Every Administration Prior to the Trump Administration has had ndas specific for anyone that had a security clearance. Then, day 11 of the manafort trial. Good day in court today. And the defense doesnt call a single witness. Mr. Manafort just rested his case. And its Election Night in america. Bernie sanders is live on set. All in starts right now. Good evening, from new york, i am ali velshi in for chris hayes. No one to root for in the escalating feud between president of the United States and his former aide Omarosa Manigault newman. A he said she said. Omarosa made an explosive allegation against the president. Whether the Trump Campaign
colluded with russia to disrupt the election. Omarosa claims that then candidate trump had advanced knowledge of the hacked emails that were released by wikileaks. You were instructed to bring up the emails at any point you could. That was our talker. Did donald trump know about those emails before they came out . Absolutely. He knew about them . Yes. He knew before he was released it. I am going to expose the corruption that went on in the campaign and in the white house. Continue to blow the whistle on all of this. She declined to say whether she has been before the grand jury. She is not a reliable narrator. There is good reason to be skeptical of this latest claim. But she has been able to corroborate. Last night, another former trump staffer Katrina Pearson denied having discussed a rumored tape of the president saying the n word. Kdid that happen . It sounds like she is writing a script for the movie. I have been talking about this. And it is absolutely not true. Yet again, omarosa brought receipts airing audio of a conversation about trump this morning on cbs news. I said well, can you think of any time this might have happened and he said no. Well that is not true. He goes, how do you think i should handle it. And i said it depends on what scenario you are talking about. And he said what he said it. He said t its embarrassed. That is according to Katrina Pearson. I was weary over this obsession. Asked directly if there could be a recording of the president. Can you guarantee the American People they will never hear donald trump uttering the n word. I cant guarantee anything. But i can tell you that the president addressed this question directly. I can tell you that i have never
heard it. Just to be clear, you cant guarantee it. I havent been in every single room. I can tell you the president has addressed it directly. And i can tell you what the focus and the heart of the president is, and that is on helping all americans. Now the president is going to war on omarosa. Quote, when you give a crazed, crying low life a break and give her a job at the white house. I guess it just didnt work out. Good work by general kelly for quickly firing that dog. The Trump Campaign has retained the same lawyer who. You will hear it referred to an nda. For more on the battle between the Trump White House and one of its own, joined by betsry woodrow. And jeff bennett. It is very clear that omarosa, whatever evidence she has has gotten under the president s skin. Without a doubt. That is not something up for debate. She has caused the week to be spoiled for white house staffers. Sort of crumble underneath them, omarosa was in a lot of rooms. She attended a lot of meetings. And people in the white house tell us that even though she didnt have a large Policy Portfolio and even though she doesnt have that much of a record of accomplishment to roll out. Many colleagues criticize her for being there. She managed to place herself in the room for a host of meetings. And having conversations. And people dont know how much of that she taped. It is the big question mark. It is the open question and that is why there is so many agitation in the white house. She may have been one of the most productive people around every meeting she was in she taped. Trump staffers live in fear of omarosas next tape. Three times in a row she made an allegation. The white house or someone in the trump orbit has denied it and she has come with a recording. President trump is consumed by this. Tweeting about omarosa at least ten times in the last 24 hours. White house staffers describe the psychological warfare that former Hillary Clinton campaign. Belonging to Clinton Campaign chairman john podesta, so an interesting parallel. Senior white house staffers say they feel relatively safer. She wasnt included in smaller high level meetings. Betsy, matthew from. Would in fact change minds about him. I dont know if that is true. Is the issue now whether or not the president ever actually used the n word which Sarah Huckabee sanders was not able to deny today. The president stuck in the mid30 Approval Rating despite everything we know about him. It is hard to talk about what hypothetically, what type of response this hypothetical situation would generate. What we do know is that the president has a long history of comments and actions as it relates to racial issues in the United States that many, many people find to be deeply troubling. This goes back to the 70s when
he was sued for allegedly discriminating against africanamericans. You have trump going after the central park five. Five young men accused of being in a brutal assault. For years after that fact, trump stayed pushing the line that these men were guilty. Despite dna exoneration. In the white house, we have him using obscenities. Immigrants from scandinavian countries should be welcome. You dont have to think very hard what he is getting back. What kind of impact would a tape have on the president s reputation. Look, i hate to say it, but a lot of this is already baked in. I think you might be right. Abc news is reporting several former aides receiving roughly 15,000 per month. Concept of paying people money to not talk. Seems to be out there. This came up today in the White House Press briefing. We know that donald trump has a long history of using nondisclosure agreements. Both in Business Life and now in political life. Paying people in some instance to keep silent. We heard Sarah Sanders say. And as we called former officials we learned that that is in fact the case. We talked to chris lew. Ari fleischer. All men said that ndas have never been used in the white house. There are protections for highly classified Sensitive Information but that falls under a security clearance. Ndas are used for preserving personal secrets not state secrets. Thanks to both of you. For more on these ndas, i am joined by legal analyst mimi rocah. And Jason Johnson politics he had editor for the route. Anything that governs who is
allowed. We are talking about the government putting an nda in place with Government Employees and that is what is so controversial and why Sarah Sanders claims that every administration has done this cant be right. This isnt really trump a party to that he is ndas, this is the white house. The government. Whenever you have Government Action trying to limit the speech of Public Employees and even private employees, there is a First Amendment analysis here. And a lot of people are saying these are likely unenforceable. The move to sue, to enforce this nda, i cant believe they are going to be able to win that claim. So must be some other reason to
file this. Get inside omarosas head, she has been dripping little bits of evidence out there. Successfully now, three times in a row said something in her book that has been countered out there and then has recordings. She knows the Trump Campaign is coming for her and they appear to be fearful of what she knows. They are trying to muzzle her. Might be getting a temporary Restraining Order to do this. Where do you see this going. This goes as far as omarosa selling the book. She is a very, very smart woman. She has been doing this for years. Can you name anyone else in the history of Reality Television who has had a 15 year career. She knows how to keep herself in the public sphere. She has been mentored by donald
trump for years. She knew legally what she was going to be able to keep doing. They dont want to go go to trying with her, discovery would blow up in their faces. The white house is concerned in given the number of people of how long she was there and how close she was to the president of the United States. So mimi, ndas are signed by parties if i have some sort of secret. And i dont want you telling other people what i am up to. And we know there is classified information, but what omarosa said to katy tur is remarkable. It is remarkable. It is explosive if true and that is the big question as you and other people have said. Good reason to be skeptical of
her. If she has a recording of some form that corroborates that, that you would be hugely important. Even if she doesnt have a recording, we dont know exactly in what form the questioning is taking place of her by mueller. But, they may want to talk to her again now. She has said she has talked to the investigation once. They are never going to take just her heard for it. They wouldnt do that with anyone witness let alone this witness who everyone has reason to be skeptical of. I didnt see the full interview but i dont believe she was asked how do you know he knew. That claim that trump knew ahead of time about the hacked emails, it Doesnt Sound Crazy because of what else we know about the investigation, the facts that came out about what happened. If she can get the investigators closer to the how, jason, that becomes interesting. But you mentioned she is inoculated. I am not sure that the dirt about the fact that the president may have used the n word is needle moving, but if she gives mueller something he can use. She was five, 20 steps, she was batman on this. Five, 20 steps ahead. She knew when her book was coming out and they didnt know. There is a political element to all of this and a legal and american democracy element to this. For all of the people that want to poopoo this, no, this is drama. No. What we are hearing at its core is a close advisor to the united
states regular recorded and now using it for profit. That speaks to the lack of vetting. A year and a half into the administration, speaks volumes. Mueller knows that having a witness like that in the investigation, if they got in trouble for the steel dossier, imagine if he brought this up. The first trial of the Robert Mueller era is coming up to a close. Find out why resting without calling any witnesses. Not cool. Freezing away fat cells with coolsculpting . Now thats cool coolsculpting safely freezes and removes fat cells with little or no downtime. And no surgery. Results and Patient Experience may vary. Some common side effects include temporary numbness, discomfort,and swelling. Ask your doctor if coolsculpting is right for you and visit coolsculpting. Com today for your chance to win a free treatment. And i dont add up the years. But what i do count on is boost®. Delicious boost® high protein nuritional drink now has 33 more protein, along with 26 Essential Vitamins and minerals boost® high protein. Be up for life. Called into the courtroom after the Noontime Break for the sole purpose of hearing the attorney said they will not be calling any witnesses and they are resting. That was the defense in the first case. The first of two cases against Paul Manafort president trumps former campaign manager. With 27 witnesses and 367 exhibits, the prosecution appeared to put on a solid case. The jury will hear Jury Deliberations tomorrow. I am joined by nbc National News reporter julie ainsley. Was there any discernible action when the lawyer rested the case. More of something that we wanted to see if they had anything to put up but in some ways it wasnt that surprising. All through this case, the defense has had a strategy of in their Cross Examination of taking chips away. Whether that is bank fraud, tax evasion. They want to cast doubt. Is this really mr. Manaforts signature. That was their strategy. Particularly with gates who probably the most notable this this entire case. The prosecution knew he was going to be dangerous and they attacked gates character. They used that strategy all along and i think, and of course dan can get into this as well,
they didnt want any defense to be just a few Character Witnesses and say manafort is a good guy. Their best defense is to say the Offense Didnt Go far enough. That is interesting. What are the options . A mistrial, a hung jury, an acquittal. This seems like a risky strategy on the part of the defense. What do you make of it. Two times a defense does not call any witnesses for their case and one is where they really do feel like they, the government doesnt have been the evidence. And the other is where they really have no case of their own. And they have no affirmative defense. We are in the latter situation here. The government buttoned up their case with documents, emails, and records. And they buttressed it with
witnesses like rick gates. On the flip side not much of a case for Paul Manafort to affirmatively make. Rather than put on a few technical witnesses to try to pick away a little bit on the margins, they made a decision, which i think is a wise one not to put any on. In this situation, the defense is much better off to say and to argue that the government hasnt met its burden, the case is all about rick gates. And you saw what a liar is, you cant convict my client based on rick gates testimony. I am not sure it is an argument that is going to win, but the best they have to work on here. There are other things going on here. Some discussion that may have to do with a jury, an issue about that. And then a judge who on several occasions taken issue with the
prosecution and gotten into it with some of the lawyers. Tell me what these two stories are about. The second, i will take that first. An awkward pause in the courtroom today. The prosecution said they wanted to include something in a Jury Instructions that would tell the jury more explicitly that the judges interjections and questioning of the witness shouldnt be considered. And the judge thought he already explained that and didnt understand why the prosecution needed to go farther. He said do you think that i interjected too much and there was a long pause and they said yes, there were times where he said obviously manafort didnt Pay Attention every dollar because you embezzled from him. The prosecution wants to be careful that the jury doesnt
read too much into the judge whiwho is supposed to be the independent voice. Daniel and i were both outside the courtroom today waiting two hours. And we saw jurors go in one by one to meet with the judge. From where we sit and the press, it looks like there is at least been a conversation under seal through motions started by the defense and responded to by the government that could be over this issue of a juror. The judge over and over again saying please dont talk to anyone on the outside. Come in with an independent mind. And with a case like this that is saturated in the media and we know the jury is not under sequester, that is hard to do. Daniel less than a minute, but tell me about this judge, ellis, i dont know if it
mellowed out during the course of the trial, but in the beginning seemed to be Butting Heads with the prosecution. And seemed to echo Donald Trumps view that this has got anything to do with the mueller investigation. Or the investigation might be overreaching. He has mellowed out this week and he realized that he went too far by interjecting as much as he during the questioning. He is not wrong to limit the charges in the case. Notwithstanding. He really did overstep his bounds by interjecting the questioning. And that is to be distinguished by a judge giving prosecutors a hard time and always trying to move things along. Keep the prosecution moving. And that is often to the prosecutors benefit even if
they dont think it at the same time. When he is interjecting during, and questioning, that is inappropriate. And that is the one issue the prosecutors took issue with. And he seemed amenable to it. Because he probably realizes in retrospect that he went too far. Thanks to both of you. Julia ainsley and daniel goldman. Coming up, senator Bernie Sanders on tonights primaries. The senator joins me right after this. We just got married. Were all under one roof now. Congratulations. Thank you. How many kids . My two. His three. Along with two dogs and jake, our new parrot. That is quite the family. Quite a lot of colleges to pay for though. A lot of colleges. You get any Financial Advice . Yeah, but im pretty sure its the same plan they sold me before. Well your situations totally changed now. Right, right. How bout a plan that works for 5 kids,
2 dogs and jake over here . That would be great. That would be great. That okay with you, jake . Get a portfolio that works for you now and as your needs change from Td Ameritrade investment management. And the wolf huffed and puffed. Like you do sometimes, grandpa . Well, when you have copd, it can be hard to breathe. So my doctor said. Symbicort can help you breathe better. Starting within 5 minutes. It doesnt replace a Rescue Inhaler for sudden symptoms. Doctor symbicort helps provide significant improvement of your lung function. Symbicort is for copd, including Chronic Bronchitis and emphysema. It should not be taken more than twice a day. It may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. Tell your doctor if you have a Heart Condition or high Blood Pressure before taking it. Grandpa symbicort could mean a day with better breathing. Watch out, piggy giggles get symbicort free at saveonsymbicort. Com. If you cant afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. They are the Industry Expert with utilities. Whether it is a gas leak or a wire down, just having someone there that deals with this every day is pretty comforting. We each bring something to the table that is unique and that is a specialty. With all of us working together we can keep all these emergencies small. And the fact that we can bring it together and effectively Work Together is pretty special. They bring their knowledge, their tools and equipment and the proficiency to get the job done. And the whole time i have been in the fire service, pg es been there, too. Whatever we need whenever we need it. I do count on pg e to keep our firefighters safe. Thats why we ask for their help. Election night in america. Polls have closed and we can now report that senator Bernie Sanders has won the democratic primary for vermont. Congratulations on your victory. Thank you very much. It was a nail biter. I think you got 94 of the vote. Something like that. You won the democratic primary, but you dont run as a democrat. I defeated republicans. I always run as an independent. And i think people in vermont understand that. We have a Good Relationship with the Democratic Party. I suspect that this coming campaign will be putting more money into the Democratic Party than anybody else. So you will decline the democratic nomination. Yes. And i understand that you have a Good Relationship with the voters of vermont. But now you have a profile nationally where a lot of democrats saying this is not a good time for Bernie Sanders to be separate and apart. I am not separate and apart. Democrats and republicans have to understand this. There are more people now who are independents. I dont want to break the bad news to anybody. Two party system is not held in wide esteem. What i am doing is bringing working people and young people who are not crazy about the party. Clearly that is a far better alternative than the Republican Party and we are trying to
reform the Democratic Party. Ma making it a party of working people and young people. Pushing an aggressive agenda. Health care for all. Raising the minimum wage. Demanding the wealthy start pay their fair share of taxes. Those ideas seem to be radical ideas supported by the majority of the American People. Take a look at this tweet. In races where insurgent progressive democrats are running against party backed nomineeses. The Stabment Democrat is winning 80 of the time. How much money did the establishment have. We are winning the ideological
struggle. Ideas that seem radical are now seeming mainstream. Are we going to win every election . Of course not. The truth of the matter is, if you look at races from the school board, members of congress, we are winning good races. In this instance, in this time that we are now as donald trump as president , is the winning of the longer term battle of mainstreaming some of your ideas in the Democratic Party better or more important than the shorter term . Donald trump has got to be defeated and i intend to do everything i can making sure that happens. You will recall, though, that four years ago in the midterm elections, we had the lowest voter turnout. Twothirds of the American People didnt vote. Our job, and i think we are
succeeding. Is get people excited, to run for office, getting people to vote. Candidates who stand for Working Families, the democrats are going to do fine. The complaints was not dissimilar to a lot of those who support donald trump. The distrust of the political system, of wall street and the banks of Trade Agreements who have left them out. And they are many of the same people. How do democrats get those people back . You talk to the issue that impact. We demand the media talk about these as well. Why is United States not to guarantee health care lets talk about. So you push the idea of
medicare to all which is a similar system which i grew up under. Is that the Winning Strategy . I think it is part of it. Not just one thing. Raising the minimum wage. Whether they are working people, working class. You got one guy, jeff bezos whose wealth increases every single day by 250 million but doesnt pay his workers enough money to keep them off food stamps and medicaid. People who do not benefit from his policies. We have to do heck of a lot better. I am not going to deny that some of those supporters are racist, sexists homophobes. And that is not the majority. What trump was able to do was
pick up on the failures of the democrats. People cannot afford to send their kids to college or afford child care or housing that they need. So i think the future of the Democratic Party has got to be the focus on the needs of Working Families to demand that we have a government that represents all of us. You talk to republicans and ask them how they feel about citizen united. So at this point, the democrats have got to get out there with the message. You have been crossing the Country Campaigning for people. Who will the leaders be . A number of Democratic Socialist candidates who have run. And there are back to this nate silver tweet. That is that is a troublesome tweet. Because i cant pre i can back 100 . The number troublesome to you . 89 of what he is calling establishment democrats. It doesnt mean anything unto itself because the truth is that all over this country we are seeing working people and young people often for the first time getting involve in politics. Some of these rural more conservative constituencies, you think it is good to get in there with a consistent message, a progressive message. Ones who have been winning are people who i didnt know that was the situation out here in new york. You have drawn the clearest example. Or john feddermans victory in pennsylvania. But you get the point. There are some. People are going run their own campaigns based on their own district. It is not only good policies, it is good politics to talk about issues relevance to working people. You ask people do they want medicare for all . Yeah. Should the rich pay their fair share of taxes. Yeah. Should we deal with climate change. Yeah, lets do it. And yet we have used in the opposite direction. Congratulations on your victory. Look forward to talking to you more. Still ahead, the president making drastic attempts to distract from the mueller investigation. Is it working . Tonights thing one, thing two starts next. vo people with Type 2 Diabetes are excited about the potential of onceweekly ozempic®. In a study with ozempic®, a majority of adults
lowered their blood sugar and reached an a1c of less than seven and maintained it. Oh under seven . vo and you may lose weight. In the same oneyear study, adults lost on average up to 12 pounds. Oh up to 12 pounds . vo a twoyear study showed that ozempic® does not increase the risk of major cardiovascular events like heart attack, stroke, or death. Oh no increased risk . Ozempic® ozempic® should not be the first medicine for treating diabetes, or for people with Type 1 Diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. Do not share needles or pens. Dont reuse needles. Do not take ozempic® if you have a personal or Family History of medullary thyroid cancer, multiple Endocrine Neoplasia Syndrome type 2, or if you are allergic to ozempic®. Stop taking ozempic® and get medical help right away if you get a lump or swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, itching, rash, or trouble breathing. Serious side effects may happen, including pancreatitis. Tell your doctor if you have Diabetic Retinopathy or vision changes. Taking ozempic® with a sulfonylurea or insulin
may increase the risk for low blood sugar. Common side effects are nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, stomach pain, and constipation. Some side effects can lead to dehydration, which may worsen kidney problems. I discovered the potential with ozempic®. Oh oh oh ozempic® vo ask your Healthcare Provider if ozempic® is right for you. Heres a trip tip when you Search Hotels on tripadvisor. Enter your destination and the dates of your stay. Tripadvisor searches over 200 Booking Sites. To find the best deal on the right hotel for you. Tripadvisor. Im all about my bed. This mattress is dangerously comfortable. When i get in, i literally say ahh. Introducing the Leesa Mattress. A better place to sleep. This bed hugs my body. Im now a morning person. The Leesa Mattress is designed to provide strong support,
relieve pressure and optimize air flow to keep you cool. Hello bed of my dreams. Order online well build it, box it and ship it to your door for you to enjoy. Sleep on it for up to one hundred nights and love it or youll get a full refund. Returns are free and easy. I love my leesa. Today is gonna be great. Read our reviews then try the Leesa Mattress in your own home. Order now and get 150 off, and free shipping, too. Go to buyleesa. Com today. You need this bed. With the new Chase Ink Business unlimited card i get unlimited 1. 5 cash back. Its so simple, i dont even have to think about it. So i think about mouthfeel. Introducing Chase Ink Business unlimited with unlimited 1. 5 cash back on every purchase. We are praying for the people of puerto rico. We love puerto rico. Heroin overdoses are surging in nevada. Great to be back in missouri and god bless the United States. That is just the record that we have. Trump while studying a briefers map of south asia with indias. And then there are the president s trouble with time zone. That is thing two in 60 seconds. [burke] at farmers, weve seen almost everything
also wobbly in time zones. Issue came up on a constant basis. Staffers resorted to telling the president the time is messed up. He is the president of the United States, not stopping to add up time zones. But the current president s trouble with time zones may have an unexpected benefit. It turns out to be a convenient excuse for his performance. I dont know. I will give the benefit of the doubt, maybe jet lag and time differences but holy molly i can do more to lower my a1c. Because my body can still make its own insulin. I take trulicity once a week to activate my body to release its own insulin, like its supposed to. Trulicity is not insulin. It works 24 7. It comes in an easytouse pen. And i may even lose a little weight. Trulicity is an injection to improve blood sugar in adults with Type 2 Diabetes when used with diet and exercise. Dont use it as the first medicine to treat diabetes, or if you have Type 1 Diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. Dont take trulicity if you or your family have medullary thyroid cancer, youre allergic to trulicity, or have multiple Endocrine Neoplasia Syndrome type 2. Stop trulicity and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of a serious allergic reaction, a lump or swelling in your neck or severe stomach pain. Serious side effects may include pancreatitis. Taking trulicity with a sulfonylurea or insulin increases your low blood sugar risk. Common side effects include nausea, diarrhea, vomiting, abdominal pain, and decreased appetite. These can lead to dehydration, which may worsen kidney problems. To help lower my a1c i choose trulicity to activate my within. Ask your doctor about onceweekly trulicity. You always get the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed . Lets say it in a really low voice. Carl . Lowest price, guaranteed. Just stick with badda book. Badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com
then there is this. Only 37 of americans believe what trump has said publicly about the investigation is true. 56 said his comments are false, in other words that he has been lying. With all that said, is the president losing the pr war with Robert Mueller . We will debate the question next. Ction of a cancer cell by the bodys own immune system, thanks to medicine that didnt exist until now. And today can save your life. Whoooo. Tripadvisor makes finding your perfect hotel. Relaxing. Just enter your destination and dates. Tripadvisor searches over 200 Booking Sites to find the hotel you want for the lowest price. Dates. Deals. Done tripadvisor. I have no idea how were going to get through this. Follow me. Unitedhealthcare has the people and tools to help guide you through the confusion. Well that wasnt so bad at all. Thats how we like it. Unitedhealthcare. Are. Can say its not working or one can say how is it that 37 of people still believe him . Thats the Million Dollar question. The answer is just a theory that i have. There is a portion of the population that is viewing facts through a very tribal basis. They are not coming at things for the first time, but who gave me this information. If you trust donald trump. Or distrust the media. I think there is a lot of overlap there. Thats what you are seeing. You are saying i believe whatever he says, meaning the president. There is a tribal silo now on the right that consists of fox news and talk radio and a certain cluster of right wing and post conservative blogs. They say Donald Trumps word is law. He can literally say we are
living on mars and the sky is red and they will say of course we are living on mars. They isolate themselves into a bubble around them. Its very powerful. You bring up something. Lets play something where donald trump said believe just me. Just stick with us. Dont believe the crap you see from these people. The fake news. Just remember, what you are seeing and what youre reading is not whats happening. Why does that work . I have been thinking a lot about this. I think if you bring it back to the think about, this is a president who started runging for office with a claim that barack obama, the Countrys First Black President was not born in the United States. A kenyan born muslim myself, he was not in any of the meadings. I dont think he would believe you, but the point there
to take it a step further, but if you are living in a world in which you have trouble believing or accepting the fact that there is a black president , okay, you essentially have to accept Donald Trumps reality instead. If you are willing to believe that lie, its an original sin. This is just everything is an extension of that. Various polling indicates 22 or 23 of people believe that story. Its not that much of a leap to get there. It is a leap. No one else who has run for the republican nomination or successfully got it was able to get this group of people. This band of extremists, experience theorists. How does the Republican Party fix this . They have a choice to make in the post trump era and there will be a post trump err a. Are they going to be part of these experience theories like qo none
and the art right boys and the scum backs. Citronlea isis or they can rediscover the limited government and rule of law that are out of fashion right now with trump and still reflect the conservatism that should inform in my humble opinion where the movement should go. Mara, what does the media do . There is valid criticism. Some of it is experience nonsense and others is the ability to spread this nonsense on the internet. Do they do anything to fix the level of distrust thats out there . Thats a great question. Its important that we dont become stenographers. Donald trump said the sky is green, but some people say the sky is blue. I think that not all facts are relative and i think that when they become relative if you look at russia and the way Vladimir Putin rules the country, its a lot of creating chaos that there is no truth. He can say there is no truth. Its whatever i say. Its important that we stick to the facts as much as possible. The way that americans consume news even though its changing, there has to be responsibility in schools, frankly. In terms of how to consume and what is the difference between news and continue . The difference between entertainment and hard news . Americans dont know how to read newspapers. Im looking at the clock and we are awful close. I do not want to invoke the wrath of rachel maddow. Thank you to both of you. What a great conversation