Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20171109

What the shocking thing the president said about china, he doesnt blame them. They should be commended for doing the tension he said he would stop during campaign. Its just like the president on the campaign trail in 2016 promising he was going to pass Economic Reforms and health cuts to help working class americans. Thats not happening now also a couple nights ago, the impact that his broken promises from the campaign ads in the elections tuesday night when he promised the Health Care System, that was going to be keeper, more affordable, give people more Health Care Coverage and wouldnt have any cuts for medicaid or medicare, those broken promises lead to lost elections and mika, the fact that the Republican Party right now in castle hill seems to be in a sense of denial, thats great, great news is any can the running in 2018. It means they will keep rung towards that cliff and jump off that political cliff like a lot of people in virginia did the other night. I dont understand this strategy at all, republicans on capitol hill reacted to tuesdays large democratic gains in new jersey, and elsewhere around what those results can middle eastern for next years midterm. John mccain said unless we get our act together, we will lose heavily. Many colleagues werent so sure. Im not surprised the democrat won the election over there. I think it would probably surprise people the margin. How much the president played into it, its going to be the pundits will debate that. The Democratic Party in this election was more energized it looks to me than the republican voter. Why that is, i dont know. A lot are saying its because of the president. Well, you know, maybesh maybe not. Reporter are we seeing the president potentially be a drag on his party here. I dont know. R. Is the president going to be a drag on republicans next year . I dont think so. I dont think so. Actually i think if anything, if he had gotten more involved in these races, it may have turned the other way. This is not a typical cycle we hope to reverse this thend next year. Reporter are you worried about next year . No, i like a good fight. To him till liss said on tuesday quote, he got to be rhino, republicans in need of outcomes, thats something House Speaker paul ryan echoed in an interview yesterday morning. In virginia, new jersey, elsewhere, what is your does that capping your reading of the current political moment and of the urgency surrounding tax reform in. It doesnt change my reading of the current moment, it emphasizes my current moment. Which is we have a promise to keep. We have to get on with making our promise. I adore gillespie, i feel bad he lost, i think it means we have to deliver. Joe. Actually, i dont, i dont read any of that as negative, i think paul ryan is exactly right. They have to get things done. This has been a donothing Republican Congress. Theyve controlled all of washington. Theyve delivered nothing. I dont know that that played really big in virginia and across the country in the state wide races. I think, and were going to have a guest on later on today who has said that we pay too much attention to people that are down ballot. We look at their characteristics too much, something suggested in his twitter feed that a bag of mulch just one the governship of virginia. I think thats a little hoursh for half northam. But the point was, that it really did all flow down from donald trump. He has offended twothirds of americans, he has offended women. He has offended a lot of independents. Hes offensive in general. I mean, cmon. Around the world. Well, there is no cmon here. Im not debating you. Im saying, donald trump was the cause of the tidal wave. He was the earthquake that caused, well, well just say, willie, that caused the tsunami. Those republicans, you didnt expect them to come out and draumpb and most of them just were politely brushing away the questions. But there is no doubt behind the scenes him im sure heidi can tell this, republicans are fretting, because they know unless they are in a dark, dark red district in 2018, this is going to happen this them. I dont think the blinders are so big based on the people i talked to yesterday in the Republican Party, that was representative of what we heard on camera from some senators of what the party is feeling right now. There is no way you can watch tuesday night, not just at the governors level, do under the ballot through the House Flipping in a historic way, what happened in maine with the expansion of the medicaid benefits, not see some concern over a president polling at 35 and who hasnt doten anything done, i think this puts a lot more pressure on the tax bill we will get a peek at today. If are you a member like barbara come stack sitting in a hillary district or in illinois, you woke up in a cold sweat. Why . Because this really wasnt about some democratic model, maybe i can gain this out and be a rhino and win. No, if this repieces itself in 2018, members like her are toast. There is no model how you run against this. This was a wave. You have a lot of people claiming victory today in a Democratic Party t. Moderates, the liberal progressives. Because everyone was represented in a wave, which is what this was. The white house yesterday insisted the democratic gains had nothing to do with the president a. Person familiar with the president s political operation called the results unsurprising. When asked about the fear level for the upcoming midterms, says 2018 is a far way away, now as far as 2016 is in the past. Still the president tweeted yesterday to mark the i was in of the 2016 election writing, quote, congratulations to all of the deplorables and the millions of people who gave us a massive 304 to 227 Electoral College landslide victory. Joe, lets see who is Still Standing in that picture. Hmm. Well, we will see next year, it may be a little different next year. But, harold ford, we brought up this point yesterday that after the 2016 loss, everybody was focused on Hillary Clinton, it was all about Hillary Clintons loss and thats what was wrong with the Democratic Party. Were still having people talk about the divide in the Democratic Party. But if you wanted to know how sick that party was, you looked at that time thousand legislative seats they had lost over the past seven, eight years. Its the same thing with the election yesterday. You can talk about ed gillespie and what type of campaign he hasnt all day. Thats not the story. The story is that the democrats were down Something Like 63 to 37. I dont know noe those numbers are exactly right. They came storming back. Again, its that tidal wave. They can only be explained away by one thing, donald trump. I agree with the way you characterize. I listened to the house members yesterday, including the one from virginia. He said this race was not nationalized. In fact, it was. The republicans did not accomplish a lot in washington. It certainly played into voters minds, trump himself we all have been known such an objectionable and inflammatory figure its hurt them badly. Democrats should not overread this. You can look back on history and when new jersey and Virginia Governor races have gone one direction, its slightly mixed. It shows when democrats did updates the most recently in 05 they were able gain. Governor northam, he fit the state. Heres a democrat that fit george w. Bush two times for president. Its up clear if given the chance to have chosen a nominee in virginia, would have chosen dr. Northam the message is that blue dog moderate lil liberal, progressive. It takes both wins to flight. To be successful, remember its only one year since donald trump was elected. Mika says so much has changed. So much can change for the better or the worse, my urging of them, my own party is, stay focused, continue to pick good candidates, work with the president where it makes sense, especially on taxes and other things, it will benefit the very voters we have to win back come next 84 and obviously 2020. You know, sometimes it comes down to bakes. You seen this all the time on the zoe show before elections. It is obvious, but its obviously the reason why people win it. Its like block and tackling football games. Its turn jut, turnout, turnout. You can lock and see across the state, ed gillespie did fairly well with republicans. Those ads, that brought a lot of republicans home, if you look at the polling. Just mike barnacle, more democrats went out to vote. More democrats stood in line longer. More democrats called their friends, more democrats took their friends to the voting booths. More democrats were engaged than republicans. It was just because of a great turnout. Few look at next years elections, its going to come down to turnout again, because the democrats, they still have a tough uphill battle if you look at whats happening in the senate. Joe, no doubt about that. You saw that in the numbers and the percentages yesterday, in every place where they voted. But back to basics, one of the basics we have to measure here as you walk around any place in this country. There is a level of both exhaustion and embarrassment with donald trump. Yeah. Exhaustion because of the tweets, multiple times a day, embarrassment because i think a lot of people sit and think, is this the kind of behavior we want from the president of the United States . We saw a clip from the president at the top of the show talking about congratulating china on the fact that theyre doing for their people what he is unable to to do for our people here, theyre taking advantage of us. Because within moments of his assuming the presidency one year ago, he immediately rescinded tpp the Transpacific Partnership, which was a terrific boone for trading for the United States of america. Thats gone now the chinese and russians will dominate the pacific rim. Because were withdrawn. Right. You have that. Then have you the reality, people Pay Attention in this country. People Pay Attention to things like the proposed tax bill, they call it tax reform, no, its tax revenge if you look at that bill, the elements of that bill. People are sitting out there in the disturbs, the cities, thinking, wait a minute, state and local tax, we will not be able to put that on our tax rurps. You know high medical costs, Student Interest loans eliminated . Thats the problem we have. Thats the problem they are living with. That itself the problem that will drown them. The bill, mika, there are some portions of that bill, that tax bill, that are absolutely inexplicable. That itself the sort of thing we have to pay for. If you want to go to the inside game and see how the elections impact donald trump. Members of the house and senate are going to be less likely to follow him off the cliff and also a tweet like he did right after ed gillespie lost and obviously could have used a little moral support from the president. A tweet kicking him the second he was down hard saying he lost because he didnt bow down to me enough. That remembered by members in Congress Just like that tweet and just like his comment talking about the mean gop House Health Care bill. This is scar tissue. It adds up. When you see somebody running and cow tail to you as much as they can. You still get kicked because you lose by the president of the United States . First, obviously, its classless, its horrific management. It makes them less loyal. Its mean, it shows how quick he will turn on someone transactionally. Of the trump supporters, many are close to you. I wonder how long they can actually hold on to protecting someone who consistently lies, lets them down and embarrasses them. At some point, there is going to be a breaking point, especially if they are let down in their wallet. Ron mcdaniel claimed that Democrat Ralph Northam won because he embraced trump. I think whats very interesting with the virginia vase Ralph Northam started running ads, saying i will work with this president. He moderated sanctuary cities and statues. We seen him gain traction. He moved the needle by saying i will work with this president. Wait, im confused. Heidi, she follows data. No, he got stomped. Ralph northam got stomped in rural virginia, in fact, he did worse in rural virginia than democrats in the past did, again, this is an alternate reality that if republicans choose to live in that alternate reality, its only going to hurt the republicans at the end of the day. You will have what happened in 2012 where carl rove and the romneys and other people believed late into the night that they were still going to boat barack obama when everybody else was fought watching fox news knew it was over. Heidi the white house believes in ultnaat reality. Is it working for them . What is going on. We have numbers, throw down some numbers here. Facts . In terms of the virginia vote the number one issues were decidedly a backlash to the president s agenda, healthcare number one, guns number two. In terms of explaining this margin, we really got to point out here that there was a decisive shift they think was in Ralph Northams favor. When i showed up at my polling station. I pulled up behind a woman driving a prius, every Single Person in there was a middle aged woman and sure enough when i came out, we looked at the data, this was women revolting. Turning out in higher numbers. And that is proven out in the data. Everywhere. One of the big stories here is what happened with the house of delegates. You can draw a direct line from the women who participated in that womens march in january to the women who then decided to stake action and run and contest these races where, by the way, they didnt go for open seats, they knacked off incumbents. Amazing. Maybe thats been from the rnc, we helped them sleep at night, its preposterous that Ralph Northam embraced donald trump too much completely preposterous, alarm bells ought to be going off, i understand why the senators say what they say. They want to project calm. Behind the scenes, they should be very worried, democrats are energi energized, this was the catharsis, the beginning of the comeback, donald trump for one year made their lives miserable, now they are ready to come back. They believe virginia is the first step back. You may have heard this story from tuesdays elections, its worth telling again, in new jersey, a 32yearold woman was elected to her local county board after deciding to challenge a republican law makeer who mocked last januarys womans march. Ashley bennett decided to run in a republican strong hold after the incumbent posted a facebook quote will the womens march end in time for them to cook dinner . Carmen said he was joking around, now its bennett who is laughing hysterically. She won by nearly a thousand votes, kicked him out. About 14,000 total cast. You know what . I mean i guess i should say the story speaks for itself, joe. Well, it does, but heidis story is so important. Again it fits with what you and i were hearing both of us from a lot of women that were in virginia saying, guess what . Its raining, and guess what . There are women standing in line. Its so interesting in all my years covering politics and being in politics, ive never heard a description like that. Its raining and these women, theyre just standing in line and theyre not moving. Er that not going anywhere. This is the revenge that they are seeking for all of the slights that donald trump has done. By the way, question go back to the access Hollywood Tapes, all the hor risk lights, et cetera, et set remarks we can talk about all that. Few look at who donald trump is nominating for positions in washington, d. C. , predominantly white men, overwhelmingly white men, if you look, for instance, at the u. S. Attorneys hes appointing. I saw some in i dont remember exactly Something Like 49 out of 52 or 53 men. Donald trump is basically saying women need not apply in this administration, if you are looking, if you want to be a u. S. Attorney or a judge or these other positions and guess what, women are pushing back and theyre pushing back hard. Its going to make a huge difference in 2018. Hired by looks, by the way. Ralph northam won by 22 points, hillary in virginia by 17 points. Ralph northam got a bigger share of the women votes than Hillary Clinton did. I think women are inspired by Hillary Clinton, stepped up and ran, take it forward. Still ahead on morning joe, the newly reelected mayor of new york city, bill deblasio joins us on set and joe manchin and Susan Collins looking to bridge the divide on capitol hill. Well be right back. You are watching morning joe. Witness katy perry. Witness katy perry become a legal witness. Witness katy perry and left shark. Or a card shark. Grandma . Witness katy perry work. Witness katy perry firework. Witness katy perry swish. Witness katy perry. Aaaaaaw look at that dog katy perry with music videos and behind the scenes footage, xfinity lets you witness all things me. Trade between china and the United States has not been over the last many, many years a very fair one for us. Right now, unfortunately, it is a very onesided and up fair one, but, but, i dont blame china. After all, whoa can blame a country for being able to take advantage of another country for the benefit of its citizens . I give chosen great credit. But in actuality, i do blame past administrations for allowing this out of control deficit to take place and to grow there thats President Trump speaking in front of Business Leaders last night in beijing. Joining us the deny at the university of denver, u. S. Ambassador to south cre why and assistant secretary of state for east asia, christopher hill. Mr. Ambassador, great to see you. Your reaction to those comments, perhaps a shot at the Obama Administration that came before him. What itself the i8 pact of a president of the United States saying that overseas. First of all, its a shot at president obama, its a shot at everybody. On the one hand, there is a note of sarcasm in it. The other hand, maybe a note of being a football coach at halftime saying the other team is playing better. On a deeper sense, this is a president that doesnt seem what hes representing. This has been for now the greatest country in the world, i wish id hear more about that than to suggest we are being fleeced by the chinese, we have done more for ourselves, but also for the rest of the world and the rest of the world combined. Id like to see a little note of pride from him. He wears these big old lap el buttons, there are other things to be happy about in this country. I dont see it coming from this president. Joe. You know, its interesting you say that you are right, this country is fed and weve freed more people than anybody else on the planet. There is not a close second. You dont hear that from the president. You hear about whats wrong with america, instead of whats right with america. I do wonder, though, as donald trump goes to coin, he could be talking about trade, whatever he wants to talk about. Right now its all about north korea, is there a chance he is cow towing because he is trying to get the big deal in north korea . Frankly, that itself not how we will get them by cow towing to them. We need to explain why this is important to us. Why the china relationship is important to us and why we need to work towing on this. But we need to show our own capacity and make clear to the chinese we are actually going to deal with them. I think cow towing to them and playing to the audience, flattering them, it may work with him, im not sure it will work with them. It may be soul crushing to hear the president embarrass us on the world stage, there someone else on this trip that can be productive . We have to see, we have secretary of state tillerson who seems to be more interested in getting to the state department than working on foreign policy, this Administration Needs to understand, this is a team sport, they need to get people nominated. Envoys out there they need to stick wit. These are not episodic issues that come up every few months, these are things you need to be in the trenches. You dont see that from them. How would you grade the president s speech the other night in north korea and does that change the way hitched haase and others said we may be the 5050 proposition in some sort of mission there. I must tell you the president said we will not put up with a nuclear north korea. I think there is a lot of loose talk about the idea, gee we need to accept it and somehow contain it. Id be careful with. That i think we need to be firm, on that sort of narrow basis, i was pleased to see it and that he avoided the rocketman stuff and you know i dont mind if he speaks harshly about north korea, if there is a country to be spoken of harshly, thats north korea. He needs to develop relationships with the south koreans, he needs to hold them close, hold the japanese close. He needs to work with china, this will not be a real estate transaction, if he needs to develop a deeper feel and for once maybe crack a briefing back. Boy, heidi. Given the political realities, would you think its advisable for the president to meet with Vladimir Putin and how would you expect that interaction to go . I understand that can look odd, on the other hand, i cannot think of a president that has gone to an International Meeting and did not talk to the president . The issue is not that he talks to him, what does he say . And id like to see clarity from dealing with the russians, frankly, they have not been helpful and they should b. He should be clear about that. You mentioned secretary tillerson. Excuse me, perhaps you have spoken to as well are disappointed in rex tillerson, they thought he would come in he had been a leader before. It appears now to be doing the bidding in many ways of donald trump. I cant figure out. We were talking about a minute ago, why exactly theyre not filling these state department positions, is it a incompetence or agenda the administration has, why not . What would be the down side to fill those spots which you no eare so crucial than anybody . I think he doesnt understand the job he has t. Fact that these spots extend his reach. If he sends an envoice you want to have that envoy in your office, 1225th of the second depending on the lighting conditions should be enough to show that envoy works for you, he is extending your reap. We have a secretary of state who just doesnt seem to understand any of. That so the consequence is, he plays very small unlike the secretary of defense who has constituencies all over town. People have good thing to say about secretary mattis. The secretary of state doesnt seem to work on any of these groups and the kwepss, hes kind of easy pickings for some people, including the president. Joe. Mr. Ambassador, i want to finsh by going back to russia for a minute. You know, everybody has been focused so much on the 2016 election. Weve forgotten that despite what barack obama said about russia, they are not a regional power, because theyre causing problems all over the globe for us, few are john huntsman, how do you build out that relationship in there hostile environment right now in i fear we will turn around and have such an envision because of trump and putin and the scandal that is brewing that it cant be put back together. What are our common interests we should build with russia . I think if you are john huntsman, you have to show have you the support and confident of the president and the secretary of state. He needs to do that but in talking to the russian, he needs to keep the door opened to the russians, being an ambassador is not to be another politician back here can say whatever they want. Its to keep the door opened, its to have the capacity that would, you want to see someone or someone says, sure, come right in, mr. Ambassador and lets talk about. That so i think he has to keep the door opened to the locals. 2ndly, i if i were ambassador huntsman, id like at issues where we can get traction. I would say north korea should be one of them. We should try to build out from there. Obviously, there is a huge baggage here over our election. Im not sure we will got honesty from the russians onment that if i were the ambassador, id be looking forward trying to get something cooking so it looks like we have some relationship. Ambassador christopher hill, always great to have you on the show. Its great if we have this thinking. Can you imagine . Things would work. Thank you very much. Coming up, former labor secretary robert rice on what he calls President Trumps most damming legacy. Plus, columnist peggy noonan and republican strategist Steve Schmidt on where his party goes from here. Morning joe is coming right back. What if we could keep more amof what we earn . D. Trillions of dollars going back to taxpayers. Who could possibly be against that . Well, the National Debt is 20 trillion. As we keep adding to it, guess who pays the bill . Him. And her. And her. Congress, we should grow the economy. Not the debt. Bp uses flir cameras a new thermal imagining technology to inspect difficulttoreach pipelines, so we can detect leaks before humans can see them. Because safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. [ click ] [ keyboard clacking ] [ clacking continues ] good questions lead to good answers. Our advisors can help you find both. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Yours. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. I am the proud father of aeness very strong little girl named adelaide who was diagnosed with infantile spasms an incurable and debilitating form of epilepsy. Its been a devastating journey that has robbed my baby girl of normal development. Thats why i have launched the my shot at epilepsy campaign and im asking you to join me. Take your shot at the hamilton pose, donate to help us find a cure, and lastly, share it on social media. This is our shot to take. Learn more at myshotatepilepsy. Org what was the hardest thing to get used to on the first day that you were no longer president as a civilian . Because thats got to be a massive change . What was the hardest thing to get used to . They dont play a song when you walk into a room anymore. Literally. Its amazing. Forbe three or four weeks i was totally lost, i didnt know where i was. Former president bill clinton on conan and former president barack obama was at a downtown courthouse reporting for jury duty. This was the scene as the 44th president ep terred through a back door, still could be seen by a crowd of people taking photos, in chicago, of course the scene inside, much more controlled, though. Nan. Hey, mr. President. Thank you, thanks, everybody, for setting up the jury. Good to see you. How are you all doing . This is like chicago right here. The former president was dismissed from duty. What . Still gets his 17 bucks, the Spokesman Says he will do na it to charity. He pulled the i was a former president t. Best excuse. Okay. Coming up, the president cant take away broadcast licenses, has his administration found another way to punish what he calls the Dishonest Media . Well talk about that coming up. Zplmpblths now to speculation that the Trump Administration may be trying to punish cnn by blowing up the proposed merger between time warner and at t. A senior insider close to the deal tells nbc news the Justice Department wont approve the 85 billion merger unless at t agrees to cell cnns Parent Company under time warner or directv. However the Justice Department is pushing back at that claiming it was actually at t that brought up the idea of selling cnn and the government rejected it saying it would not solve potential antitrust issues. The ceo then hit back denying in a statement that he offered to tell cnn in writing he has no intention of doing so here is then President Donald Trump talking about the proposal on the campaign trail last year. As an example of the power structure im fighting, at t is buying time warner and thus cnn. A deal we will not approve in my administration because its too much concentration of power in the hands of too few. Ha, ha, ha. Im sorry, you know, there are so many times and even Kellyanne Conways husband at one point basically said, mr. President , you need to just shut up because you are hurting yourself in your legal cases. He did that, his tweets, his words have been used time and time against him rightly in courts by judges to strike down decisions that actually would have gone for him. I am just a dumb country lawyer. I am thinking that clip can be used by any attorney, at t, to see you can see what was in his mind before he was president of the occupation, even before he knew the merger looked look. He said he wouldnt approve it and brought up cnn. His obsession with cnn that i cant think of a single judge in america that wouldnt say, Justice Department cant reject this because of cnn. You know, again, donald trump puts the burden on himself so they will look at this with strict. Strict scrutiny, not the legal exact term. They are going to be very skeptical of any attempt to stop this merger now. The law speaks to whatever harms competition the antitrust of the Justice Department has the right to ask demands and ask concessions and take companies to court. You are absolutely right t. President hurt his own travel ban early on you look at Bowe Bergdahl case, the president spoke so much about him, it made it impossible for the president to do anything again, i have fought seen long time a Company Looking at a merger, considering a merger told it may sue arguing at the very beginning of their counter that this is a politically motivated effort. Its hard to see the Justice Department prevailing when the president said during the company he would deny and he wished he could exert more control over his open Justice Department. That will certainly impact the court in this matter here. It has to, its important to remember, he said this before he became president of the occupation, he was prenl dissed against this deal before he became president of the United States. He listed the reason he was prejudiced because of this deal because of cnn. There is no way a judge cannot look in an weekend stroextraord exceptional way. If that speech, he said amazon should be paying massive taxes since the Ceo Jeff Bezos owns the Washington Post. Heidi, if the argument could but cant believe anything he says, he never says anything true, therefore, these things cant be held against him . At this point this president has spewed out things right and left that are so ridiculous that there are republicans who say, you dont have to believe what he says, its hyperbole. This is how we have to translate the way he speaks. The beg story here, is the question whether this goes beyond tweets, right . Does this go beyond tweets to some kind of influence being exerted by the executive branch, by the white house on these agencies supposed to make these based on the rule of lie. This tendency of this president to believe that he has this kind of power for example over comey in the fbi investigation so what this is investigative reporting, foias, an effort to find out whether he is blurring those lines that have been set. Weve had interagency contact policies since the watergate era for this very reason, to prevent this type of abuse of power by the executive branch. Im not an attorney and i would love to argue this case for at t that it was a political decision. Because you just go roll the tape, roll the tape. This was the speech october 22, 2016, gettysburg, pennsylvania. Heres how the president feels. But heidis right, can you go from a speech in october last year and some tweets to the white house now putting pressure on the department of justice . We havent seen that yet. If thats true now youve got a story. And also, and also, harold, i think you have to look at the people who are career antitrust people at the department of justice. In other words not trump appointees whose job it is to look at these things. What was their recommendation to justice in this case . Thats an interesting point because jessie from propulica, he tweeted this a couple hours ago, i strongly urge the media to be cautious in reporting this at ttime warner merger story. Im not convinced its political. I hear the staff is pushing the conditions, not the politicos. And trumps tweets are just knee jerk reactions to everything including at t, including cnn. Everything he tweets about is a knee jerk reaction. Its not really grounded. Theres no doubt in ideology. The law will take care of this and new assistant attorney general over there is a decent guy and good guy. But remember the president also said he would not have appointed Jeff Sessions to be the attorney general if he knew Jeff Sessions was going to proceed with these investigations. So this president not only tweets, hes openly and repeatedly and proudly stating that hes wanted to have a role with the Justice Department. Lord. Coming up, some republicans are getting nervous tuesday nights elections may be a sign of whats to come. The Washington Post bob costa joins us with new reporting on that. Plus, senator Susan Collins and joe manchin join forces in search of Bipartisan Solutions on some big issues, but is tax reform one of them . The republican and democrat join us live for a rare joint appearance coming up on morning joe. If youre looking to save money on your Medicare Part d prescriptions, switch to walgreens. We make it easy to seize the day, so you can get more out of life and Medicare Part d. Just walk right in for savings that will be the highlight of your day. Walgreens has 0 copays on select plans and 100 points on prescriptions. So, swing by and save today. Walgreens, at the corner of happy healthy. You might be missing to stasomething. Your eyes. Thats why theres ocuvite. It helps replenish nutrients your eyes can lose as you age. Nourish your eyes to help keep them healthy. Ocuvite. Be good to your eyes. You can do it. We can do this. At fidelity, our online planning tools are clear and straightforward so you can plan for retirement while saving for the things you want to do today. Whoo while saving for the things and the wolf huffed like you do sometimes, grandpa . Well, when you have copd, it can be hard to breathe. It can be hard to get air out, which can make it hard to get air in. So i talked to my doctor. She said. Symbicort could help you breathe better, starting within 5 minutes. For sudden symptoms. Symbicort helps provide significant improvement of your lung function. Symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. It should not be taken more than twice a day. Symbicort contains formoterol. Medicines like formoterol increase the risk of death from asthma problems. Symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. You should tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking it. Symbicort could mean a day with better breathing. Watch out, piggies child giggles symbicort. Breathe better starting within 5 minutes. Get symbicort free for up to one year. Visit saveonsymbicort. Com today to learn more. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide r wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. Discover card. I justis this for real . Match, yep. We match all the cash back new cardmembers earn at the end of their first year, automatically. Whoo i got my money hard to contain yourself, isnt it . Uh huh let it go whoo get a dollarfordollar match at the end of your first year. Only from discover. Dad molly, can you please take out the trash . sigh dad molly trash whoo mom hey, molly . Its time to go bell ringing class, lets turn to page 136, recessive traits skip generations. Who would like to read . molly i reprogrammed the robots to do the inspection. Its running much faster now. See . Its amazing, molly. Thank you. you know, this is what i love about morning joe. Every damn morning joe the geniuses on morning joe, on morning joe, i think it was morning joe, my favorite show. [ laughter ] i didnt know about that. Thats so sad. Steve, is that sad . Oh, no steve, thank you. No, well take the publicity. Steve, we still need to get coffee some time and talk about i would love to do that. So, mika, you know no, i dont i just just say the name right. I mean sometimes you dont say morning joe. You Say Something else, mika, so im glad at least hes saying the name right. So, listen, theres this great oped that i missed the first hour. Its in the wall street journal, the antitrump wave and all the things that basically weve been saying, ive been saying over the past hour about how republicans really need to Pay Attention to it, you know, the wall street journal has said it here in the antitrump wave. Its very important. It basically said republicans took a beating in tuesday nights elections and no one should sugar coat the results because the voting was just confined to some democratic states. And it goes through point by point by point that this is a wakeup call, especially for republicans that are in swing districts and republicans that have College Educated suburban voters there. Very important message. And by the way, steve, they talk about you here, too. So you ought to read it. No, im glad he watches the show. Thats great. Okay. The more the merrier. So joining us now, speaking of steves, former senior strategist for john mccains 2008 president ial campaign, Steve Schmidt, columnist for the wall street journal and political contributor for nbc news and msnbc, the great peggy nunan. And great political reporter of the Washington Post and moderator on pbs, robert costa. And former congressman harold ford jr. With us this morning. Joe, what a great table we have this hour and so much to talk about. Steve thought you were talking about him, schmidt. No, no, im talking about steve bannon who obviously watches the show. We thank you for watching, steve. And also doesnt seem like you watch a lot. You just mention it all the time. No, he watches it. Thats good. Somebody else watches it. Somebody else still watches it too even though he wont admit it. So, peggy, the wall street journal editorial, the antitrump wave, seems that the bottom line they bring out and it is its critical for republicans to understand, a trump Majority Coalition doesnt seem to be forming. It is a 33 coalition, peggy. And at best sometimes maybe a 40 . And that doesnt win you elections. It didnt on tuesday. It wont next year. Yeah. Look, what happened if the republicans think about this right, what happened on tuesday will be for them bracing and defining. I spent a lot of time on wednesday talking to activists who politicos and regular normal humans in virginia. And one of them said the smartest thing to me. I said just explain to me what happened. And she said what happened is the Republican Party is caught in what i call trump catch22. We cant win with him, we cant win without him. You cannot let one man at this point a man so divisive, controversial, drawing of animus even as he draws passionate support hes got a core of support but he hasnt reached out to build on that each day in the past year since he was elect and make that core bigger, make it a real base. Therefore the party is going to have to figure out what it stands for, what it intends to do and do it. Yeah. Well, and, Steve Schmidt, that is the problem. The problem is that there is a leader who as the wall street journal says this morning sometimes mr. Trumps comments are so transparentally false that you wonder if hes laughing as he writes it. There are republicans, there are independents, a lot of women that are deeply offended by this president. The fact that he will not expand his base beyond 33 , he doesnt try to. He seems to keep playing only to the base, but peggys right. Republicans cant win their primaries without donald trump. And they cant win competitive general elections with donald trump. So what do you do if youre a republican . You prepare other than retire. You prepare to lose. The dye is cast here, joe. There is no more time on the clock. Paul ryan said yesterday, were with trump. And thus the dye is cast. Oh, god. But you look at the special elections, the georgia six race, tom prices previous elections had been at about 66 . The republican who wins the special election before price resigns in disgrace and the committee spends 50 million to save the seat, he wins with 49 . Math is an underappreciated virtue in politics. So what you have coming into 2018 is this, you have 100 of the democrats, you have about 65 of the independents and about 25 of the republicans that are in a coalition, what i call the coalition of the decent, opposing this administration. And were going to hear from them all in november. And there are many more of those people than there are in the composite 33 of the trump faction in the country. And so were going to have an election. And i think theres a singular question on the ballot. Im not anxious to see a Progressive Agenda enacted in the house of representatives. Theyre not going to be able to do it because trump is still president. The singular question is, do the voters want to put a check on Donald Trumps power . Because this Republican Congress has not exercised oversight, has been complicit in the degradations of this office, in whether its the nonstop lying, whether its the attacks on a widow whos pregnant, of a fallen green beret or a hundred other outrages. And i think when we think about the las vegas shooting, johnny smith, africanamerican young man, he runs into the gunfire. He saves 33 peoples lives. Hes running towards a group of children when he is shot twice. And its a white cop who runs into the gunfire to save Johnny Smiths life. Thats also america. Uhhuh. And i think that decent people are saying enough. Enough of the lying every day. Enough of the degradations, the cruelty, the meanness, the bullying out of this administration. And you saw the implications of this behavior at the oneyear point. And were going to get another important barometer on this at the twoyear point. And yet as you said, steve, many Congressional Republicans hanging in there with trump even after the result on tuesday. Here is House Speaker paul ryan when asked if the Republican Party has to choose between siding with free trade and Immigration Reform policy of former president george w. Bush or with the populist approach of donald trump. Is it going to be a choice for republicans of bush or trump . We already made that choice. Were with trump. We already made that choice. Thats a choice we made at the beginning of the year. Thats the choice we made during the campaign which is we merged our agendas, we ran on a joint agenda with donald trump. We got together with donald trump when he was president elect trump and walked through what is it we want to accomplish in the next two years. We all agreed on that agenda. Were processing that agenda. Bob costa, thats consistent with speaker ryan what he said over the last year and throughout the campaign in fact. Hes stood even through these dark moments of the trump presidency. He has stood side by side with President Trump. Many people have said its strategic because he needs to work with him to get tax reform. Theres always a reason for it. What do you hear as you talk to people up on capitol hill yesterday . Is this projection of everythings okay even after tuesday in virginia, or do you hear quietly that people are worried and this is a canary in the coal mine . Its messy here on capitol hill, willie. Because as much as theyre having trouble with the white house, Congressional Republicans are still having trouble with themselves. Senate republicans want to move first, House Republicans are wary of what the senates up to. And theyre not ready to go to war with the white house over temperament, over conduct, over policy until this tax plan pans out. Theyre hoping to pass it, but right now there really is a concern that theyre not going to have a legislative victory by the end of the year. Thats why ryan is not breaking away because he bought in early onto get Something Like this proposal. But what i dont get, Steve Schmidt, and peggy noonan, its not working for them to walk the plank for donald trump. Why cant they say we want to work on this tax plan, by the way socially hes completely inappropriate, hes a bully, he seems to be completely ignorant, were doing the best we can. Theyre going to lose anyway, right . Arent they on losing track . Why dont you lose with dignity. I ponder this question sometimes on a quarter hourly basis. Look, appeasing this clearly isnt working. If you just look at it obviously. Outside the prism of right and wrong doesnt work. Paul ryans appeasement of this is only hastening his own demise. He looks pathetic. Just a point of clarification, this is not tax reform. They passed on tax reform. This is a Corporate Tax cut, no corporation pays a statutory 30 rate, financed on the National Credit card to be paid off 1. 5 trillion by my kids, your kids and their kids. Okay. And so its an abomination. And i cant help but think as i watch paul ryan talk about that how profoundly ashamed jack kemp would be. Jack kemp, an icon of the Republican Party, the conservative movement, a decent man, and how far we have come from reaganism to trumpism. Remember the kemp forum with paul ryan, joe . Yeah, ive known paul for a long time. I like him. Ive always respected him. I have absolutely positively no idea and absolutely positively no explanation for why he is not stood up to donald trump trampling over constitutional norms and just basic societal norms. There are no good explanations. Peggy, i want to i want you to lift our spirits this morning. Because i am such a believer in the dream of america, i have told my friends as low as i have gotten over the past nine, ten months when the legitimacy of judges have been called into question by the executive branch, when the press has been termed enemies of the people as if donald trump were channelling stalin. I always said, hold on, wait. There are checks and balances that our Founding Fathers and mothers put in place. And they will carry us through this time. And i look at that picture of donald trump that he posted, hey, this happened one year ago today. And it just proves my point, one year later they go from the top to the bottom. And this just isnt about donald trump. Voters checked barack obama one year after the race that was supposed to be the race to end all races. Uhhuh. A year later republicans swept in virginia, you remember Ronald Reagan in 1980 being swept to a massive victory. This is the coming of the new conservative era. Two years later republicans were trounsed. What an amazing country we have that any time voters perceive an overreach they knock the powerful down, they punch them right in the face whether theyre republicans or democrats and they say hold on, right there youre not as powerful as you think you are, were still in charge. Yeah. Its always i guess i keep coming back to the word bracing when this happens. I found virginia to be rather bracing. A few points, look, adam smith, theres a lot of ruin in a great nation, do you know what i mean . Great nations can take some significant damage before they turn it around. You mentioned our institutions and the strength of them. Trump donald trump is said to be so hard on the press, against the press, antagonistic towards the press, fine. But have you ever seen the American Press more dynamic, stronger, breaking stories, being more fearless than it is now . All of our institutions are working. And when the people dont like what they see they push back. On tuesday in virginia women who didnt like what they were seeing stood online in the rain for hours. They had dynamism behind them. They had deep motivation. They pushed back. We will see how all of this goes, but theres a lot of movement going on. Were not stuck. It may seem like a big merck. I think it is a big merck, but mercks have a way of disappearing in the end. Resist has turned into running and voting. Bob costa, good morning. Harold ford. How are democrats interpreting obviously theres got to be some glee and joy, but what are the lessons youre hearing from democrats talk about that theyre going to take from this victory in virginia . And, two, is it likelier or less likelier that can support some tax bill, tax cuts, tax reform, whatever it might be called after the virginia race . Congressman, i called up senator bob casey of pennsylvania yesterday and i said how do you see this . He said, look, im pleased with the developments of the party, in the suburbs were winning back voters getting skittish about President Trump. Said hold on celebration if you are democrat, because he thinks democrats in pennsylvania and elsewhere still need to do a better job of reaching out to voters in small towns and rural areas, they see the beginnings of a new Democratic Coalition of some of the suburban voters wanted change last year but moving back to center. At the same time he knows as much as every democrat knows the Democratic Partys going through its own grumblings and rumblings right now, but what kind of party does it want to be . A progressive party, a Mainstream Party thats business friendly. And they have decisions to make in the coming year in their own primaries. Yeah. Whats going to be the notre dame wins by how much . I think its so tight. This is a heck of a season for notre dame. 33 josh adams i think he should get the heisman. I think notre dame wins by three or seven. It will be close. Joe, jump in. Boy, i dont know. Phil griffin may disagree with that. So, Steve Schmidt, bob caseys a perfect case and point of a democrat who has a reason to be concerned because you can go across large swaths of pennsylvania, ask them what they think about donald trump and theyre still fine with donald trump. I mean, a lot of the towns that voted for him, a lot of the areas that voted for him outside of philadelphia, the further west you go, the more theyre still fine with him. So the democrats still have a challenge. You look at that virginia map. Red, red map. Eddie gillespie did great. In fact, Eddie Gillespie did better than some republicans in past elections there. So the question is how do the democrats turn it around over the next year to make sure they dont just win, you know, educated white women and dont just win the same groups theyve won in the past . How do they get the working class white voters in western pennsylvania back on their side . I dont think youll see that until they go through a president ial primary process and the Democratic Party makes a choice between the identity politics, which defines much of it today and its previous affinity for working people, a lot of them in the middle of the country that have deep roots, historic connections to the party. This was not an affirmation of the Democratic Party on tuesday. This was a repudiation of donald trump. And there were no small number of republicans, particularly republican women that weighed in decisively in these elections and voted many for the first time in their lives for democratic candidates. Theres also a couple of other facts that will be a consequence of this election. Its going to be a lot easier for democrats to recruit alist candidates. Its going to be much harder for republicans to recruit decent candidates. And then theres going to be a fair number of members of congress who are looking at this, looking at john boehner and saying, wow, he looks really happy to me. I need this in dealing with all these crazy people like i need a hole in the head. Im out of here. And not for nothing. When you look at the election, in the last 118 years only three times has the incumbent president s party picked up seats in the first midterm. Theyve lost seats in every other midterm. So even if donald trump was doing well, hes structurally facing some real significant headwinds coming into the race. Wow. Joe. You know, peggy, also it seems this election was election once again where voters went out and didnt so much vote for a party or for a candidate than they did against a party and against a president or against a candidate. We have a Republican Party in search of itself as ted di might say. But we also have a Democratic Party grasping for itself in the dark. I wonder if democratic parties keep falling off to the side more and more as we move forward. Yeah. Every election cycle, over four years for my lifetime, past 25 years at least people say, my gosh, both parties are kind of struggling and going down. This may be a time when a third party rises. Actually, i never saw that coming, but this time when i look at 2020 and 24 im wondering if were going to see a third party seriously come up. Another thing i just want to key off what steve said. It will be very interesting to see if the Democratic Party now misinterprets what happened on tuesday if they get heady, if they decide, oh, this is a time to go crazy, now were going to go back to all of our divisive social issues and have big fights with everybody. It would be somebody in virginia told me, a very conservative republican, he said, you know, when the democrats stay moderate, theyre going to do okay here and other places. When theyre not, theyre not. And they dont know they can go or stay moderate. This is just a start. Peggy noonan and Steve Schmidt, thank you so much both of you for coming on this morning. Thank you. Robert costa, thank you as well. Still ahead on morning joe, new york city getting four more years of mayor bill de blasio and mayor de blasio gets four more years of the citys tabloids. The democrat joins us here onset following his big reelection victory. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Bp developed new, industryleading software to monitor Drilling Operations in realtime, so our engineers can solve problems with the most precise data at their fingertips. Because safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. You can do it. We can do this. At fidelity, our online planning tools are clear and straightforward so you can plan for retirement while saving for the things you want to do today. Whoo while saving for the things accused of obstructing justice to theat the fbinuclear war, and of violating the constitution by taking money from foreign governments and threatening to shut down news organizations that report the truth. If that isnt a case for impeaching and removing a dangerous president , then what has our government become . Im tom steyer, and like you, im a citizen who knows its up to us to do something. Its why im funding this effort to raise our voices together and demand that elected officials take a stand on impeachment. A Republican Congress once impeached a president for far less. Yet today people in congress and his own administration know that this president is a clear and present danger whos mentally unstable and armed with nuclear weapons. And they do nothing. Join us and tell your member of congress that they have a moral responsibility to stop doing whats political and start doing whats right. Our country depends on it. Swho live within five miles of custyour business . 54, like these two. And that guy. Or maybe you want to reach women, ages 18 to 34, who are interested in fitness. Namaste. Whichever audience youre looking for, well find them were the finders. We work here at comcast spotlight, and we have the best tools for getting your advertising message out there. Anywhere, any way your audience watches. Consider them found. Our message was this, you cant take on new york values and win, mr. President. If you turn against the values of your hometown, your hometown will fight back. And joining us now that man right there fresh off his reelection as the democratic mayor of new york city mayor bill de blasio. Mr. Mayor, welcome. Congratulations. Thank you very much. Good feeling. So we were talking about the journey of your four years, your first term. Yeah. The first time obviously being elected mayor of a major city and there were some stumbles along the way. What did you learn over four years that allowed you to win by almost 40 points two nights ago . Ill tell you something, willie. In this work you better be learning something every single day. Its a humbling experience. What i learned is go out to all the people, neighborhoods, including places youre not popular and talk about the changes you are making many peoples lives that are tangible. I had 43 town hall meetings. I have 8. 5 million constituents, i always say every single one of them has a strong opinion. And i heard a lot of those strong opinions, but it helps you to grow to listen to what is on peoples minds. They wanted to hear very tangible change. We showed specific ways to create more Affordable Housing, specific ways were going to fix schools and give free prek to people in new york city, when people saw this happening, it opened the mind up to the direction were going in, we reduced crime, we quit stop and frisk, it worked. This is something i say to all democrats, get out of your office, go out in your community, talk to people, listen to their concerns and show them you can make a difference in their life that they can touch and feel because otherwise theyre not going to be moved. There were some moments in regards to the Police Department where, you know, at Police Officers funerals some of the officers turned their back to you, but i think there was a dissidence and i talked to leadership at the nypd and they said, no, actually, we love the mayor. Hes a great mayor to work for. He gives us what we need. A lot of them supported youre ending stop and frisk. Talk about the evolution with the Police Department over four years. Willie, the Police Leadership in this town is amazing and i was proud to support them and give them the resources. We added 2,000 more officers on patrol. We created neighborhood policing approach meant to bond police and community again and literally get people on a first name basis knowing each other and having that mutual respect. And we created some of the strongest antiterrorism tools weve ever had. Actually have the biggest antiterrorism force of any police force in the country. So the Police Leadership knew i was in favor of investing in them. The union, look, its not a shock the police union often stirred the pot. Thats some of what they do all over the country. But i think a lot of rank and file officers saw over time that i believed in making Real Investments in them, more training, better equipment, all the things that could make their lives better and safer. And over time i think it really helped to create a more positive atmosphere. I got to tell you, also, look whats happening around the country. We need police and community to come together. And one of the ways to do that is create a philosophy that says were going to train officers to deescalate conflict, build personal relationships in the community and get everyone feeling like, hey, were 100 on the same side here. We got to help each other. Community has to help police too to do their job. And weve seen that happen in new york city, crimes gone down four years in a row. Were the safest big city in america. Im very, vu proud of that. Joe has a question for you. Yes, joe. I do. So, mr. Mayor, you were reelected mayor of the biggest, greatest, baddest city in america, and the world. We will all say. Youre the first democrat reelected since 1985. Thats a pretty extraordinary achievement as well. Thank you. You win by almost 40 . This is the landslide to end all landslides. And i got to believe when you woke up the next morning the greatest thing in the world for you was to see that you had finally wonover the citys tabloids. Lets put those tabloids up. Oh, come on. Come on, man, what do you have to do to get a little respect here . Come on joe, i was not surprised. I was not surprised. I was impressed by the creativity. You win a landslide victory, what are they going to do with this, but they found a way. Give them credit for that. So what is the challenge moving forward . And lets just talk about the one challenge. What is the one big challenge that you would like to accomplish over the next four years . Look, the challenge in new york city and i think its a challenge all over the country is still fighting income inequality and helping working class and middle class people to have an Economic Future they can believe in. And, you know, bhen i ran four years ago i said, look, whats happening here is the whole social fabric is being undermined because there are so many people working so hard, harder than ever and not getting anywhere and dont feel confidence in their Economic Future or their kids Economic Future. What weve focused on is literally putting resources back in peoples hands. When we did prek for all kids and after school for all middle school kids those are free, that took a financial burden off families, paid sick leave took financial burden off of folks who were sick and going to lose a days pay if they went to the doctor. We took away that challenge. We worked to bring up the minimum wage. But theres so much more we got to do. So my goal right now is a huge Affordable Housing plan going to reach 750,000 new yorkers. And they would pay no more than 30 of their income and rank Going Forward, again, take away the biggest expense in peoples lives as a burden, which is housing. And a plan to create 100,000 new good paying jobs in new york city. This place has to remain affordable for working people. And one of the things we can do is create better paying jobs. We have a great tech sector here in this city, for example, film and Tv Industries booming in this city. A lot of different pieces of our economy are working but they have to work for everyday people in all five boroughs and have to give them a job they can live on, thats going to be the focus of the next four years. You know, mr. Mayor, a lot has always been said and written when it comes to politics about the coastal elites, west coast, east coast. Yeah. Except when you go to Washington Heights or e estoriar staten island, you see america uniquely i think more than any other place in america. Yeah. And yet we live with this constant fear in the country of a lot of people do, of the other. What do we do about that . Well, first of all, the elites are part of the problem whether theyre on the coast or any place else. And we have to confront that. Anyone who looks down their nose at their fellow americans or fellow new yorkers is part of the problem. And i get very upset when i hear people disdain everyday people and working people. You know, joe has spoken powerfully about this, about the folk who is go to cocktail parties in manhattan but never been to staten island, that to me shows a misunderstanding of the kind of society we have to have where everyones respected. And working people who make the society come together, who make it all function, deserve our respect. And this is a problem in the Democratic Party too, to the previous conversation you guys had earlier, i think Democratic Partys got to refocus on working people of all backgrounds and what transcends the question of identity politics is economics. People of all backgrounds who need a better economic reality, who need opportunity. We should be speaking to that. And we should go to them. And we should go to places where people are doubting us and have the conversation. Because when youre talking to someone, you value them. If you go to someone, it means you value them and respect them. And so that to me is part of overcoming this whole concept of the elites because the elites are not comfortable with the notion of a society that actually serves working people. And thats a society i think we should be building right here in this city. I think what you saw on tuesday was an affirmation that people want to believe their government is on their side and doing something tangible in their lives. We showed them enough for them to believe the government can work for them and they want more. Pivoting off of that, what exactly is the lesson from tuesday more broadly from sea to shining sea of these very different type of candidates who won . You have a candidate like Ralph Northam considered to be more like a centrist establishment republican then you have in manassas, virginia, woman part of democratic socialists of america, what is the lesson for democrats about what their model should be to appeal particularly to moderates in these republican leaning districts held by republicans. Sure. Northam is someone who i think understood, he went and talked to people about the direction for the state, i think thats half the battle there. This is what democrats were very good at and should be again, a central message around peoples economic needs, showing that we could use government as a positive tool to improve their economic reality and that of their children ahead. And then going out to people in every corner. This Party Started receiving from whole swaths of the country and not contesting things. Huge mistake in my view. You go everywhere. You contest every inch. And when you do, some surprising things happen. People hear something they like. And things start to move. Look, i dont buy it was just a rejection of trump at all. That kind of clean sweep, that blue wave is not just about donald trump. Its also about the fact that 3 million more americans voted for Hillary Clinton than donald trump, the country is becoming more progressive. Look across the board on obamacare, the country now supports it on Immigration Reform, comprehensive Immigration Reform, most people would like to see that. Issues theres a merging progressive majority in this country, the problem is democrats have not been tapping into it by contests elections and going out to grassroots. So i think tuesday was the beginning of towards that approach. Mr. Mayor, this is will amped up now since you are twoterm mayor, there are people going to want you to run for president willie, thats the sweetest thing youve ever said to me. No, im not saying, but people ive spoken to its going to be a free for all, all kinds of people will want to come in and run against donald trump. I understand youre 36 hours from your reelection, but is that something you would consider if the party came to you and said we think youre the guy who could take out donald trump, would you consider running for Higher Office . My focus is new york city, willie. Ive got four years and its going to be four years of intense urgent action to do everything i want to do in this city. Thats what im here to do. I understand that, but what if the party came to you . Would you at least consider it . If they said weve looked at the numbers and we think youre the guy that can beat donald trump. I would say in willies rich fantasy land. Its not my fant sasy land, its the partys. In the meantime, i want to help this party in every way i can to get back to reaching working people and to come up with a clear progressive economic message which we had in 16 no question we would have won. So i want to be part of the solution, but my job is here in new york city. Would you favor any potential candidate for president of the United States as a democrat that one of the things that the candidate must do is ride the new york subway . I think everyone thats america. That is america. When you go on that subway you see everyone. And of course its an example of being connected to people. Its just get out there where they are. Every candidate should do that everywhere. But ill tell you something, i think another big factor is going to be how this tax plan plays out. Because i think whats going to happen is more and more americans are going to realize theyre being bamboozled. It is a ripoff of the middle class. And i know now as a result of the election that a lot of republicans say, lets rush the tax plan even more, we need it, we need an achievement. But the problem is people are going to realize all over the country ends up being double taxation, ends up being tax increase for the middle class and giveaway to the rich and corporations. Thats the kind of thing that will dig the republican hole deeper. They dont realize yet if they try trickledown economics again, its just going to backfire on them. Now, twotime twoterm mayor bill de blasio. Congratulations, sir. Good to see you. Ill see you on the 1 train uptown. There you go, brother. Coming up, Susan Collins isnt afraid to challenge her own party. Joe manchin knows what it feels like. The republican and democrat join us for a rare joint appearance as they look to. [ keyboard clacking ] [ click ] [ keyboard clacking ] [ clacking continues ] good questions lead to good answers. Our advisors can help you find both. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Yours. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Mariecan make any occasion feel more special. So she makes her pie crust from scratch, and sprinkles on brown sugar streusel. So that you can spend more time making special moments with your family. Marie callenders. Its time to savor. Thats why a cutting edgeworld. University counts on centurylink to keep their global campus connected. And why a Pro Football Team chose us to deliver fiberenabled broadband to more than 65,000 fans. And why a leading car brand counts on us to keep their Dealer Network streamlined and nimble. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. We cthen we are toldrld its braver to go it alone. That independence is the way to accomplish. But there is another way to live. A way that sees the only path to fulfillment is through others. That our time here can be deep beyond measure. No one who chose interdependence ever found despair. Because what the world taught as weakness, is in fact our greatest virtue. Obamacare appears to be having its day in the sun, according to a new report the Affordable Care act is seeing record levels of signups despite the Trump Administration cutting its enrollment advertising budget by 90 . Along with other cuts, Obamacare Signups more than doubled during its first day according to a tracking website. That comes as health care proved to be the top issue for voters in virginia on tuesday. More than double the second top issue. And in maine voters came out in force to approve medicate expansion with 59 of the vote despite governor paul le pages defiant vetoes. He said yesterday he will not implement the expansion until the Legislature Funds it. According to the Portland Press herald, the state would have to spend 54 million annually to receive 525 million matching federal funds under the Affordable Care act. Trying to do the math there for him. And maine senior senator republican Susan Collins will certainly have some thoughts on that. She joins us alongside democrat joe manchin next on morning joe. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. What if we could keep more amof what we earn . D. Trillions of dollars going back to taxpayers. Who could possibly be against that . Well, the National Debt is 20 trillion. As we keep adding to it, guess who pays the bill . Him. And her. And her. Congress, we should grow the economy. Not the debt. The market. Redict but through good times and bad. At t. Rowe price. Weve helped our investors stay confident for over 75 years. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. Oh, my gosh. So much fun. House majority whip Steve Scalise posted this video to twitter yesterday of him challenging fellow Republican Congressman sam johnson to a scooter race on capitol hill. Scalise has been using a scooter since he was severely injured in the congressional baseball shooting in june. Johnson also uses the vehicle to navigate the halls of congress. Former congressman john dingell weighed in tweeting, dont make me come back there, kids. I love it. Wheres scalises hat . So good to see him there. It is. Thank god hes there. Thank god. And with that in mind joining us now from capitol hill newly announced cochairs of the bipartisan group, no labels, republican senator Susan Collins of maine and democratic senator joe manchin of West Virginia. Lets start right there, no labels. I know the organization. Why did you two decide to take over . I like it. Well, first of all, were the most centrist and we Work Together the most. And when i have a goto person to go to, its right here, Susan Collins. We have to get along and show civility and show we can Work Together and function together. Those of us who show desire to find the moderate middle we can make things happen. Thats where its always going to happen and if were going to fix things thats where its got to be. Theres so much hyperpartisanship in washington right now which reflects all the deep divides in our country. Too often the debate in washington has been controlled by ideologically groups on the far left and on the far right. What no labels is to do and were happy to join as honorary cochairs is to bring people together and energize the middle. What ive said we need our fanatical moderates to start speaking out and being as energetic and involved as those on the far left and the far right. So, senator manchin, its willie geist. Good to see you, and you too, senator collins. How are you . Im well, thank you. There are people who have looked at no labels will look at this as the squishy middle of american politics trying to have ko moments, how do you bring those people together in a practical way, what do you believe you can accomplish together . Let me say this about no labels, since arrived in 2010 it was the only organization i saw trying to bring people from both sides together. Yep. And ive been a fan, ive been involved for all these many years. And for me to be able to step up with susan now and show were bringing people in from the high echelon of the corporations, Corporate Leaders to the rank and file on the streets say, listen, cant you just get along . Wed like to see you Work Together. Were in trouble out here. We like to do a little better for ourselves and our family. So i think what theyre saying is theyre not getting anything accomplished from the far right and far left. It just doesnt happen. These respectfully i respect their positions. I like to listen to them. And then basically find how do you move forward. And thats what were trying to do. Thats what weve always done. If you look at the 2013 shutdown it was susan and i working together to find out how we open government. If you look just recently at the Affordable Care act, susan and i now signed up with patty murray and Lamar Alexander and now were going to have the same situation, i believe, with tax reform. So lets get practical, senator collins, and senator manchin mentioned tax reform, which were going to hear about today. Whats the no labels solution there . What can change in our tax system . Well, first of all, theres a matter of process. And we need to have ample opportunity for democrats as well as republicans to offer amendments. And that is going to happen in this case unlike the way the Health Care Bills were brought to the floor. So thats an improvement to start with. Its going through the finance committee. There will be a real markup on the bill and an opportunity to change it. I think all of us have our views on what should be in it. The republican chairmans mark is going to be released today. Thats what he thinks should be in the bill. And then next week youll see the committee deliberating on the bill and ample opportunity for both sides to offer amendments. And then well take a look at what the Committee Comes out with today and after the markup. And maybe theyll be a bipartisan amendment that well want to offer on the senate floor. Its too early to tell. One thing i will say is i do think we need an overhaul of the tax code. That hasnt been done since 1986. Willie, the thing i think susan and i are both saying very loudly and very clearly is that you cant do it from one side. The democrats cant fix it without the republicans helping them. And i would like to think the republicans think they cant fix it without the democrats helping them. When they dont want to do that from the leadership and they want to hunker down and just say party lines, susan and i are going to find enough that want to sit down and say, wait a minute, thats not right, its not fair and it wont be balanced or bipartisan. Were looking at how do you help the working person, how do you help the Small Business person. Right. If youre going to assume were going to take on 1. 5 trillion of debt, if you want us to take that risk, who gets helped the most from the risk were taking . Thats what were trying to look for. Heidi. Senators, you have as we know you call them in congress gangs. Weve had a bazillion gangs from everything of the budget and im wondering whats materially different about this in terms of attaching yourself to no labels which is a group actually in the end could see itself kind of splintering off into a third party. Do you feel comfortable attaching yourselves to that idea . Well, first of all, the purpose is not to use no labels to form a third party but rather to bring together democrats, republicans, independents, people who believe in Good Government who want to see compromise who understand that we need to have a more respectful debate in this country. And about those gangs, and i think ive been involved in every single one of them as has joe since weve been in the senate, those gangs have produced results. A lot of times they brought us back from the brink including ending the shutdown in 2013. So i dont diminish the power of people in the senate coming together, listening respectfully and trying to find common ground. And what were hoping to do wit instituti institutionize that. Now, the members may change from issue to issue, but right now theres not an entity on the outside cheering on that activity. And thats what no labels will do. Let me just say the silent middle has been silent for far too long. Theyre starting to speak out now. You hear movers and shakers on the republican side, whether it be the cochleke brothers, you h on the democrat side, george soares, at the high echelon of the corporate ladder. You dont know the Corporate Leaders we have involved with no leaders who said enough is enough. Were going to find a way to make this country work again. We have a hundred thousandplus people basically the soldiers doing the job. Theyre going to speak up louder and clearer. We want to find the sensible middle, we want to get things done, Work Together. You saw that in election returns. They want us to Work Together. If youre stuck in the ideological right or left, youre not going to be openminded to get anything accomplished. Mike barnicle. Senator collins, senator manchin, great to see the two of you together this morning. Very happy you two would be willing to car pool together and bipartisanship and all that. Gang members, too. A gang of two right now. Forgive me for injecting a bit of cynicism into this, and i understand that both of you work across the aisle and both of you have friendships within the senate across the aisle, but how will this work whenever the majority seizes control of things like the tax bill and you, senator manchin, as a member of the minority are often blocked out of marking up a bill or having public hearings on a bill. How is this going to work Going Forward . Let me just say that, first of all, when you saw john mccain do what he did with the Affordable Care act. He didnt do it for any other reason, he gave them a chance and say lets move the bill for ward. Then he voted to shut it down when he saw there was no open pathway. We know there are parts of it broken. We can fix it. You dont have to throw the baby out with the bath water. Youre going to see myself and susan and other john mccains of the senate step forward and say this process is not right. First time in history in the United States of america theyve ever tried to do a major policy reform on a budget reconciliation to do tax reform by one side of the party or the other cited of the party. Its never been done. I think theres a reason it has president been done and it wont work. Were all going to have to start working together. Mike, let me just add that when the Affordable Care act was passed, i remember it well, on Christmas Eve in 2009 in the senate. It was passed, jammed through without a single republican vote, and then my party made the same mistake in trying to push through the Senate Without a single democratic vote various repeal and replace bills. Thats not how you get good legislation that will have Lasting Impact and that the American People will support. If you look back at how the Medicare Program passed, there were democrats for it and against it. There were republicans for it and against it. Thats what we need to get back to. And i am far more optimistic than you are. As soon as those Health Care Bills went down this summer and fall, what happened . We had four substantive hearings that were completely bipartisan in the Senate Health committee, and the two leaders of that committee, senate store alexander and senator murray, put together what would have been the first of a series of bills to fix some of the flaws, and there are flaws in the Affordable Care act. Im hoping we can bring their bill to the senate floor to help lower premiums and stabilize the insurance market. That bill is teed up and ready to go. Were both cosponsors on this bipartisan bill. Its teed up, will get 60plus votes if Mitch Mcconnell will put it on the floor. I guess hes waiting for President Trump or the white house to give him the okay. I cant see us leaving out of here before christmas without having something that we can fix for the American People. West virginias prices have been spiked by 15 to 20 just because of the uncertainty of that piece of legislation. If we get it passed, it helps us all. Were pushing it hard. We both come from common sense states. The people in West Virginia and maine say, hey, just Work Together and get it done. We understand the definition of insanity is trying the same thing over and over. It hasnt worked. Maybe we can make amen. Signs of hope. Senators Susan Collins and joe manchin, great to see you both. Thank you very much for being on this morning. Thank you all. Good luck. Pope francis has a message for the worlds 1. 2 billion catholics. Lift up your hearts, not your cell phones. Francis said seeing the use of cell phones to take photos while celebrating mass by parishioners, priests and bishops made him sad and called it a very ugly thing to see. He went on to say the mass is not a show. So remember no cell phones. Pope francis comments were made during his weekly audience in st. Peters square and were met with laughter and applause from the crowd. I love him. I love that guy. Hes up there with Pope John Paul ii. Use do not disturb. No phones at night. And get off facebook, too. Exactly. Were talking to ourselves. Were talking just to ourselves. Get off my lawn, get off facebook and snapchat. Is the president s mantra still America First when hes overseas . No, its just not. He doesnt know what his mantra is. Its hard to watch. Well have his toneddown rhetoric while in beijing. Toned down . Plus republicans try to figure out a path forward after tuesday nights trouncing. Is there a strategy for the midterms . If there is, no one is using it. Morning joe is coming right back. So, that goal youve been saving for, you can do it. We can do this. At fidelity, our online planning tools are clear and straightforward so you can plan for retirement while saving for the things you want to do today. Whoo while saving for the things avo if yand constipation,ling and youre overwhelmed by everything youve tried all those laxatives, daily probiotics, endless fiber it could be wearing on you. Tell your doctor what youve tried, and how long youve been at it. Linzess works differently from laxatives. Linzess treats adults with ibs with constipation or chronic constipation. It can help relieve your belly pain and lets you have more frequent and complete bowel movements that are easier to pass. Do not give linzess to children less than six and it should not be given to children six to less than eighteen. It may harm them. Dont take linzess if you have a bowel blockage. Get immediate help if you develop unusual or severe stomach pain, especially with bloody or black stools. The most common side effect is diarrhea, sometimes severe. If its severe, stop taking linzess and call your doctor right away. Other side effects include gas, stomacharea pain and swelling. Ask your doctor if 90 days of linzess may be right for you. We create machines that make every experience more real. Because the best feature of a pc Gaming Machine is the power to make you forget its there. Get 200 off at dell. Com gaming. get 200 off at dell. Com gaming. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. This job that they created to do Online Grocery grocery. And to have that oneonone experience with the customers, hes meant for it. Im joey gabe, personal shopper for walmart and i love to see a smile on my customers face. We cant continue to allow china to rape our country and thats what theyre doing. Its the greatest theft in the history of the world. I dont blame china. After all, who can blame a country for being able to take advantage of another country for the benefit of its citizens . I give china great credit. What works in ft. Wayne is a lot different than what works in beijing. Well get to that story in just a moment. Plus the continued fallout for the Republican Party after tuesdays elections. Good morning everyone. Its thursday, november 9th. With us we have veteran columnist and msnbc contributor mike barnicle, White House Reporter for usa today Heidi Przybilla and professor from the university of Michigan Public Policy former democratic krong man harold ford, junior. Joe, frame the morning for us. Weve got to start in china. The shocking thing the president said in china about doesnt blame them, they should be commended for doing all the things that he said he was going to stop during the campaign, its just like the president on the campaign trail in 2016 promising that he was going to pass Economic Reforms and tax cuts that would help working class americans. Thats not happening now. And also, and we saw this a couple nights ago. The impact that his broken promises from the campaign ad in the elections on tuesday night when he promised a Health Care System that was going to be cheaper, more affordable, give people more Health Care Coverage and wouldnt have any cuts for medicaid or medicare, those broken promises lead to lost elections. Mika, the fact that the Republican Party right now on capitol hill still seems to be in a sense of denial, thats just great, great news for any democratic candidate running in 2018 because it means theyre going to keep running toward that cliff and jump off that political cliff just like a lot of people in virginia and across the country did the other night. I dont understand this strategy at all. Republicans on capitol hill reacted to tuesdays surprisingly large democratic kratic gains in virginia, new jersey and elsewhere around the country, and what those results could mean for next years midterm. Senator john mccain said, quote, unless we get our act together, were going to lose heavily. Many of his Senate Colleagues werent so sure. I dont think it was any surprise that a democrat won the election over there. I think what probably surprised people was the margin. How much the president played into it is going to be the pundits are going to beat that. The Democratic Party in this election was more energized, than it looks like, than the republican voter. Why that is i dont know. A lot of people are saying thats because of the president. Maybe, mash not. With we seeing the president potentially be a drag on his party here . I dont know. Ive got a hearing to go to. Is the president going to be a drag on republicans running next year . I dont think so. I dont think so. Actually i think, if anything, if he hat gotten more involved in these races, it might have turned the other way. This is a typical cycle. The question is whether or not we produce the result and reverse the trend next year. Are you worried about next year . No. I like a good fight. That last person was senator tom tillis of North Carolina who also said on tuesday, quote, weve got to be rinos, republicans in need of outcomes. Thats something House Speaker paul ryan echoed in an interview yesterday morning. In virginia, new jersey, elsewhere, what is your does that change your reading of the crept political moment and of the urgency surrounding tax reform . It doesnt change my reading of the current moment. It emphasizes my reading of the crept moment which is weve got a promise to keep and weve got to get on with keeping our promise. If anything, that puts more pressure on us pushing through. I adore ed gillespie and feel bad that he lost. It simply means weve got to deliver. Joe. Actually i dont read any of that as negative. I think paul ryan is exactly right. They have to get things done. This has been a donothing Republican Congress. Theyve controlled all of washington, delivered nothing. I dont know that that played really big in virginia and across the country in the statewide races. I think, and well have a guest on later today, patrick gafini who said we paid too much attention to people a that are downballot. We look at their characteristics too much. Somebody suggested in his twitter feed, a bag of mulch just won the governorship in virginia. I think thats a little harsh for ralph northah. The point is it all did flow down from donald trump. Its offended twothirds of americans. Hes offended women. Hes offended a lot of independents. Hes offensive in general. I mean come on, around the world. There is no come on here. Im not debating you. Im saying donald trump was the cause of the tidal wave. He was the earthquake that caused well, well just say, willie, that caused the tsunami. Those republicans, you didnt expect them to come out and trash donald trump, and most of them just were politely brushing away the questions. But theres no doubt behind the scenes that im sure heidi can tell us this, no doubt behind the scenes republicans are fretting because they know, unless theyre in a dark, dark red district in 2018, this is going to happen to them. I dont think the blinders are so big based on people i talked to yesterday in the Republican Party that that was representative of what we just heard on camera from some senators of what the party is feeling right now. Theres no way you could watch, heidi, what happened on tuesday night, not just at the governors level but all the way down the ballot through the House Flipping in a historic way, what happened in maine with the expansion of medicaid benefits, and not see some concern over a president polling at 35 and who hasnt gotten anything done. I think this puts a lot more pressure on the tax bill that were going to get a peek at today. If you are a member like Barbara Comstock who is actually my congresswoman in virginia sitting in a hillary district or someone like peter ross cam in illinois, you woke up in a pretty cold sweat. Why . This wasnt about some democratic model that won here, maybe i can gain this out and be a rino and win. No. If this repeats itself in 2018, members like her are toast. Theres no model for how you run against this. This was a wave. You have a lot of people claiming victory today in the Democratic Party, the moderates. You have the liberal progressives. Thats because everyone was represented in a wave which is what this was. The white house yesterday insisted the democratic gains had nothing to do with the president. A person familiar with the president s political operation called the results unsurprising. And when asked about the fear level for the upcoming midterms said, quote, 2018 is a long ways away. Now 2018 is as far away as 2016 is in the past. Still, the president tweeted yesterday to mark the anniversary of the 2016 election writing, quote, congratulations to all of the deplorables and the millions of people who gave us a massive 304227 Electoral College landslide victory. Joe, lets see who is Still Standing in that picture. Well, we will see next year. It may be a little different, that picture. Harold ford, we brought up this point yesterday that after the 2016 loss, everybody was focused on Hillary Clinton. It was all about Hillary Clintons loss and thats what was wrong with the Democratic Party. Were still having people talking about the divided Democratic Party. If you wanted to know how sick that party was, you looked at the thousand legislative seats, state legislative seats they had lost over the past seven, eight years. Its the same thing with the election yesterday. You can talk about ed gillespie and what type of campaign he ran all day. Thats not the story. The story is that the democrats were down Something Like 6337. I dont know that those numbers are exactly right and they came storming back. Again, its that tidal wave that can only be explained away by one thing, donald trump. I agree with the way youve characterized it. I listened to some of the house members yesterday including one from virginia who said this race was not nationalized. In fact, it was. Republicans have not accomplished a lot in washington. It certainly played into voters minds. Trump has been, as we know, such an objectionable and inflam torp figure politically its hurt them badly. D should not overread this. You can look back over history and look at when new jersey and Virginia Governors erases have gone one direction, democratic or republican, what has happened. It shows what democrats did most recently in 05, able to ginn a majority. Recent history suggests strongly. Dr. Northam, he fit the state. Here is a democratic who supported george w. Bush two times for president. Its unclear to me if democrats in the house and Senate Leadership if given a chance would have chose dr. Northam. It takes both wings to fly. To be successful next year, remember, its only been one year since donald trump was elected, as mika said, and so much has changed. So muchl can change again for the better or the worse for the Democratic Party. My urging of them, of my own party stay focused, continue to pick good candidates and work with the president where it makes sense, especially on taxes and other things that will benefit the very voters who we have to win back come next year and obviously 2020. Sometimes it comes down to basics. We say this all the time on the show before elections. And it is obvious, but its obviously the reason why people win. Its just like blocking and tackling with football games. Its turnout, turnout, turnout. You can look and see across the state, ed gillespie did fairly well with be republicans. The ads that were offensive to a lot of us, they actually brought republicans home if you look at the polling. Mike barnicle, more democrats went out to line to vote, more stood in line, more democrats called their friends, more democrats took their friends to the voting boolgts, more democrats were engaged than republicans. It was just because of a great turnout. If you look at next years elections its going to come down to turnout again because the democrats, they still have a tough uphill battle if you look at whats happening in the senate. Joe, no doubt about that. Absolutely no doubt about that. You saw that in the numbers and percentages yesterday in every place where they voted. Back to basics. One of the basics we have to measure here, if you walk around anyplace in this country, theres a level of both exhaustion and embarrassment with donald trump. Exhaustion because of the tweets multiple times of the day, embarrassment because i think a lot of people sit and think is this the kind of behavior we want from the president of the United States. We saw a clip of the president at the top of the show talking about congratulating china on the fact that theyre doing for their people what he is unable to do for our people here. Theyre taking advantage of us, because within moments of his assuming the presidency one year ago, he immediately rescinded tpp, the Transpacific Partnership which was a terrific boone for trading for the United States of america. Thats gone now. The chinese and the russians will dominate the pacific rim because weve withdrawn. Then you have the reality. People Pay Attention in this country. People Pay Attention to things like the proposed tax bill. They call it tax reform. Its tax revenge if you look at the elements of that bill. People are sitting out there in the suburbs and the cities thinking, wait a minute, state and local tax, were in the going to be able to put that on our tax returns . High medical costs, thats going to be eliminated, Student Interest loans are going to be eliminated. Thats the problem republicans have. Thats the problem theyre living with. Thats the problem thats going to drown them. Still ahead on morning joe, there may be one area where steve bannon and robert reish actually seem to be saying similar things . The old assumes has been the division is democrat versus republican. But what were beginning to see is that its actually anti establishment versus establishment. The former clinton labor secretary joins us straight ahead with his new documentary saving capitalism. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. [ click ] [ keyboard clacking ] [ clacking continues ] good questions lead to good answers. Our advisors can help you find both. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Yours. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. Nahelps protect eyesin blue from damaging blue light, filtering it out to help you continue enjoying your screens. Or. You could just put your phones down and talk to each other. [laughing] natures bounty lutein blue. Because youre better off healthy. Going somewhere . Whoooo. Heres some advice. Tripadvisor now searches more. Than 200 booking sites to find the hotel you want and save you up to 30 . Trust this birds words. Tripadvisor. At bps cooper river plant, employees take safety personally down to each piece of equipment, so they can protect their teammates and the surrounding wetlands, too. Because safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. I cant wait for her to have that College Experience that i had. The classes, the friends, the independence. And since we planned for it, that student debt is the one experience, im glad shell miss when you have the right financial advisor, life can be brilliant. Ameriprise my friends, we are on the way of becoming a twotiered society, imposed of a few winners and a larger group of americans left behind whose anger and whose disillusionment is easily manipulated. Once unbottled, mass resentment can poison the very fabric of society, the moral integrity of a society, replacing ambition with envy, replacing tolerance with hate. Some prophetic words there from former labor secretary robert reich speaking back in 1994. That speech is included in the new Netflix Documentary saving capitalism based on his book by the same name. Robert reich joins us now, professor of Public Policy at the university of california at berkeley. That was almost chilling to hear those words, especially looking at today because recentment can also be taken advantage of. It has been taken advantage of. Looking 20 years back, theres some people at the table who i remember talking with 20 years back, about some of these issues, widening inequality, the stagnation of wages and people becoming angry politically and also the rigging of the game. 20 years later or 18 years later, 17 years later, those themes become much more central to american politics because people really do believe and this is not just trump. If it werent for donald trump wed have somebody else. We have demagogues lined up. If we dont get this system working for more people and people feel like they have a chance to become winners in the system, were going to have demagogues forever. I think we have to identify, mr. Secretary, weight means to have a rigged economy so people know how to approach it, attack it and solve those problems. From where you sit, how is the economy rigged . Its rigged because big money has invaded politics in a big, big way. And that big money buys favors, laws, regulation, tax favors, subsidies, bailouts. It buys almost everything, even if you look at something that is supposed to be neutral like a bankruptcy system. You know if youre a student, you a student loan or somebody who cant pay on your home, you cant use bankruptcy. But if you are a casino owner and your casino goes down and your name is trump, you can use bankruptcy four times. Its those kinds of rules and laws multiplied thousands of times that people are gradually understanding are undermining the standard of living in most people. Pharmaceuticals, we are paying more for pharmaceuticals in this country than the people of any other country are paying. Why . Because the pharmaceutical industry has a lock on washington. It continues to get laws passed that make it more and more expensive for people to buy pharmaceuticals. What gives you hope that that lock can be unlocked . This is a system thats been in place for a long time. People like you have tried to fight it to no avail in many cases. What changes . What gives me hope is that, number one, history. You look at the last time we had this kind of situation in america. The gilded age, the robert borons of the 1880s, 1890s, we as a people we said no. We had a progressive era of republican president , Teddy Roosevelt who went after the trusts, the monopolies and the corruption. Its also optimistic because i have never seen as much citizen activism right now as ive seen since the anti vietnam war, and that eventually bubbles up. It bubbled up a little bit tuesday. Well see more of it. Its not just republican versus democrat. Lets get out of that box. Its people who are so tired, theyre anti establishment, either anti establishment authoritarians, the trump voters, or anti establishment reformers, progressives. To mike and then heidi. Lets talk about this slow slide maybe a couple of decades long toward the disiespaiispari we live with today. Were confronted with the enemies that have created this, automation, technology, Companies Operating for shareholders only. What else are we confronted with and how difficult are the odds against pulling this disparity a little closer together . Mike, globalization and technology, a lot of other countries most other countries face the same things. They dont have the degree of inequality of income and wealth and political power we have in this country. The issue is not globalization and it is not technology. The issue is money and politics. The first step is to get big mon anyplace out of american politics. When i said that 20 years ago people didnt know what i was talking about. I say that around the country now its resonating. They understand it. Citizens united. Get rid of citizens united, reverse that. Also Public Financing of campaigns, reducing the sort of inevitable the kind of between government and business, the degree to which we are seeing and, of course, the Trump Administration exemplifies this, lobbyists in government or people in government going into lobbying. When i first went to washington in the 1970s, 3 of members of corning became lobbyists. Right now its 50 of retiring members of congress become lobbyists. Heidi. That type of sweeping legislative change is highly unlikely in this congress. Is there anything this congress can do today to put us on the road to tackle that issue of wages, unrigging wages . A Corporate Tax cut, im sure you will agree, is probably unlikely to do that. What can kind of put us on the road to trying to unrig the wage problem . I think the most important thing right now is to make sure the tax cut does not ever reach the light of day. That is that whole tax cut is a giant Corporate Tax cut, the id manial class are going to be hurt. The very wealthiest members of our society are going to come out even better than they are doing right now, better than theyve ever done in history. There should never have been this tax cut on the agenda. We have many, many pour important things to do right now. For example, instead of unemployment insurance, we should have reemployment insurance, people who lose their jobs get job counseling, job training, job search assistance. We ought to have wage insurance. The chirps healldrens health , we havent even renewed that. Theres so many things this country desperately feeds to do, and a tax cut for corporations is the bottom, the least important. The documentary is saving capitalism, debuting on Netflix November 21st. Robert reich, thank you for being on. Good to have you. Thank you. Up next, an Election Night full of firsts. Keep it right here on morning joe. As you can clearly see, the updates you made to your plan strengthened your retirement score. So, that goal youve been saving for, you can do it. We can do this . We can do this. At fidelity, our online planning tools are clear and straightforward so you can plan for retirement while saving for the things you want to do today. Nana, lets do this aye aye, captain and as you go through life whoo tryin to reach your goal and as you go through life heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. What if we could keep more amof what we earn . D. Trillions of dollars going back to taxpayers. Who could possibly be against that . Well, the National Debt is 20 trillion. As we keep adding to it, guess who pays the bill . Him. And her. And her. Congress, we should grow the economy. Not the debt. That adjusts on both sides semito your ideal comfort,y bed your sleep number setting. Does your bed do that . Right now our queen c4 mattress is only 1499. Plus 36 month financing. Ends monday. Visit sleepnumber. Com for a store near you. Eight hundred dollars whenlmost we switched our auto and home insurance. Liberty did what . Yeah, they saved us a ton, which gave us a little wiggle room in our budget. Wish our insurance did that. Then we could get a real babysitter instead of your brother. Hey, welcome back. This guy. Right . Yes. Ellen. Thats my robe. You could save seven hundred eighty two dollars when liberty stands with you. Liberty mutual insurance. We are the driven. The dedicated. The overachievers. We know our best investment is in ourselves. We dont take no for an answer. We fight for what we want. Even for the things that were once a given. Going to college. Buying a home. And not being in debt for it for the rest of our lives. But were only as strong as our community. Who inspires and pushes us to go further than we could ever go alone. Sofi. Get there sooner. To embrace the trump agenda in the last four weeks, the Washington Post is rerting he may be up one or two points. You see the grassroots firing up to embrace the trump agenda. As gillespie has now articulated it, with the grassroots so up, we win. One of the things it shows is you cant fake the trum agenda. You have to go all in. And this agenda is a winning agenda. Do not believe the opposition party. Do not believe the fake news and fake media. This agenda is what America Needs now, its what America Needs to rebuild its future, and its a wink ticket. Mention morning joe a lot there. Super proud of that. Hes a morning joe fan. Steve bannon speaking before tuesdays election in virginia and then after. Joining us now, author and nbc news contributor annan gear dare dass. How did i do. You did terrific. New york times reporter jan nearby als door of. And patrick rah finney joins us as well. Good to have you on board along with heidi, me and joe onset. Patrick, ive been loving reading your insights about the turn out, the election. A lot of times we really dont know exactly what the deep dive means for two or three days. Where are you right now . Do you agree with the wall street journal editorial that this definitely was an anti trump wave an something republicans theed to worry about . Absolutely it was in virginia particularly. We started out you start out in virginia. Trumpism is not particularly a winning proposition to start out with in virginia. He lost virginia by five points, demographically it is very unfavorable it was very unfavorable to him among white, College Educated voters. What republicans were hoping for is that ed gillespie would be able to break that pattern, able to recover with these suburban College Educated voters. In fact, what you actually had was a result that looked, if possible, more trumpy than trump. The Election Results at a precinct level on tuesday night were 97 explained by the 2016 result. So they did not succeed in breaking. Possibly you have an electorate that was even more unfavorable to the trum agenda than the one you had in a president ial election in 2016 when high turnout normally favors democrats. Jian nearby, you look at the numbers, it certainly looks like women across virginia and ag cross the country actually decided they were going to stand in line, even if it was in the rain in Northern Virginia and deliver a message to donald trump. I also think it looks like women not only went to vote but also became candidates. What was really historic, when i was reading the stories of all the women who said they were essentially inspired to run by donald trump. You think in virginia and the transgender woman who won, basically out seating someone who called himself the chief homo phobe. It doesnt bode well for the message of donald trump. I was doing this report about the access Hollywood Tape when it came out and there were these republican women who said it doesnt bother me, im still going to vote for them. Were now starting to see who are, one, very, very offended by the president personally, but i think are also now looking at the policies of health care, tax reform and all these Different Things saying we really need to do this. I think about the womens march and the fact that that was a sign that there was something changing with the election of donald trump. Annan, im reading your tweets. You wrote the message tonight is a new america insists on being born. A new country is acoming. You dont want to read too much into one night. What did you see as you saw the returns come in. The revenge of new america. This country is today incredibly messy, pluralist, full of people of complicated identities, mixed backgrounds, many races, people who are rising into power, the groups of the kind youre talking about, that theyve been shut out of for too long. Last years result was in many ways an attack on that trend, and the result this week was that america and candidates and the people voting for these candidates saying, look, were a big pluralist country and were going to fight for that. I think whats interesting is today is the oneyear anniversary in a way of the resistance being born, oneyear anniversary of the feeling of waking up this man might degrade our republic. What i would say to people in this country is weve had a year of resistance now. This result was perhaps the fruit of a year of resistance. I think its time now with this result to have a year of persuasion. The people who won cant just keep resisting. It is now time, and a lot of the candidates did an amazing job of persuading people. Standing for the new america in their identity but also reaching across, route 28 as a transgender woman. You made a point, that danica roem was a historic candidate winning in the Virginia State legislature. She didnt sell transgender as the reason to vote for her. She talked about taking out some of the stop lights on route 28. Thats her identity, of course, but she also wanted to do things. It wasnt strictly identity politics. Watching her, i was mesmerized when i saw an interview with her. It seems like theres such a future in thinking about how to protect this country. She is identity politics. She is that new america. She doesnt need to go out loud. When she fights for route 28, shes telling you, even if you dont like my being and identity, im fighting for things that we can actually agree on which is being stuck in traffic is awful. Joe . Its what ive always said. I dont know that many people on either side will love the comparison, but it was Margaret Thatcher. Margaret thatcher got elected in one of the most conservative with a small c cultures in the world when it came to women. She was a woman that won as Prime Minister and changed Great Britain, but people didnt look at her and go, oh, im voting for Margaret Thatcher because shes a woman. Im voting for Margaret Thatcher because shes going to make Great Britain work again. That is the key in that case. Patrick, lets try to go beyond donald trump. Lets try to go beyond 2016 and 2017 and look at something that youve keyed in on which actually causes me great concern causes me concern. Im sure it causes you concern as well because this is not how we want our country to decide elections. You said the key visual was, if you looked at College Educated grads and you went precinct by precinct, you could predict how democratic turnout and independent turnout was going to be just based on education. The last two elections seem to show an america divided more by geography than ever before and education ever before and race ever before. Are we really becoming two americas when we go to the voting booth . What this election showed is that 2016 was not necessarily the high watermark of Political Polarization in this country, that it still could have further to go. There was some evidence in the results in virginia that two candidates were even more polarized than ever before. When you actually if you watched the debate between these two candidates, these were two very thoughtful candidates for governor offering substantive policies both on the left and the right. So the fact that were seeing these polarized results even in an environment where you have yes, there were some blows thrown at the end, but you have two relatively normal candidates unlike the choice that we faced in 2016, is somewhat troubling and shows how locked in people have become in those partisan camps. Mika, its real little i think for the republicans republicans need to be especially concerned about the fact that they continue to bleed support from educated voters, people with a college degree, past republicans with advanced degrees are more likely to vote democratic and independent than ever before. I would think democrats,ian nearby and anand need to worry about getting ahead on tuesday night, that a lot of these candidates are amazing and groundbreaking and the moment is beautiful. But a lot of it is a reaction to something far greater, far more concerning and how do we take it into the future. I thought it was really interesting. I was on msnbc when northah called up and said whats going to be your message. He said essentially we need a new direction. He said what drks have been saying what they werent going to run on, that he wasnt donald trump, that this country needs a new thing. When bill de blasio was on the program just now saying we need a, woulding class message, need to be thinking about the fact that Hillary Clinton won more in the popular vote, we actually need to have a message and when heidi is saying all the democrats who won had different agendas, different messaging, they didnt emerge someone this is the way drks are going to win. Drks need to be cautious about the fact that virginia is somehow going to be i think overshadows or foreshadowing for the rest of the country. Do you agree . For some people the American Dream is getting to live your identity in safety and freedom. For a lot of people, its a country run pour the many, not the few, thats a unifying idea. It could be traffic for a third person. Frankly, the Democratic Party needs to it cant keep running on the fumes of trump. There is going to be an america after trump. America was ailing before trump, and the Democratic Party needs to have a 40year theory of how to save this country and save this dream that educated the world. Look at why trump happened and address that, maybe we have a direction. Yamiche al sin door, anand and patrick, thank you for being with us this morning. Coming up, syria signs the paris climate agreement leaving the United States as the only nation on earth not taking part in the pact. The leader of france is now leaving President Trump off the guest list for next months summit. Time magazine profiles president macron and well reveal the cover story straight ahead on morning joe. honking beeping were on to you, diabetes. Times up, insufficient prenatal care. And administrative paperwork, your days of drowning people are numbered. Same goes for you, budget overruns. And rising costs, wipe that smile off your face. Were coming for you too. At optum, were partnering across the Health System to tackle its biggest challenges. At and the wolf huffedring like you do sometimes, grandpa . Well, when you have copd, it can be hard to breathe. It can be hard to get air out, which can make it hard to get air in. So i talked to my doctor. She said. Symbicort could help you breathe better, starting within 5 minutes. Symbicort doesnt replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. Symbicort helps provide significant improvement of your lung function. Symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. It should not be taken more than twice a day. Symbicort contains formoterol. Medicines like formoterol increase the risk of death from asthma problems. Symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. You should tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking it. Symbicort could mean a day with better breathing. Watch out, piggies child giggles symbicort. Breathe better starting within 5 minutes. Get symbicort free for up to one year. Visit saveonsymbicort. Com today to learn more. Depend silhouette briefs feature a comfortable, sleek fit. As a dancer, ive learned you cant have any doubts. Because looking good on stage is one thing. But real confidence comes from feeling good out there. Get a free sample at depend. Com. Up next is that where the dog went to the bathroom on the fireplace . The french president s dog isnt reminds me of cajun. Hes not very well behaved in polite company. But beyond doing his business on the fireplace, our next guest experienced during his recent visit to the palace is amazing. The new editor and chief of Time Magazine joins us next. Lets get the big guy in place. Perfect fit. Santa needs an f150. Thats ford, americas best selling brand. Hurry in today foring for 72 months across the full line of ford cars, trucks and suvs and just announced. Get 0 apr for 72 months plus 1000 cash back take advantage of these exclusive holiday offers during the ford year end sales event. The markets change. At t. Rowe price. Our disciplined approach remains. Global markets may be uncertain. But you can feel confident in our investment experience around the world. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. If you have moderate to Severe Ulcerative Colitis or crohns, and your symptoms have left you with the same view, it may be time for a different perspective. If other treatments havent worked well enough, ask your doctor about entyvio, the only biologic developed and approved just for uc and crohns. Entyvio works by focusing right in the gitract to help control damaging inflammation and is clinically proven to begin helping many patients achieve both symptom relief as well as remission. Infusion and serious allergic reactions can happen during or after treatment. Entyvio may increase risk of infection, which can be serious. While not reported with entyvio, pml, a rare, serious brain infection caused by a virus may be possible. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, experience frequent infections, or have flulike symptoms, or sores. Liver problems can occur with entyvio. If your uc or crohns medication isnt working for you, ask your gastroenterologist about entyvio. Entyvio. Relief and remission within reach. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. [ click ] [ keyboard clacking ] [ clacking continues ] good questions lead to good answers. Our advisors can help you find both. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Yours. I have a strong relationship with not just the u. S. , but President Trump on security, counterterrorism on a lot of topics. I do believe we have a very good personal relationship and we have some disagreements, one on climate change. I mentioned it because i think thats a mistake. Its good for our planet today and there is no planet b. Its my belief President Trump did this to that was french president Emmanuel Macron discussing his sometimes friend, sometimes foe donald trump. Joining us is time mag zones editor in chief, edward fall zen that. He sat down with american journalists inside the palace. The interview is the cover for the new issue, the next leader of europe if only he can lead france. So many questions. Did he answer that one . What did trump say to him do you think . Aboutclimate . Well, we were there actually on the day the invitations went out for the december Climate Summit that macron is convening. 100 World Leaders are invited. And its an incredibly stunning statement of where we are at this moment that the president of the United States is not on the list. If you open up a museum and you invite 100 World Leaders, much less a summit of this nature. He plays a fascinating game with trump. He does not like to be called he has been called the antitrump but he does not like to be called the antitrump. They obviously have some profound policy disagreements, climate, iran, among them. He went on with us at some length about why president s shouldnt use twitter. But there are also some commonalties. Among them theyre both disrupters. Theyre deal makers. Macrons positioning toward trump is a hand to say this isnt okay but also an invitation to and a continuing to hold that hope they can cut a deal. Sounds sort of like what approach you would want perhaps a fellow republican to take. Yes, criticizing when its appropriate doesnt seem to hard. If you want them at the bastille day celebrations. To celebrate the revolution there. They were boys, you know, they were hugging, the long goodbye at the end. Is that a strategic play by macron . Does he know that flattery works to some extent . I think. They have some things in common. First of all, they both love palm, the palace where we did the interview looks like what, you know, trump tower if it were built 300 years ago, its mirrored and glittering gold. Macron loves that environment. Hes unlike most of his recent predecessors, you know, he had putin at versailles. He loves the pomp, he loves the ceremony. And trump as you know left there thinking he wanted to do a similar parade in july. I think some of it is a genuine chemistry and some of it is very calculated play. Heidi. So just a question about the choice of macron as the next leader versus merkel who in many ways has stepped up in the void thats created on the international stage. Shes defending the euro, playing a big role in the crisis in greece and seen internationally as a very trusted leader. She was our person of the year two years ago for just that reason. She, you know, shes 12 years into her term. Shes currently mired in the domestic trouble, struggling to form a coalition, a resurgent right in germany. Her ability to look outward has really diminished. I think one of the most Amazing Things about macron is, you know, he ran a campaign that was really focused on france, on overhauling france. You know, the youngest leader of france since napoleon, orchestrated this incredible victory from nowhere immediately on taking office, he saw there was an even bigger job opening. Some of it is because merkel is distracted. And, in fact, he his biggest speech to date on what the eu should become and europe should become and the dangers of not cooperating, having a common un yoond the dangers of nationalism, was on the first day merkel was stuck in meetings to try to form her coalition. I mean, he sees an opening. Britains out. Trump is explicitly renounced interest in leading the west, and hes marched right into that. The new issue of time is an interview with 39yearold president Emmanuel Macron. Edward belsenthal, thank you so much for being on the show this morning. Thank you. Its an exciting day here at rockefeller center, joe, as the tree whats that . Selected for the annual holiday display outside our studio begins its trip from its former home in pennsylvania to new york city. Oh, my goodness. Okay. Willie. Think of the retvenue opportunities, think of it. Im just saying the fact that right now little children across america are waiting for the comcast commerce tree to land right there in that sacred spot. Willie, i mean, it brings a tear to the eye. Im weeping openly. Willie, will you go on the skating rink again this year . Accused of obstructing justice to theat the fbinuclear war, and of violating the constitution by taking money from foreign governments and threatening to shut down news organizations that report the truth. If that isnt a case for impeaching and removing a dangerous president , then what has our government become . Im tom steyer, and like you, im a citizen who knows its up to us to do something. Its why im funding this effort to raise our voices together and demand that elected officials take a stand on impeachment. A Republican Congress once impeached a president for far less. Yet today people in congress and his own administration know that this president is a clear and present danger whos mentally unstable and armed with nuclear weapons. And they do nothing. Join us and tell your member of congress that they have a moral responsibility to stop doing whats political and start doing whats right. Our country depends on it. And my brother ray and i started searching for answers. vo when its time to navigate inhome care, follow that bright star. Because brightstar care earns the same accreditation as the best hospitals. And brightstar care means an rn will customize a plan that evolves with moms changing needs. woman because dad made us promise wed keep mom at home. vo call 8444brightstar for your free home Care Planning guide. Pudding. Pudding. [sigh] did grandpa win again . What do you think . Yes download the new words with friends 2 today. The updates you made to your plan strengthened your retirement score. So, that goal youve been saving for, you can do it. We can do this . We can do this. At fidelity, our online planning tools are clear and straightforward so you can plan for retirement while saving for the things you want to do today. Nana, lets do this aye aye, captain and as you go through life whoo tryin to reach your goal you know, this is what i love about this is what i love about morning joe. Every damn morning, a genius is on morning joe. Excuse me. Theres a morning joe i think it was morning joe, my favorite show. The best around youre the best around thats the first time anybodys ever called me a genius. Well, you know i appreciate steve call meg a genius. He looks up to you. I feel better. And he does not watch, but he says there are geniuses hes standing up all this stuff happens on morning joe, but he would never watch. Neither would donald, ever. The president of the United States final thoughts, joe. Well, first of all, im very complimented that steve watches. Steve, lets get that cup of coffee sometime. A lot of crazy stories there, im sure. Willie geist, what are your final thoughts of the day . Well, i think weve got an interesting and diverse viewership that we didnt even know about. Over last few weeks, we found out some folks in north korea. The bannon demo. Steve bannon as well. What we were talking about of the election, well see if republicans have learned the lesson. Publicly, a lot of them appear to have not learned the lesson. You know, joe, steve bannon doesnt often cross my mind but we just showed that clip and i keep looking at him. Hes done fairly well in america. I just wonder where he is always getting this bubble of resentment that he spills up. It makes me want to clean a bathtub with acid. Heidi. Real story from tuesday may be what happened at the house of delegates level, not necessarily the governors race. The real demonstration of the Democratic Party has been in the statehouses. Theyre down to like 16 governorships now in the statehouses. Its been bad news. Well see to what extent this translates to state legislative wins as well. I think this is an incredible reaction and action on the part of democrats and people who may be never ran before but, joe, a lot more work for the Democratic Party. A lot more work for the Democratic Party. A lot more work for the Republican Party. Steve bannons out there for a reason. I mean, hes got a segment. A third of america agrees with him. Republicans have to figure out how to get past that wing of the primary and still win general elections. If they figure that out over the next year, that will determine whether paul ryan stays as speaker or whether nancy pelosi becomes speaker of the house once again. All right, that does it for us this morning. Stephanie ruhle picks up the coverage right now. Thanks so much, mika. Hi there, im Stephanie Ruehl with a lot to hit this morning. Are you ready for reform . In a little over two hour, the senate is expected to unveil its plan for tax reform. Relieve some of those economic anxieties at home. That goes a long way and those are real anxieties. After