Replies(5) The scene of the house fire in Garden City, where three people died early Thursday morning. Police have identified two of the victims as Gail and Molly Madigan. (John Scalesi) GARDEN CITY, NY Nassau County police have identified two of the three people who died in a tragic house fire Thursday morning. Gail Madigan, 60, and Molly Madigan, 18, both died in the early morning fire. Police are still working to identify the third victim, a 62-year-old man. Molly was a senior at Garden City High School and had just been accepted to New York University next fall, NBC 4 reported. The fire broke out at the home on Washington Avenue just after 5:30 a.m. Garden City firefighters were battling a massive fire in Westbury at the time and left to respond to the home, which was engulfed in flames.