Police shooting i want everyone to vote i think ms. Rice has done one of the worse jobs as is occ director thank you for your time. We werent invited to the festivities either. Good evening and welcome. My name is shannon on may 13, 1998, of the stewardship shot and kindly my friend during a stack out they were trying to apprehensive someone on a drug wandered cox went into the backdoor and she was a passenger in the front as the vehicle left the residence recessing listen fired into the car and suddenly shely she was 17 years old after nearly a 9 year battle the residents the statute of limitations expired not because the facts and every day failed to as voted on in the past june sheila what about alive today shes been gone longer than alive two painful for her family and given me permission to speak on her behave theyve heard about the use of force policy and the family strongly supports mrofltz from shooting at moving vehicles her family as transformed into a sense of law we need to see sheila grow she was robbed of opportunities to live her life and create a family of her own her 10yearold niece and nephews on her through photos nothing will bring sheila back but hope this didnt happen were grateful to the Police Commission and the Bar Association for hard working to make sure that bayer officers from shooting 09 vehicles are stopped the q poa stop this from being for the policy the sfpd is not barricade from 1409 at vehicles and this type of thank you, thank you for being here. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Good evening. Im dean jones a Community Organizer and work for a local agency that helps deal with your homeless problem not mine yours you have people sleeping open our lawn in the front and i get bay window paid no good money to take care of your problem you definitely dont pay me enough so im here for two reasons one is because you can do something about the regulations of how you hire people greg suhr when you hired him before our chief he worked was an officer that the obesity called balanced i didnt and beat the black off their skin had you knew that maybe you wouldnt have hired him as chief what else do you know about those new chief or the people maybe you cant hire you guys because their personally 1r689 number one and number 2 the use of force youre creating a problem for the officers theyre handling every problem in San Francisco including Mental Health you should have a Mental Health unit instead of defunding it youve laid off me before i worked with mr. Lee and mentally ill people who do you think they call pay is a psychiatrist integer Services Video you call the police im pretty much you dont know that it is sad that we hire you to do a job and you dont know what is going on in the city take off our uchldz and let me show you what is happening in the city so you know how to take care of our people sitting behind the desk our hurting your People Police should have to deal with mentally ill what is what happened to mario woods that was someone that is suffering from mentally ill the go to jail there are people i have clients thank you, ms. Jones. clapping. next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Good evening as you may know im julia a Bar Association representative stakeholder in the development of the use of force policy as such we committed Considerable Research and time and hard working to collaborative over many months together with marion i met with the poa over a to day period that resulted in 80 to 90 percent of use of force general order how reflectly the meeting and confer was not the full implementation of this order prior to my involvement that the general order then grufr, supervisor cowen and i were on a Radio Program im well aware how deeply committed to the implementation of the problem by greg suhr he know well though dangers this policy had become and spoke passionately about the need for implementations that was prior to the death of Jessica Williams and the rejuvenation of greg suhr how tragic and ironic we were able to do that the review of hundred iceds since 2000 published by the selfemployed reveals shooting at vehicles are 10 death and one injury to a fellow officer 10 started as troolts that is deesclation how are we helping our officers to calm the situations not just safer for the public but safer for our officers the city cant afford morally or economically another death the poa recommendations to get 24 order implemented and the training underway on the deesclation so all our stakeholders hard work all of our research 24 doj has been approved by you on june 21st has is completely squared with the department of justice and were not there yet less us know how we can help you. Dont compromise please. Thank you, ms. Chang next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Ms. Young. Good afternoon. Im the deputy public defender im here to speak on two issues before the commission San Francisco spell need a new use of force policy the commission knows that the policy that it approved was wellthoughtout and considered by highly intelligent and trained people what appears to the community that the Police Commission and the mayor are held hostage by a police union that is relocation and feels it can say and do whatever in the protection of socalled contract issues theories the i iron the most recent shooting in the city by the Police Officers into an alleging moving vehicle that would have been banned i say pending use of force policy now i say alleging moving vehicle im the attorney for the notorious ive read the Police Reporting and would like to correct a couple of things he was shot 4 not six or eight or 12 in the intensive care unit in zuckerberg San FranciscoGeneral Hospital the family is not allowed to see him, i was allowed to talk with him heres the tragedy of that car he had been in the car for less than 5 minutes when two Police Officers discharged their firearms into the car the good news for this Police Commission and this Police Department is they were not San FranciscoPolice Officers but daily city and chp, however, what concern is this morning the San FranciscoPolice Department swat team arrested the only wooits to this shooting the only civilian eyewitness has been taken into custody and held in a location we do not know where he is hes posted blogs and sought and put that on facebook and was a taken into custody at 3 00 a. M. Thank you, ms. Hale. Thank you. Thank you, ms. Young. Thank you, ms. Young general Public Comment. clapping. good evening and welcome. Good evening and welcome. Sir. Good evening. Im here to talk about the use of force which i understand you unanimously approved that order has importance in the issues of deesclation time and distance and the prohibition against shooting at vehicles. Im tony i know that a number of i know but im here because there is a case that i was involved in as a defensive lawyer that has 12uk with me for years and years the images of that dead young woman in the car completely has taken over my psyching every in and out that is sheila that particular case was including but not limited to so unnecessary and if the use of force not have not shooting as vehicles was in effective it at that time that young woman would be here he television she was 17 yearold a case to go after an individual on a drug case what they did they saw their suspect get into a car driven by an individual and missed 17 years old a teenager sitting next to him and what happened was shots rang out several shots and she was mortally wounded they drove off and stopped on the boulevard and thats where you see that picture of her slum over and dead it in her car i know that we cant bring her back but think about what it means to shoot at a vehicle she was not a defendant an innocent bystander inaudible yeah. Thats right thank you sir, thank you. Your time is up. Oh, we get it thank you for being here. Good evening and welcome. And welcome. March 29 the sfpd came to my house i live on 12 avenue my 17 yearold was instructed by the police to come down any son complies as on sfpd posted on youtube you see the flashlights yet the Police Reporting said my stone was at the bottom of the stairs and reviewed to open the gate thats why his face was bashed up the City Attorney thats why what is going on after the Practice Police do what they do their attorneys are the ones that get everybody off when we have to remove greg suhr then the City Attorney were caught redhanded in you say that my son is at the bottom of the gate fates pirj thats deceit and use the technology cattles to get off and statute of limitations we have a trial and my son graduated from high school and pro per for my son to have to grow this because of what the police did to him is ludicrous i hope that november 28th someone goes to jeffs office and sees that he is lying and helping to cover up police scuzzy have to posted sfpd tactical an youtube that corrections everyone in everything in the Police Reporting that means all the names are across the board crossed out we dont know who to sue so for the City Attorneys for paid to cover up Police Misconduct is inappropriate. Thank you. Next speaker. Good evening. Good evening and welcome. Thank you very much im here to practice saying thank you might surprise you but id like to thank you for all the things you tried to do like to thank you for forwarding some names of pro seismic chiefs to the mayor and deciding whoever you forwarded names to the mayor to select you can live with because you will id like to thank you for having whatever courage to recommend descent honorable, strong candidates for that position i dont know whether to be be sympathetic to chief chaplin i think youve been set up by the poa by enclosing you theyve taint you and caused us to believe youre in their pocket that is an unfortunate situation you have spoken as if youre not at times id like to be in position to thank you for speaking stronger hope you will if you turn out to be chief so im practicing saying thank you my main thank you to the officers for justice who have tried they very best to right the wrongs at great risk to themselves at great risk to their lives at great risk to their safety with the poa turned in their back on them so id like to thank the officers for justice id like to the folks behind me to leave in a moving vehicle to raise their hands those are the folks at risk. Im sorry im front of the of you. Your in front of the me but behind me if you raise your hand. Im behind you everyone raising their hands is at risk for shooting at moving vehicles he get to get in my mine and drive home wondering if 2 policy effects me the folks that raised their hands are in the same position let us say thank you for what youve done. Thank you for thanking us. Mr. Gilberty. We want a chief of police that wants to be better okay needs to stop the militarization and the suicides of Police Officers they are second veterans in the country clearly it is not working for them either we need better policies new policies out of boxes maybe experiments with gun also belts what choices do we have continuing this awfulness of abuse the militarization of our police and the peace officers and the choke holds why not stop this it madness and why not do it here we we all have a chance and opportunity a little bit of good luck amen one candidate asked Douglas Mccartney advise on sending american soldiers to vietnam and Douglas Mccartney said no. You cant send american troops to a fight they cant recognize the enemy and since that time we mill transition our police and given them people to recognize as brown and black suspects we need a better alignment we want the Police Officers in the community to stay alive and prosper that should be our goal. Thank you 34rig9 next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Hi good evening jennifer from the coalition on homelessness as you know i was part of the Stakeholder Group talking about the use of force policy and i just want to review things a little bit and make some recommendations in terms of moving forward we have an intensive and rushed as you recall process to come up with recommendations around use of force that was a series of previous intervene meetings and work that was done there was recommendations that ended upcoming to this body that were approved and were not put in place and waiting for the Police Officers to do a meet and confer with the Police Officers association it, it is in Police Officers association in terms of having the least accountability possible when those processes go forward that shouldnt be in your interests it is a different perspective how to have an audible Police Department and Public Safety in terms of not using extensive use of force as well so we just want to strongly recommend because as we are halting those things they have policies that are the old policies that are currently in play we have for example, on the vehicle shootings shooting at vehicles happening about every 8 months in San Francisco so you know we really need to move along and have a very strong use of force policy the department of justice is recommending a full ban on shooting at vehicles should be moving forward the other two recommendations is that came from the Community Groups should be moving forward as well us from the ebs coalition of homelessness interface with Police Officers were particularly concerned thank you thank you, maam. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Hello, i grew up in lake view ingleside area you know something i at Ocean View Park i was beat up in the early noticing by the police at Ocean View Park i mean it was just it was an all the time occurrence being seen you know what will happen to our music i know like ours is a moving the fact of the matter you know and its been ongoing for so long and now instead of the abuse they shooting you know they really shooting and you know something this really has to stop because you know my niece and nephews is coming up i want them to say a normal life you know i dont feel you know that they have to worry about protecting themselves or being a place afraid to run when they see the police you know and if this was the car was supposedly moving not supposed to be shooting at or no chase especially a residential neighborhood so they say if it was a highspeed chase you you know and it wasnt like a whole bunch of crime activist take place in the area you know so i wonder why you know this person you know was targeted and why his family cant see him this is never unheard of and what is really going on with the on wooits is in jail it is totally not right and his house got rated why . Because he was a witness to the Police Nothing new nothing new so i hope we can make a difference if not maybe thank you, ms. Moore house. Next speaker. clapping. good evening and welcome. Hello, im barbara about being arrested actually whatever my defy divorcee share my rap sheet was not short my divorce was i have nothing against the police you can only go with the reports put forth to you false Police Reports are against the law but some people get away with that but i wanted to say when they have like mario woods the officers look like a bunch of dummies they were all filmed to completely you have to realize our on candid camera everyone has a camera and could you please role a more professional they all subdivided their guns and whats the glory of bringing in a corps one shot will do and if they ever try to train the Police Officers to wound and maim and not shot to kill they can have another shot it fair charging mario woods was not a big imperfect boy type he had a knife but broken his arm or something thought is sort shoot to wound only is a request i want to put forward here. Thank you. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Good evening welcome again remember last i seen you going to have a more slogan make it happen chaplain i did not see you yesterday but with the new chief thing our assumptions it ed lee want to appoint whatever ed lee want we dont want i dont care youre cool behind closed doors we dont need our shrines we came today, the whole community of los angeles view this is a very important and strong statement you should take serious this is a community you may arrest 80 percent of them with trumped up charges didnt deserve to get beat like you heard the sister earlier i think were going to doing everything we can were organizing were trying to get this together regardless of what your job you know restrictions or whatever you can do like with the Hunger Strike and everyone trying to show compassionate and humility like general concerns regardless of your jobs you should make our way over there and do something to make sure that brother is alive you know what i mean you guys tried to kill him not like the San FranciscoPolice Department or the daily city Police Department you all have drinks together im asking you actually demanding that you somebody needs to do something about that like i said you may live off the brothers misery try to make some happen. Thank you. Next speaker. clapping. good evening and welcome. Good evening i try to keep my appearances on a Rare Coalition it is pretty bad because last time i spoke we were choosing the chief the community had no participation equip for a few of you who listened to the community and take it back the community wanted to say a seat at the table to choose the next chief that didnt happen supposedly against the rules of this body ive not seen the rules to choose the next chief you have a poa that condominium i was in the room i work with the task force that negotiated with in in going to well not prohibit those protocols to come into play in our meet and confer we promised that what did they do they said well rescind that agreement and not agree there is not only a lack of trust of the community what happens now youve picked the wrong community because we have youve never seen a room full of black people demanding justice from the Police Department usually white and latino wanted justice for the community it theyll willing to organize this case with mr. 34078d is one of the most suspicious cases i guarantee i see the footage theyre claiming a highspeed chase and ran over an officer that over has a scrape on his arm something is wrong the only grace is that an sfpd not 1409 him a daily pice officer that shot him thats our daily grace but ill make sure we find the officers guilty they failed to kill him his story been told he is a stroke in the hospital when he speaks justice will be served and well be here to back thank you. Thank you, sir. Next speaker. clapping. good evening and welcome. Martinez if from the mission activist, and im here im disappointed you know another shooting another officer another man of color im not from the mission didnt personally know the man but brown and black solidarity my problems will be their problems we stand together i was told that morning theyre going to keep bringing my folks we cant dont think Law Enforcement those rules and laws if someone gets arrested that is probable cause you expect us to respect the Police Officers it is an corrupt system how do you expect the community to trust the Police Officers theyre the ones getting racist textmessaging and protesting and doing positive things they attack us you know, i personally experienced things with the sfpd tenderloin bayview and the Mission District ungdz and right now all the people got a lot of conscious folks but kids 16 and 17 didnt know the next policies theyre a target like i am i feel survive with my folks by the by myself i get stopped and harassed my record is clean as of now those past couple of years let me say that what do you expect our community to do thats why we gather together and do what we do im out there giving the youth jobs and graduating high school but when im enrolling them as their case manager a lot of the issues Police Harassment and Police Brutality you know what i mean all the things in the city that is one of the key things i have 35 percent of my youth and thank you. Thank you, mr. Martinez clapping. good evening and welcome. I dont feel welcome. You are welcome. I really wasnt going to say anything away was going through the motion i dont think a lot of you care this is just another death you dont care; right . But you guys are making San Francisco into johannesburg and now weve past the point of racism your record makes you look like a bunch of thugs your disrespecting our badge your disrespecting the oath that you took you know because this is ridiculous shooting pregnant woman and racist texting message for the district of what you do and serve the only reason you people get away with that the people in the city dont know about the structure how to compete i know were not reading up on laws 80 how to thats the reason he getting away with that we want the answers sea questions once we start learning about this system again, were going to change things well not have to come to this place with answers to the mayor with that ive said enough please. clapping. any further general Public Comment oh, ms. Brown come on uptake our time. Good evening and welcome. I am here as usual to talk about my son Aubrey Abrakasa who was murdered august 14, 2006, id like to use the overhead. I just wanted to still come here and bring the awareness that my son is not to be forgotten and his case is not solved yet even though theyre having new investigators investigate any sons case ill still here and in pain i still want justice for my son the overhead is not working. And my time is leaving. Well give you your time back ms. Brown one second. As always they always know who murdered my son and the police know the da know know who murdered my son and former gavin newsom put it in the paper himself saying he know who murdered my son with one exception no witnesses there are witnesses because they gave those names of the perpetrators that murder my son those are witnesses that gave those names of the perpetrators that were there when my son was shot thirty times with a semiautomatic gun im still watering for justice for my child you got Thomas Hannibal and paris moving get and Anthony Carter i didnt pull those names out of a hat those names are on any sons file on 850 bryant on the fifth floor those names were not pulled out of a hat those are the names that everyone has so i dont understand why my as opposed to case is not solved when you know when did this i bring this because i want the people to see and feel what i feel i want you to see what i feel every morning i might look okay. On the outside but im hurting on the inside i want justice any child and like i said im not just fighting for my child there is other homicide victims, too, we making this big folklore about the Police Killings and our children getting circled on the streets everyday we need to make that same uproar thank you. Thank you ms. Brown if you or anyone you know has information into the 2006 murder of Aubrey Abrakasa an id like to take the opportunity 415 5754444 thank you ms. Brown. Any further general Public Comment hearing Public Comment is closed. Sergeant, next item. Item 4 Public Comment on all matters to 6 including the Public Comment to hold item 6 in closed session. Any Public Comment on this matter. Welcome back. Thank you again, the same thing i said yesterday you guys need to look at the cops report that assess you should be holding these hearings with as much transparency as possible i dont believe youre doing that you know there is no reason why all the use of force has to be behind closed doors it is corrupt in the in the first place and the poa has from business with a second bite of the apple i hope owl talk with the City Attorney and open up this prosper the doj. Any Public Comment on this matter. Welcome back. Commissioners you heard in the public we need to change our ways we cant change our ways unless our heart is in the right place if youre heart is not in the right place youve waste nine hundred sanctuaries trying to do something you know we have jesus witness institutions we have people representing the blue or the police force and if they were alive today, if saving nations were alive today, there would be ashamed take thousand of pages and just to make a point which Means Nothing at all we dont need to go through the history of what the police stand for or ordinary from the days of slavery we dont need to tell the whole world there is real documentation about the association with the kkk right here in the rotunda interest an inauguration the k k were having big banners today, i refuse to let people bring banners a joke in the year 2016 we need a change of heart theyre going to close doors is a mickey mouse and someone will come out and say oh, i know move not to thank you sir, thank you, sir. Any further comment mr. Gilberty. At some point in the future those meetings will be open to the public will be on tv they should be were watching the neighborhood is watching nci all the cops shows with commercials the real stuff is happening here it will be heath for the community and the Police Officers will be more involved will recent each other more i think in the near future those sessions will be open. Thank you mr. Gilberty. Next speaker. Welcome back. Thank you i believe that one of our agenda item is dealing with officerinvolved shootings and whether the officers involved in the shooting should return to the force pending the investigation and the outcome of investigation and i would urge they innovate return to the force in fact, ill urge you discipline and terminate officers involved in officerinvolved shootings officer who shot and killed derrick in the city serves in the mission Police Department he attacked and wounded one of our fellow ever protesters members for the Police Accountability we know the Police Officer that shot alex 14 times found not to be competitive use of force posted open facebook why not burn his familys house down and taser his friend we dont need officers like that on sfpd if theyre involved in a shooting they shouldnt return to the force to active duty while the investigation is pending and after the investigation occurs i get it connor it is extremely difficult to the officers we need to remove them so that san franciscans can be safe from the very people that are supposed to uphold the law. Thank you. Any pursuant to p. M. Hearing. Sergeant, next line item. To vote to go into closed session action. Colleagues do you have a motion to hold item 6 in so moved. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . clapping. the airport it where i know to mind visions of traffic romance and excitement and gourmet can you limousine were at San Francisco inspirational airport to discover the awardwinning concession that conspiracies us around the world. Sfo serves are more 40 million travelers a year and a lot of the them are hungry theres many restaurant and nearly all are restaurant and cafe thats right even the airport is a diane designation. So tell me a little bit the food program at sfo and what makes this so special well, we have a we have food and Beverage Program at sfo we trivia important the sustainable organic produce and our objective to be a nonterminal and bring in the best food of San Francisco for our passengers. I like this its is inaudible i thank my parents for bringing me here. This the definitely better than the la airport one thousand times better than. I have a double knees burger with bacon. I realize im on a diet but im hoping this will be good. It total is San Francisco experience because theres so many people and nationalities in this town to come to the airport especially everyone what have what they wanted. Are repioneering or is this a model. Were definitely pioneers and in airport commemoration at least nationally if not intvrl we have many folks asking our our process and how we select our great operators. The food option in San Francisco airport are phenomenal thats if it a lot of the airports yeah. You dont have the choice. Some airports are all about food this is not many and this particular airport are amazing especially at the tirnl indicating and corey is my favorite i come one or two hours before my flight this is the life. We definitely try to use as many local grirnts as we can we use the goat cheese and we also use local vendors we use greenly produce they summarize the local soured products and the last one had 97 percent open that. Wow. Have you taken up anything unique or odd here. Ive picked up a few things in napa valley i love checking chocolates theres a lot of types of chocolate and caramel corn. Now this is a given right there. Im curious about the customer externals and how people are richmond to this collection of cities youve put together not only of San Francisco food in San Francisco but food across the bay area. This type of market with the local savors the highend products is great. I know people cant believe theyre in an airport i really joy people picking up things for their friends and family and wait i dont have to be shopping now we want people take the opportunity at our location. How long has this been operating in San Francisco and the late 18 hours it is one of the best places to get it coffee. We have intrrnl consumers that know of this original outlet here and come here for the coffee. So lets talk sandwiches. Uhhuh. Can you tell me how you came about naming our sandwiches from the katrero hills or 27 years i thought okay neighborhood and how do you keep it fresh you can answer that mia anyway you want. Our broadened is were going not irving preserves or packaged goods we take the time to incubate our jogger art if scratch people appreciate our work here. So you feel like out of captured the airport atmosphere. This is its own the city the Airline Crews and the bag handlers and the frequent travels travelers and weve established relationships it feels good. When i get lunch or come to eat the food i feel like im not city. I was kind of under the assumption you want to be done with our gifts you are down one time not true we have a lot of regulars we didnt think wed find that here at the airport. People come in at least one a week for that the food and service and the atmosphere. The food is great in San Francisco its a coffee and i took an e calorie home every couple of weeks. Im impressed i might come here on my own without a trip, you know, we have kids we could get a babysitter and have diner at the airport. This is a little bit of things for everybody theres plenty of restaurant to grab something and go otherwise in you want to sit you can enjoy the experience of local food. Tell me about the future food. Were hoping to bring newer concepts out in San Francisco and what our passengers want. I look forward to see what your cooking up laughter today weve shown you the only restaurant in San Francisco from the comfortableing old stand but you dont have to be hungry sfo has changed what it is like to eat another an airport check out our oblige at tumbler dating. Com here we are at the embarcadero. We are standing at one of locations for the street artists. Can you tell me about this particular location, the program . This location is very significant. This was the very first and only location granted by the board of supervisors for the street artist when the Program Began in 1972. How does a person become a street artist . There are two major tenants. You must make the work yourself and you must sell the work yourself. A street artist, the license, then submitting the work to a committee of artists. This committee actually watches them make the work in front of them so that we can verify that it is all their own work. What happened during the holiday to make this an exciting location . This would be a magic time of year. You would probably see this place is jammed with street artists. As the no, there is a lottery held at 6 in the morning. That is how sought after the spaces are. You might get as many as 150 street artists to show up for 50 spaces. What other areas can a licensed street artist go to . They can go to the Fishermans Wharf area. They can go in and around union square. We have space is now up in the castro, in fact. How many are there . We have about 420. Are they here all year round . Out of the 420, i know 150 to sell all year round. I mean like fiveseven days a week. Are they making their living of of this . This is their sole source of income for many. How long have you been with this program. How much has it changed . I have been with the Program Since it began 37 and a half years ago but i have seen changes in the trend. Fashion comes and goes. I think that you can still find plenty of titis perhaps. This is because the 60s is retro for a lot of people. I have seen that come back, yes. People still think of this city as the birth of that movement. Great, thank you for talking about the background of the program. Im excited to go shopping. I would like you to meet two street artists. This is linda and jeremy. Night said to me to print them nice to meet you. Can you talk to me about a variety of products that use cell . We have these lovely constructed platters. We make these wonderful powder bowls. They can have a lot of color. York also using your license. You are also using your license. This means that i can register with the city. This makes sure that our family participated in making all of these. This comes by licensed artists. The person selling it is the person that made it. There is Nothing Better than the people that made it. I would like you to meet michael johnson. He has been in the program for over 8 years. Nice to me you. What inspired your photography . I am inspired everything that i see. The greatest thing about being a photographer is being able to show other people what i see. I have mostly worked in cuba and work that i shot here in San Francisco. What is it about being a street artist that you particularly like . I liked it to the first day that i did it. I like talking to mentum people. Talking about art or anything that comes to our minds. There is more visibility than i would see in any store front. This would cost us relatively very little. I am so happy to meet you. I wish you all of the best. You are the wonderful artist that makes these color coding. Nice to me to. I have been a street artist since 1976. How did you decide to be a street artist . I was working on union square. On lunch hours, i would be there visiting the artist. It was interesting, exciting, and i have a creative streak in me. It ranges from tshirts, jackets, hats. What is the day of the life of a street artist . They have their 2536 in the morning. By the end of the day, the last people to pack the vehicle probably get on their own at 7 30 at night. Nice to me to condemn the nice to meet you. It was a pleasure to share this with you. I hope that the bay area will descend upon the plaza and go through these arts and crafts and by some holiday gifts. That would be amazing. Thank you so much for the hard work that you do. Good morning, and welcome to the government audit and Oversight Committee for today, november 17th, thursday. Im eric peskin joined by supervisor katy tang who is sitting in for vice chair supervisor nor man yee. Well be joined shortly by member and president breed. Our clerk is dash derrick evans. Do you have announcement. Speaker make sure all Electronic Devices and complete speakers and it should be submitted to the clerk. Board of supervisor agenda thank you, mr. Evans. Supervisor tang, can we have a motion to excuse supervise yee. So moved that will be the order. And mr. Clerk, could you please call item 2 out of order. Item number 2 is hearing to consider appointing one member, term ending february 1, 2017, to the park, recreation and open space advisory committee. rules committee vacant seat 4, succeeding heather fuchs, resigned, must be nominated by the district 4 supervisor and from district 4, for the unexpired portion of a twoyear term ending item number 2 is hearing to consider appointing one member, term ending february 1, 2017, to the park, recreation and open space advisory committee. rules committee vacant seat 4, succeeding heather fuchs, resigned, must be nominated by the district 4 supervisor and from district 4, for the unexpired portion of a twoyear term ending february 1, 2017. Theres 1c and one applicant supervisor tang. Thank you for considering this item which would go through rules committee, but we have an eager appointee who would like to start in december. I would like to invite mrs. Dylan to speak. Thank you for your email. The floor is yours. Hello. Thank you for having me today. My name is Natalie Dylan. Im the native of San Francisco. Born and raised in the mission where mission play ground became my second home. It was there where i formed character, i formed friends and i formed a community. And i was introduced to my first tennis classes and it was through tennis that i got my scholarship of standard. I was able to play for 4 years and study urban studies. My honor species was on the relationship between graffiti and crime in San Francisco. So it was addressing the broken window theory which was has been spoken about in qualitative measures in new york and chicago, but much of the research has hasnt been conducted here in San Francisco. So back to kind of pro sack. I think parks and open spaces have always been a had a special place in my heart, particularly because of my child and how kind of intra gal mission play ground was for my development. And secondly, as someone who has studied urban studies in urban development cities, i think open spaces is a powerful mean if build community at great and enormous scale. Thats one of the benefits in San Francisco is for us to be concentrated in one place, and to really build community, so i hope you accept my candancy any members who would like to testify on item number 2. Seeing none. Close item 2. Thank you ms. Tang. I think youre going to be a wonderful asset to this committee. I would like to move forward Natalie Dylan to this seat. Without objection, well forward item number 2 without recommendation to the full board which would be considered on the 29th. Mr. Clerk, could you read item number one, please. Speaker item number one is tanghearing on the citys electric vehicle fleet, to determine what would be required for the city to commit to procuring 100 of its lightduty fleet as electric vehicles by 2020, and how to accelerate the adoption of electric vehicles for our medium and heavyduty fleets; and requesting the city administrator, the General Services agency, the department of the environment, the mayors office, and the San FranciscoPublic Utilities commission to report. Supervisor tang has brought this hearing to us. Supervisor tang. Thank you so much. And a colleague, as you probably know i rarely bring forth hearings to the board of supervisors, but i do so when i feel an issue is morning and one that our city should take a leadership role on. Today we have a hearing before us where well hear from sf environment and City Administrators Office and representatives from puc and our Public Works Department to talk about how it is that we can collectively achieve our goals in reducing Greenhouse Gas admissions and to moving our own internal city freak towards a greener fleet. And this interest really sums from my personal interest in pursuing the ability to drive an electric vehicle myself, but live nothing a multi unit building, its difficult. After working on this initiative with our city, i really do hope that we can expand how it is that San Francisco as a whole and our private market can adopt other markets to encourage the use of electric vehicles or other improved technologies so we can collectively achieve our client goals. With that, ill have more to say and ask later during the presentation. Let get started. Im going to call up jesse for our sf environment. Good morning. Good morning. Is this presentation loaded . Thanks. Terrific. All right. Today, myself and the City Administrators Office are going to give you an overview of local, state, and federal policies that apply to electric vehicles across the country. Al turn tifsh vehicles and charges general 101, what are we talking about when discussing electric vehicles, general adMission Vehicles progress we have made through this last year around electric vehicles, both within our Fleet Operations and city wide. City Administrator Office is going to give you an overview of the current city fleet. Fleet initiative and then discuss next steps around the question that supervise tang has asked regarding our municipal procurement. This represents 40 of the citys Greenhouse Gas admissions. Today there are over 400,000 vehicles registered in San Francisco, and more than 100,000 inbound vehicles via commuters. Transportation is a key strategy that will help San Francisco meet its Greenhouse Gas reduction goals, and stick with our city wide Renewable Energy goals which of course in 2008 was established via the board of supervisors to have 100 Renewable EnergyElectricity Supply by 2030. Just a reminder our other municipalities are theyre delivering 100 Greenhouse Gas free electricity to the vehicles we have. Any expansion of electric vehicles we have in the fleet is 100 reduction in Greenhouse Gas admissions from that component of our foot print, and in 2015 mayor lee signed a west coast mayors Fleet Initiative that established a 10 procurement goal annually for electric vehicles in our municipal fleet. Locally the legislation that implements this is 10 this applies to fleet vehicles that are 800 bounds and less so these are light duty sedan and trucks. This is is safety vehicles like police, pursuit and fire. As well as some exemptions to enter prize. They have that includes fleet management, Vehicle Selection, with some support from sf environment. And really what the City Administrators Office is achieving through hacto is mandatory fleet reduction fleet requirements so theyre exercising the fleet and how to use fleet vehicles appropriately and how to size the vehicles so they meet the needs of the different departments. And also to select vehicles via a Vehicle Selection list that are the highesty the highest efficiency. Its aligned with the greenhouse goals around fleet operation, which is a 4 reduction in Greenhouse Gas admissions by the end of fiscal year 2017 and a reduction by end of fiscal year 2021. Sf environment within hacto has alternative field Vehicle Infrastructure and ill talk about what were doing on that in a few minutes. But this includes looking at how we expand electric vehicle charging infrastructure throughout city to we apply for grants from the state federal government, and foundations which ill discuss as well. A quick review of california policy that applies to electric vehicles. In 2012, Governor Brown established an executive order that mandated 1. 5 million zero Mission Vehicles that are on the roads by 2025. When we talk about zero Mission Vehicles from the states perspective, this includes plug in hybrid electric vehicles, battery electric vehicles and fossil vehicles. S it established a 50 renewable portfolio goal to ensuring inveters and utility was delivering 50 of their electricity portfolios throughout the state which is sinner jess tick of the state with the 1. 5 million zero Mission Vehicles and we need another outlet for that Renewable Energy generation. Besides the built environment and that is they lek tri cajun of transportation. Just this month, state of california also issued the zero admission plan which established a new procurement goal for state vehicles so theyll be working to ensure that 50 of the states annual light duty procurement is zero Mission Vehicles by 2025. And then the federal government, they have their procurement goals which were established last year which requires 20 of the federal fleet to acquire electric vehicles by 2020, and their procurement goal of 50 electric vehicles by 2025. When we talk about zero Mission Vehicles just quickly, battery electric vehicles only runon a charge that is electric. This is a fully plug in vehicle that has a battery on board to store that energy. Plug in hybrid electric vehicles use an electric motor for short range trips, and then after that charge has run out, there is a hybrid gasoline engine that kicks in for the extended range. And Hydrogen Electric vehicles are electric vehicles that use hydrogen as the fuel to power an electric engine through fuel cells. Primarily what were discuss is the plug in and hybrid vehicles which are plug in electric vehicles. What were not discussing is cng and hybrid simply because they dont fall under the definition of zero Mission Vehicles from the state of california. So what is the range of some of these vehicles, battery electric vehicles we see that full electric capacity having range from anywhere to 80 miles to 115 miles currently on a charge. There are some possible options here that could be integrated into municipal procurement including the ford focus, kia, the nissan lease which is what we have and smarty remembering trick drive vehicles and you can see the varying range of these cars, plug in hybrid electric vehicles. They have a shorter range on the fully electric component of their power system with extended range, hybrid engine that can be in access of 30mile and were familiar with the different hybrids that exist. Coming soon and not when i mean soon i mean next month are the long range electric vehicles which are battery electric vehicles that have a higher range than the electric vehicles we have seen on the market to date. This includes the chevy bolt which yesterday was named motor trend car of the year. This will be a 30,000 vehicle that gets over 200 miles of range. We have the tesla model three which gets 200 miles of range with a sim particular price range that has and then the Hydrogen Fuel vehicles, we do have the Hydrogen Fuelling station near ssfo and a potential for pro hydrogen stations to open in San Francisco in the next couple of years via a couple of energy grants that are pending decision. There are fuel electric vehicles including the honda tusan and the honda clarity. The San Francisco bay area is already a leader in electric vehicle adoption. And this is consist at that point with california is one of the Worlds Largest mark hes for light duty zero Mission Vehicles with plug in electric vehicle ownership exceeded 230,000 vehicles by the end of the summer. Californians drive 40 of all the electric vehicles on the road in the united states. And California Electric Vehicle market represents 1 3 of the worlds easy market. In San Francisco, theres approximately 5,000 electric vehicles registered to residents and businesses. And in some areas of our city, this represents 2 to 3 of the registered vehicle totals in those neighborhoods. So what this image represents is the darker green is where we have higher up take of electric vehicles throughout the city. So this shows how many vehicles are actually registered in these neighborhoods, and how many electric vehicles are registered in those neighborhoods as well. New sells of electric vehicle in San Francisco represent about 4 of those of the sells of vehicles in this city. And in the bay area, we see in communities and the south bay, new sells of electric vehicles representing 20 . So San Francisco and our early adopters of technology and throughout the bay area really are driving the market transportation for electric vehicles. But nationwide, worldwide, electric vehicles still only represent 1 of annual car sells. But this is going to change and its going to change really soon. What this image represents is electric vehicles that are coming to market. I mentioned the chevy bolt which of course is being released in december that will have better range and lower pricing. So in addition to the chevy bolt, we have the tesla which has the lower price point and the nissan lease is going to have over 250 mys miles of range and we have those entering the market who have promised, this week at the la auto show to deploy multiple models of electric vehicles by 2020. So electric vehicle adoption, i cannot be successful without implementing accessible ev charging. Theres three primary types of ev charging bases on use case of the vehicles, so a level one charger is what you think of when you think of a wall socket. This is the lowest cost for charging. This is for charging over night at home or in the case of our that municipal fleet when vehicles are not used after work hours and they can charge all night. Level two charging is common at work places. The chargers that we do have installed through the city of San Francisco are mostly level 2 chargers. A level 2 charge enables you to recharge that battery to gain about 25 miles of range per hour of charge. This is when you think of when you install a 234 vault driver socket if the and the range can level for level 1 and level 2. If we needed to install for example, a run to support a ped stool for level one at a municipal facility, that could require trenching and require labor cost, so we do see that this range of cost could vary based on the municipal facility and the use case of the vehicle, and how we pair a different a specific type of charging to that vehicles use case. And in San Francisco, of course, our cost are generally more expensive than what we see across the country, and these averages that we see here theyre average from a cross the country. We want to ensure moving forward in the analysis we conduct of how much it will cost for us to support municipal vehicles that were really looking at appropriate levels of budget for that charging. With level 2 charging, one of the important components that we also want to look at when assessing municipal facilities and the appropriate types of charging for vehicles is the Electrical Capacity of the building and make sure theres in the electric cal facility. One way for us to manage that is to through manage charging because they can be expensive. Load control strategies, these technologies that enable fleet recharge management through an integrated computerized system can really help accelerate deployment of electric vehicles without requiring those electrical upgrades and they sequence multiple chargers through an Automatic Process so you dont have all the cars charging at one exceeding that building. And also it helps to reduce cost for labor, for fleet, staff to be managing charging of electric vehicles. And reduces those, again, those electrical infrastructure needs. Likely what were not looking at for dc fast charge. Thats going to be applicable in the private sector when meeting the needs of business and Transportation NetworkCompanies Like uber and lift, and how we work with them to electrify their fleet of drivers. City does have one of the highest per capital rates of electric vehicle charging infrastructure vehicles in the bay area. At municipal across about 20 minutes of post facilities we have 217 publicly available charging ports. 111 of these are located at various municipal facilities, mainly concentrated around mta garages and lots, and then there are over 100 at sfo as well. 25 of these charging ports are dedicated to municipal fleet vehicle charging. You can see there in the green box, the september statistics for use of these municipal Public Public available charging ports, so theyre being utilized frequently. City wide we have 200 charging stations deployed. These points on the maps representing charging station thats can have multiple ports, so what you see here doesnt look like necessarily 600, but there are 600 here with multiple ports at each location. And then there are also dc fast chargers throughout the city. Not all of these are publicly accessible. Some are at hotels and other locations. But in general, we have one of the highest per cap rates of charging infrastructure in california and San Francisco has done a great job over 5 years of leading the charge of integrating charging station, but we see the private sector picking up this, and i think that as much as we can work with the private sector on Public Private partnership on how to deploy that would be great. Just quickly, and just if you dont mind, looking at the various maps and the up take within the city for ev, it once we expand into talking about the private market, really theres so much opportunity as you can see visually on the west side of town where we have more Single Family homes and probably more availability in terms of charging infrastructure, but there isnt a level of uptick as we would want to see, so i think again in the few just focusing on outreach efforts would be beneficial. Yeah. When we put together the green square illustration, we were really surprised actually to see the opportunity that exist in these areas that have Single Family homes, that have actual dedicated parking spot and garages and we also know our places where people are driving a lot compared to the center of the city where we have Public Transportation thats available, and what not. Its definitely an opportunity. Just quickly on what weve been up to in 2016, the city of San Francisco of course was one of the 7 finalist for the u. S. Department of transportation smart city challenge, and through this process, we were able to, in a very quick period of time, develop a strategy around ev deployment in the private sector with internal and external stakeholders. We of course were not successful in winning the dot smart city challenge, columbus, ohio won that particular grant opportunity. But from that particular from that experience, the city and the other smart city challenge finalist have begun to collaborate and work together. We collectively submitted a department of energy Grant Application that were waiting to hear about. Weve all agreed working together rather than competing against each other is a gra g strategy to move forward we included projects including work place charging, andy remembering tri cajun of medium duty