know from the opm hack where the chinese went into the u. S. Government office of Personnel Management and stole records, we know from many other hacks just how determined nation state actors are. Well, well see and thats the concern. There is a concern, but well have to see whether apple is able to prevail here or whether they will have to comply with that court order. And of course, it could go, as eamon said, to the supreme court. Susan landow and ron hasko, thank you. Wall street sees its first threeday win streak this year helped by a rebound in oil prices, decent Economic Data and upbeat reports. The dow gained to 16,453. Nasdaq added 98. S p 500 exited correction territory with a gain of 31 points. Also had its first backtobacktoback gains of 1 or more since october 2011. Tyler, as for that Economic Data, wholesale prisions ticked higher in january, offering hints of inflation in an economy looking for it. The Producer Price index rose 0. 1 last month, and that was stronger than the decline that economists had been looking for. Core prices, which exclude food and energy, rose 0. 4 , the biggest onemonth jump in 15 months. A reading on industrial production, thats a broad measure of everything made by manufacturers, mines, utilities, up in january after three straight months of declines. Some economists say the 0. 9 rise should alay fears that the economys headed for recession and suggests the Manufacturing Sector may be weathering weak demand globally all right. The rebound last month being attributed to strong car sales. But the latest housing data wasnt as strong. The Commerce Department reports that new Home Construction fell nearly 4 in january, and thats the second straight monthly decline, which some say is due to snow in the northeast. Weve certainly had a lot of it. Despite the drop, though, many economists feel the fundamentals of the Housing Market remain strong. At the last Federal Reserve meeting, many policymakers werent sure whether the u. S. Economy could withstand the turmoil in Global Financial markets. According to the minutes of the january meeting, members of the fed saw more pronounced downside risks, and as Hampton Pearson reports, their outlook for the economy was growing increasingly cloudy. Reporter when monetary policymakers met at the end of january, concerns about commodity and Financial Market volatility and the economic slowdown in china raised concerns about the impact on the u. S. Economy. According to the minutes from the fed meeting, it was enough for fed members to decide they would move slowly and cautiously along the path of raising Interest Rates. Fed chair janet yellen echoed those concerns during two days of congressional testimony last week, and longtime fedwatchers see little likelihood of an Interest Rate hike in march. They didnt act in late january, and i think they wont act in march. Theres a lot of emphasis there on Global Developments and instability. So, i think theyre on hold for a while. Reporter stocks held on to gains after the release of the fed minutes. Monetary policymakers say market volatility so far this year has been a factor in figuring out a timetable for raising Interest Rates. Those policymakers also want to see proof of inflation moving closer to the feds 2 target. But marketwatchers say the fed needs to send a clearer signal. If they hold to the increases that theyre implying, you know, the market is not going to be able to move forward. We really do need the fed to take their foot off the accelerator, ratchet back those rate increases maybe just to 1 , 2 . Reporter those fed minutes also shed light on why chair janet yellen says rate hike policy is on no preset course. On the one hand, there is a u. S. Economy with strong fundamentals offset by global uncertainty. For nightly Business Report, im Hampton Pearson in washington. Still ahead, the high cost of cheap crude to one part of the transportation sector. Oil prices moved back above 30 a barrel on hopes of a deal among some Oil Producers to freeze production. Domestic crude rose about 5. 5 . Iran says it welcomes the saudi russian deal to freeze production that we told you about yesterday but stopped short of committing to hold back output. And despite todays price rise, many who follow the Energy Markets remain skeptical such an agreement will ever materialize. For years, oil shippers preferred to move crude by train, rather than by pipeline to save on cost, but the economics have changed. And as Morgan Brennan reports from linden, new jersey, thats pushing the crudebyrail business off the tracks. Reporter from 2008 to 2014, as fracking boomed, so did the business of hauling oil by train. During that time period, crudebyrail surged 5,000 , peaking at just over a Million Barrels per day in the Third Quarter of 2014. But as crude prices have collapsed, volumes for the biggest railroads have tumbled by nearly a quarter. According to the association of American Railroads. When Oil Production starts to drop, so does moving oil drop. And one of the areas thats been the most affected has been the light sweet crude that comes out of the balkan and the larger percentage which went on rail. Reporter the larger trains that haul crude rail come from the bakken formation. Jenscape estimates 1. 2 Million Barrels of day of frail capacity, but only 350,000 barrels are being loaded currently, down almost half from a year ago. The process of hauling to the refineries is less economical because its expensive and imported crude is more attra attractive once again to those refineries. Now, oils still a small piece, only 2 of overall business for the railroads, but it was a fastgrowing, highmargin one. Its also throwing a number of Infrastructure Projects into question, including how much oil this philips 66 refinery, bayway, will continue to accept via rail. The slump is beginning to affect rail Car Manufacturers and Leasing Companies like greenbrier companies, trinity industries, American RailCar Industries and gatx. After a Record Number of deliveries in 2015, analysts say rail car demand has begun to weaken. All of those items have combined to form a headwind in this market, and weve seen rail car backlog fall by roughly 20 from peak levels a year ago. Reporter but there have been some winners as well, particularly grain shippers. Over the last two winters, when oil trains still took precedence in the dakotas, many agricultural customers suffered steep delivery delays. That dynamic has reversed. And while the grain market is struggling with its own headwinds, railroad gridlock is no longer one of them. For nightly Business Report, im Morgan Brennan in linden, new jersey. Priceline reports higherthanexpected quarterly profit, and thats where we begin tonights market focus. A rise in hotel and rental car bookings lifted results and helped offset the effect of a strong dollar. Ceo darren hustin is also attributing the results to a decline in the price of gas. One of the things people underestimated was travel specifically really benefits from lower oil prices, and were seeing in particular that macro effect having a positive impact on our business. Shares gained more than 11 to 1,232. 56. Shopifys revenue doubled in its Fourth Quarter, thanks in part to a strong Holiday Shopping season. The Ecommerce Companies make software that helps retailers manage online stores. Shopify also issued an upbeat outlook for 2016 and said it expects to see a jump in revenue as high as 61 . Thats as a Record Number of new merchants recently signed up for the service. Shares of shopify rose 9 to 22. 37. And garmin, maker of gps devices and wearable fitness products, reported a 37 drop in profit for its last quarter, but that was still good enough to beat the streets estimates. Revenue also came in above targets, and the company forecasted fullyear revenue to come in above expectations, but it does expect profit to lag. Garmin shares still rose more than 16 to 41. 06. Bloomin brands, operator of outback steakhouse, saw a decline in both profit and revenue for its most recent quarter, as samestore sales fell across all four of its brands. As part of a restructuring effort, the company said it would close 14 of its Bonefish Grill locations. The Company Also Announced a new 250 million Share Buyback program. Shares of bloomin lost more than 10 today to 15. 10. Similar story at the newspaper publisher gannett. It saw its sales and profit fall for the Fourth Quarter as a result of lower advertising demand and declining circulation. The company said it expects the declines to continue through the year. Shares down more than 7 to 14. 24. And Sherwin Williams announced a Quarterly Dividend increase of 25 . Shareholders will be paid 84 cents a share on friday, march 11th. The paint company has increased its dividend get this for 37 consecutive years. Shares up fractionally to 259. 15. Now heres a good story. A dairy farmer, a Convenience