The nanny is 18 years old, she was crossing the road with her child, she was hit, the girl in the red chevrolet didnt stop , the camera recorded it, but there were no cameras , the road was being widened, all the digging was removed for the camera, but she accidentally hit the flowers . Sasha liked it, there were witnesses, only me and the courier remained at the scene, but he immediately drove away, but the child was not hurt, i didnt have time to push him to the side of the road, its my fault, its my fault that my wife died, max, you re not to blame for anything. Yes, i was driving, she was sitting next to me, she was reading something funny to me from her phone, and the truck was at the intersection, there was nothing, a slight concussion, she was in place, i scrolled through it, then a thousand times, you dont know what youre talking about, you you know, i know, i know what its like to kill a person, even if hes not really a person, but what happened . Something on the way, at work . You could say so, what are you doing here . What did you do in maximum silence . Max helped me solve problems. Marta, for tomorrow s court hearing, uhhuh, im still somehow uneasy, everyone is uneasy, we are ready, for what, because the victims will demand retraining . Yes, im sure that there will be a more serious charge, well, yes, otherwise why would you need an expert with a new conclusion to accuse berezina of arson, to imprison her not for a suspended sentence of 5 years, but for a real 10. Because its one thing your wiring caught fire and the alarm system didnt work, and another thing is that you deliberately waited for the sake of benefits, which means berezina will go under arrest tomorrow, we should prepare for this, but where is the proof that this berezina waited . One experts opinion is not enough to hide her in a pretrial detention center, but it is also impossible to let her go, because it is now impossible to prove that she did not set the fire, that is , everything will depend on the judge, not everything, but a lot, but if he decides take her into custody, season and day. It wont last, it will break, yes , yes, when, okay, i will, something happened, they call the investigator, why . I am a witness in an accident, matveeva, marta sergeevna, what happened to the victim, she is alive, she died. And the girl was arrested . A girl, i was describing a girl with pink hair, she was driving at speed, didnt stop at a red light , it was a man, the car was stolen, the thief was caught on camera, no, it was a girl, well, you said it yourself, the car was driving at speed, you didnt could see. But i have good eyesight and i saw everything, but what about the other witnesses . But there are no others, did the delivery guy on the bike find him . Here i ask you questions, boy, the boy could also see something. We have a lawyer, but not here, its clear, here you are matveevs witness, here im asking you questions, youre answering them, you understand, ask, lets clarify your testimony when the nanny and the child were crossing the road, is it true that the green light was on, and you definitely want to. A man, and not a girl in a red chevrolet. Yes, im on my way to my parents, the girl was injured in an accident, sorry, im at work, now the client will come, i dont have time to do anything. What do you do . Yes, this is increasing memory, and so on, and so on, being stuck with work, because of everything, the wife is pressing, she is busy with the child, everything is on to me. Yes, its easier to forget everything at work, to forget katya, katya lived with you, yes, but she wanted to move out, our baby is screaming in a cramped place, but there are two women in the house, its difficult, and katyas mother died, she was sick, and you are now living with young wife, is this katya . Yes, and the nanny, she worked parttime to help the family, she could go to college, she didnt have enough points for the budget, she wanted to retake the eg, she signed up for courses. Victor, please, if you have any questions, call at any time, any doubts about the investigation, call immediately, an agreement . At we dont have money for lawyers, but sometimes i work for free, why, suddenly, do we get it for free, what do we deserve, its not about you, its about the criminal, who it seems no one is going to punish, but for some reason you care so much, it seems like you were just passing by, or maybe you were sent on purpose , well, to turn things around in the right direction, but what, we dont know who is helping for free now . A client has come to you, lets punish her, her, not him. What kind of accident . A sporty chevrolet hit a nanny, a girl was driving, she is looking for a man, allegedly ill take the car out, yeah, ill. My testimony really bothers them. The owner of the car, they dont tell me, i think its some kind of major who is now being tried with all their might to excuse it . I ll find out everything. The time of the accident is 22 30. Okay, without thinking about it anymore, think about listening to dream west. Ill deal with the rest. They always take so long, im about to be arrested, hello, calm down, please, i cant, my hands are even shaking, i cant tell them not to shake. They all hate me, why . Martha, i dont want to go to prison, god, how did i end up in this nightmare, well enough, a nightmare, if you had waited for the dream west, i didnt set the dream west on fire, that s great, well have to prove that you didnt do it, and well prove it. Please move away without comment, yes, please go away, lord, whats wrong with you, have you packed up your things, or do you doubt that the case will be sent for retraining, that she will be arrested . We doubt that it makes sense to discuss this now, there will be a real deadline, we will do everything for this, you hear, from the text of the indictment of the resolution on the involvement of berezina alladorovna, as accused, it follows that berezina alladorovna is accused of committing an act provided for in part three of article 219 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation , violation of fire safety requirements, committed by a person who had the responsibility to comply with them, if this caused by negligence the death of. Two or more persons the basis for this accusation was the following circumstances on september 12 at 0 20, spontaneous combustion of the system wiring occurred in the building of the dreamwest shopping and Entertainment Center air conditioning due to a short circuit. Timely extinguishing of the fire was impossible due to the malfunction of the fire alarm and fire extinguishing system. In connection with this , information was received at the emercom control panel with a significant delay, and the local fire extinguishing system was unable to localize or stop the fire. Fire in a commercial building. Center resulted in its complete destruction the death of minors lebedeva ekaterina ilnishnaya, ivanova lyubov aleksandrovna, isakov mikhail glepovich, infliction of grievous bodily harm injuries to the adult grenevich konstantin yuevich. Meanwhile, these circumstances do not correspond to the evidence examined during the trial. So expert kilin explained that chemical residues were found at the source of the fire in the Shopping Center. Their presence was ignored during the examination. The presence of the specified chemical elements indicated the presence. Signs of arson. These testimonies are also confirmed by the report of the cheremnykh expert, brought in by petition of the victims. In addition, during the judicial investigation it was established that on the night of the crime , the defendants car was in the parking lot of the Shopping Center, which was burned as a result of the fire. In addition, at the court hearing, a representative of the Insurance Company alliance krutikov pp confirmed that in the event of the destruction of the Shopping Center building, including in the event of a fire, oot rrimvest, the general director of which is the defendant, would have paid insurance compensation. Thus, neither in the resolution on engaging as the accused, nor in the indictment , the event, the crime and the corresponding criminal qualifications are not disclosed in full. The court finds these circumstances an obstacle to considering the case on the merits. In this connection, the criminal case must be returned to the prosecutor to remove obstacles to its consideration by the court. At the same time, in accordance with part three of article 237 of the criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, the Court Decides to select a preventive measure against the accused. Based. V guidelines of articles 107, 236, 237, 256 of the criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, the court decided the criminal case against alla fedorovna berezina, accused of committing a crime under part three of article 219 of the ukrf, should be returned to the prosecutor to eliminate the violations that prevented its consideration in court , choose a preventive measure against alla fedorovna berezina in the form of house arrest for a period of 2 months. Fine, the decision can be appealed in the Moscow City Court court, within ten days from the date of its issuance, no, no, no, wait, wait , what kind of house arrest, you need to be taken into custody, wow, i thought she would be taken into custody just by house arrest, but why arrest her . , see you tomorrow, see you tomorrow. Just suspicions, no evidence , well, just in case, they do the same thing when the judge is under pressure, injured journalists, listen, our judge is great, i have a friend whos new at school, yes, great, whats her name . Lika, she dances too, shes still a boy, be friends. Wants with you no, he just comes up, he seems to like me, when i tell him something , he starts to blush, he says, mom, nothing, he just looks, thats where, thats it, then its me, hello, yes, max, hello , martha, i want to see you, well meet, like that, to meet somewhere, they have no way, but they really want it to be no way, but i wont let them, you smoke, sometimes, and you, our relationship with you more and more interesting. I wouldnt say that interesting is the right word here, but what word is more suitable is complex. I want to finish, you called for this, say its over . No, i dont want to end anything. On the contrary, i want to continue, this is the problem, there is no problem, everything is in your head, it is in the law, yes, if the judge acts outside the law, thats the end of everything, we never talk about dreamvest, we dont talk, that doesnt mean we dont think, i dont i think at least while im with you, right . I cant help but think, because i cant be objective in this process, and it took a lot of effort not to look at you, but i thought about you every second, every second, mark, max, i need be able, not to think, i am separate, the process is separate, it is important for you to be objective, it is important for me to protect, if i defend and you are objective, the world will not collapse, in general our quarry is the deepest in the world, everything is big in yakutia, but for what purpose are you coming from moscow . Move the stones to site 11 46. Or they stand and go on course, maybe well intercept more, but they turn back, through bad weather, not even six months will pass, who are you, and i will appear, what happened to your wife, to leave again, im crazy, dont tease, its dangerous, for half a year. Sergei bezrukov in a multiepisode film by valery todorovsky. Major, if this is what i think, then you and i are in quarantine. Bison, the case of a fashion model, premieres on october 9 on the first. We have always admired you. Those who break the horizons, not forgetting about loved ones, those who build not a business, but the future, you who know that action is more important than loud words, who know how to give more than receive, who choose faith, hope, love, not only how. Times, investing in your future, living in a huge country on which the sun never sets, there are already 38 of you millions, those who trust us, and we do everything to have the right to say, tinkov, bank of the year in russia, dzhem makheev is one hundred percent natural, he helps prepare. Real delicacies. Jam makheev makes my dishes tastier. Shopping with a rosbank credit card 120 for everything is an unforgettable emotion and 12 forgettable. Rosbank credit card. Would you like to shoot with an audi . No interest at all. Rosbank. Real opportunities. Free sofcombank debit card. Cashback up to 5 or up to select order online at sofcom. Ru. Season of big premieres on film search. Go. Well hello. Sounds tempting. Kinopoisk premiere today, tomorrow, always. Each organism is unique. Everyone needs their own unique one. Pharmacy, necessary medications with a discount of 450 rubles. Find out your Credit Rating for free on the website sravni. Ru. We will help you choose a loan taking into account your current payments and. History and check that you have no arrears and no one has taken out a loan in your name, if a loan, then on the website sravni. Ru. Find out your Credit Rating for free on the website sravni. Ru. Stylish solutions for a childrens bedroom, bright blankets and bedding sets from the pavlina brand. At competitive prices on wildberries. 24 months installment plan with kholva. Buy any goods from partners, or pay off your credit card debts. Installment plan for 24 months, purchases and refinancing of credit cards in installments with kholva, urgently need to find interesting content, roorub application for children, children are happy, parents are calm, back to work, a new task, yes, my business works without your it stuff, soso it works, mom, can it be better if . So smart, will you manage my salon . Yes easy. So, one fine day, i entered the world of business. Technology will help in any unclear situation. We open a savings account and connect services. Let clients choose their own convenient time. And so that no one is late messenjeh reminders. Analysis of finances for masters and general for the salon. So simple. It stuff , open an account in sberbank, use special services for the Service Industry for free forever, and come to work with me, and im thinking of starting my own business, sberbusiness, millions trust us entrepreneurs, any business begins with the question can we introduce innovations in familiar areas, yes, of course we can, everything can be done more technologically, but without support in any business there may be a pause, with support we have doubled in size, we are expanding further, the National Project is small and average. Support for your season premiere, the voice is no longer children, on friday on the first, this is my secret sl. Red chevrolet car number s55 no. Is stolen, from whom 3 million were stolen. The owner of the car is zoya viktorovna serikova, 21 year old student at moscow state university, the car was parked at the institute, and was stolen from there a week ago. Did your dad give you the car or did your lover give you the car . I assume that serikovs father, viktor gennadievich, with whom there is no need to contact, is a businessman, official, employee of a state corporation. Nika, please find me a photo of zoya serikova now, marta, are you sure that we should even get involved in this . The deceaseds father, by the way, is also called victor, and he honestly repairs mobile phones in his small apartment in a panel house, help your daughter already cant do anything, unlike the other victor, who from the height of his state corporation. And can do everything to prevent her daughter from going to jail, so i dont understand how the second daughter, who saved the child, differs from the first, who killed the child, but we also cant help, right . Not for katya, but for other girls who cross the road when the light is green, we can. That is, we are now working towards a brighter future, right . And completely free of charge, i understand correctly. Is it just me, or does your words sound like mockery . Martha, im the only person which is in ours. The team really looks at things, oh, heres the second victor, yes, this is katyas father, you asked to call, yes, yes, you say , they found him, he confessed to everything, the hijacker who hit my daughter, do you hear, uhhuh, he was recently released from prison, he used to be in prison for coffin, clearly, but you dont happen to know what his name is, pervushin, konstantin, or something, i think they told me. He will be tried, judged, okay, okay, thanks for calling, hang in there, she, yes, she. At least one recording from cameras is needed so that on that day it i was driving, and i need to find the food delivery guy. Nika, kir, we need to find out everything she did on the day of the accident, restore everything minute by minute. Yes, pash, hello, there is not a single recording from the cameras yet, but the major is crazy, a fine after a fine, they should have taken away the right a long time ago. I dont know why they havent picked me up yet, its clear, but it doesnt matter, i found the delivery guy, nikita levchenko, 20 years old, great, send me the coordinates. Nikita, good afternoon, good, today youre not late even without a bike, im on a break, well, last time you were late, what are you talking about, a girl hits a car in front of your eyes, and you dont even turn around, because shes late to deliver food to someone, but you were there, i saw you got out of the car and ran, which means you turned around after all, but lets go . Then it was as if nothing had happened, so what should i do now, choke, no, why . Live happily ever after, after you help punish the driver of a red chevrolet, they found her, her, a girl on a shawaral, so you saw her after all, briefly, she, she is excused, it was her or not, well, yes, it is. Driving, her they excuse it, yeah, on the eve of the accident, zoya serikova quarreled with her man, there are many witnesses, she drank all night and lit up in a night club, and then during the day she came to the institute angry, sat through a couple of lectures, or rather slept through a couple of lectures, then went to a bar with friends, drank again, drove home in the same car, there is a witness, the car could have been stolen, except on the way, marta, we have a problem, well , maybe this is not a problem, but the judge who was at dreamvest was, well, litvinov maxim anatelevich was, zhenya, what happened to the judge of litvina, the judge is fine, but he is no longer at our trial, has he been removed . No, he resigned from our business . No, he actually went to the bench. I know, i had to tell you everything myself, what to say that you ran away, i could nt cope with you, like a sentimental girl, i asked you, im separate, the process is separate, i couldnt be objective, marta, im not a robot, but i would never choose you, i would choose the court, i would always choose the court, i understand, i understand, that means im not you, that means you shouldnt have approached me, please dont touch me never again, and you didnt choose me, max, you chose yourself, your beautiful s. About professionalism and conscience, if you had chosen me, you would never have left the process, dont you understand, dont you understand, yes, you dont understand how important it is for me to do this, thats why i left , my split, your split, you should have been with me to the end, period, since you contacted me, since you slept with me, since you got in into my family, since you understood at least something about me, stay to make an honest verdict, but he wouldnt be honest, he would honest, max, because you are an honest person. And you are an honest judge, but now who can i count on . Yes, i left. This is not the end, is this not the end . What, do you really think that this judge, who will be appointed, will not turn everything in the right direction, because they will tell him, not his conscience, just to punish someone, just to satisfy the public, it doesnt matter that the person is not guilty, look, we have punished the guilty, we have a strict but fair trial, that in general everything in our country is according to the law, you naive stupid a girl who trusted. Her husband, this is her only fault, she must be in prison somewhere, yes, now you dont understand, well, someday you will understand, fuck you, sash, yes, mom, im here, so what . This is it, Galina Nikolaevna and i came from school, well , the door was inserted, mom, he started talking to me, who . That boy, so far only on the internet, but hes already making progress, can you imagine, mom, who took this picture . I dont know, they probably wanted to make a surprise, but i invited guests for the weekend, the girl i told you about and the boy, but i dont think he when he comes, everything will just turn red. Sasha, no one will come to you this weekend, we are going to dad, and you. Will you go there for a couple of weeks . A couple of weeks . No, i wont go, you can go wherever you want, and ill stay here with my friends , this is not discussed, get dressed quickly , im not a suitcase for you to carry me back and forth, its because you ca nt. The nanny, or because that nanny was hit . Yes, i heard you tell max that night, the 18yearold nanny was crossing the road with a child, and that she was hit, and now you think that the nanny you cant trust me, so, to explain, you dont have time to do anything, so you hand me back to dad, and he immediately said that i would feel bad with you, why didnt i listen to him . Yes, sir, yeah, i understand. Problems at work, i cant tell you everything now, but when you took sasha, didnt you think that you would have problems . I thought, i didnt realize it was on such a scale. Dim, sash, we need to provide security for a while, can you, what, what happened . You can, what happened, martha, explain to me why you took her away in the first place, thats enough now read, its not helping, read, whats the matter, you think no one can get here, so im asking you about security, dim, i understand everything, thats it, im trying to solve everything, i resolve issues there, you provide sasha with security, everything will be here ok, nothing good. It will never happen, because you are abnormal, what is happening now proves that you are abnormal, you cannot have children. A year ago she accused me of betrayal, now you see that it was not betrayal, your work and family are incompatible, do you at least know who cares about you . I came, who didnt i cross over to, will sasha have security . Sasha will have everything without you, ill take it from you, sasha, uhhuh, uhhuh, yes. Well, whoever is running into trouble here, i know you, you are a witness in an accident, so what do we want you to do, go to jail right now. No, well, if you came here, ok, im ready, put the handbrake on, what . Put on what . What do you want . Go and try to persuade everyone to say that ive been shot down, i know everything, my dad knows everything, youre really trying to get into trouble, you dont understand this, but why . Well, are you jealous that i have everything . But yours isnt very good, whats the reason . There is only one reason, of a legal nature, you have completely lost your fear, okay, so fearless, but you dont feel sorry for your daughter, but what about your daughter, everything is known about her, you didnt receive photos, you did receive photos, though without the senders name, i came to find out. I just said, well meet in court, dad will help me, but he wont be here, this time it will be, hello, dad, and then he opened the door and went into the fence, youre just unlucky that i ended up on this street, you would at least they asked for the sake of decency. Who i am, how i conduct business, it would become clear that this time you have nothing it will come out, it wont be possible to get the criminal off the hook, the day of the accident, video from the registration cameras on komsomolsky prospekt, motto pervushin is careless behind the wheel, there is also a witness who saw her at the time of the accident, like me, two living witnesses, i hope well live to get here, and also there are witnesses who saw serikova that day. She was drinking and after that she drove home in a red chevrolet, so the car was not in the throes, she was in the throes, after you got down to business, they began to keep an eye on my child immediately after visiting you, i will attach evidence when i go to your boss, or if necessary to the prosecutors office, although maybe syurikovs arms are so long that he has already reached the prosecutors office, yes, then every newspaper in this city, call, yes, yes, serikov, viktor gennadvich, and tell him that this time everything will be according to the law, i dont know the number, its always hidden, that means, if you dont call him today, youre on your own. I promise you, legal and actual dual power, russia is driven into a political dead end. Yeltsin himself for a long time. I cant, well, who can i negotiate with . Its a real coup, we need to take it by storm today. Under this old building we discovered a secret mothballed radio center, from where we could broadcast in conditions, for example, there is a big war there, in connection with the armed siege of the ostankino television company, we are forced to interrupt the broadcast. 1993 autumn on fire. Today is the first one. Maheevs citrus jams are great for dessert and delicious. Jam makheev is 100 natural. Anxiety can be treated. New afobal retard. Gradual release of the active substance. Just one tablet per day. Afabozole anxiety can and should be treated. Free sofcom bank debit card. Cashback up to 5 or income on. Remaining up to 15 . Select order online at softbank. Ru. This is fonbet russian football cup. Largescale, spectacular, real, punchy. Backgroundbet russian football cup. Go to the bcs investment level. Offers. The best analytics and investment ideas for any situation, open an account number one in company. Bks mirinvestitsii. Dancing is your bag of popcorn, this is the norm for a discount store. From october 19th, order goods from the scooter with discounts. Your friends, our friends. Advise alfabank. You get 1,500 rubles for each recommendation, and lets not forget about your friends, they will also receive money, find out how to recommend making money on alfabank. Ru , alfabank is the best mobile bank, pay less, orion chocay cake 1290, pyaterochka helps out, oh, cashback has arrived, since , and he gets cashback for all purchases, dad, tinkov gets cashback for everything, peak everything, in real money, get a card, hes the only one, everything youre interested in is collected on vk video, even all of shastuns shows, yes, even my shows, and not only mine, even dramas, and thousands more films and tv series, and even the latest seasons, all seasons, everything you are interested in is now in vk video applications, compare osaka at the best price and without overpayments. Each body is unique and each requires its own unique approach to health. Sber epteka necessary medicines at a discount of 450 rubles. One of my friends has a difficult relationship with the internet. Cool shot, ill post it now, damn it, its the wrong file, how can i cancel it . No way, artyom. This is a megaphone, everything flies with it. Go to the megaphone. How to choose the right osaka. Wait, there is nothing special about asa, its just insurance, value your time, buy the policy yourself. In comparison, asaga is at the best price and without overpayments, dancing is your bag of popcorn, for discounts, swelling is the norm, from october 19, order goods in a scooter with discounts. Find out your Credit Rating for free on the website sravni. Ru. Well help you choose a loan that takes into account your current payments Credit History and check that you are not in arrears and no one has taken out a loan in your name. If its a loan, then on the website sravni. Ru. Find out your Credit Rating for free on the website sravni. Ru. Each organism is unique. Everyone needs their own unique approach. To health sber and pharmacy, we will deliver medications that are right for you. Sber eapteka necessary medicines at a discount of 450 rubles. Yes, i found out here, it turns out that perya doesnt have a mayor, actually there is, shes just in kovrrio, well, for now shes there in perya on dancing at the carnival, kvn summer cup, on saturday at the first, i want to date a real man, real men dont like pink, they love red and white, and this is pink. Yes, allah, im listening, marta, i remembered, there is one person with whom gleb was in close contact, his classmates name is vladimir, where he lives, works, i dont know anything, we dont know each other, i understand you, gleb met him a couple of times per year, but always said that it was one of his best. Old friends, i understood you, thank you for remembering, yeah, bye dates, yes, i was worried about finding out how you were, uhhuh, i thought i came to remind you about dinner, well , i understand everything, you dont have time for dinner, why not, you can have dinner. Yes, dont regret coming to us, on the contrary, im just getting the hang of it, which means you have good taste. Why did you hire me without experience, i liked the diploma, seriously, you read my diploma, of course, i thought that you were brave, a nonstandard solution to standard questions, and nika, she also has a good diploma, no, nika surprised me, she said, that im ready to work for free for a year, really, well now, what the difference is, even if it wasnt, she was resourceful. I value her desire just as much as courage, but zhenya, thats who, who, she definitely wouldnt have said that she was ready to work for free for a year, zhenya is a pragmatist, then she has children, when i offered her a job, she immediately agreed to me, then she believes that the way we protect women is the right strategy, profitable, march, but for you its not a question of benefit, but a question of what . Well, what kind of life there is, honor is a word like, a parasite, again you teach me russian, and pasha, pasha he once helped me out a lot, well, then he was fired from the police, he was fired, i was fired, you were fired, how can you even be fired . I had dinner, you wanted to go to india , you dont need them in india, you need to look for one person here, his name is vladimir, berezins classmate, uhhuh, uhhuh, okay, calmly, let him in. Seriko viktorovna, you have been detained on suspicion of committing a crime under paragraph b, part 4, article 264 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation. Violation of traffic rules by a person driving a car, resulting in negligence death of a person. And associated with leaving his place. Committed, you will still answer for this, understand . No, not everything, so tell your serik that if anything happens to me, if anything happens to sasha or anyone from my team, i know who to blame, that s all now. Good morning, good, good, i have good news, sirikova has been arrested, and also, the new judge for dreamvest has set a date for the hearing, and this is good, based on the stated guidelines in articles 97, 101, 108, 110, 236, criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, the court decided to change the preventive measure in relation to berezna alladorovna, to select in relation to berezina alla fedorovna, a citizen of the Russian Federation, working as a general director, a nonconvicted preventive measure in the form of imprisonment for a period of 2 months from the moment the decision entered into legal force. The decision can be appealed in the Moscow City Court within three days from the date of its adoption. Chairman klochkov, the meeting is declared closed, no end, no the end, al need to take off the jewelry. There is a big game on the air, today the russian minister of defense, general shaigu, held a Conference Call with the high command and spoke about the results of the Russian Military operation in ukraine. And frankly speaking, the results are very positive. There are no serious successes of the ukrainian offensive. And, there is not a single breakthrough of the russian defense, the planned , and much advertised, ukrainian strike in the area of ​​​​rabotin and verbovoy was not crowned with success, in general, the picture is developing very, very positive, and also good news that they do not yet see the need for mobilization and since the beginning of the year more than 355,000 people have joined the volunteer formations , this is the point of view of the russian minister of defense, it is interesting that this point of view, in general, more and more coincides with western assessments, i practically do not i know that ukrainian conversations about individual advances that have been achieved, these conversations are also placed, well, in some more real context, so lets see what the New York Times writes about this, military experts say that instead of to hold the fortification lines at any cost, they used the longknown military tactics of elastic defense. This tactic involves Russian Troops withdrawing to a second line, allowing the afdf to advance, and then retaliating when enemy forces move through open terrain and become vulnerable. The goal of russian tactics is to prevent ukrainian troops from gaining a foothold in the position and using it as a springboard for a further offensive. That is, in other words, even from the point of view of american specialists, american observers, ukrainian advances, but they are very relative advances, and not advance in one part of the day ends with entry into another part of the day, and they do not have any strategic significance , they matter mainly due to the very large ukrainian losses, the losses that usually occur always significantly higher than the losses of the defenders. General buzhinsky, an outstanding military expert, a regular participant in our program, what do you think about these assessments, the results of the ukrainian offensive . You know, dmitry, i must say that you cited an excerpt from the New York Times , a lot of articles, over the last week i wont even list, uh, dedicated to, well, actually the failure of the ukrainian offensive, but ill highlight an article in the economist magazine on last week, which is called time for rethinking, you probably read it, a serious article, and i really liked the first part, everything is there, that is, without embellishment, the offensive failed, the losses were huge, there was no, so to speak, favorable position to start with the ukrainians, so to speak, could not reach negotiations, and they couldnt go any further, but naturally , no one wants to admit defeat, so we need to prepare for a long, exhausting war of attrition, i dont really believe in such losses, because the losses. Are huge, there is already a figure of 350 this is considered to be 350,000 killed only, this is already considered as a minimum figure, many already operate with figures there of 400,000, almost half a million, and if you take the wounded, multiply by three, that is, some exorbitant numbers, i already im not talking about technology, there are also thousands, tens of thousands of pieces of equipment, including all the most modern ones, what both challengers and. Leopards delivered, i think thats why the americans hesitate with their abrams all the time, you know, its like a carrot in front of the face, now theyve already arrived, now they are already in ukraine, but it seems they will wait until things start to unravel; they will say that a tank weighing more than 60 tons is simply not suitable for moving through the rich, fatty ukrainian black soil, they will leave this whole matter for later, so moreover, there have already been reports in the same, here is rabotina, its not just that ours are repelling, so to speak, repulsing the offensive, but they themselves are going on a counterattack, this is not yet an offensive, as some of our, so to speak, military correspondents say, that our troops have already gone on the offensive, i dont see a broad offensive operation being carried out yet, yes counterattacks in all directions, not only in the kupyantsky direction, but in the south, already our troops, yes, as part of defensive tactics, the offensive is already going on, i do not agree with this assessment that our troops are using american tactics of flexible defense, i do not i heard that they broke through the first line of defense, they are still marking time in the line of combat outpost, in the zone of combat outpost, somewhere they may break through in some area, go a few hundred meters, but this is not a breakthrough of the first line. Defense