It is good that so many people turn out for Gaza ceasefire protests. It is bad, and odd, that placards and megaphones on those protests are dominated by slogans devised by groups who want not so much a ceasefire as Hamas to war and win; and that most protesters follow the placards and chants without signalling dissent. Best if we, Workers’ Liberty, and other groups who want peace, two states, workers’ unity, can be numerous enough to have our placards and banners dominate. Pending that, let’s analyse some of the slogans.