And provided the right direction as they move forward with their lives astray is most senior Catholic has won the right to appeal against his convictions for child sex abuse George Pell who's 78 was jailed for 6 years in March for abusing 2 boys in Melbourne in the 1990 s. He's always denied any wrongdoing. Concerns have been raised about an n.h.s. Scheme which I used to help people with mental health issues in England more than 20 Serapis sov told 5 life patients were coached into entering inflated wellbeing measurements to try to increase success rates and h.s. England says any falsification is unacceptable yet h.s. Is expected to be the focus of election campaigning later Labor will announce a package of health policies including bringing back bursaries for student nurses in England to help with the cost of studying the party says it'll spend the conservatives on health. A draft copy of the review applied a hitch to says it should be built despite the huge costs the report was commissioned by Boris Johnson in August and won't be published until after the election Michael being worked on costing for Network Rail he says it won't be value for money I believe it cost $106000000000.00 I believe it won't be delivered so at least 2035 possibly 2040 and the sheer costs the benefits can deliver over that Sean and beaches have been closed in France after hundreds of packages of cocaine were washed up along the Atlantic coast almost a tonne of the drug has been recovered so far but let's get the latest on England's tast a warm up match against New Zealand 11 from out among fires yes 53 for 2 the New Zealand 11 side replied and 37645 arches his 1st wicket of the tour McCoy ever to be for 7 months had another rushing the ball just dropping short of stokes and stupor all struck with his 3rd ball before lunch early in England's total Pokemon $31.00 butter and Vietnam 38 and stakes 30 this commentary over on 5 Live Sports Extra here on 5 Live in get the rest of the sport with an accountant Lee Williamson's 1st international goal rescued like 3 to win for England's women in their friendly against the Czech Republic and even the pressure on manager Phil Neville. Where Northern Ireland against Wales finished in a goal is stronger in their Euro core fire Gar sad case says England's players have already drawn a line under the rain Sterling and Joe Gomez spat and are ready to focus on the football move Fabian Delph has left the England squad and would send Everts and because of injury Dominic's a mystery to the last 4 of the a.t.p. Tour Finals for the very 1st time he beat Novak Djokovic and I finals that time break and Briton Sophie hard broke her own world record when her 4th consecutive t. 38100 metres title that's at the World Power Athletics Championships in Dubai this is b.b.c. Radio 5 Live on digital b.b.c. Says it's. In the weather forecast it's expected to feel rather called overnight as rain eases off in most places leaving clear skies Wednesday will be chilly and largely dry for many but northern and western parts are likely to see one or 2 sharks the right the day highs of at 3 degrees in Edinburgh and 9 in London b.b.c. Sound. It's dark on the ground in case done quite often. Where the act in front of you for hours and you a. Clear. Weather the name of the earth around you could collapse Every your life that the water gently dripping into the space has nowhere else to go. Or the soldier on patrol just a few metres above your head was. On fire. 29 the podcast about a remarkable true escape underneath the Berlin wall download the free b.b.c. Found out to listen. To them around the u.k. On digital and on why I brought shopping. And we're up all night in December 24th team lawyers representing the parents and relatives of 20 school children aged between 6 and 7 their principal 3 teachers and 2 education specialists began a lawsuit for unspecified damages after they die by the hand of a lone gunman who attacked our school the building at Sandy Hook Elementary in Connecticut has long since been razed to the gravel and a new school opened in its place the gun store where the murder semiautomatic Bushmaster together with 1030 round magazines were bought was closed and on Tuesday the Supreme Court allowed the lawsuit suing Bushmaster Remington cam for firearms and Riverview sales the defunct gun store for unspecified damages to go ahead prime minister bars Johnson has described the flooding in northern England as an absolute tragedy as he announced more support for the communities affected the government's America's sick Cobra committee met on Tuesday afternoon as the opposition continued to pummel the government for what Jeremy carbon called a wall full response there will be people who feel it isn't good enough said Mr Johnson adding There are schemes to cover those losses Carol Foster who lives near the river dawn in the village of Kut promise in South Yorkshire says she's been completely cut off now for 5 days it's just a huge lake all around me. Food that is just I don't have any power so I only. Know which of the flat fall so I'll be seeing you know puns of milk for hot drinks and or to watch a prize a put them on top of the warm through so it's been really back to basics. From today another 100 members of the armed forces will be deployed to help the bell once again makes America the compensation available to councils for temporary accommodation and new funding allows up to 2 and a half 1000 pounds for small medium sized businesses have been flooded but don't have insurance 5 lives are on bridge spent his Tuesday in the area well right I started off in a place called Bentley It's a suburb of Doncaster and it was one of the areas that was most badly affected by the flooding on Friday when I was there the roads that were underwater impassable today when I was there the water levels have receded the river Donna's has gone back into the river but what you have is the sort of tale of destruction the you always have with this flooding so I went down to there's a caravan park there where people's homes are and of course they're single storey buildings so for people whose homes were flooded where they've got a 2 story building they could move up stairs or move belongings of course if you're in a caravan park in their single storey buildings there is nowhere to go and that caravan park is right by the river done so is one of the areas that most heavily affected by the flooding on Friday I went out there today and literally you saw people's lives thrown out into the streets and may have had to rip out you know that the floor is all gone they've had to throw up belongings and the buildings you could just feel the dampness in the air people are desperately trying to dry out their caravans and so awful so are they expecting more I mean the forecast at the moment for the next sort of 24 hours or so doesn't look too bad. But there is an awful lot of water still on the ground in some places so for example fish like. Not far from Don Cass that is pretty much cut off at the moment or has been today certainly you needed sort of a 4 by 4 attracted to be able to get in that there's about 500 homes in the Doncaster area that have been flooded around a 1000 or so that have been evacuated and now those water levels have started to recede and will probably fall again through went through Wednesday the concern is that there is forecast for more heavy rain on Thursday and that that could then cause further damage or you know you could see further flooding happening then and that is going to be a real concern for people who've already seen their homes flooded out in the last sort of 48 hours or so I see the prime minister now says he's making 2 and a half 1000 pounds available to every business affected by the flooding doesn't sound like all that much money from a from a business point of view are most businesses carrying flood insurance Yeah I mean there's a couple of things that they announce are 3 things really one is. They are going to bring in $100.00 more army personnel into South Yorkshire to help with the recovery efforts there's also going to be money for local authorities the equivalent of $500.00 pounds per eligible household towards the cost of things like running rescue sensors overtime for staff So for example I was at a community resource center where people have been donating goods all day today that is being kept open overnight it's been staffed by council staff so some of the money the government is promising will pay things like their wages for example then there is as you say the $2.00 you know are 1000 pounds for small and medium sized businesses who suffer damage that's not covered by insurance the key thing there is not covered by insurance so lots of people will have flood insurance but some of them won't and I think the problem is some businesses may well not have flood insurance because it wasn't part of their insurance policy and this is to go towards some of their costs but do nothing $1000.00 pounds I don't think is necessarily going to cover the full costs of some of those businesses in terms of what they're going to have to replace and repair. And the government response is evident that the government is in there no helping the local authorities Yeah I mean the response has become more coordinated on the ground you know you see some bags at people's doors people are donating. Stuff to to the relief effort and in fact they were saying that people in Fish Lake don't actually need any more help and supplies immediately you know the people who wanted to get out of got out people have got what they need for the short term. The situation now is really it's going to be one of waiting for those floodwaters to recede and then the real clear up operation is going to be Ok now the mop some buckets and sweeping out all the Deputy clearing out people's houses and taking that debris away now some of that started in some of the areas where I was today for example in Bentley where the roads have cleared and the local authority has been out trying to clear some of that rubbish but it is a massive task and there is still a lot to do on that front. And when you were traveling could you see any evidence of livestock being affected by the flooding I mean there are any farmers talking about what they're going to do yeah I mean it's interesting that I've lost even driving through urban areas so you've not seen sort of farmland but I have seen aerial footage and it is devastating I mean it's hard to tell where the river Dawn finishes and that farmland starts are just massive swathes of it which have been overtaken by flood waters and you would presume livestock is well within that So I think there is going to be you know farm is definitely going to be severely affected by this flood as well as ordinary homeowners and business owners as well and we have at least 11 death farmer high sheriff of Darbyshire. Yes that was over the weekend the details are released of that and that was in flood water in the Midlands because. Although a lot of attention has been on on South Yorkshire as a source of Ground 0 this problem there's of been there's been flooding in other parts of. The Midlands as well and as a say the problem now is further rainfall forecast for Thursday which is probably going to have the most severe effects around South Yorkshire but there is also the possibility of some other localized flooding across much of England on Thursday as well. Ron bridge Well Spain had an election on Sunday but the trouble is it's left the country in an even less certain position that it was before still has not stopped the socialists of the present prime minister signing an agreement to try and work together with the hard left put de Marse bloc to try to farm a progressive coalition government Prime Minister Petro Sanchez is hoping that this deal can last for 4 years well the trouble is they tried it before in April it didn't work at all fight and fell apart before it began I ask airline grey light sure and politics and Spanish University in Birmingham why it should work this time well I think basically the change in circumstance is just the difference election results last time around we have to remember in April the off the April elections the Socialists won those elections but with only $123.00 seats out of $350.00 in Spanish parliament and they hoped that if they had run an election rerun they would be able to build on build on the opposition gain more seats and be able to form a stronger government without needing a coalition that backfired they ended up with fewer seats this time round of really the only policy that gained from the electoral rerun was the far right as well as the conservatives so the so the left realized that really plans to rerun elections backfired that the. They need to form a government if they don't want to give the far right more of a chance to to grow further and so really that explains why now the socialists and pull their most have got together very quickly to try and come to an agreement and do they have enough to make a majority government of the 2 of them do sit side by side No I mean that's the big issue this is not the situation is not solved between the socialists and their most they have 155 seats between them but for an absolute majority in the Spanish parliament you need 176 seats so they're still short and they will need to negotiate with other parties now there are some who are likely to support some smaller parties like for example there's an offshoot of them us which has 3 seats the Basque nationalists are probably quite likely to support it they have 7 seats but what's going to be very difficult is that really they need one of the Catalan pro independence parties to support this government and that's going to be very difficult indeed to achieve Yeah you might say when pigs fly that's a problem from a society isn't it. Yes it is definitely a problem I mean let's not forget that it was the Catalan pro independence parties who affectively brought down the last socialist government and that's why we had elections in April in the 1st place because at the time you had a minority socialist government which needed support from people that most and an array of regional based parties including the Catalan prone dependence parties and I actually when the sun just tried to pass the 200-1000 budget the Catalan pro Independence Party said no we're not supporting it unless you unless you give us an opportunity to hold a referendum on independence and not effectively was what led Sanchez to call early elections in the end so it is obviously a very difficult scenario we've been in that situation and essentially we're in that situation again now and what about the chemistry between Mr Sanchez and the far left the put they mostly don't. Well it's very interesting because you know after the April of the actions they really they seem to be so much animosity between them I mean they negotiated for weeks on end couldn't do anything but fight with each other and yet now within you know 48 hours of the reelection rerun suddenly they're hugging each other and saying their best pals but I think really we have to understand that use of the fact that the plan the socialist plan to get more seats back Fahd's pulled their most also lost seats so you're left wing parties both lost seats in this election and the right wing policies were the ones that gain seats so it's not in the interests of Sanchez or in the interests of the head of the Palermo's party yes for an another election rerun so they will want to form a government so I'm getting the impression that speed is really quite important here they want to do this before the far right on the right have a chance to really group themselves. Well to be honest the right wing parties wouldn't manage to form a government now unless there were further elections and they gained more seats because between them the right wing parties don't have an absolute majority either and certainly there will not be any regional based parties who would be willing to support a right wing government because you have to bear in mind that in Spain your right wing parties a far more centralist they're the ones that are most proposing to crack down on cattle and independents but not just the us I mean you're far right Vox For example it suggests completely removing any form of devolved powers in Spain and re centralizing ever saying there are no regional based policies that would support that so in the grand scheme of things it is more likely that you will get regionally based parties to support a left wing government than a right wing government Caroline grey from Ashton University on what happens next and spade. Well let's head up to France it was about a has been telling me about Emanuel Mark Karr who recently talked about the dangers of NATO becoming braindead and hasn't been willing friends in any other countries of the European Union either well to some extent the problem of McCourt is that he came with such promise he was probably the only real leader in Europe political leader who actually can paint for the presidency in our case with as many European blue all flags as French tricolors and he kept on saying we want more unity we want the e.u. To be stronger want it we wanted to go to the next direction and it was you know it was beyond the dreams of the people at the commission and the European Parliament to begin with but they have started thinking that yes he wants more Europe and he was this more Europe to be directed by the French and this is not popular at all or at least that's the perception of the government here and the Foreign Affairs Ministry will tell you that that's not the case and things started rather badly because they made him across party is a brand new bull and so they couldn't join the a conservative group because they're not really conservative they couldn't join the e.p. The broad center right group because that's where little of is this is a lot it and they decided to join the centrist party. Called Paris and having joined it they were immediately decided that because the French number and then peace was was your own peace was larger. Candidate who was the head of his list at the European elections last year. And that he was all former European Affairs Minister would as a matter of course become the president of that group well this was possibly acceptable here. Arrived in Brussels having been anointed by the president and having led an extremely lackluster European campaign in Paris and the 1st thing she did was to call a press briefing with about 12 or 15 journalists most of them were French but not all and this was supposed to be Chatham House rules you do not quote the person in question after which she spent 20 minutes insulting everybody in sight she insulted men for their bar the instance of Candide out of the German conservatives and the e.p.t. She insulted that you did not want him to be the president of the commission anyway so she probably was following you at least a blueprint but she started insulting the most important m.p. In her own party the group who she wanted to be president there her shut out is a very outspoken Belgian m.p. Few think Belgian m.p. Ben Pease and your own piece in general are grey figures well that's not what he is he's a bit of the greats. And he's articulate he's scathing and as she told 12 journalists that he was ridiculous you know she learnt it with everybody else and then she said well you know we'll have to change your organization because frankly what I see of this is that it's not well organized I'm not sure she was talking about the European Parliament a lot or just the other party but the result of this was complete anger among those people who were supposed to allies at the end of which she did not become the president the president of the group and she sort of put really sort of smoked most of the relations with the rest of the Europe and next thing you know we have to nominate for the new commission a a French commission of the French commission are supposed to be to have a very large fault furniture which was the next year to buy a Macor it it had financial regulation it had economics it. Industry and it was a mega ball courier it was a new thing. Against the advice of all his experts they are Macor nominated and Euro and he Netanyahu who is quite competent but she's also under. Investigation for corruption with her party and everybody said look it is not going to flood he still fielded her she was heard by the Euro M.P.'s who listen to who is in the hearings for new commission proposed commissioners and basically they they they fund and they float ert remembering what night it was who had said above and thinking you know there are various reasons that we can we can flag this woman we feel that she should not be running for this we feel that her portfolio is too large and incidentally we've been insulted by her lost and by. And that's too much one single woman so that's it Michael has nominated another character auditioned for a commission and this is just it were to a former head of at last the company that's well in service company known in Britain too says not necessarily popular and little was absolutely not popular at the doors and he had to leave in disgrace and before that he had been finance minister in France and he also had to leave. For well it call in political reasons there are questions in bottles c.v. Of conflict of interest and the question is how ready how sort of how much have the Euro M.P.'s got the bit between their teeth about Macor not a capable of thinking is 2nd and date this does not look good and the question is it's been 2 years and a half it's exactly half term for Macor he came in as the shining young leader who would rescue Europe and in effect he has made himself vastly in popular in Brussels that's a no go. Now the mayor of Paris jobbers coming up. Here Gore has been. Quite a popular mayor of Paris won't be standing again she's done her 2 terms as a right no I don't know could stand as long as she wants and she's not popular anymore and must of Eat talent to machine party person she's a socialist she was what she was once quite close to forswear a lot she was the deputy of the previous socialist mayor of Paris who was quite popular but under new it and she absolutely is running again but she her decisions in all directions have been so in particular that that could be a possibility. Unseating there are lots of candidates left and right against. The candidates that everyone hears about of course is the candidate being fielded officially by mineral McCloy or was. It to be karma and he's called version of evolution of people as a kind of clone of him and make work he's our young white man 4840 in good spirits and he used to be the government spokesman and sitting in cabinet and he is completely that lost. He certainly is not a local politician somebody who sort of you know presses the flesh and talks with people and so far I'm a woman who has decided that never never Might this is his candidate but he's got a possible other candidate in reserve for the possible other candidate in result this is Michael making hay of. His own difficulties he is a mathematician or city green and he is incredibly colorful He looks like a dandy of the 830 years he's got he was. A colorful the jacket he has long hair and a lovely little musketeer. He's a mathematician who what if feels medals that's the equivalent of a Nobel Prize for mathematics and he has refused to stand but only form and of course candidate ask him too much who has left them to it hoping that who. Sort of floats to the surface will be his candidate which is a strange way of feeling against it then you've got a socialist you've got a communist you got a green they were headed to a night 2 and then you go and finally you got the underdog and it's the underdog I'd like to mention this time because nobody is giving her any chances she's a 100 to one we don't have bookmakers the way you have in England but she certainly is not the person you expect to it and she's got a high she does debts She's French Moroccan she must be about 45 she was and he could I suppose he's must Minister for Justice she is energetic branch has been accused of being slightly being mean but she was asked by primary to pose on the cover and she she borrowed clothes from Joe and then people said she was bling it was a bit unfair if you're a woman you're barely dressed people are going to poke fun at you as well she was put in charge by Sarkozy the judicial reform which was an extremely difficult thing because the idea was to reorganize the the map of tribunals all across France the Ministry of Justice in France is is it's an ministration the judges are civil servants and it was a complicated and unpopular reform and she she led it quite bravely and so has the respect. She essentially had been chosen by the right in Paris because they felt they could they could not win and they've got a number of candidates who are men the men of the past and they felt well you know this is the election we can't win that send a woman to do this and. Some of us old enough remember that this is more or less what happened to Margaret Thatcher in the seventy's when people thought oh cut when you know let's let's give her the leadership she's I mean she worked at it as well but that fell to that and she did it he can either do what her predecessors did or in fact start reading energetic campaign and surprise people and lie herself with a group. That doesn't want any longer to true to stand within and he doubtless correlation but that's a possibility and it would be very interesting to see you know when. Well know the authority of those in charge of Paris has council housing as public housing has had a lovely idea for some of its very oldest residents yes this is this is this is this week's feel good story because the editor which is the council house authority and Paris are not always popular and the l a they are worried Paris like London has got extremely expensive 3 rents and not enough really available moderate council housing for everyone and one of the problems that the identified but they find it difficult to deal on it is that they've got elderly people who are eligible for the size of flats usually it's not separatist. They moved into 40 years ago but their children are gone possibly the husband or wife has died and they are all alone in those shots and they themselves are facing going to a care home because they start really needed a bit of help and they do not want to go to care and the solution that both groups for the elderly when is an engineer in the other one is public they decide they want this elsewhere the cancer has authority that he and and the ideas will find we've got young people who cannot afford the rents in Paris a small room which can be a $7800.00 euros a month to London renters it's not much to Paris renters it still is quite a lot and certainly is more than what a student at before can afford and the idea is to have them share with an all person who is interested in having somebody live with it's often women and so they decided too much personality isn't to run. Ads in which we say that it will find someone will see if you're a match and. Then you will have a perfectly aboveboard official rent subbrand so subtle that within the flight of somebody else. It will be securely you because he got out unless you misbehave but the whole thing can work out and so they now have found it's a beginning program they felt about 30 or 40 young people who have been much too elderly people under stories that come out of this hot woman because you have family people all people whose families worry about them but we need to be there all the time do not necessarily want them in camps but are afraid to leave them alone in a flat and you've got young people who start helping with things like just finding out bureaucracy especially online and sort of being there is a presence and as long as they have a sort of living arrangement and they they have rules in the beginning you know you come home at such and such a time where you know me know that sort of thing. These are the solve the problem of the young person who is looking for a place to stay the elderly person who may need someone full time but can't afford the round the clock professional care and the council house the thirty's who sold the problem of under a 2 can see by older people and unneeded you know would be renters looking for places to live. And Elizabeth moved in Paris at just after half past 1. On digital b.b.c. Sent us 3. Cities b.b.c. Radio 5 live here with the news it's clear Graham pushed on Send has a mind to more support for communities affected by floods in northern England more Army personnel are being deployed and there will be up to 2500 pints for small and medium side space Mrs not covered by insurance a number of Says saying and former Conservative consular is have been accused of sharing or endorsing racist or anti Muslim content online The Guardian says it's seen a number of social media posts compiled an adult ca. 2 parents who murdered their 2 teenaged sons of been sentenced to 35 years each in prison Sarah and Brandon mentioned here also half brother and sister killed the boys aged $13.14 in Sheffield in May and French police are trying to work out why more than a thaw is in Quito of cocaine contained in hundreds of packets of them washing up on beaches the bags have been seen from nonce in the northwest to be arrests more than 500 kilometers to the site by it's day 2 of England's warm up test against a New Zealand 11 a month for it has the latest force and the local side of $84.00 Tewson a breakthrough for England in the last little while since Archer took a week at just after the lunch period just to a broader shtick with his 3rd ball just before lunch went all the oil but just as a pretty good although he did get a cut for 6 gnashing his 1st over but he's got a bit of pace going we're now seeing Ben Stokes and Jet Leach having their 1st bowl of the top to some occurrence at the new ball wasn't expected to place day after featuring all those Cheech onesies but Sakhi Mahmood has a migraine so he's back at the hotel in an area 376 for a fight Butler 39 not out stakes 30 Pope out for a fluent 30 want to reach retiring on his overnight 41 saves 80 for chewing apart that 37645 you can hear comments on this game from 5 Live Sports Extra right now but here on 5 Live Let's get the rest sports with Nick happened earlier Williamson's 1st international goal rescued late 3 to win for England's women in their friendly against the Czech Republic easing the pressure on a jet Phil Neville Williamson's goal came in the 86 minutes but never felt his side should have done better process I think we should be beating Czech Republic by more than 3 goals to say but I suppose it's the last game of the year we wanted to finish on on some kind of when we did the players upon unbelievable effort in this these last 12 months we know the last 3 months have been good enough for myself all the same we know that we take responses. For the Northern Ireland Wales women had to settle for a point of pace and a goal a stroll that does little for either side 02021 qualification prospects and the manager guy says Kate says his players have already drawn a line under the Raheem Sterling and Joe Gomez spat in a ready to focus on the football Sterling's been dropped for Thursday's Euro qualifier against Montenegro they told him defend the Danny Rose says everybody must move on for me it's just something that you know ups of seeing you know many a time been a professional and you just literally shake hands and we all move forward and we've got a massive game on Thursday that we have to win we want to win but we have to be Man professional and we move on meanwhile Fabian Belfast withdrawn from the squad because of injury and Tomic same is true to the last 4 of the a.t.p. Tour Finals for the very 1st time their district or his driving charge backwards for a cross-court party mistress left headed their 2000 but Joe coverage heard that so much it means to talk about it teams were told is back I am real the person in the stadium over their feet tall Money team has just one more the person matches the artillery and has ever see guest same basic question 2 hours and 47 minutes Djokovic will face Roger Federer on Thursday to decide who goes through to the semifinals before British Cycling technical director and Team Sky head coach Shane Sutton furiously deny claims that he's a doper for storming out of Dr Richard Freeman's medical tribunals Dr Freeman alleges the testosterone that he ordered to British Cycling headquarters in 2011 was on behalf of Sutton That's a claim that Sutton denies and spoke outside after his appearance to bring up things like me winning medals and no one in 78 did that seriously who is it was in my past history it's about me here painted judge a British saw it and tames God you know particular period in we've done nothing wrong and was stick to that that you know this was nothing to do with me finally Britain Sophie on broke her own world record with her 4th kid. Of t. $38100.00 metres title that was at the will power Athletics Championships in to buy . This podcast the one and only. Goal against Leicester. It's not a game we just have to express something on the pitch that we and other times. I was fortunate to be the guy to do it. And Bronx for everything going on in the world of football schools surely they're going to get into the Champions League. Table the Premier League this year download the free b.b.c. Sounds confusing radio and podcasts this is b.b.c. Radio 5 available on the b.b.c. Sounds cool night with rock shop the Us Supreme Court gave hope on shoes day to the parents and families of those who were murdered by the range gunman at Sandy Hook Elementary School 7 years ago by refusing to hear an appeal by the Remington gun company the court affectively greenlighted the parents' lawsuit against Remington and its Bushmaster subsidiary which manufactured the a r 15 deployed against defenseless 6 and 7 year olds by Adam Lanza Remington argued unsuccess way that they were protected from prosecution by the protection of lawful commerce and which became a law in the United States in 2005 Chris Brown joins us Chrysis president of Brady united the gun control campaign named after President Reagan's popular press secretary who took a bullet to the head in the failed presidential assassination attempt 1981 Well Chris you must be quite pleased. We are cut quite pleased this is a really important victory for victims and survivors who deserve their day in court unfortunately as you well know that the plaque of the proper protection of lawful commerce in Arms Act was passed by Congress really to to provide broad and you know the 2 gun manufacturers but Brady has long sought in the courts to assert that there are limitations to that law this is a landmark decision holding that advertising and especially advertising aimed at particular young individuals really designed to sell. You know extremely harmful kinds of gun. Can be litigated in court effective So when you're touring as you're you're you're really attacking the the marketing of let's say the Bushmaster as a as a kind of gone that real men use you know that you you know why you know why use a gun only fires a couple of bullets when you can of us are 2 magazine rudder authority run magazine . Correct and we don't have to look long and hard to litigate this case because all we have to look to is the way the Remington marketed its guns literally it was marketed if you look at the materials that were put into court as get your mark man card here if you want to be a man buy this product that's literally the exact words that they use That's what the Supreme Court reviewed and determining that they were going to allow argument that plaque stopped this kind of lawsuit from proceeding which means they'll have their day in court and a lot of coverage will now happen about exactly how marketing how the marketing worked for that particular weapon wonder if there's a comparison to made here with the tobacco companies just saying there will be disclosure of internal memos saying we need to do more to get the the young mom market Peter. You know I think that there's a lot that's going to be disclosed and I think there's a ringing reason Remmington thought all the way to the Supreme Court to stop those disclosures from going forward basically where we were in the state court proceeding because this is a case that was in the Connecticut Supreme Court the next phase would have been discovery. Remington attempted to stop that took it all the way to the Supreme Court and the very next step is to get discovery that is Remington producing all the documents about all of the research that they did to determine how they would market this product where they would market it and I think what we're going to find is a lot of internal memos a lot of internal discussions about exactly what market they were going after and I think we'll find a lot of really concerning information about marketing this to minors and individuals based on. An assumption that if you stoke fear and a sense of power fullness with people that's the way to sell guns. If you. Already it would it would seem that you're going to be getting all you're going to get your day and court the victims are going to get their day in court a lot is going to take place but this this plaque Lall it didn't give them a defense to give them a defense that they could they could say well all of. The bulwark of the law includes our advertising materials includes our marketing the 2. Now you're right I mean placket let's just be honest in the United States of America plaque was designed by the National Rifle Association the n.r.a. And it was designed to shield in a comprehensive way the gun industry from any and the unity associated with their product they intended it to be extremely broad Brady the organization I lead has been litigating and courts for 30 years and over the time that plaque a has been an effect we've been poking holes in it as far as we can this case is very decisive the Supreme Court is basically saying advertising and marketing of these products is fair game. For further litigation and that is a big deal to the gun violence prevention movement because it is a green light to continue these kinds of cases which we fully intend to Bree bring across the country that Connecticut statute that this case was brought under every state in the us but they will they will continue in the defense of themselves to blame the the the shooter and not the weapon what I'm looking at the language in an n.r.a. Statement really stops the decision and it says lawsuits the flaked attention away from mental illness and criminals in order to blame anonymous all objects would reduce violent crime that's the that's the crux of your case isn't it well or not the man is mentally ill he still has this deadly weapon in his hand in the 1st place yeah just the way we should blame children from for opening a bottle of aspirin and swallowing the contents that's a garbage argument they know it it's the last refuge for Scoundrels every other industry and the United States of America is subject to liability on these exact same terms why is it that the gun industry should be shielded from liability that under tort law no other industry does it's because of backroom deals that were secured by the n.r.a. When they were a powerful lobby in this country they no longer are so that has to change and this lawsuit will help change it and one possible. One possible. I don't want to say weapon but one possible tactic still available to them is delays and it may take you quite some time to actually get this stay in court even. Yes that's true but I think the court that's actually hearing this case won't really allow for it I mean the judge can set particular requirements in terms of the discovery you have a very assured asserted and capable plaintiff's lawyer representing the player plaintiffs in this action I don't think that they will allow for that and of course delay that is not good reason under the court sees the system here in the u.s. Is sanctionable So we do have a pretty good sense of where this will go and I look very for to reviewing and seeing the documents that are produced year because I think it will show what we already know the n.r.a. Was marketing these documents to sell as many guns as possible and it didn't matter whose hands they ended up in including potential shooters who had no value for human life which is obviously the case here with the Sandy Hook shooting Chris Broughton Brady United thank you for being with us thank you so much I appreciate it. Well I think a quick look at the paper shot way about spending plans to read the Guardian many papers talking about spending in the Guardian saying that Labor is to unveil a rescue plan for the n.h.s. With a pledge to spend an extra $26000000000.00 pounds but of an option the better to Labour's 10 point plan to save the n.h.s. And then it's appalling time as far as the expression times are concerned Times headline says the Tories lead by 14 points after Nigel for decided not to contest any of the conservative held seat so that's where we begin we're going to look at the I and I with Paul Gallagher is the battle for the n.h.s. Front page headline. Act you know arms race gets big on it both Labor and the tour restrikes gun each other both main political parties resumes the battle over the future of the health service last night in the 1st sign for health policy the key election battleground germy Corbin pledging to run top and it just spending in England by 40000000000 pounds of him becomes prime minister the Tuileries claiming that his radical economic policies really cuts in health funding and a continuation of the war of words over the health service and this coming as a poll showed that voters were strongly in favor of putting more money into the n.h.s. Even if it meant higher taxes so all and later today Labor will pledge to raise the Department of Health a new budget by school 1000000000 pounds over the next saw years and that's 26000000000 pounds higher than it would be if it rose only in line with inflation and how they're going to pay for that is going to be funded by higher taxes. On businesses that was those cuts the current government made to corporation tax. And high taxes on person person no. Wealthy individuals and this money they've said whether it's reducing waiting times a knee units improving Tanso cancer survival rates and funding counseling services to prove John people's mental health in a speech like today the shadow health secretary John Snow is expected to cite a decade of Tory underfunding and cuts as Doesn't aren't just into a year round crisis moment $15000.00 beds have been cut hospitals a crumbling and on an h s is chronically short of nurses and suddenly doctors now since they were conserves apply themselves pledging or They've already pledged promised in fact to raise the health budget by just under 34000000000 pounds 520-2324 I probably had to put this in percentage terms rod that equates to around about a 3 and a half percent annual rise to the health budget what the labor are promising is a roughly 4.3 percent rise a little bit more money from there but that's possibly in line with what the n.h.s. Has seen historically on average right up until the financial crisis crisis and of the last 10 years those budget rises has been around hovering around the $1.00 to $1.00 and a half percent and that's obviously led to a lot of problems within the n.h.s. Much longer waiting times problems with people getting their cancer treatments on time as well and it's pretty clear that both realise the situation can no longer continue and the promising to raise those budgets by rather large sum of money. Momentum which is that the core of supposedly New Labor Party you've got some the momentum actually admitting to a reporter it's not going to be easy to win this election. That's right this is lower park who's the head of momentum conceding met her own party has a mountain to climb in her words to achieve victory on December the 12th but she didn't says that the protocol been grassroots movement which cites a thought bigger and more sophisticated campaign than 2 years ago and Laura pocket herself declaring yesterday look at what we did last time to defy expectations and she argued that Labour's internal strife was last year a thing of the past as the vast majority of the party's M.P.'s who fully behind their leader's anti austerity platform and in an interview with Right to Die fields are disclosed that momentum would continue its activities if Jeremy Colgan wins the election next month switching focus to championing a radical agenda. Government and. Lower pocket knowledge in the similarities with the last election when labor began the campaign well behind the conservatives in polls she said there's no denying that we still have the same mountain to climb with the vast majority of the media who are determined to distort Labor's a message and she went on to say nobody knows how this election is going to play out because certainly in my lifetime I don't remember such. Volatility she did except that it had been challenging for labor a bit of an understatement there and had affected the party's support ilish there was a point out that the conservatives have performed even worse than labor in this year's European elections and she was of course previously germy Coburn's private secretary she said she was happy with the party's moderate position in her words of offering a referendum choice between a late negotiated withdrawal deal and remaining in the e.u. And Jules insisted that the labor leaders neutrality between the 2 options was logical because he will be prime minister of Britain and did not want people whichever way they voted in 2016 whether that result in propelling mystical wouldn't Downing Street was just got a few weeks left to find out. I'm David dollar of the Boston Globe where some movers and shakers are making some very big decisions Hello David. We are all jacked up here in Massachusetts because yet another person from the state is talking about running for president this year former governor Deval Patrick about 24 hours ago word came out that he was looking at jumping into the Democratic primary field. There are already something like 15 or 16 people remaining It's only about 3 months before the New Hampshire and Iowa contests and but nonetheless Patrick is talking about doing it he has he was a governor here from I think 2006 to 2012 or thereabouts he was the state's 1st black governor he's got a great personal story grew up on Chicago's South Side. In a very low income situation and ended up coming to Milton Academy here in Massachusetts and on to Harvard he served as the Civil Rights Division Director in the Clinton administration and has sat on several boards one of our columnists today Rick referred to him as one of the most effective political speakers he'd ever seen and best politician ever seen but and here's a big but the reviews so far to the idea that he would run for president are very negative there's a lot of people out there saying What the heck are you doing. So we have several stories on Boston Globe dot com And in the Globe about this and here's another but didn't he already decided not to run as he changed his mind you are right sir about a year ago. He was actively considering it he had been out and about campaigning for other Democrats around the country he was raising some money he was sort of trying out his what could be his agenda which is to kind of he says unite the country. He's he's more of a moderate than than would be Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren. But he decided not to do it he said that he couldn't undergo the rigors of the the campaign he kind of alluded to the toll that it would take on him and his family and he backed out so here he comes again and a lot of people who are aligned with him who helped him run previous campaigns as kind of political staff have kind of gone to the wind they've they've signed up to other candidates and so he's now left would if he really wants to do this and the signs over the last 24 hours have been that he does if he really wants to do this he's going to have to quickly assemble a team raise a bunch of money he the 1st deadline for him is Friday where he would have to sign up for the New Hampshire primary which is the big one here abouts for right nearby and arguably he would have name recognition but the fact that matter is there's a whole bunch of Massachusetts people in this race. Kristen I bet you know the answer to when with the last type of the anybody with a Massachusetts connection actually got into the White House. Actually won it would probably be John Kennedy no right but but that hasn't stopped many many Massachusetts residents from running over the years Michael Dukakis our former governor in 1988 for example John Kerry Mitt Romney twice this year we have Elizabeth Warren the senator from as a suit message choose it's Michael Bloomberg interesting Lee enough the former New York City mayor it was actually born a year. And we have William Weld on the Republican side who is a former governor himself and is running for the Republican nomination so there are a lot of people from our state in this race and who have run in previous races and now here comes Deval Patrick so. There are a lot of people scratching their heads about this today but one of the stories that we have here in the globe is is the what does this say about the field and that's an interesting story because there are a lot of Democrats out there who are saying well this this field isn't strong enough. We need to get somebody else in the race Joe Biden looks a little wobbly Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders a little bit too far left Pete Pete good a Jag who has had a great few weeks here and has risen in the polls some people are saying well he lacks experience he's a little bit too young so what we're seeing here is some of the folks who sort of sat on the sidelines over the last 12 months or so are now reconsidering it and believe it or not who should who should raise their hand here in the last few hours our own kind of it for Goldilocks who. You may remember this name would that would be Hillary Clinton actually who is saying that. She told the b.b.c. That many many people are pit placing enormous pressure on her to enter the race but not at this time she's really probably not in her plans to do that which in political terms is leaving the door open just a crack so. Things are still a bit unsettled so it was little bit unsettled a little bit fluid Well well well well thank you for that. And after Friday it should all settle down a bit shouldn't it because it was anybody to send the papers as a royal you know people could still still get in and you know it's not over until year from now which is when the general election is Meanwhile the president remains unpopular with everyone except for his most loyal supporters where he's solid as a rock so it's going to be an interesting 12 months or so. For news and he's playing football and one hour this c.d.c. Radio 5 Live. Here with the news Richard Foster the main story on 5 Live this hour labor promises to outspend the conservatives on the n.h.s. And in sports for straight stuff to break through. This is b.b.c. 5 my. Labor will unveil what it's calling an end a chance rescue plan later with a promise to add an extra 6000000000 pounds to the funding announced by the conservatives last year Joe McDonald is expected to say the extra money will be used to fund a major expansion of public health services health it is a hugh Pym has more what we've learned is that Labor wants to add to the money already pledged by Theresa May when she was prime minister for the n.h.s. In England she said our plans for an extra $20000000000.00 pounds more in real terms per year but 2023 Labor says if elected it wants. Add 6000000000 more to that but it wants the money to go on cutting waiting times for Spittal treatment and better mental health care for young people amongst other measures Boris Johnson has to announce that the u.k. Can't afford to squander more time deciding whether and how to leave the European Union in his 1st major speech of the election campaign he'll say ending the current groundhog will benefit the economy and the promise is announced extra military and financial support for people and businesses affected by flooding in South Yorkshire and the East Midlands Labour's describe it as too little too late for the Green Party's deputy leader isn't really a Womack this is something that happens every year and this is about long term action of taking action against climate change taking action against ecological emergency and putting flood defense in place to protect community a former m.p. Who lost his seat following a conviction for a false expenses claim has quit the election after briefly becoming the conservative candidate for in a small Chris Davis pulled out after other Welsh Tories criticised his selection. Former treasurer to the Vatican Cardinal George Pell has been told he can appeal against his convictions for child sex abuse in Australia the 78 year old was sentenced to 6 years in prison back in March for attacking 2 choir boys in the 1990 s. He's always denied any wrongdoing concerns have been raised over the effectiveness of an n.h.s. Mental Health Scheme 5 lives Investigation Unit has heard claims of inflated success rates from current and former staff these therapist comments are voiced up by actors there were threats made for performance management if you're not meeting recovery targets recovery targets got to be silly figures I know colleagues who got really really upset about this it was more respect for people who can manipulate recovery statistics if you schools aren't good to go through your schools with a patient and squeeze them until they put down better schools so you say you're feeling a bit better aren't you n.h.s. England says clear standards are in place and any false occasion is unacceptable and police in France say hundreds of packages of cocaine are being washed up on beaches along the Atlantic Coast nearly a ton of the drug has been found since the middle of last month as the news no let's get the latest on England's Test warm up match against New Zealand 11 at a Melford has more force and the local side 115 for 2 England being the frustration young players promising and close below on 48 and Allan on 39 England took wickets with this short broad and Chopra Archer in an earlier 376 for 5 useful runs for Pope Butler and Stokes you can hear conch on this match over 5 Live Sports actual right now but here on 5 Live we get the rest of the sports and they can play Williamson's 1st international goal rescued in late 32 win for England's women in their friendly against the Czech Republic in the pressure on manager Phil Neville elsewhere Northern Ireland against Wales finished in a goal is stronger in their Euro qualifier. Says England's players have already drawn a line under the rain Sterling and Joe Gomez spat and ready to focus on the football move Fabian Delph is left the England squad and return to Everton because of injuries. Dominic's a mystery to the last 4 of the a.t.p. Tour Finals for the very 1st time he knew that Joe commit to a final set time break and Britton Sophie Hahn broke her own world record when her 4th consecutive t. 38100 meters title that's at the World Power Athletics Championships in Dubai this is b.b.c. Radio 5 Live on digital b.b.c. Sound smart speaker. And the weather chilly night for many of us is rain eases off in most places leaving clear skies the day ahead will be chilly and largely dry for many places northern and western parts like to see one or 2 shells a little later highs of just 3 degrees in Edinburgh and 9 in London d.c. 5 lines Hello 5 lifemate we are. Crystal. Clear you're in the middle of a big Dispy right now on the. Sea just a. Very. Cool. Sam Page please meet international rugby referee Nigel I know you've got to go and pretty much you're going to do that. You have to secure Cisco mills and Chris Stark Saturday morning from the p.c. Brady is. On an f.m. Around the u.k. On digital and online I'm Roger Sharpe were up all night on the day of Game 5 against the Connecticut Sun everything came together for the Washington Mystics the 1st time champions of the u.s. Women's National Basketball Association played coherently more supporting the star player and the League's Most Valuable Player Della done as she secured 21 of their 89 to 70 and I 78. Points sometimes a city seems to act as a magnet for winners as the country's baseball fans saw a near legendary World Series that left the Washington Nationals with their 1st ever title Admittedly we should draw a veil over the far distance of the Washington Redskins now rock bottom of the National Football Conference East but you can't of everything can you. All over Britain as 5 by.