Stay updated with breaking news from Ignatowa story. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.
shore did not respond to our repeated requests to tell us her story. but this man, bob hill, columnist for louisville s courier journal, and author of the book called double jeopardy, has studied all of shore s on the record statements and agreed to tell us what she told the assembled group this day. the word evil keeps coming back to me. as shore describes it, the story begins at about 6:00 p.m., the rainy night brenda vanished. she says ignatow tells brenda a friend of his wants to see her jewelry and takes her to maryann shore s house. the shack of a place, two bedrooms, living room and a kitchen and dingy, awful place. shore is waiting for them. once inside, shore says ignatow dead bolts the doors, trapping brenda. they put brenda on the couch between the two of them and said we re going to have a sex therapy class. a sex therapy class? this is what he said, brenda ....
Torture of brenda schaefer. there was no doubt in our mind that there were pictures. that evidence is considered so crucial, police go back a few weeks later and search a second time. but, again, they turn up nothing. still, ignatow is charged with murder, kidnapping, sodomy and assault. how did it feel for you to finally have mel ignatow behind bars? it was a great feeling. i truly felt like, i gotcha. but no one yet has heard ignatow s side of the story. could he be the victim of a malicious plot to frame him? could police have overlooked clues that would lead to the real killer? and what would the jury believe about a crime that shook a town to its very soul? capital one s new cash rewards card gives you a 50% annual bonus! so you earn 50% more cash. according to research, everybody likes more cash. well, almost everybody. ....
i talked to my attorney today. talked to who today? the fbi, that murray guy. shore has been instructed to tell ignatow she s getting pressure from the fbi. for most of the 13-minute conversation, ignatow berates her. you re just plain [ bleep ]. afraid to stand up in the face of authority. that s all it amounts to. you re letting them intimidate you and they know it. shore also tells ignatow a story the fbi concocted, that the property behind her house, the woods where brenda s body s was buried, has been sold. i m worried about the property back there. i am not. that s it, okay? i don t give a [ bleep ] if he tells you they re going to dig eight feet down the whole length of the property, okay, don t get rattled. it isn t going to stir up anything, believe me. it s not shallow. that place we dug, it s not shallow. those listening believe they have enough to convict ignatow and brenda s body is found the ....
Holds it up to her mouth and nose until she dies. he s got these pieces of rope and ties it up in these neat knots, this little bundle about the size of a suitcase shoved into several garbage bags. together they carry the body out the back door into the rain, into the hole they dug two weeks before. shore says ignatow had already removed all of brenda s jewelry, including her diamond engagement ring, and now hands over to ignatow the film they shot. three rolls that look like these. what happens to brenda s jewelry and that film will haunt everyone involved in this case for years. back in the u.s. attorney s offices, the story stuns the prosecutors and fbi agents, who are listening to it. you just think to yourself, we need to get prosecutors in here and police officers. well, i am one. it s really dramatic. jim wesley, the detective on the case from the beginning, hears the story a few hours ....
Melvin henry ignatow, the jury got the case. would they send mel ignatow to prison for the murder of his fiancee, brenda schaefer? four jurors agreed to speak with us about their deliberations. i believe we all feel in our hearts he was guilty. but they say they were bothered by the lack of physical evidence against ignatow. i have to have one hair, one blood sample, one anything. they kept mentioning pictures and jewelry, yet nobody showed us any, you know. no pictures, no jewelry. where are they? as for the eyewitness, maryann shore, they had trouble believing her. she didn t shed one tear. she didn t she was cracking smiles. how can you tell such a horrid story and sit on a witness stand cracking smiles? there s no way. so, then you start questioning, was she just involved or was she the one who did it all? and that tape, the one prosecutors felt so sure would ....