Transcripts For FBC The Journal Editorial Report 20240713

Signaling an ease in tensions, at least for now, following the u. S. Strike last week that killed irans top military commander, Qassem Soleimani. Retired fourstar general jack keane is a fox news senior strategic analyst. Good to see you again, general. Good to see you, paul. Paul you have said that the events of the last week add up to a strategic victory for the u. S. How so . Yeah, very significantly. I think its a big win for the president because by killing soleimani, i mean, he clearly got in khameneis head here, whos the stream leader of Supreme Leader of iran. Theyve never had an action against them of that magnitude and that significance that so impacts how they are cutting their foreign conducting their Foreign Policy and their foreign wars and also how they do with their own people. Soleimani was very much in charge of putting down the protest movements inside of iran. So what the president accomplished and many of his detractors had no appreciation for what was really taking place is the Supreme Leader deescalated. He was fundamentally deterred by the president s actions. I mean, he calculated that i will do something in return for soleimanis death thats largely symbolic, largely playing to my own audience, but i dont want to conduct a massive attack where im guaranteed to kill americans. And why didnt he want to do that . Paul yeah, thats the key question, because presumably they have enough targeting expertise to have been able to do more damage had they wanted to. Yeah. They could have shut down the straits of hormuz, that would have caused some real problems, and they could have targeted the major u. S. Ground bases, air bases and navy bases that we have in the region. Not in iraq. I mean, we have significantly large scale u. S. Bases, and the patriot missiles that are defending those bases, they could defeat those because the advanced cruise missiles that they used on the saudi oil field, paul, penetrated under the radar of those patriot missiles. Paul so, general, why did they blink . Why do you think the iranians blinked . They blinked because they knew that President Trump is a person of his word, and theyre dealing with a very different president than what theyve dealt with over 40 years here. And they knew that the retaliation from the United States would be significant. What am i talking about here . They would have taken down oil, all of the eight refineries that the iranians have. They would have taken down largely their entire industrial base. I mean, power plants, etc. And then their Strategic Deterrence to protect the Iranian Regime is built around shortrange and mediumrange Ballistic Missiles paul and we could have taken them out too. We would have taken them out all in one night, and they know that. That would have been the beginning of the end of the regime. And that was an accurate calculation, i think, on khameneis part. Paul all right. Do you think the president was wise then in the wake of the response from iran that did not kill any americans, was the president wise to restrain his response and to deescalate are along with khamenei . Yeah. I think it was absolutely one of the president s finest moments as president of the United States. I mean, clearly they were trying to kill americans, could have been killed paul right. In that insignificant strike. And he had, certainly, he had the authority to take out the launch sites, take refineries out and the rest of it. But he got on the moral high ground and told them im going to sanction you for what youve done, but im also offering you a diplomatic solution. And that, i think, was absolutely the right call. And i think he also has an opportunity here, you know, to reach out to the europeans, as he stated in his speech, and to nato to further isolate the iranians to help bring them to the negotiating table. Paul all right. So what do you think that the iranian response, the military response, retaliatory response is done, or do you expect to see some acts of terror or strikes via proxies in the future . Yeah, they but they have limited actions. The president has drawn a line. Iranians as well as proxies, youre not going to kill americans. If you do, im going to retaliate. So that immediately begins eliminating now, these proxies, so our audience understands, theyre not homogeneous, and some of the commanders have a lot of energy and emotion associated with them, and they may lob some rockets from time to time paul they could act on their own without approval from tehran, perhaps. Even though iran says knock it off, theyll take some action. But it wont be significant action, in my judgment. They can tell the hezbollah in lebanon and hamas in gaza to attack israel, but israel knows how to deal with that. And the israelis, by the way, have contained the 80,000 proxies in western and southern syria from establishing missile bases by conducting over 200 airstrikes. Were containing the iranians in Eastern Syria by not letting them have access to the oil fields. So there are things they can interrupt the oil flow again, and they can knock out some oil production. So there are limited actionings. But i think their most significant action, paul, is going to be political. Paul all right. Well, i want to ask you about that. We dont have a lot of time, but i want to ask you is there anything, any chance, do you think, that the iranians could come to the table and negotiate over the nuclear deal . Its hard for me to see that taking place when they have in their minds the uncertainty of President Trumps reelection. Paul right. And i think thats a big card for them. So i dont see Much Movement unless it becomes obvious that President Trump is going to be reelected. The political move i think theyre going to make is bribe, coerce, intimidate the iraqis to force the United States out of iraq. And if theyre able to achieve that, thatll be a big political victory for the Iranian Regime, for sure. Paul and thats a good argument for the United States staying there. All right. Thank you, general, appreciate it. Very helpful. When we come back, Foreign Policy Takes Center Stage in the 2020 president ial race as the showdown with iran shines a light on the 2020 democrats and the epson ecotank. No more buying cartridges. Look at all this ink it comes with. Big ink tanks. Lots of ink. No more cartridges. Incredible amount of ink. The epson ecotank. Just fill and chill. 1 in 4 of us millennials have debt we might die with. And most of that debt is actually from credit cards. Its just not right. But with sofi, you can get your credit cards right by consolidating your Credit Card Debt into one monthly payment. Including your Interest Rate right by locking in a fixed low rate today. And you can get your money right with sofi. Check your rate in two minutes or less. Get a nofee personal loan up to 100k. Get a nofee personal loan do you recall, not long ago we would walk on the sidewalk all around the wind blows we would only hold on to let go blow a kiss into the sun we need someone to lean on blow a kiss into the sun we needed somebody to lean on all we need is someone to lean on my agerelated macular degenso today i made a plan with my doctor, which includes preservision. Because he said a multi vitamin alone may not be enough. And its my vision, my morning walk, my sunday drive, my grandsons beautiful face. Only preservision areds2 contains the exact nutrient formula recommended by the National Eye Institute to help reduce the risk of moderate to advanced amd progression. Its how i see my life. Because its my vision. Preservision. Car vending machines and buying a car 100 online. Vented now weve created a brand new way for you to sell your car. Whether its a year old or a few years old, we want to buy your car. So go to carvana and enter your license plate, answer a few questions, and our technowizardry calculates your cars value and gives you a real offer in seconds. When youre ready, well come to you, pay you on the spot, and pick up your car. Thats it. So ditch the old way of selling your car, and say hello to the new way at carvana. Were cooking with mom. She always said, food is love, so when she moved in with us, a new kitchen became part of our financial plan. I want to make the most of every meal we have together. At Northwestern Mutual, our version of Financial Planning helps you live your dreams today. Find a Northwestern Mutual advisor at nm dot com. This is the epsonve no more buying cartridges. Big ink tanks. Lots of ink. Print about. This many pages. The epson ecotank. Just fill and chill. The Decision Making process that led up to it, the failure to consult with our allies or congress and the reckless disregard for the consequences that would surely follow was, in my view, dangerously incompetent. Paul former Vice President and 2020 democratic president ial hopeful joe biden criticizing the decision to take out the iranian general, Qassem Soleimani, and calling President Trump dangerously incompetent. The soleimani strike and irans response reverberating across the campaign trail this week as the 2020 democrats criticized President Trumps strategy while trying to make their own case to become commander in chief. Lets bring in our panel, wall street journal columnist and Deputy Editor Dan Henninger and columnist kim strassel and bill mcgurn. Dan, you look across the whole week, how well do you think President Trump handled this . Well, i think hes handled it really quite well. I mean, lets make no mistake, killing soleimani was an event of incredible magnitude. It was the biggest thing in Foreign Policy. Hes been negotiating with north korea, talking to the chinese. This trumps, shall we say, everything. Paul this is the biggest decision hes made in the presidency so far on Foreign Policy . Yeah, i think so. And the response of his critics and the democrats was extraordinary. Normally thered be a 24hour grace period for an american president when they do Something Like this. But bipartisanship reigns for a day. But not this time. It was overwhelming against the president. Normally when you attack donald trump, you get attacked back. But in this instance he didnt do that. He eventually made a statement to the american people. It was restrained, hes announced more sanctions on the iranians, and he has not engaged in a tit for tat with his create ings on this critics on this. And so it was a president ial act. At the moment hes looking very president ial, and i have to say a lot of the criticism is looking, by the democrats even the Democratic Candidates looking uninformed and insubstantial. Paul bill, the democrats clearly want to run against the president as the chaos president , as somebody who really is impulsive, reckless, looks for war. I guess, did this image counter that, in your view . He had a couple of tweets during the week which suggested, you know, the critics took after, one on attacking cultural sites in iran if they would retaliate. Well, with donald trump theres always a lot of noise behind hem that comes in, and the democrats seem to obsess over the things that dont really matter too much, right in now theyre haggling over the word imminent, you know . This guy was a threat just Walking Around to americans. I mean, i think the president has, one, really given iran to think about in strategic terms with this strike, and also he just the dem its not just the president , but the democrat response which seems to be some of them are blaming america for the ukrainian airliner going down seems to make them want to look weak. Were back to the blame america first. And the big problem that democrats have is trumps really stolen their Foreign Policy. He came in against the long wars and involvement but saying the flip side is im going to be tough. Thats what obama tried to do in the beginning with the afghan surge, but he announced the withdrawal the day he announced the surge, and then he never did it. Hes actually doing it. And its a contrast. Remember when those four contractors were killed in iraq on the bridge, and we didnt do anything. And now theres an american life, and he says theres going to be consequences. Paul kim, how do you think this is going to play inside the democratic president ial contest . We had joe biden come out, as we showed, very forcefully criticizing the president and the strategy, and that was in advance of the iranian retaliation and the president s restraint in response to that. How is this going to affect that debate . Well, that biden statement was an example of how it is already affecting that debate. Joe biden missed an opportunity here to himself look president ial. What he could have done is come out and say, yes, this guy wassed bad, yes, the president was right to take him out. I have some questions about his overall strategy in the region because that is still a bit unclear, and its a fair question. He didnt do that because hes being pushed to the left on Foreign Policy by the progressive, ascendant part of the party. And youre seeing that on domestic issues, but now were having this Foreign Policy debate. Youre seeing it on Foreign Policy issues too. Its led by bernie sanders, Elizabeth Warren saying, basically, there is no reason why we would ever engage against a terrorist, very much the kind of Peace Coalition within the party. But its also putting pressure on candidates like biden, and i think that that undermines democrats reputation among voters in terms of Foreign Policy and security. Paul dan, do you feel, do you think that biden maybe felt he had to position himself this way to inoculate himself against the attacks he knows are coming from bernie and warren about his 2002 vote for the iraq war . I think it, thats precisely the reason. And its not just to inoculate himself against bernie. One of the problems for joe biden and i would say amy klobuchar, two moderate candidates running is that in all these primaries now since 2016 the rise of bernie sanders, its not just bernie, its the fact that youve got younger democrats basically who agree with bernie sanders, socialist, pacifist. And i think biden and klobuchar are having a difficult time gauging how substantial they are, what their presence are in iowa, new hampshire, south carolina, super tuesday. To what extent do they have to mollify them at the risk of, if they dont do that, getting hurt in the primaries. Its a very difficult choice for them, but at some point theyve got to show more clarity about where where they stand, i think, for voters generally. Paul bill, briefly, who do you thinks going to get the edge here . Is this going to help bernie or biden . I think because of the way biden handled it and buttigieg, in my opinion, its going to help bernie. And i think thats a miscalculation on bidens part. I dont think he can win the antiwar vote. I think in the primaries hes looking, he knows hes got south carolina, but hes looking at iowa and new hampshire, but hes not going to win that. Again, all bernies going to say is, joe, you voted for iraq. And what he should have done is look like a commander in chief. He could still criticize the bush strategy, as you laid out, but say its a good day when we get a guy thats killing americans. Paul thank you, all. When we come back, democrats on capitol hill nearly unanimous in their criticism of President Trumps order to kill Qassem Soleimani. One of their former colleagues says it deserves more bipartisan support. I am totally blind. And non24 can make me show up too early. Or too late. Or make me feel like im not really there. Talk to your doctor, and call 8442342424. When you look at the world, what do you see . Where others see chaos, we see patterns. Connections. Relationships. When you use location technology, you can see where things happen, before they happen. With esri location technology, you can see what others cant. The american people, rightfully, have serious concerns about a war with iran and whether we are safer today because of this president s Foreign Policy which is so often impulsive and erratic. Paul democrats on capitol hill nearly united in their criticism of the president and his decision to order the strike that killed Qassem Soleimani. A move my next guest says deserve ises more bipartisan support. Former connecticut senator Joe Lieberman joins me now. Senator, good to see you. You too, paul. Thank you. Paul so when you say it deserves more bipartisan support, why . Well, to me, it just seems that the killing of soleimani seems so eminently in the National Security interests of the United States. I mean, everybody by now knows the record. You can hold him responsible for the deaths of hundreds of americans directly since, over the last 15 years and thousands of others. All those, including democrats who deservedly are critical of us standing back in sir what and watching more than half syria and watching more than half a Million People there, can put the blame mostly on soleimani without whom assad would never still have been there. So this is again a reflection, im afraid, of how partisan tribal our politics have become. And this, to me, is an extreme of it. If you cant agree that its the right thing to do for the United States, to kill, to take off the battlefield a general literally in the war against us, then what can we agree on without partisan politics . Paul well, its striking to me because this is iran in particular which, as you know going back to the revolution in 1979, has been targeting americans. And Many Democrats over the years, including Chuck Schumer and others, have said, look, we have to get tougher against iran. Whats behind it . Why the change now . Is it just donald trump . I really think it is. Its donald trump and the increasing partisanship of american politics. You are absolutely right. For years in the face of iranian aggression against us including all that they did training and equipping iraqi militias which went back into iraq and killed over 600 american soldiers by conclusion of our state Department Paul official count. Official count. People like Chuck Schumer, right across the bipartisan board supported economic sanctions. We didnt want to go to war against iran. Economic sanctions against him to squeeze iran so that they would stop doing what they were doing. And why, why did this become a point of, the killing of soleimani become a point of partisan disagreement . I think its got to be because were so partisan generally and because were at a point where whatever donald trump does, President Trump does, democrats will oppose it. Frankly, whatever donald trump does, most republicans will support. And thats a suspension of rational thinking, particularly when it comes to our National Security. Paul okay. But so you look at the Democratic Party and the change of opinion over the years, i mean, i dont see many, you know, Henry Jackson democrats anymore. Yeah. Paul he was the antisoviet Union Democrat for years, worked with president reagan. Right. Paul and you yourself, you were challenged in a primary and had to run as an independent in order to keep your seat. Right. A. Paul how do you see the drift in the party on Foreign Policy . Is it really moving in a profoundly dovish direction . Well, it certainly seems like it is. Certainly, among the candidates who are involved in the hothouse of the democratic primary in which the left is disproportionately represented. But i worry about it. This is a tension, a dialogue thats gone on in the party for some years paul right. I mean, in a sense it hit the farleft point in 1972 when George Mcgovern was elected. First, it was in the middle of the vietnam war. Paul right. President nixon was not that popular, but he won a landslide over mcgovern. The democrats who have won the presidency since then were either centerleft and prosecurity. Remember, jimmy carter, no matter what he did during his presidency, he was a navy veteran. He was a submariner. Bill clinton took some strong positions on security. Barack obama himself was more of a center, centerleftist when he ran for president. Incidentally, i was looking at history, and the congress got very angry at president clinton for going into kosovo without congressional authorization. Paul i remember that. And tom delay, the republicans in the house, tried to stop it. You know what happened . Mitch mcconnell and the republicans in the senate yes. Paul and combined with democrats basically said, no, we support the president. Exactly. [laughter] to their credit. And congress was also angry at president obama for taking American Forces into libya paul right. Without an adequate congressional authorization. In fact, even under the war powers act which president s of both parties is have said they dont really feel obliged to follow, usually they try to, president obama kept our forces in weeks after the timeline for that expired. [laughter] so you have to say that all this invoking of the war powers resolution today by democrats in congress against President Trump for what he just did to soleimani is a classic pattern, partisan pattern paul either side. On either side, but its worse than ever today because the partisanship is worse than ever, and there should have been nothing controversial about the killing of soleimani. Paul all right. Senator lieberman, thank you for coming in. Great to see you. Thank you, paul. You too. Paul still ahead, the Congress Passes a war powers resolution aimed at limiting the administrations actions against iran, reigniting a longstanding limu emu doug and now for their service to the community, we present limu emu doug with this key to the city. [ applause ] its an honor to tell you that Liberty Mutual customizes your Car Insurance so you only pay for what you need. And now we need to get back to work. [ applause and band playing ] only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Oh, your shes landed. Ed. And shes on her way to our house. What. I thought she was coming next weekend. I got it. Alexa. Start the coffee. Set the temperature to 72. Start roomba. We got this. Dont look. What . Dont look. Lets move. Mom. The lexus es, eagerly prepared for the unexpected. Lease the 2020 es 350 for 389 a month for 36 months. Experience amazing at your lexus dealer. Beyond the routine checkups. Beyond the notsoroutine cases. Comcast business is helping doctors provide care in whole new ways. All working with a new generation of technologies powered by our gigspeed network. Because beyond technology. There is human ingenuity. Every day, comcast business is helping businesses go beyond the expected. To do the extraordinary. Take your business beyond. I wanted more from my copd medicine thats why ive got the power of 1, 2, 3 medicines with trelegy. The only fdaapproved oncedaily 3in1 copd treatment. Trelegy the power of 1,2,3 trelegy 1,2,3 trelegy man with trelegy and the power of 1, 2, 3, im breathing better. Trelegy works three ways to open airways, keep them open and reduce inflammation, for 24 hours of better breathing. Trelegy wont replace a rescue inhaler for sudden breathing problems. Trelegy is not for asthma. Tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking it. Do not take trelegy more than prescribed. Trelegy may increase your risk of thrush, pneumonia, and osteoporosis. Call your doctor if worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling, problems urinating, vision changes, or eye pain occur. Think your copd medicine is doing enough . Maybe you should think again. Ask your doctor about oncedaily trelegy and the power of 1, 2, 3. Trelegy, 1,2,3 man save at trelegy. Com. His stylist browsed hundreds of styles for him so that tonight,. John could feel totally himself. Let us find your perfect fit at stitchfix. Com. The administration conducted a provocative, disproportionate airstrike against iran which endangered americans and did so without consulting congress. We are passing today a war powers resolution to limit the president s military actions. The Administration Must deescalate and must protect prevent further violence. America and the world cannot afford war. Paul House Speaker nancy pelosi this week calling last weeks strike that killed Qassem Soleimani provocative and disproportionate. The house voted mostly along party lines wednesday. The nonbinding resolution directs the president to terminate the use of u. S. Armed forces unless Congress Declares war or there is, quote, an imminent armed attack upon the United States. George terwilliger served as Deputy Attorney general and acting attorney general during the george h. W. Bush administration. George, nice to see you again. You too, paul. Paul so lets talk about the accusation there that this, the implication by the speaker that this was an illegal action in taking and killing, the targeted killing of soleimani. Do you agree . No. The notion that it was illegal is absurd. The president has Plenary Authority under the constitution as commander in chief to act in defense of the nation. If you look at the example of when president ken canty deployed kennedy deployed military forces not to thwart an attack on the United States, but rather to neutralize the capability of the soviets to attack from missiles they had in cuba, we dont have to wait to be attacked in order for the president to act. And here this particular man had a history of attacking and having the potential to further attack the United States. Paul so this point that some people are making, well, the threat has to be imminent for the president to attack, you think that that is just false. I do. I mean, i think if there is an imminent attack, thats a factor. But the attack doesnt necessarily have to be imminent for the president to act. Its one of the flaws, frankly, in the war powers act that senator lieberman referenced in your with earlier segment. In that it, one of the three exceptions to that act, whatever the constitutionality of that act this general, is that the president is acting in response to an attack on the United States. It would be far better if that law said acting in response to an attack or the threat of attack on the United States. Paul what about the executive order on assassinations that goes back to assassinating government officials from other governments . It goes back to the ford administration. Some people have suggested that because soleimani was so senior in the iranian government, that that should have put him off limits to such an attack. Do you agree or disagree . No, i disagree with that because it is inherent in the right of national selfdefense to recognize that new forms of warfare require new forms of defense and response. And theres no question that the Iranian Revolutionary guards and this man in particular has been at war with the United States and has been for a long time and has employed lethal force and prosecution of that in prosecution of that war. So taking him out was not a political assassination, it was a military act. Paul all right. So lets talk about the war powers resolution. The house has now invoked its name at least the, although strangely only in a nonbinding resolution. What do you make of this house action . I mean, i guess its never going to make it to the president s desk because its nonbehinding. Right. Its not a law, its just a resolution. And, you know, i think, paul, if you want to understand why donald trump is president and what that great swell of american sentiment against washington and in favor of an outsider was, its exactly the kind of partisanship that senator lieberman described around a National Security issue like this. It makes people sick to see Something Like this politicized to the degree that it has been. There can be legitimate policy disputes about when and how to use military force. But to have this kneejerk reaction that because the president did it it must be bad is so obviously partisan that i think people see right through it. Paul what about this issue, though, of congressional authorization . The constitution stipulates the congress has the power to declare war. It hasnt invoked that specific power though since, i think, world war ii. Lots of uses of force since then. But is that, in your view, an abdication of congressional authority, and should the congress reassert it more vigorously the way that senate mike lee, for example, of utah, republican, has asserted it should . Well, abdication is both a big word and a strong term, paul. [laughter] im not sure that congress has paul im trying to provoke you, george, thats what im trying to do. [laughter] i think, frankly, they dodged their war authorization responsibility over the years. But maybe in a way that recognizes the realities of threats to America Today is healthy. If you just very quickly look at president reagan sought and obtained authorization from congress to put marines in lebanon. President bush, at the time that iraq invaded kuwait, sought and received even though he legally did not need it permission to put our forces at work there. President clinton also used certain provisions of the war powers act. So i think president s and congress, recognizing the realities of how things are today, have found a way to deal with it. But i dont think congress, you know, congress is not going to declare war because they dont want to be politically accountable for doing so. But theyre awful quick, it seems now, to pull the trigger on saying that what the president should not do. He has a responsibility under the constitution which trumps any statute to defend the country. Is so i think president s will continue to act as they see fit and necessary to do so. Paul all right. George terwilliger, thank you very much for that illumination. Appreciate it. Thank you, paul. Paul still ahead, Senate Majority leader Mitch Mcconnell gearing up for an impeachment trial in the senate as a former Trump Administration official says hes willing to testify if subpoenaed. House democrats had their say in december. Senate republicans are going to have their say real soon. The epson ecotank. No more buying cartridges. Look at all this ink it comes with. Big ink tanks. Lots of ink. No more cartridges. Incredible amount of ink. The epson ecotank. Just fill and chill. And my lack of impulse control, is about to become your problem. Ahh no, come on. I saw you eating poop earlier. Hey my focus is on the road, and thats saving me cash with drivewise. Whos the dummy now . Whoof whoof so get allstate where good drivers save 40 for avoiding mayhem, like me. Sorry hes a baby everything your trip needs for everyone you love. Expedia. For everyone you love. Apps except work. Rywhere. Why is that . Is it because people love filling out forms . Maybe they like checking with their supervisor to see how much Vacation Time they have. Or sending corporate their expense reports. Ill let you in on a little secret. They dont. By empowering employees to manage their own tasks, paycom frees you to focus on the business of business. To learn more, visit paycom. Com this is the epson no more buying cartridges. Big ink tanks. Lots of ink. Print about. This many pages. The epson ecotank. Just fill and chill. Paul Majority Leader Mitch Mcconnell gearing up to begin President Trumps trial in the senate as House Speaker nancy pelosi says she will send the articles of impeachment next week. The gop leader saying that he has the 51 votes needed to establish the impeachment rules and delay a decision on calling witnesses until after opening arguments and questions from senators. And telling pelosi that there would be no haggling over the terms of the trial. All this as former National Security add add rise adviser john bolton says hes ready to testify during the proceedings hes subpoenaed. Were back with Dan Henninger, kim strassel and bill mcgurn. Kim, looks like the speaker of the house has yielded the floor, so to speak, to Mitch Mcconnell. [laughter] why do you think she finally gave in . Well, i think its because Mitch Mcconnell has been remarkably consistent from the start about this. He has both said that the house was not going to dictate senate rules, and hes also said that the senate was going to conduct a trial much in line with the clinton impeachment trial the last time around. And that consistency ended up being very persuasive with his republican colleague, even the moderates folks like mitt romney or Susan Collins who gave him the votes to say, yes, lets start. In the face of that, even democrats understand that they could not win this battle, and they have conceded. Paul yeah. Of Chuck Schumer and nancy pelosi seem to be in league here, with Chuck Schumer demanding witnesses and pelosi backing him up. Some democrats in the senate were finally losing patience, Dianne Feinstein, joe manchin, some others, said lets get on with it. They had even lost support among democrats. Well, it was becoming clear just how incredibly cynical this move was after House Democrats spent months, this is urgent, it must get done, and then to just sit there on them. And i think those democrats were getting some blowback in their districts and increasing worries that this was looking highly political and it could blow back against the party. Paul and i would say theres probably one very happy democrat in the house, bill, and thats adam schiff. As the chief impeacher, hes now going to get his star turn. This is going to be the capstone of his career, making the case to impeach donald trump. Right. And the question is what kind of case theyre going to make. Again, i think paul i think it will be grand eloquent. Well, the question is on the witnesses. They defer that decision for a while. So mcconnell has two things op his side. Right now he has the constitution that leapts the senate set the rules and the votes. And as long as he has those two, he can do whatever he wants. Im not really sure the democrats really want witnesses because what if they subpoena joe biden or hunter biden . Im not sure they really want it. And igy, again, one of the priorities of the senate is to show the disdain for this goldberg way that nancy pelosi handled impeachment, the unfairness of her process and so forth. And now its out of her hands. You know whats incredible about this is the extent to which weve been talking about nancy pelosi, impeachment, trial in the senate, is so forth. Donald trump has become basically a bystander. Hes fallen out of the news. As we know, its nominally about him, but hes standing over there watching the senate and the house fight with one another paul well, but actually this is very shrewd. Hes been asked about it every single press event. What do you think about witnesses, mr. President . Thats up to the senate. Thats smart. Let mcconnell handle it. And i think it was very telling that Dianne Feinstein as well as senator Dick Blumenthal of connecticut, very liberal, he also said they had to get on with it. They have concluded the democrats are getting nothing out of this process, paul. There is no political sure, its political, but wheres the political benefit . They havent moved the needle, and its beginning to hurt them. Paul kim, what kind of trial do you think were going to see . Is it going to be limited, do you think, to arguments from the house impeachment managers for ouster, conviction, and then the president s lawyers defending it without witnesses, or are we likely to see some witnesses called . Well, mcconnell has made clear that what you just outlined is, indeed, what the trial will initially consist of, house impeachment managers and importantly, because weve never heard this yet, a defense from the president s team. Thats going to be new and important because they were denied that in the house. In terms of further witnesses, i think, look, republicans have made the very powerful argument that democrats said that they had enough already to impeach donald trump. So its their job to look at what the house presents, why is it the senates job to go and try and find yet further information, make a judgment on what the houses work product already . So thatll be the argument probably mcconnell makes. Well see if his moderates stick with that or feel pressure to go further. Paul and is there going to be, if john bolton is called, is there going to be any deep, dark secret that he is relaying to the country . I dont know. I mean, he might say some things that are embarrassing for some of the other members of the trump team, but i dont think hes going to have if democrats are hoping for some magic bullet to say donald trump is guilty, i dont think hes going to have it. And, again, as i said before, i think if you go the bolton route and you sweep that him, then i think theyre going to go the joe biden route and subpoena joe biden. Paul i dont know that theyll the republicans i talk to dont want to go with joe biden. They may go with hunter, and that in the end but you open the door to all sorts of other possibilities in a chamber that the democrats do not control. Paul one thing that john bolton will say, he didnt like what Rudy Giuliani was doing in ukraine. What do you think . [laughter] he may say, look, he didnt like the ukraine policy, withholding the aid, but john bolton was in government every day of his life engaged in this. Hes a really good bureaucratic. Fighter, and i think hed tell them, this was no different, i just disagreed with it, and i left. End of story. Paul all right, thank you. When we come back, in the wake of the iran showdown, a closer look at the economic and Strategic Benefits of the american oil boom. Oh, hi, samantha. You look more like a heather. Do you ever get that . Its nice to finally meet you in person. Youre pete nocchio . Oh, the pic . That was actually a professional headshot. Im sure thats it, yeah. I, uh, i think ive lost a few pounds recently too. Im actually doing a juice cleanse. Wait you dont. glass breaking gasp ah oh. with geico, the savings keep on going. Just like this sequel. 15 minutes could save you 15 or more on Car Insurance. I am totally blind. And non24 can throw my days and nights out of sync, keeping me from the things i love to do. Talk to your doctor, and call 8442142424. groans hmph. food grunting menacingly when the food you love doesnt love you back, stay smooth and fight heartburn fast with tums smoothies. Tum tumtum tum tums with tums smoothies. Thats it. Im calling kohler about their walkin bath. Nah. Not gonna happen. My name is ken. How may i help you . Hi, im calling about kohlers walkin bath. Excellent happy to help. Huh . Hold one moment please. [ finger snaps ] hmm. The kohler walkin bath features an extrawide opening and a low stepin at three inches, which is 25 to 60 lower than some leading competitors. The bath fills and drains quickly, while the heated seat soothes your back, neck and shoulders. Kohler is an expert in bathing, so you can count on a deep soaking experience. Are you seeing this . The kohler walkin bath comes with fully adjustable hydrotherapy jets and our exclusive bubblemassage. Everything is installed in as little as a day by a kohlercertified installer. And its made by kohler americas leading plumbing brand. We need this bath. Yes. Yes you do. A kohler walkin bath provides independence with peace of mind. Our economy is stronger than ever before, is and americas achieved energy independence. We are now the number one producer of oil and natural gas anywhere in the world. We are independent, and we do not need middle east oil. Paul President Trump touting the strength of the u. S. Economy wednesday in the wake of irans attack on u. S. Bases in iraq. Oil prices have remained remarkably steady since the soleimani strike, a far cry from previous periods of tension in the middle east. Were back with dan, kim and bill. Bill, you know, really striking, oil prices did pop up but not that much. And, you know, 56 a gallon for a while and, of course, theyre back down on the easing of tensions. But a lot of this has to do with the american oil revolution. Right. Look, we both remember the days of opecing and so forth. The real problem with oil before was that a lot of it was in the hands of bad actors, right . Bad countries that are not necessarily amenable to us. One reason saudi arabia was so important for us. All these alternative forms of energy have just done wonders for the market, and its a National Security factor. The president , doing this has to calculate the impact, and this is almost no impact. Paul look, its amazing, when you think about it, dan. Venezuela, through sanctions, its oil exports have been really vastly reduced. You have the iranian exports through sanctions vastly reduced. Theres still a glut of oil on the global markets, and so you take out two really bad actors, it just increases the president flexibility strategically the president s flexibility strategically to be able to take action against rogue actors. Yeah, thats right. And we have to include the fracking revolution in here paul central to it. Central to it. Most of which the independence the president s talking about has happened since his election. So that raises the question up what exactly has been democratic policy towards energy. And again, this is sort of like Foreign Policy, paul. The basic position is that fossil fuels, all forms of energy excavation, exploration are off the table. And so Barack Obamas presidency did a lot to suppress Energy Exploration paul well, but they they said wind, solar, the rest of it, give me a break. That isnt going to produce energy in the short term. Paul but they would say, no, look, it happened on my watch. We didnt stop it. Kim . They tried to stop it. No, no, no, no. What dans describing is barack obama had a managed plan for energy development, all of which proved to be a debacle, wind, solar, exceptional amounts of money spent on things like solyndra. What happened under his watch was that the private economy, private industry came up with a revolutionary new technique called fracking and horizontal drilling which revolutionized the oil market. So this happened despite barack obama. Now, he didnt get in the way as much as he might have, but what youve seen is donald trump really expand on this, really unleash it. And that is what has made this important difference in most recent years. Paul kim, tell the audience what happened in 2015 when, to lift what had been an export ban on oil. That was lifted, and now we really have a boom in exports. What happened . Yeah. So this was an example of Government Action making a good decision. So in light of this huge change in the oil industry, we had all this oil surging in the United States. We lifted a 40yearold export ban. There were people that worried and said, oh, you know, this is going to be less for america, higher prices. In fact, thats not how economics works. You put it out on the market, it keeps the market stable, it ultimately lowers prices overall. Its been a great boon for u. S. Producers and the u. S. Economy, but the world too because of greater stability and more flexibility, as you mentioned, for western leaders to take actions against rogue actors. Paul and that was insisted upon by House Republicans when they took the house. Paul ryan, i remember the negotiations. The trade was well lift the export ban, the republicans, mr. President , well lift the export ban, put it into law, if and well give you your subsidy extension for some of the solar and wind right. Look, the democrats were live anything a state where andrew cuomo opposed fracking. Paul still does. Still does. And, you know, one of the reasons the out of city population has said, well, look, the second part of this you said it was flexible . Its also depriving our enemies of revenues, right . Venezuela, russia, iran. Paul we have to take one more break. When we come back, hits and misses of the week. Fun fact 1 in 4 of us millennials have debt we might die with. And most of that debt is actually from credit cards. Its just not right. But with sofi, you can get your credit cards right by consolidating your Credit Card Debt into one monthly payment. Including your Interest Rate right by locking in a fixed low rate today. And you can get your money right with sofi. Check your rate in two minutes or less. Get a nofee personal loan up to 100k. Get a nofee personal loan do you recall, not long ago we would walk on the sidewalk all around the wind blows we would only hold on to let go blow a kiss into the sun we need someone to lean on blow a kiss into the sun we needed somebody to lean on all we need is someone to lean on my agerelated macular degenso today i made a plan with my doctor, which includes preservision. Because he said a multi vitamin alone may not be enough. And its my vision, my morning walk, my sunday drive, my grandsons beautiful face. Only preservision areds2 contains the exact nutrient formula recommended by the National Eye Institute to help reduce the risk of moderate to advanced amd progression. Its how i see my life. Because its my vision. Preservision. Teaching kids and having kids of my own. I didnt realize that having kids would be the hard part. So we planned to start ivf treatments. Now im ready for someone to call me mom. At Northwestern Mutual, our version of Financial Planning helps you live your dreams today. Find a Northwestern Mutual advisor at nm dot com. Time now for our hits and misses of the week. I huge hit to the American Cancer Society announcement cancer mortality rates have plunged about 30 . Part of this is better habits, less smoking. Better screening and earlier a lot of it because of breakthrough therapies all of this is because of a free and innovative market normally i am for government workers getting off the state payroll. A big miss as prince harry and his wife megan are looking for a more progressive role theyve also trademarked the brand sussex royal. Even for this Irish American i am equate with the queen on this one. God save andrew cuomo of new york. He promised to legalize marijuana. They have a 6 billiondollar budget deficit. He also said he wants studies to see he would like to avoid another Opioid Crisis isnt as he is legalizing in the step. It is incredible. Thats it for this weeks show. Thank you for watching. We hope to see right here next week. I hope you got a heck of a lot of money to get a lot more. Maries next. Space. Maria happy weekend everybody welcome to the program that analyzes the week that wasnt help position you for the week ahead. I am maria and thanks for joining us. Coming up in just a few moments a pair of explosives this weekend. First bank of americas 2020 productions. Chief Investment Officer chris is giving us his outlook and then later my oneonone with auto giant carlos on the heel of his amazing escape to lebanon from japan. He was in house arrest hes going to tells all about it and what his plans are next. But first the december jobs report friday capped