Page 25 - Throwing Knife News Today : Breaking News, Live Updates & Top Stories | Vimarsana

Correct question to get the answer you're looking for. if you don't ask it, you're not getting it >> reporter: investigators had two wildly different stories he said, she said. who was telling the truth and who wasn't >> it was clear we were down to two people it was one of these two people and they both had the same allegations about the other one. >> reporter: there was only one way to sort it out and make sure that denita smith received the justice she deserved >> if we can ever prove who was stalking whom, i think we have our case solved. >> reporter: and soon something would provide that ...

Before he knew it, the knife was on the floor, and so was kim, dead. >> i remember getting up. i remember looking at the knife and seeing the blood and knowing that i had to have stabbed her or something, and i went to check to see where she was stabbed. >> at first, he said he waited for police, but when they didn't show, he left. when the police brought you in, why didn't you tell them the story that you told in trial? >> i was scared to death. i was scared to death. i didn't say it out loud, even to myself for six months after this happened. >> did you rape kim dorsey? >> no, i did not. >> ...

The lead attorney called only one witness, an expert on tool mark identification who testified by videotape, arguing that the bayonet in evidence could not, in her opinion, be determined to be what was used to slash the victim's tire. >> subjective. it's based on the individual examiner's training and experience. >> the defense was trying to impeach the testimony of the state's expert who said hilton's bayonet had slashed sheryl dunlap's tire, and that was it for the defense. gary hilton declined to take the stand. >> do you wish to testify? >> no. >> one in 63 million -- >> in her closing arg...

A foot taller than terra. as he pushed her, he began hitting her with a bag. something hard in it. >> it just felt like i was getting punched over and over again. >> reporter: but it wasn't that. there was a knife in the bag. cutting her. slicing into her. >> and i put my arm up with my purse above my heart. and i tried to get away from him. i was screaming. he put his hand over my mouth. and i bit as hard as i could. >> reporter: cash the dog barked furiously. bit into john's ankle. >> i got thrown down on to the ground somehow. and i was just pedal kicking him trying to block the knife when ...

He said. she said. who was telling the truth? and who wasn't? >> it was clear we were down to two people. it was one of these two people. and they both had the same allegations about the other one. >> there was only one way to sort it out. and make sure that denita smith received the justice she deserved. >> if we can ever prove who was stalking whom, i think we have our case solved. >> and soon, something would provide that very answer. >> all of a sudden, then the rape allegation happens. >> coming up. >> she came crawling into my bedroom hysterical. and i'm asking what's wrong? what's wrong...