Kathryns lifeless body found in the river. She said, accidents can happen. I said, this was no accident. Kathryns husband agreed. They told people she was drinking, she was crying and threatened to kill herself. Suicide . Her friend didnt buy it. Somebody had done this to her. This investigator thought so, too. I had to lay it all out on this huge conference table. And i said, wait a minute. Unearthing two sh the andersons heard her die. A dark and damning tale. But would a jury believe it . I made a promise that i will find out who did this and i will make sure that theyre brought to justice. Im lester holt and this is dateline. Heres Keith Morrison with the reckoning. Dreams seem to flow downstream somehow, carried by or to sorrow. Here is where they came, the newlyweds, to their own beautiful river, their montana eden, where they dreamed their dreams. And where now these decades later the silent water may finally give up their secrets. Theres never been anything thats bn day. Sherry harper is talking about a mystery that seemed beyond solving. The inexplicable thing that happened to her, sherrys sister, kathryn. You tell people, and youre hearing yourself speak. And youre thinking this is like something you see on tv. Do they understand . They dont. And how could we possibly expect them to . And so you go back to the beginning. You search for the answer in the past. Together. This is kathryns childhood best friend, melissa. Either she was at my house or im at her house constantly. Like sisters in a way . We were. We were. We played together. She just had such a zest for life. The memories are idyllic, said melissa. Under the sun in the Swimming Pool in kathryns backyard. She taught me to swim. Sherry was the big sister, kathryn the youngest with a brother, thomas, wedged in between them. She was a champion equestrian rider. She wanted to continue that and then go to veterinary school. So, yes, she loved animals. But most of all she loved him. He was a part of her life every single day. His name was ralph. And it was her child. One of those little yes, he was a person. He thought he was a member of that family, and he was. Was with her at college, Southern Methodist in dallas, where she scored as and row crew, jumped horses and was captain of smus polo team. There one day on the grassy polo field she met a boy. Brian. Brian laird, another polo player, son of an imminent eye doctor. He was prela before too long they were living together. And in the summer, working together in ft. Smith, montana, population 161. Its a tiny little town. And you get to know everybody really well. And Everybody Knows pretty much what everybody else is doing. That theres a town at all is due to the bighorn river on which june and gordon rose ran a tackle shop and lodge. Mecca. It just had such a massive population of fish per mile. Theres only half a dozen places like that in the world. Brian worked as a fishing guide, kathryn worked in the tackle shop. They had both just graduated. Theyd come to the river in the summer, you know, for summer jobs. And then after brian finished law school, in the winter of 1999, they got married. The newlyweds moved to billings, montana, where brian set up a kathryn put vet school on hold to help brian run the office. But brians heart wasnt really in the law. Not when the bighorn was calling. So they bought a mobile home in fort smith. Ft. Smith. And the two of them picked up where their summer jobs left off. We didnt use him very often as a guide. But we did let him carry a tab in the store. He seemed really timid around delightful is the word that comes to my mind. Very vibrant, intelligent, devoted. Devoted to what . To brian. Oh, okay. She was working three jobs that summer. Thats true. She worked in our store, cleaned rooms at another lodge and then the shuttle business. And she was a really hardworking. Never showed up for work late. All that spring and early summer of 1999, brian and the other ft. Smith fly fishing outfitters worked the river dawn till dark. And the current carried fish and dreams and sparkling flies and darker things. It was the morning of july 31st. One of kathryns coworkers burst into the tackle shop. Have you seen her . She didnt show up for work. Did she say anything to you . I said, no. We havent seen or heard from her. And so the other person that was working with me that day said, well, ill run over to their trailer and check on brian. But brian, roused from a deep sleep, had no idea where kathryn was. Somehow, in the middle of the night, she had vanished into the vast wilderness of montana. When we come back, the search for kathryn is on. A friend makes a stunning discovery in the river. She alerted brian right away. Right away. And a family grapples with the unthinkable. I just remember lots of hysterical crying, screaming. Down came the rain and clogged the gutter system creating a leak in the roof. Luckily the spider recently had geico help him with homeowners insurance. Water completely destroyed his swedish foam mattress. Ng is 25. Call geico and see how much you could save on homeowners insurance. Mr. Clean gets tough on dirt and grime and grease in just a minute mr. Clean will clean your whole house and every room thats in it hes so tough, he cleans em all mr. Clean yeah, so moms got this cold. Hashtag stuffy nose. Hashtag no sleep. I got it. Hashtag mouthbreather. Yep. Weve got a mouthbreather. Well, just put on a breathe right strip and. Pow it instantly opens your nose up to 38 more than Cold Medicine alone. Shut your mouth and say goodnight mouthbreathers. Breathe right. Colleen loves helping the environment. And dale, well he loves colleen. They have their differences. And at least they agree one thing. New tide purclean its the first biobased detergent. With the cleaning power of tide. So you can actually clean your clothes and still. Do your part. New tide purclean. The first biobased detergent with the cleaning power of tide. If its got to be clean, i had frequent heartburn, but. My doctor recommended prilosec otc 7 years ago, 5 years ago, last week. Just 1 pill each morning. 24 hours and zero heartburn, its been the number 1 doctor recommended brand for 10 straight years, and its still recommended today. A terrible dread spread up and down the bighorn river that morning of july 31, 1999, when Kathryn Laird failed to turn up for work. A missing persons report was filed. Brian, her distraught husband, went up and down the river so did her neighbors. And pretty one one of them, driving past a reservoir the locals call the after bay, saw something in the water. Looked human. She alerted brian right away. She alerted the authorities right away. Brian laird raced to the after bay, plunged into the freezing water, carried the body to shore. It was kathryn. It was too late. She was just 28 years old. Enforcement had arrived. It was crazy. Many entities out there. You got fbi, you got dia, you got the park service, you got county jurisdiction, you have state jurisdiction. But it was the fbi whose agent took charge of the scene. Kathryn was found wearing sweatpants and a shirt and a bra, but no shoes or socks. Her white 4runner was located in a parking lot about 100 yards from where her body was found. Inside the vehicle they found her purse, eyeglasses, some prescription antidepressants of brians and a half empty bottle of tequila. The shellshocked brian was driven 40 miles to a doctor in hardin, montana, and sedated. And 1,000 miles away in texas, sherry got a call from her mother. She says, she just received this horrible telephone call from brian. All he kept saying was, theres hysterical crying, screaming. My mom just saying, shes gone. Sherry rushed to her mothers house. Thats when she said, kathryn drowned. And i said, no, she did not. And she said, accidents can happen. And i said, no. I assure you this was no accident. My sister would not drown. Did you have an idea what happened . No. At that time i really didnt. Neither did im like, who are you talking about drowned . She could swim. What are you talking about . Not just swim but swim. Yes. All i could picture was the Swimming Pool. A distraught family flew to montana. Brian met us at the airport. What sort of state was he in . Very lethargic. You could tell he was taking something. Yeah. To calm him down. What happened . The night before, said brian, he and kathryn argued for hours. Sleep, he said, and she, agitated, upset, woke him up, asked him to take care of ralph as if she was never coming back to the dog she loved since a child, then got into her 4runner and drove away into the night. Last time he saw her alive, he said. She must have taken his pills with her. That tequila, must have downed so much booze and medication that she must have d accidentally or much more likely, he said, she committed suicide. Brarns parents had arrived and they had some hard questions about kathryns family about her emotional state. How long had kathryn been depressed . And both of us are like, what are you talking about . Well, thats how she died. She apparently took pills and drank an excessive amount of alcohol and she drowned. There was an autopsy, of course. Two, in fact. And this was odd, given the pills in her vehicle and half there wasnt any alcohol in her body. No trace of those pills, either. Two medical examiners agreed on the cause of death. Poor kathryn had drowned. But as for the manner of death . Accident . Suicide . Homicide . They just couldnt say. So it was ruled undetermined. Wed made all the emergencyments through the arrangements home so she could be flown home so we could say our goodbyes. Five days after her death, brian took ralph the dog and left ft. Smith for missouri, where he moved in with his parents. And along the river, life went on. The fishing season was peaking, so much to do. And the sad story of the beautiful young woman who had drowned herself in the icy after bay faded, as stories will. Not forgotten, not exactly. But over. Not by a longshot. I made a promise to her when i saw her in her casket that i will find out who did this to her. And i will make sure that theyre brought to justice. Coming up kathryns family begins its own investigation and is troubled by the findings. When Kathryn Laird was found dead in the bighorn river and her family was told she had drowned, they were profoundly skeptical. They knew kathryn was a powerful swimmer. A water accident seemed most unlikely. As for suicide, they didnt buy it. Kathryn phoned home often, they said, and never sounded depressed. And even though the medical examiners left manner of death the fbi was suspicious, too. Of brian. So agent Randy Jackson called him at his folks home in missouri. He didnt offer much. Im just totally in the dark here. I dont know if my wife you know, if she died because she took too many sleeping pills. I have no idea. In a series of phone calls, jackson tried to cajole him back to montana to discuss the case. Be able to come back and spend a few minutes speaking with me anytime soon . Oh, not not too soon, probably. Because that would just have to be a special trip just for that one isolated matter. That doesnt sound like cooperation to the fbi. And then when they asked up and down the river, they learned that kathryn had been planning to leave brian. The week before she died, day off from work, needed it to go to the county courthouse to get divorce papers. I said, have you tried counselling . And shes like, june, ive done it all. I cant do anymore. I have to get out of this marriage. Big decision and shes made it. She gave me the impression that shed been very systematic about it. She tried many things. None of it worked. So, lots of suspicion. But the fbi simply couldnt prove brian caused kathryns death. By september, brian lawyered up. Dismayed by the lack of progress, they went back to fort ft. Smith and opened their own investigation. Kathryns mom came up. Looked and asked and looked and asked. She went up and down the river, just looking for anything to get information and find out the truth. What did she seem to think had happened . Make any sense. She wasnt suicidal. She was trying to find out anything she could. We would put out reward posters or information posters. And we would talk to fishermen. Were you here on this date . Did you see anything . Did you hear anything . We would talk to neighbors. The family expanded their investigation. We hired private investigators, both in dallas and in kansas, and they did interviews with some of her friends from smu. What sorts of things did you find out . A lot. And there was a time where she was afraid of him. And yet she got married to him. She did. Fishing season after fishing season, kathryns sister and mother returned to ft. Smith. Kathryns death, receding further and further into the towns past. We went up there for several years, every summer, and spent a couple of weeks. She tried to find out door to something that would tell her what happened to her daughter. Months of fruitless investigation turned into years. The more sherry and her family learned, the more convinced they became that brian had a hand in her death, but would never be brought to justice. And so, the business about ralph the dog is kind of like salt in a wound. All this time, brian refused to give or even sell them kathryns so after a couple of years, my mom called one day and she said, im im so tired of being nice. I want ralph. And i said, i do, too. She goes, well, then were going to go get ralph. Their private investigator found out where brian was, eight hours away. They made the long drive. My mom saw ralph in the backyard, called his name. Car. And we put ralph in the car and we drove back home to texas. Wow. He was all over us. A few years after kathryns death, the family learned that brian was trying to get licensed to practice law in missouri. So, i immediately called the bar in missouri and said, heres whats going on. Perhaps you dont want to let him sit for the bar exam. He got quite a rough going over by the questioners. He did. They didnt give him his license . No. So brian laird moved to colorado. He set up a law practice in fort ft. Collins, specializing in conflict resolution. In texas, kathryn remained deep in her friend melissas heart. When i found out i was pregnant and when i found out it was a girl, i went to kathryns mom and asked for her permission i named my daughter after danielle, because i loved her so much. I wanted her to always be there with me. In ft. Smith the bighorn flowed on. Fishermen came and went. And fresh crimes demanded investigators attention. Kathryns case grew as cold as the river in winter. And finally in 2004, the fbi closed the file. So as all these years went by, year after year after year, and nothing happened, what was devastating, knowing that he was Walking Around and getting to live his life. After he had taken such an amazing woman off this earth. It was the coldest of cold cases. But i never gave up, ever. Coming up a new i had to lay it all out on this huge conference table. And i says, wait a minute. Le. And i says, wait a minute. With a round brush head go pro with oralb. Oralbs rounded brush head cups your teeth to break up plaque and rotates to sweep it away. And oralb crossaction delivers a clinically proven superior clean vs. Sonicare diamondclean. My mouth feels super clean oralb. Know youre getting a superior clean. Im never going back to a manual brush. My Cold Medicines wearing off. That stuff only lasts a few hours. One pill fights congestion for 12 hours. Guess i wont be seeing you for a while. Why take medicines that only last 4 hours, when just one mucinex lasts 12 hours . Lets end this. Happy anniversary dinner, darlin can this much love be cleaned by a little bit of dawn ultra . Oh yeah one bottle has the grease cleaning power of two bottles of this bargain brand. A drop of dawn and grease is gone. Just gotta get the check. Almost there. I cant reach it. If you have alligator arms, you avoid picking up the check. What . Its what you do. I got this. Thanks, dennis if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. Growwwlph. Its what you do. Oh that is good crispy duck. When families gather, things get messy. Ours can help. A terrible, angry, helpless grief ground away at kathryns family in the wake of her death. And their unrequited conviction that brian laird murdered kathryn and got away with it. Hed been the prime suspect all along, but investigators just couldnt make a ca its completely changed our family. And the effects continue to roll on . Yes. Its not easy. And then one day in 2012, 13 years after kathryns death, an fbi agent named john teling happened to have some time on his hands. Hed heard about the case, as had most of them in the buildings fbi bureau. So he asked his boss if he could take a look. Given that teling worked whitecollar crime. Actuarial stuff. I work a nicer side, generally the financial crimes. What he did was turn his actuarys eye toward a very big file. And i literally sat at my desk hour after hour after hour. An i read every line. And i highlighted it. It was highly suspicious. You didnt believe it was a suicide. No. But that was the foundational story which had been told by the main witness, the husband. Thats right. He said it was a suicide. And its your job to prove thought wasnt. I thought he was lying. The family liaison with the fbi told sherry what teling was up to. She said, weve reopened the case. I started crying. But they were cries of joy and hope. And i even told her, i said, this is the call ive dreamed about. Back in the buildings office, teling was trying to solve the case from its chronology, looking for the devil in the details. What happened the evening before she was murdered, two days before, three days before . This timeline became enormous. Finally i had to lay it all out on this huge conference table. And i rolled it back and says, wait a minute. There was a hell of a lot going on the evening before. Timeline, it dawned on him hed have to shift the focus of his investigation from the scene of kathryns death, the after bay, back to the lairds neighborhood in town. I talked to the water department, the tax department, and the neighbors. And i got a plat survey of the trailer park. To show who was living there. To show who was living there. And i said, come hell or high water, i am going to find everybody that was in that teling talked to everybody in town who knew brian and kathryn. And as teling poked around fort smith, he found people who told him new things, disturbing things, about the reality of brian and kathryns marriage. I found new witnesses. Those two had fought and fought and fought. And then, buried deep in the original case notes, the forensic accountant found something curious. Either important or nothing. There was one note in there, Josh Anderson said his parents heard something that night. And i said, who is josh . Who are his parents . And they lived next door. But nobody had spoken to them . Theres no record of them being spoken to. They were never there. Never there, teling discovered, for a particular reason. The andersons were power boaters.