Transcripts For SFGTV Replay Special Govt Audits Committee 92916 20160930

[gavel] good morning and welcome to a special meeting of the government audit and Oversight Committee for today thursday september 29. I am the chair of the committee. Supervisor aaron peskin. Joined to my right vice chair norman yee and to my left president london breed and were joined by david campos. Our clerk is erica major. Madam clerk are there any announcements . Yes, please silence all cell phones and electronic devices. All documents submitted to the clerk and items will be on the. Items acted upon today anybody r will be on the eakt 18 board of supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated. Thank you. Could you read the first and only item for todays meeting . Yes. Item 1 is ordinance amending the administrative code to create the neighborhood crime unit in the mrs. And activated with the controller certifies that the department is at full staffing level mandated in the charter. Thank you supervisor yee is the sponsor of this ordinance. The floor is yours supervisor. Thank you chair peskin. This ordinance is a way for more common data driven approach to combating neighborhood crimes more specifically property crimes. And youre aware that home break in and burglaries and auto break ins are a problem for every district and its frustrating for every person to say what are we going to do about it . There are many theories, many approaches but what i did is of able to meet with a variety of stakeholders including rank and file in the Police Department. I spoke to former chiefs such as tony rivero and chief fred lau. I have speaken to Police Commissioners about these issues and what approach will make sense and at the end of the day what almost everybody said was why are what we really need is good leadership within administration to say this is what is needed that we dont necessarily want to centralize everything, and thats why there was an approach that was pretty much argued that it was not the best approach about 20 years ago, and it was beginning to decentralized and giving a lot more ability for each of the Police Stations to have a little more flexibility in how they would approach their own neighborhoods, so after many discussions this is the ordinance that i am moving forward is really a combination of what i heard and whats logical, and what people would support, and an approach that i would like to outline is really to have a combination, and also i spoke to the people from the grand jury after they gave their report and i said this is really interesting theyre thinking pretty similarly. Whats important is that we continue to support the decentralized approach letting each of the Police Stations really approach the neighborhoods. What people were asking for the Police Department was asking for was please help us with the resources. What we need is more people assigned to these units that can actually confront what is facing them today, and each district is a little bit different, Police Station is a little different as to what they see as the most important issue. Today it is about property crime in my district and other districts and tomorrow it may be Something Else so you want that flex but what they also said is important that much of this has to be well coordinated meaning theres room for a centralized place, and one of the things that were seeing is that this already theres already a centralized unit that is tackling this and the grand jury was basically saying what they need is also more resources, and rather than creating a brandnew unit, so this is what i am putting forward basically to support, provide more resources for those decentralized approach, plus giving more resources so it could be well coordinated with the current centralized unit in the San Francisco Police Department, so i am hoping we could move this forward to the full board. Thank you very much. Thank you supervisor. Supervisor campos. Thank you very much mr. Chairman and thank you to my colleagues of the government audit and Oversight Committee. I want to thank supervisor yee and his staff, jenn l low for the work on this important legislation. We of proud to work with him on this and i just want to give a little bit of background for what we have seen in my district, in district 9. Earlier this year i actually held a hearing on march of this year specifically focusing on car break ins in my district, and the reason for that is that we were hearing repeatedly from people in our community, not only in the mission but in Bernal Heights and other parts of the district about an increase in car break ins primarily in bernal and the mission, and we wanted to have a better sense what was actually happening in terms of the citys strategy and response to this proliferation of car break ins and what happened at the hearing i think was very startling to me and kind of raised even more red flags,. In that hearing we had a presentation from our District Attorneys Office that pointed out that if you look at 2015 there were more than 25,000 car break ins in the city and county of San Francisco but only arrests were made in only 2 of those car break ins, so that means that in 98 of car break ins in the city people essentially got away with it, and that number of arrests, the 2 , is by the way a fraction of what the National Average is, so something is happening in San Francisco that when people break into cars the arrests are not being made at the same rate they are in other jurisdictions, and so in thinking about this you know what we have been trying to come up with is any ideas, any outside the box thinking that essentially gives the Police Department more tools to do more, and as a former Police Commissioner i think that my experience is that the most effective way of dealing with any kind of crime especially property crimes is to have a district specific strategy because every neighborhood, every district is different, and as we look at the issue of property crime and car break ins as part of it the bottom line we need a comprehensive plan to tackle these kinds of crimes, property crimes, car break ins. We need to send a message that in San Francisco were not going to tolerate that. That making arrests and prosecutions in those types of crimes is a priority, and by the way i would include bicycle tests in this too thefts too because its another issue that that keeps come up every time we talk about property crime. Burglaries are also part of it. What this legislation does and the reason i upon very proud to support it that it focuses the attention and the resources at each district station because what could work in the Mission Bernal heights you know might be different, and in fact even in my district i have three different district stations, and different strategies might be needed in every neighborhood so i upon very proud to be a supporter of this. This legislation ensures that the police prioritize neighborhood crime issues and then the other thing is that this also makes it clear that we need to act now. We dont have to wait for anything. There is no reason why we have to wait for whatever the event. We need to act now and thats what this does so i am proud to be supportive and i want to thank carolyn and my staff for the work she has done. Thank you. Supervisor breed. Thank you. And thank you to my colleagues for your comments about this particular issue. As we know we have a lot of challenges with crime throughout our city, and more specifically i want to add to supervisor campos list graffiti. Graffiti is definitely one of the issues that we continue to have in San Francisco spending over 20 million a year to address those issues and thats with just city property. It doesnt even include the numbers for private property owners. I want just to add a couple of points with regards to the car break ins. We in many of our areas especially where we have a large tourist population are experiencing really high levels of car break ins, specifically in mos square, in twin peaks where the palace of fine arts is loated as well, and recently we added signage to alamos square park which has been helpful but not has addressed the issue. Next week or the week after i will be proposing legislation around requiring rental companies to notify those who rent cars in San Francisco and at San Francisco airport some of the challenges we have in those particular areas specifically because it happens in broad daylight and just imagine if you visited another country and your bloojings were stolen which also includes your passport, your ability to return home i cant even one imagine and one of the challenges going after the perp traders of the crimes they dont live in San Francisco and they return home and wont come back to court to testify so we have a problem and we need solutions. We not only need support around you know a strategy for the Police Department to deal with these particular crimes in the neighborhoods and specifically targeted areas, we also need to look at a Community Ambassador program, a program that will make sure in those areas that we have a friendly face, like a docent similar to the volunteer Docent Program we have at city hall and so those are the kinds of things they want it to also mention because we need a comprehensive approach to addressing many of the crimes that we see all over our neighborhoods, and i want to thank supervisor yee for his leadership on this particular issue, and thank you. Thank you for the opportunity. If i may. Supervisor campos. Just a quick note. What we heard at the hearing on car break ins its really hard to make arrests, right, because of the lack of evidence and the know the public defender folks may not like this but one of the things that came up in many jurisdictions they use a bait car that it essentially has all of the technology so that you actually get the evidence you need, and i know i mean i think using whatever tools to actually get evidence is important, but i think that unless you actually do something to prioritize this the message will remain that you can go and break into cars in San Francisco because chances are youre not going to get caught and we dont want that message. Thank you. Thank you supervisor and let me add my words too. Thanks to supervisor yee and his staff ms. Low for working on this. Supervisor yee. Real quickly thank you supervisor campos. The other thing that people, the precincts were asking in terms of the Police Precincts was these cars that youre talking about that we also benefit from having that type of resource within their own units. So if there is no objection can we have a motion to send this to the full board with recommendation . So moved. Moved by supervisor breed without objection that is the order. Public comment. Oh im sorry. Excuse me. Are there any members of the public here for Public Comment . My apologies. Are there any members here for Public Comment . Seeing none Public Comment is closed. [gavel] and without objection we will send this item [inaudible] [off mic] any amendments . Actually its so long i keep thinking this is the original language. [inaudible] [off mic] yeah, i will make a motion to rescind the vote. [gavel] moved by supervisor breed without objection. Supervisor yee. So this host of amendments and i dont know if City Attorney gibner would like to read it out for the record. Deputy City Attorney john gibner. Its a bunch of words so i wont read the whole thing but essentially the amendments correspond to the discussion that the committee had today about units throughout the city instead of a centralized unit, and i think thats the basicgist and also some clarification about what the units will focus on with emphasize on community policing. Okay. Thats correct so theres a bunch of words that were outcome. So is there a motion to accept these amendments . Made by supervisor breed. Without objection the amendments are adopted. [gavel] and as amended we will send this item to the full board with recommendation. Motion made by supervisor breed. Without objection that is the order and i believe that concludes our agenda. We are adjourned. [gavel] thank you. Shop and dine the 49 promotes loophole businesses and changes residents to do thirds shopping and diane within the 49 square miles of San Francisco by supporting local services we help San Francisco remain unique and successful where will you shop and dine shop and dine the 49. My name is neil the general manager for the book shop here on west portal avenue if San Francisco this is a neighborhood bookstore and it is a wonderful neighborhood but it is an interesting community because the residents the neighborhood muni loves the neighborhood it is community and we as a book sincerely we see the same people here the shop all the time and you know to a certain degree this is part of their this is created the neighborhood a place where people come and subcontract it is in recent years we see a drop off of a lot of bookstores both National Chains and neighborhoods by the Neighborhood Stores where coming you dont want to one of the great things of San Francisco it is neighborhood neighborhood have dentist corrosive are coffeehouses but 2, 3, 4 coffeehouses in month neighborhoods that are on their own thats commission occurring wednesday, september 28, 2016 will begin shortly. Good evening everyone can i please ask the people standing by the door to please move to the side of the room . There are some empty seats please fill them in. Thank you. The fire marshal is facing this way but at the men were all in trouble. We want to stay out of trouble. Our commission of regular meeting wednesday, september 28, 2016 and actual time is 5 01 pm. Item 1 local president francie covington, here. Cleaveland, present. Nakajo, present. Hardeman, present. Chief of department joanne hayes white, here. Item to Public Comments. Members of the public may just the commission for up to 3 min. On any matter within the kurt jurisdiction does not appear on the agenda. Speakers shall address the remarks of the commission as a whole not to individual commissioners were Department Personnel. Commissioners are not to enter into debate or discussion with a speaker. The lack of her spots by the commissioners or Department Personnel does not necessarily constitute agreement with the support of statements made during Public Comments. Thank you please take mdm. Clerk. Other any members of the public that would like to speak on matters not on the agenda . Hello my name is sylvia johnson. I was speaking to one of your [inaudible] commissioners Scientific Technology and that these codenames have been written. It says on their on these codes, that these things are going to happen under certain way and this is how the time limit and everything. I [inaudible] which i know ive already written this down and has not been [inaudible] the emails or nothing because of some substantial that i had already put now to beauty and peace on this world and we probably [inaudible] in the process years ago to make some of this stuff. For some of these congresses that has been done on these codes issues. African american historic and this is where our time is going on now which would be more aware more prepared for the Police Department and also all our Fire Departments that we can learn a lot of these issues. [inaudible] to proceed in this issue is red over because i think it has a lot to do with the Social Security number my original Social Security number was marked as a dead person. I am not dead. That is not the issue thats been going on. Now for things that we look at as republicans and congress and all our [inaudible] that we need to search for peace. Thank you. Are there any other members of the public would like to speak at this time . Please, come forward hello. My name is Evan Cambridge but i only recommend that you put the agenda for each meeting on the website. The front page of the website. So that it might be accessible more accessible for citizens. Thank you. Thank you. Any other members of the public who would like to speak again . No. Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Clerk item 3 approval of the minutes discussion and possible action to approve the Meeting Minutes of august 24, 2016. Thank you. Any member of the public that would like to comment on the minutes estimated . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. I will go to my fellow commissioners beginning with commissioner cleaveland i moved to approve thank you, sir. Second . Is there a second . Second mdm. Chairman. Second by commissioner hardeman all those in favor say, aye [chorus of ayes]. Thank you all next item, please item for chief of departments reported import on Current Issues activities events within the Department Since the Fire Commission report meeting of september 14, 2016 including fiscal year 201617 budget academies 1005000 foot hundred and 50th anniversary update Strategic Plan update special density medications in our reach to other Government Agencies and the public. Report from administration. Report on the administrative divisions fleet and facility status on its support services, Homeland Security and training within the department. Thank you and welcome, chief good evening pres. Covington and members of the Fire Commission this or are report since our last meeting on september 14 starting with a budget we recently this month finished the closeout of fiscal year 1560. We completed the year on budget for expenditures and revenue. Its good news. Accounting and finance staff currently are working with the Controllers Office on your and audits. We have begun implementation of some of the Funding Initiatives in the 1617 budget. Including women and fleet allocation. With the order of fiber engines and cordless rescue jews as was winning some of our prevention positions as civilian position. That is underway and we are moving along at a quick pace which im pleased to report. With regards to our division of training, the 1 20 classes in their 15th week. We have 52 members that are in that class remaining we started with 54. The graduate on november 4. On november 28, we look forward to welcoming the 120 firstclass. It was comprised of 54 members. 42 from the ntn National Testing network list and 12 will come over from station 49. They are level ii paramedics that will join the 121st academy two weeks and because they do not need to go through the evaluation period four emts. Last week an early this week i conducted meet and Greet Sessions with approximately 63 members and have made some alternate offers we call them for consideration for the november and april academies. What that means is they will move onto the next phase which is a medical examination. I will continue to conduct interviews and has an even further net on some background and we hope to do that in the next month of october and into november because we will have a steady stream of classes coming and which is also good news. Earlier this week on september 26 we welcome 52 height paramedic that the per diem tier which group to be very helpful during super bowl week. We were able to augment our current staff with these parttime htwo sorry, height paramedic could we currently have 50 in this wag to that group of professionals. Im my understanding is to weeks of didactic training and then the week of october 8 there will be one month of what we call right up your field evaluations. So the division of training will be continued is very busy with all the work that they are doing and are doing a very good job. Regarding our 150th celebration that this continue as you know. The committee has a meeting tomorrow at 10 am. The division of training. Since the last reporting period we did talk about the unveiling of the World Trade Center piece which was on 9 11 but since that time, also during this month last weekend we had a living history day. That was a great opportunity and i know many that are gathered here volunteers could we really appreciate the volunteers that put on help us put this on. We had a press conference on friday the 23rd that president covington and commissioner cleaveland attended should follow by two wonderful days bite fishermans work. The weather really cooperated. For me was actually a look at one or then i usually like but it was a wonderful time we had the permits represented from all over the state of california including jeff just south of the border but we had san diegos Fire Department here with an antique apparatus. We have steam engines and steam pumpers that were in the horsedrawn apparatus as well as a whole host of entries in the parade. The want to acknowledge all of you the measures for attending with us being in the reviewing stand to really take pride in our department the history and tradition the, robbery that exist in the fire service. It was a day i think that anyone went out there wouldnt be an active member or retired member resident of the city were visited the city anyone that came upon this and attended left with a great feeling and was really well done. Lots of hard work. Guardians of the city odyssey are to be commended. My previous when i previous deputy chiefs, whichwas chairs of the weekend. We had james lee president of the guardians of the city, dave everly bill koenig from guardians of the city. My staff including mindy talmadgecallie off, all of them put a lot l into it making a successful weekend. Larry yup and lieut. Mike day also very very helpful and so it was a prideful weekend. It was something that we were all proud of and appreciate your support and your interest as well. Moving forward, on the one 50th activities, we have a few months left but we still have a lot to do and to participate in and to celebrate. Fire prevention week will be october 915th. On the final data will be a drill at Marina Middle School beginning at registration i think is at 8 30 am. The duo goes from nine3 pm. And we have an open house at every price ration on the 15th in the afternoon i believe from one3 pm. All stations will have a large banner out in front all week where we will accommodate anyone that comes into we are Fire Prevention materials. We have plastic helmets for the kids so we want to welcome the public as we always do but particularly this week to provide the with information on how to be better prepared for any emergency. Conduct over 17th at 10 30 am will be officially commissioning a new fire boat and unveiling the name of that date. The Name Selection took place last week on the 21st. The was a committee comprised of myself resident of the Fire Commission francie Covington James lee from guardians of the city are cheaper protocol Charlotte Schulz and four members that work at station 35. One of our pilots one of our marine engineers and the two captains. So we want to make sure we were well presented. We have over 330 names submitted by schoolchildren and we narrowed it down to about 10 and then we discussed about four in the meeting and finally we arrived at the name. It will be unveiling on the 17th and the student that suggested the name we will invite that students and family to participate in the commissioning. So that will be at 10 30 am. Will do ibid. The petticoat. The giants have been great. The other partner that i shouldve mentioned not just for the commissioning but for the history date belt port has been incredible partner to accommodate all the asked for. For the weekend. And they have just been wonderful to work with. I have very good working relationship with former port director Monique Moyer and i praise it relationship continues with our own director you mean forbes. I also note our sponsors that day. It was a reception after going back to the living history day, the credit union provided support and really, for the parade itself and for the cost and the stands to be installed and so forth, are two major sponsors for that event were the civic gas electric and aim are our private partners that help provide free hospital care in the city. Then moving onto another event in november, we have our present of the bar commissioners sharing and organizing this event. The via wonderful event, freak at the main lobby to our Film Festival we be held saturday november 5 and sunday, november 6. We are blue looking forward to that. We something for everyone of all ages. And we are working with local 798 specifically executive board member adam wood on helping sponsor with some of the funds that we raised. The showing of the documentary on the garland fire that took place years ago and so we have decided to support them to underwrite that event and doing so with some of the funds we raised for the 50th and i believe that rochelle in them mission disappeared will get an update from firefighter would that tomorrows one 50th meeting. Then finally, l ration on the actual 150th anniversary of the department on december 3. We plan to have Something Special for everyone thats working that day. All of our stations in the city all 44 stations in the city the three stations at the airport and we will do something on the friday for all of our office Staff Headquarters staff and staff that worked mondayfriday. Then followed by an evening for those that wish to come and are off duty, and event salvatori event december 3 at the zoo. San francisco zoo. Well provide more details on that as they arrive. Regarding Strategic Planning, the committee met last wednesday on the 21st. I know commissioner hardeman we appreciate you been there and vp cleaveland thank you in the Committee View the latest ipo that apartments Strategic Plan. We are getting closer taken a while but we want to get it right. Feedback and input was given at the meeting as part of the overall discussion of the plan. Our goal that we said at that meeting is that we asked Committee Members to review and submit further feedback. Was a lot of feedback shared at the meeting. Any comments they had by friday, october 7. So the end of next week. With the plan being that we will then bring all those comments and come up with a draft that we would be present into the Fire Commission. We will give you a copy ahead of time and at your discretion and at your call, to have a discussion item on an upcoming agenda for the Fire Commission meeting. Which realistically come i think as early would be the october 26 meeting but possibly the november meeting would be more realistic to be able to present to you. Then i just want to let you know, since the 14th some of the activities that my office and ive been involved in person. We met on monday as part of our Monthly Labor management meeting. We met with folks 798 to discuss events, issues, and so that occurred this week. An ongoing effort to reacout to the employee groups i think i mentioned before that in august i sent an email. We try and do this at least three times a year we sent an email to all the employee groups. Some have gone back and some have not. Probably almost at least 50 maybe 60 we met with over the last six weeks and on tuesday seems like it was longer ago but since yesterday we met with United Fire Service Women to discuss they come up with an agenda and its kind of a q a and sharing of information. So that went very well. I participated in the ugly bits quarterly the dem department of Emergency Management has a Disaster Council meeting why was there yesterday representing the department. The type of the week and upcoming activities and whats been achieved this year to date. Just also want to let you know on friday at and asked to participate in a citywide Strategic Planning retreat with some of my colleagues of the Department Heads. Its going to be hosted by the port and location wise and its put on by the mayors Budget Office can all be able to bring back some information on that at the next meeting. I provided each of you a extensive list of whats happening for fleet week which is october 3ninth before our next Commission Meeting. Will be happy to answer the question might have. Its a lengthy schedule. Theres a lot going on. And many of our members including myself will be participating in a number of the activities. I know im going to be going at least two mornings to Senior Leader seminars which were going interacting with members of the military for more training. Retraining taken place over the division of training to partner the military and civilian uniform members to discuss what working well it would be like working together in the event of a largescale emergency unit we were to need military assistance. And on october 9, there will be another parade. Italian heritage parade that will be held down in north beach. The other thing i want to mention, i had the opportunity to go to the Harvey Milk Recreation Center which is at across from davis metro was under on scott and a bolus. Theres an exhibit there. Its called the art of five. Fighting the beast. There photographs of San Francisco firefighters at work it it spectacular. Its on i went to the opening reception on saturday evening at number 17. It goes on until october 16. Ive more information on that but the exhibit is for about a month and is comprised of photographs of sf firefighters engaging the biscuit is a collaborative exhibition featuring work from photographers who captured images that put the viewer on the fire hose alongside firefighters in the fight to save lives and property. There are many different photographers works that are displayed. Some of our own members mission bay fires displayed and retired member duane newton it was his doctor but all this together and its very impressive. It cosponsored by San Francisco park and rec. Certainly our department local 798 San Francisco firefighters Cancer Prevention foundation. San Francisco Chronicle and its a free exhibit. So i would encourage any of you to take that in over the course at least until october 16. That concludes my report. Thank you chief hayeswhite could any member of the public that like to comment on the cheese report . Okay. My name is sylvia johnson. My comments[inaudible] a report on monday and i was [inaudible] i wasnt really alive so somebody took a shotgun to my temple and thats pretty serious when its in your temple area. But i would have been there [inaudible] on that success but because of that medical issue i had a lot more easier because i think it had a lot to do with the Climate Control. Because i was get hit with a Climate Controlled when the climate does. [inaudible]. Also i want to tell you that thats one of the reasons why i have been missing a lot of the events [inaudible] going on that ive been [inaudible] its very hard with medical issues. With medical advisors and i was standing in there because of my sadness that i have been going through. Its been putting me to a point where i was not able to make the class. But i am trying to still proceed and making the class. Really id rather go to santa monica and push with [inaudible] to make all these issues we have. I have been trying to get my birth certificate on this issue. And its been like [inaudible]. They said that the Police Department when i didnt talk to them that theres one here that i had no idea about that. I think [inaudible] it was one of the things in my past history that needs to be addressed and i do apologize for all these missing because of his illness but i dont think i will have too much of Climate Control [inaudible] stars and the moons. Thank you. Is there any other member of the public that would like to speak at this time . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Welcome chief williams for the Administration Report. Thank you president covington. Good evening president covington and fellow commissioners, chief. Gevity chief of administration Ramona Williams with my report for the month of september 2016. Starting with the assignment office, they have recently completed the vacancy for the members in the field. This report should be distributed the first week of october. There presently preparing the vacancy list for the airport division. Under Homeland Security, as the chief mentioned, theres various activities that are in the works for the upcoming fleet week either and. Chief francisco continues to attend various meetings and training exercises and continues to disseminate Situational Awareness information regarding various tactics which include heightened threat reports against civilians and First Responders. The prizes the command staff and units in the field of potential or real terrorist activities. Chief franciscos as mentioned is planning for the fleet we activity which includes very various training activities and demonstrations such as training k9 demonstration airshows to name a few. The department ms. Williams excuse me, for the micro little closer. Is that better . Yes that atomic continues to learn as much as we can from the recent terrorist incidents and say ever vigilant. During my reporting id like to continue to remind the public that if you see something to say something. Under Investigative Services bureau, the bureau continues to conduct random accident and fire boat drug and Alcohol Testing for the reporting period and i was happy to report that all results have been negative during this reporting period. They also continue to conduct candidate background checks are upcoming academies. Under the departments positions office they also continue to administer candidate promotional probationary physicals for the department as well as return to work and work related injury exams. The Physicians Office reports 28 work related injuries for the month of august up from 26 drained the previous month reporting period. Under support services, construction at pump station one which is located fire headquarters is moving along. They have opened up the fire headquarters lobby this week. As is essential portion has been completed with full completion estimated at the end of october. At this time all projects are continuing to move forward and on track. Station five construction has been pushed back to march of 2017 due to renegotiating the contract between the general manager, general contractor, and the subcontractor. As you have been reported earlier, it is scheduled set station five spindle talk station 238 and division ii station 38. Members of station 16 are scheduled to move out during the first week of october and again, the move out is as follows engine 16 two station 52, and truck 16 to station 10. Chief lombardi will give a conference of report on the work currently in progress with the court on peer 26 relocation of the fire to both during construction as well as with station 35 and that progress. The project should be completed by the end of november. During this reporting period, there were 131 request for Services Received and processed for the month of august. In as previously mentioned our new fire boat has been delivered and we are looking for to the commissioning ceremony which will take place as the chief mentioned, monday, october 17 at the c cold. Under fleet management, all bids have been awarded and apparatus are on order or have been delivered. One apparatus is currently awaiting moving to the field with their hose tender 18 which is very close to being put in Service Following the arrival of [inaudible] which were waiting for eight. Under division of training, under ems during this reporting period, weve had to suspend active Shooter Training temporarily due to our paramedic and emt training requirements. The active Shooter Training will resume on october 10 and so far weve trained over excuse me for 75 members of the department and were looking to administer this training to all members of the department. During this break in training, we have administered the pat assessment for station 49 hthree paramedic members and these members are those that are interested in being considered for placement in the htwo academy. Currently, the 61 the list. 45 passed during the recent testing and to be considered members must pass the pat. They must complete a task book and anticipate or excuse me attend a oneday training. Under fire reserve, the members attended the following events during this reporting period. The commotion he street there the volunteer day, which was the 75th anniversary of the fire of valerie reserve. And theyll also assistedorganizing donation. They also attend weekly training at the division of training at the fulsome and Treasure Island campuses and during this reporting period a have trained in various battalion drills scenarios. Under inservice training, we have continued to construct the props for the upcoming transit training module as well as continue Field Training that operations with positive results from the field. As a chief mentioned, we have an upcoming drill on october 15 at 9 am at Marina Middle School with registration at 8 30 am. Under nurse they continue to hold various meetings conduct various outreach presentations and provide valuable neighborhood in advance training throughout the city. Under the group training, as chief mentioned, there are 52 members of the h a Classroom Academy began this week. Consists of two weeks of classroom training followed by the field preceptor evaluation. The chief mentioned this is the 15th week of the 108th123 two academy and theyve completed their engine block as was their talk block and they have just completed their Hazardous Material training while im training and firefighter survival training. They be given their final examination during the first week of october. We anticipate a full competent of 52 on the graduation date on november 4. That concludes my report. I am happy to answer any questions. Thank you chief ones that i think at this time we will go to the commissioners in case they have questions for our chief of the department and for chief williams. Ill begin with the Vice President than cleveland thank you mdm. Pres. And thank you, cheaper your conference of report as always and at a couple questioning first off i want to also echo what you said in terms of the last weekend in celebration about 1 50 anniversary of very proud event for all of us and it was a really a very moving thing to see so many of our retirees come out and have so many of the other five the permits around the state bring their apparatus down and their historic fire engines and fire trucks and horsedrawn apparatuses so that we can all enjoy them. It was a really wonderful thing and id like to again thank the guardians of the city garbagejames galindo Port Authority building forms were allowed us to make that and for helping us create such a wonderful evening could id like to also thank pg e and amr for their financial contribution because without that we would not have been able to sponsor as many things as we did. So that was a great event for everyone and im just hopeful that many of our citizens enjoyed it and many of our taurus enjoyed as well. Really find a fair getaway think all the volunteers that are here present as well as watching who helped make that date, that we can i should say, a success. So they do for taking the time to show off our 150s years of proud history of the San Francisco Fire Department. I would like toim impressed by the 330 names that were offered up by where they middle School Children . I think was k8 k8, okay. For the fire boat. Probably you get a number of good names that we can use for future fireballs, right . [laughing] yes i know my fellow commissioner sent hardeman would like to see more fireballs and so what i. I want to ask you about your trip where i guess youre Planning Session with some of the other Department Heads good i hope that you will talk to them a little bit about the cities general vehicle replacement budget item which for years was so pitiful. For the entire city that needs to be looked at and we are very pleased that the mayor and the budget folks have given us additional funding for our equipment needs in the Fire Department had some serious equipment needs and we have a program now to replace the fire engines and apparatus and keep our fleet as modern as it can be. We are privileged to have that. But i think a discussion with the other city Department Heads about what the other City Departments are having a robust replacement budget as they need so that we can modernize all of our City Departments. We need to do that. We need to budget for it. I dont think we been doing enough to do that. Weve not been budgeting on up your so bring that up in your conversations with fellow Department Heads. The art of the fire exhibit being held at the harvey milk academies the Recreation Center right. Is that something we could have brought here and put on as part of an agenda item for the future Commission Meeting . I mean i think its something that would be of interest to not only everyone here, but everyone watching it if that were portable at some point in some way. I dont know. Is that something we can check out . You can certainly check it out. They are framed photographs. So i dont know they would have to take obviously some sort of picture of all the pictures and then i can pass that along to the organizers spews i think would be dumping worthwhile and useful throughout the city were not possibly able to make it to the exhibit itself. I mean if its worthy its worthy of preserving. We can preserve it on film and bring it to the commission i think would be great. Theyll also be something to use in our on permanent display at our Fire Department history museum. So its all good. Chief williams, you mentioned we had 28 workrelated injuries this past month. Were any of them serious . From my reporting they were maybe some havent placed on disability as a result of them. Yes. Longterm other hopefully not . Hopefully, not all right. I guess you do an investigation of each of these injuries to see what the cause was and how we can improve in the future, etc. Etc. Yes, theres always that. Their investigation based on the reporting documents that are been submitted with the regarding the employees and elicit any safeguards that were in place and any precautions that they can take in the future to prevent that from reoccurring. Im just concerned of course about liability and that kind of thing. I want to make sure that not only are they taken care of but the reasons for those accidents are investigated thoroughly and we know how to prevent them in the future. Most of them are human error i am sure but were all human and we all err keep that to a minimum, that would be good. Station 16 you said was moving out next month. Do we have an idea on when the demolition as can happen on that station . Theyre moving out next week actually and i believe demolition will start the following week. Hooray. Thats going to be a great new station and im real pleased to hear that. You talked about the active Shooter Training that been suspended until next month. Where do we do the active Shooter Training for the Fire Department . The was that is actually held on your book wayne island near the library. B was okay excuse me its been moved to the Treasure Island system. We risen plan to have it at the naval library with an associate with the Police Department involvement but since we have not had that involvement as yet we are currently holding it on our training facility. On Treasure Island the rock library objectives . Last question. The street there is this coming sunday. Are we can have agreement is the Fire Department can have a recruitment both their . Was definitely good. Thats all my question thank you vp cleaveland could commissioner nakajo good evening chief dwight chief williams good im in a differentiate the questions because a couple of these questions are questions that i was and ask both of you but ill ask you, chief williams good in the report of hh hires in terms of [inaudible] you were talking about there might be a 100 members of height corrected i believe we have about 50 at this point so it would add to that number. So just for my information and the colleagues on the commission, what kind of a Employment Status are they . Are they a temp . Is there a Civil Service number or how do we hire these height and what rain do they have . Rank name status, employment identification and if theyre on board with us and we liberalize them tomorrow i know we utilize them because chief gonzales has reported that could do they wear uniforms etc. . He was sure. During a height expedition to there are represent a local 798. Basically most of them not all of them have other employment elsewhere. Theyre all state licensed as paramedics. They do where sort of a hybrid uniform. They do not wear badges. But they work alongside an ambulance with a sworn member of the department. We have with some of the height hired firstround and actually brought them into the department is fulltime employees. Okay thank you for that. Do you want to add anything chief gonzales because otherwise i have the answer to my questions he was the chief handled it very deftly good answer thank you very much. So when hundred members is quite a bit. Yes if i went on the scene i guess i would be able to identify these height and it would be with the ambulance yes. Theyre actively working on the emirates group. Ambulance crew. I dont know if we have ever two or height working together but generally the working with another fulltime member of the department. Is that height paramedics he was correct. The classification itself does allow for flexibility to either emts down the road but we have chosen to hire all paramedics at this time. So there are paramedics there not emts . That a higher level of training. Theyre able to utilize their advanced life support skills. Versus basic life skills. I was asked a little bit more. Chief myers, t want to chime in on the information on this particular discussion . The only comment i was going to make about two height working together. Davis set agenda as far as training both in the academy and postacademy. They have 240 hours of precepts service and by another member field a valuate her and her preceptor at station 49 and a task book that has to be completed before they can work with any member of 49 including another height please identify yourselves he was jeff myers ems chief so chief so i am clear in my mind, these height they can ride ambulances only if they clear the qualifications that you just cited. Theres not ever dispatched to height on any indolence . Is use the height are qualified not only a state that county accredited. The vent through the Department Training program along with field evaluation which qualifies them toward their county accreditation to work in San Francisco. Generally the parents are one regular member and 1height paramedic it within completed the after education at Treasure Island training which is the 240 hours of presented work with another member the station 49, and theyve had their height task work signed off, then they are considered what we consider a super height and they can work with paramedic and the emt from 49 or another height because they met all the qualifications to be considered basically a regular member is our service capability. This gives us the greatest flexibility in staffing down the road. I believe that she does write. We have fit for a 650 currently in service and seated 54 in training started on monday. Okay. Again, its part of the experience of this commission and this department is that we can be introduced to conceptuals terms of programs h eight was a conception that got defined clearly in terms of personnel. The [inaudible] all along several questions in terms of that here i think over time the question was if the height vehicle entry is a possibility within the department. For me, it clearly is. If your field of choices paramedic or that particular level, thats why i asked to the differentiation between the emt and paramedic and the other thing that i hear is that if everything goes right and theyve feel for phil all the requirements, is a super height they could be basically a member of the department if budget allows and of entry allows. Can ive some interpretation on that . The super height allows him to work with any member of station 49 as a per diem employee. The ability to become permanent were moved to a level i entry position is at the discretion the appointing officer and the chief. Weve done at one time prior but that is a budgetary and decision for the chief of department. If i could add, there are people that want this to be in sort of a way to consider entry into that apartment. But there are also a number of height that are very satisfied with her other employment could we have firefighters are working other jurisdictions that because of the schedule are able to pick up another shifter to work as paramedics. Thats worked very well. Many of them dont envision necessarily entering into the our department on a fulltime basis could so theres a blend i would say either that of that h eight. I truly appreciate the candid answer because when hundred members is quite a bit. I know we are utilizing them. I know that is really important that they havent entry level but i need to be reminded that some of them take it as a optional career addition could i just want to be clear in that because again when the Paramedic Division station 49 first came on board, same question i asked if they have a uniform do they have a patch and we do not want to devote to different kinds of cultures and h [inaudible] ive one more question in order to be a h evans read yesterday and h 2b was the physical agility test is for htwo for the candidacy of the h2 academy. So we know we take normally approximately 12 members from station 49 and we found that by giving them the free testing training orientation on the equipment and the recruits Academy Exposure by giving them that preview of it the better prepare them to successfully complete the academy. Make sense. A question on the fire boat on october 17. We will have the identification of the new fire boat at some point i assume theres an integration of usage about that new boat is going to be rotated within or fleet usage or boat usage . Corrected our goal is to always have two in the water. We do have a third boat now. Right now theres two in the water one is been dry dock. So there will be a priority order if you will and then a rotation. If needed. Depending on the drydock schedule and at this time since the boat did arrive late july, numbers are still getting orientated to it and sober. So we feel that we will be able to definitely put it underway once its officially commission. Under regular basis. Chief, does that mean theres a crew thats already designated on a boat new boat . Yes. Not an additional crew. We want crew in the event we need to watch the second boat we would call in an additional computer theres one crew and its a split crew so we have an officer of the fire boat in conjunction with the Marine Engineering pilot and were an officer engine 35 the landbased units. The crew the other three members go back and forth. So if the fire boat does get a call in is underway, engine 35 in effect goes out of service because they dont have the staffing. So they work in tandem. Okay. Thank you. Chief williams, at some point i know when you talked about station five being delayed theres going to be some transfers of engines and trucks. I cannot catch all of that. Is there some point in way that you might be able to get that information to us . Im sorry commission or a transcript is first legal relocation . Right. I was trying to write it down some turks are going to 38. Some division ii is going i can give you that information please if you could speak slower engine five is going to station six. Truck five will be going to station 38. As well as division ii. There will also move over 238. Okay per engine 16, there will be going to station 51 and trucks 16, will be going to station 10. And is that all occur within the next within the first week of october the crew from station and 16 will relocate out of the station 16 okay. Two other comments and then i will complete. I also wanted to the mark chief hayeswhite] schedule of the fleet week schedule of events, i ran out of paper. Talk about impressive. The logistical. Im again want to talk about it again be part of the San Francisco oc the blue angels and fleet week but this is a tremendous event in a really glad that we did department and yourself participating within this as well. Whoevers in the audience i know that we participate with that. The other mark was i believe you said that our plan will be presented somewhere around november. Commissioner mean im looking for to that i think is a lot of work with this whenever we can calendar mdm. Pres. Other than that the client question left was i also want to acknowledge the 150th parade this last weekend, saturdaysun. They give vp cleaveland for the knowledge meant. Pg e and did you say [inaudible] the Ambulance Services sponsors as well . Yes i just want to thank all the volunteers that participated when the audience to make that a great thing. Thats all i have matter present. Thank you thank you mission or nakajo commissioner hardeman be thanks matter present. Other stuff like around trying to figure out where to start. I do not think i was not any questions or anything to say until everything comes out. The chief talked about this Strategic Planning committee. So i think shes very generous in saying that we are still workingits come down to wordsmithing where everybodys interpretation of words which is i think the chief and everybody else handles this all very well but its there. Just a matter of how people interpret sentences and words otherwise its very good. I think its really terrific job. Everybody did a good job on that. The 1 50 which is great appreciated to participate in having a little shade and i dont number ever having shade in any event port. That was really nice. Even though they had to move this awful little good they were getting crowded on the stage there. Was nice to see all the command staff could also there. All the horse drawn engines and equipment was great. Going back somebody is good the volunteers. Everything was wonderful. Was nice to enjoy it so i appreciate very much all the effort everyone wants. Very good job including you president covington which was chairing the Cook Committee for the commission. Really good. Its nice to see all these new ambulances going around town. Then to see more efficient. I will also would we were at the 150th capt. Mcdowell made a wonderful presentation to us on volunteers since the inception of the Fire Department, he asked commissioner covington and i would be a briefing on the entire heart among the skies like a dynamo. He must have that information to. I told him we probably would but something he should run by the chief and see if you can spare 15 min. It somewhere if he was willing to do because the presentation was just fantastic westmont. As a matteroffact, the other night its five after 12 am channel surfing baby was five afteri stay up late. This Commission Meeting came on and a made sure that i kept listening until he does report again. It was just fantastic. Very good. It was nice to see how the volunteers and incorporated not a lot of history of the Fire Department but i think of you would be willing to do history of the active Fire Department, not just the volunteer that would be fantastic. The naming of the fire boat, commissioner cleaveland is right. Thats what my theory thinking about boat not good i like boats. Those on the Port Commission always try to support the fire posted like that you said we need to fire boats at all times and thats not even a question good so we have this new fire both quite often we have one in for extensive drydock and only have one. Theres not extra fire boats floating around the bay area so emergency happens. Im real happy that were going to be dedicating that fire boat in the 17th. Thats terrific. The first couple fire boats again dennis open [inaudible] and the frank g white and ive a hunch this wont be named after a former chief but you never know. They were former chief. So that was interesting how they chose to do that. I guess i will stop there. Very good report chief williams. Thank you report chief. Its always good. Nice disease graduates and lets hope we can get to 52 for the november 4 graduation. Good job. Thank you thank you commissioner cleaveland. The living history days. This past weekend. They were fabulous, fabulous, fabulous. Usually when you hear the phrase, a living history its a bunch of very elegant people Walking Around in period dress. Here the nurses were dressed all. As were the people and it was wonderful to see particularly the the three steam engines. Im going to call out chief francisco. Chief francisco was so enthusiastic. I was already enthusiastic it but he was beyond enthusiastic so some of his enthusiasm rubs off on. This is probably the last time were ever going to see three steam engines together in one place. I was like, okay. [laughing] it was a wonderful time and i want to thank all of the volunteers. There was a legion of volunteers, 120 volunteers for that day. Many of them are in this room. The jiggly, i want to shout out to the google scooper squad. Because when you have horses you need someone there. Or elephant you need someone there and these guys were very very very meticulous in their work and they were very gracious in their work. So people coming from all over the state, its really quite an undertaking for people to travel with her horses and with this antique apparatus in mint condition looking sparkly and shiny and just gorgeous. Gorgeous. People being very proud of the history of the fire service in general and particularly here in california. So having that brotherhood and sisterhood is very very warning to the hearts. So i want chief, i want you to talk just a little bit about the grand marshal. And the other young lady. Certainly. So we did select mr. Al waite was a retired italian chief. As our grand marshal and he served in the department from 19541983. We believed but not seen an email apparently any milk came in that there someone that is older than mr. H was in the permit i have to figure that one out. That just came out today but however we believe that is the oldest living member of San Francisco Fire Departments. Still resides here in the city. He was thrilled to be selected as a grand marshal. Our idea was to pair him up on friday the day before that festival began with the youngest number of our department was hired in january of this. Her name is amanda conley. She is 21 and he is 97. I the opportunity last tuesday afternoon to visit al at his home up in the twin peaks area and was very gracious welcoming to his entire family was there. We spent some time going over some of his memorabilia, his captains jacket that still fit in which he purchased in the 60s. So we were happy to have him with us at the press conference and then he spent a good 45 hours that day in the heat enjoying the parade and the festivities. So we were delighted to have him as our grand marshal for the parade. Thank you. He was a great choice. A great choice. The pairing of the youngest and the oldest was a master stroke of very very good. Also, just Walking Around fishermans wharf, i think the location was ideal because we had a lot of outoftowners and we also had a lot of san franciscans. It was a wonderful mix of people and before i go too far afield 012 really make sure that people understand this was not an intimate gathering of people. This was thousands of people who came and enjoyed the day. The fire reserves that we had on the turnout coats and their taking pictures with little kids and so many people had on little plastic fire helmets. I imagine that those members of the reserves are going to be you know, on refrigerator is all over the country with those wonderful wonderful photos. So, thank you all to everyone who participated in making this such a wonderful occasion. Now i also want to just shift in gears here, chief,excuse methe Strategic Plan. Youre thinking you be ready for our october 26 meeting . I said thats a possibility i could check in with that. I think to allow just slightly more time weve asked for feedback by october 7. We will synthesize good i know we only have one meeting i believe in november. I think that might work better to present it as a discussion item. On your agenda for the november meeting. All right. I think we can have it for the 26 that would be great. As a result of us canceling a meeting in november in a meeting in december because we are backed up against the National Holidays i think that our agendas for the remaining two meetings might be quite lengthy. So whatever we can put on the agenda for the 26 would be good if its at all possible okay. Certainly, i think it would be best to provide the document to you well in advance state we can advance in a meeting. Let me check in with mr. Corso and his staff and see what can be possible. Thank you. I encourage my fellow commissioners to look at the document and give candid feedback and if theres anything that you feel is on this were absent please do bring it up when we go to public discussion about it. So that we can help inform the process. The was president it covington if i could add commissioner ken hartman has been with us at several of the meetings and has participated actively in, say vp cleaveland we both smirked when you give recent give feedback and lots of it and he certainly did at the meeting. E had pretty much line by line with some of his comments. I would agree with commissioner hardeman that substantively its there but its more sort of the word choice and so forth an order of the document but we are very close to it its a lot of hard work from the committee so we will be very proudwe took your feedback as well to provide greater detail in some of the places so that we are not just our audience is not just our members but its the public at large nets very good feedback we took into consideration. As well that you gave us. Thank you. Regarding your Administration Report chief williams, you said the weather 131 request for service. Can you tell us the nature of these requests for service . Typically in the field you have an opportunity to report to any repair that you may have in your station and you submit it to our online reporting system hr ms, and it goes straight to support services. They can send out the proper way sources to mitigate or repair any damages that may incur in the station. So thats how many we received. I do not get provided with the specifics. Okay. I dont think i need that level of detail. I was just wondering what branch of the service were speaking of support services thank you. The active Shooter Training. How long is that training . Thats a day long. Although the training. Members are detailed over to the training facility. They are to bring their own lunch. The training is eight hours. Okay. So you said approximately a third of the department has gone through it . Yes over 400 members of gone through it and we anticipate another thousand numbers and we will complete it. We want civilian as well as uniform numbers to go through this training. When do you think the entire force will have been trained . According to chief hopefully by the middle of next year. Okay so its a lengthy process yes. Thats barring any distractions or delays in the training. Okay well thank you very much for your report. Chief, thank you for your report as well. Next item please is there additional Public Comment on what would just be the Administration Report. We arent all the common on the cheapo Department Report already seeing none, the comment. We will go to the next item item 5, discussion on civil grand jury viewports. Discussion pertaining to the Fire Commissions amended response to the civil grand jury report fire safety inspections in San Francisco a tale of two departments. Department of Building Inspections and San Francisco Fire Department. Thank you. Ms. Johnson, okay ms. Johnson im sorry. We are starting on another item you are you going to speak about the grand jury report . Okay then please come forward. My name is sylvia johnson. Ive been talking to the City Attorney and [inaudible] secretary about some of these Court Hearing sessions with a civil grand jury and this is one of the grand jurys that i was [inaudible] intended to because most likely my phone did not coordinate with me right. I thought the number was [inaudible]. Im trying to discover a phone that will be more wracked on these issues. Because this is the way the grand jury has been to explain [inaudible] and associated with [inaudible]. Org and i have with Railroad Construction [inaudible] not olden times but [inaudible] the tracking licenses that are [inaudible] here in the city for our safety and some of the areas that we have a driving situation [inaudible] is more like a [inaudible] driving and i dont think [inaudible] categories need to be put on our driving [inaudible]. Ill probably said to [inaudible] it might improve the backwards way. Its not short really. [inaudible] thank you. Is there any other member of the public that would like to comment on the San Francisco Fire Commission response to the grand jury report . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. By fellow commissioners, do you have comments regarding this matter . Were questions doing commissioner cleaveland thank you. We have put together a response to the grand jury in their request that we work more closely with the dbi with the department of building inspection. We have a couple of very good suggestions for doing so and i think i am ready certainly as one commissioner here, to adopt our response and officially present it. But im asking you i guess is that the right process . What is the process for adopting our response . Thank you. As president i was responsible for getting the response to the grand jury by the deadline which is passed. So for transparency purposes, i want to make sure that our Commission Secretary would be to our response into the official record. So thats why we are here. So its a discussion no action necessary . No action necessary at this time. Do want to read the findings and recommendations . Lets see. Yes, unless there is another commissioner that has something to say at this time . [inaudible] thank you in mdm. Clerk please read this into the record the grand jurys findings were dbi and sf as of date inspector multiunit residential buildings for many of the same fire safety hazards but do not coordinate of the any effort of their inspections were Code Enforcement efforts including not sharing information. The Fire Commission responded that the partially agree with the findings in the explanation was sf fd is always open and willing to foster improved interdepartmental engagement and cooperation. The particular case of dbi and sf fd one mistake into consideration the very different Business Models of dbi and sf fd. Dbi has staffing dedicated to residential two inspections was sf fd bar suspension and subcommittees are first and foremost tasked with First Responder duties. As of ft inspections of all residentialdo occupancies is both an art of responsibility that must be timed in a manner so as not to Compromise Health and safety emergency. In spite of different different Business Models per above, there are key ways to enhance and drive greater collaboration. Number one, establish a perpetual working committee that meets with regular candidates and seeks to evaluate the housing code and fire code in parallel identify where there is a lack of overlap and develop a referral process to support these areas in a proactive and transparent manner. Number two, implement a 21stcentury close loop Digital Solution that enables dbi and sf fd to seamlessly share data across departments and provide Online Access to interdepartmental referral tracking and reporting. The civil grand jurys recommendation was that the Building Inspection Commission and Fire Commission should require a task force be formed to study dbi and sf fd inspection and Code Enforcement processes and make recommendations on how they can coordinate their efforts. The Fire Commission responded the recommendation has not been but will be implemented in the near future. The Fire Commission will work with dbi with the dbi commission to implement a task force. The goal is to have a task force in place by february 2017. Take you very much. Mdm. Clerk i like to think fire marshal danfour providing the necessary framework for the response. Thank you chief because you. Next item, please im sorry commissioner shannon nakajo is a common this is on the response of the grand jury report. I also want to concur the support of the commission to this resolution. Theres been a lot of work involved with this. I also want to acknowledge our fire marshals in this. The spirit is to work collaboratively with the department but also i dont want to reinvent wheels. I know we dont have that relationship now but i certainly would like to take the lead from the Chiefs Office and the fire marshal as how we best try to form formalize that because its just easier said than done to create another committee and we could good spirits and intentions but we the commission we have a lot of work with what we need to do as well. I just want to publicly acknowledge that we are going to back up our offers of relationship and meeting together. I just wanted knowledge that and acknowledge the department that we did respond a little late but we did respond in a timely manner should [inaudible] thank you commissioner nakajo. We can call the next item, please item 6, resolution 201608 discussion and possible action to approve resolution 201608 recommending that the board of supervisors authorize the San Francisco Fire Department to accept and expend a safer grant from the mud in the amount of 8,533,008 or 72 for the hiring of 36 new firefighters. Thank you. Welcome to good evening matter president and members of the commitment mark or so finance and planning here to present on the next item which were thereupon is very pleased to present on. Its a fiscal year 15 staffing for adequate fire and Emergency Response for safer grant award from fema in amount of 8,533,000. That covers the salary and benefits of 36 new hires for two years. This is actually the second Consecutive Year the department was allocated funding in this grant program. The planning from the fiscal year 14 grant is currently funding the salary and benefits of 36 numbers from the weasley graduated 119th academy class. I graduated back in june. This will add a muchneeded academy to the permits hiring model were the next few years. This part of the Mayors Office the board of supervisors and the Fire Commission department will now be conducting five htwo academies with this fiscal year and eight academies with the next four years. These governments will help offset pending retirements and supplement current staffing for the department. Theres no matching requirement for the city or their apartment and happy to answer any questions that you may have. Thank you mr. Corso. Is there any Public Comment specifically regarding this resolution to authorize these monies by the board of supervisors . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. I will go to my fellow commissioners for their comments and suggestions. Beginning with commissioner nakajo b was thank you director corso. Thank you director course. This is good news. Im here to support this. Again for clarification of this runs having similarly gave this information the last Commission Meeting is a twoyear fiscal cycle mr. Corso . Correct. The twoyear period. Yes. Is that 2016 throughwhat is it . He was technically the performance period begins in february in general while the department was awarded in august, fema generally gives you a period of time costly 180 days to ramp up if youre starting in hiring from scratch it obviously where the eligibility process for that and a list. If you dont they allow for the claimant ramp up at center. So this is only projected to start in separate. The grand period it can be moved up were able to higher in advance of that. Which looks like we will so will be working with fema on that will be a twoyear grant performance period director corso, do you say this would be somewhere around 2017 . Is that what you said . Thats currently without terms of the grant performance state. I believe or look at chief mention a believe the last academy will look at november is the timeframe for the next academy and be working with fema and the approval process essentially to select 36 of those bombers to be part of this grant reported as no matching requirements for this department correct last time i asked the question after two years in roles into our budget request, into our budget operations . Correct. After the twoyear performance period was 36 members will be absorbed into the budget overall budget and will have [inaudible] part of that dedication of Revenue Source for negotiation continue with the Mayors Office . Absolute. This ongoing discussion we have got to Staffing Levels and impact of retirements and new hires that we have in the department this is great news. Thank you director corso. Thank you. Commissioner cleaveland excuse me permission or hardeman i did real quick. Real quick, mdm. Chairman, thank you again mr. Corso. I see why you have received your promotion earlier this year. This would that you do not know this was coming and this is [inaudible] the best about this is it shows the system doesnt work against good citizens that dont lay off their Fire Department employees. San francisco do not lay off any employees even though shorthanded working overtime and other Fire Departments were receiving state programs lay off employees, a couple years later its the same program because you get off your employees. So we were just as deserving this department for hanging in there and to see that two years in a row that the folks that work passing out these safer grants realize you cant penalize the city for doing their duty and to me, this is just shows the systems working and its great that you continued and the department continued to persevere even though director feeling that youre been a be denied, denied but we were not for two years ago so congratulation. Great job thank you very much okay. Thank you commissioner hardeman. I also want to, lament you and say thank you for your steadfastness in this regard. Because 8 million is a nice chunk of change and we need it. So, thank you mr. Corso. Your abilities at grant writing are becoming widely known and admired. Thank you, again. Did you have a comment commissioner cleaveland. Not at this time. All right. Well, thank you on this and [crosstalking] [off mic] this a possible discussion item he was only sure adam has had a chance to speak. Before i thank you village on a motion, okay commissioner cleaveland has some move. Is there a second, please second moved and seconded. All in favor of accepting a plus Million Dollars please signify all those in favor say, aye [chorus of ayes] thats allowed aye. Next item please resolution 201609 discussion and possible action regarding proposed resolution 201609 recommending that the board of supervisors authorize the San Francisco Fire Department to accept and expend Port Security Grant Funding in the amount of 60,524 from the federal Emergency Management agency to purchase a Rapid Development dock system. Mr. Corso good evening again commissioners. The next item is a quest for approval for the port this for your Port Security grants. Allocation in the amount of 60,504 for the purchase of a Rapid Deployment dock. You may recall couple Commission Meetings ago that apartment put forward for approval by the Commission Eight fiscal year 15 port said 30 grant for of the apartment. This project is in conjunction with that boat with the vessel itself. The Rapid Deployment dock for that vessel. Theres a match of approximate 20,000 that will be absorbed by the permits budget for a total overall project amount of 80,006 and are 99 happy to answer any questions for this project thank you. Is there any Public Comment regarding this particular item the 60,000 coming to the department . My name is sylvia johnson. My regarding is the equipment and stuff though we might be able to use and theres a new way [inaudible] that its put on the shipments and other processes that which the supervisors probably had put a lot of these questions put a percentage at [inaudible] because it wasnt in their [inaudible]. We probably even laughed atprobably already lived written[inaudible] they put [inaudible] everywhere and was all detected by me being there. On this [inaudible] this is what ive been thinking on the wide the [inaudible] historical that has already let some of these disadvantages we have in our congress. Process and [inaudible] that we have [inaudible] not even precise. [inaudible] in this process of making [inaudible] to be able to gain a whole lot more [inaudible]. Its about my music. Thats words been all these years. [inaudible] thank you could any other members of the public that would like to speak at this time . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. I will go to my fellow commissioners. Regarding this resolution. Vp cleaveland i make the motion that we accept this grant from fema and we appreciate it very much thank you bid is there a second . Commissioner nakajo i have a question would you like 7 seconds b was a. Be the person to second, yes i second the motion of vp cleaveland and have a question yes the clerk the patient question on director course. New a purchased the rapid dock system, i dont know what that is. To have a visual for me or description i do not have a picture for you but if using our rescue boat or i believe the police have one as well, its not a boat and vessel its okay to talk to rest at the birth at the marina and allows for Quick Deployment of the vessel its oh. We dropped into the water where crews can board and immediately respond to an incident chief hayeswhite whose that fall under operationally in terms of that instrument . Is that the boat or what is that to be under gevity chief of operations Mark Gonzales okay. Is this deployed at the airport or is that over here with us itll be deployed in this in. This is not an airport asset. Dubious City Department has been unaware of the actual final location has been determined at this point will be deployed in the city so its like a lowerlevel dock that has access for this corrected its like an inflatable dock system that allows the boat rest on men for times of employment the crews can immediately access okay thank you for the karthik is good thank you very much director or so thank you. Since this is a Port Security grant i think its wonderful for us to have these additional resources. There is a motion and a second. All those in favor say, aye. [chorus of ayes]. Thank you, all. Thank you mr. Corso. Item 8, amendments to the 26 in california fire code. Discussion and possible action to approve recommended amendment to the 26 in california fire code and recommending the board of supervisors approved amendment torn to the 2016 california fire code. Good evening commissioners did good evening, chief. I believe you have a copies of the amendment and your possession should i believe you also the copy of the legislative digest summarizes those change. The is these identified herself and e0 fire marshal. Thank you, fire marshal personal i like to adults that help persistent fire Marshal Brown or capt. Kim coghlan a deputy City Attorney janet clark for helping putting this document together. The amendment cycle with a threeyear cycle. So every three years we repeal the existing San Francisco cargo to replace with a new fire code. So come january 1 one he 17 well be repealing the 2013 San Francisco fire code and replacing it with a 2016 San Francisco fire code. The majority of the code carries over to the latest version to the 2016 however we do have some changes. The code itself is based on the model code which is the isc international barcode. It is the Building Standards Commission of sacramento adopts and publishes with california amendment july 1 i just did it this last july 1 good that becomes the california fire code that they do. Then we have the local jurisdiction 180 days to submit our amendment from the chief through this Port Commission here to the board of supervisors for approval and then onto sacramento. Our local amendment are based on three things. We have to satisfy our amendment that we can be more sick of due to climate, due to geology, or due to topography. As we all know, all three of those apply here within our jurisdiction. The density of the city topography and the age of the buildings. So keeping with that in mind, i like to do a brief summary of those changes could slightly tucked him and take some any questions you may have. Ill be reading from our legislative digest. First item there is a group radical occupancy which is education, schools. Right now, Public Schools fall under the jurisdiction of the dsa Division State architect. So they do the plan review and the construction inspections are all Public Schools. The local jurisdiction, us San Francisco, has jurisdiction over the private schools. So where there was a kind of a gap or loop oh i should say is new construction we were not always in the loop with dsa because we were not part of the review process. Now this section here were require all schools to register with our bureau before occupying after new construction has begun. We get the marlys for anyone special was also conduct our first initial life safety inspection. The next item on there is supervisor weiners ordinance bettys put forward and that has to do with art and ob process which is already underway. And it has been implemented. Our next item adds to our citation section making it 1000 fine with tempering for new Fire Protection systems. Next is our acknowledging the h42 position new position as this last year made and so giving deposition the assistant fire marshal the authority to issue citations. Next is supervisor tangs legislation regarding fire safety disclosure information. So all rtwo new tenants will be provided with fire Safety Information and annually that information will be given to all tenants regardless of not just the new tenants could someone so year and went to new tenants moving. That has to do with the basic iris ac since fire escapes, basic life safety concerns. Next item has to do with our Fire Department access. The last code had in a clear width for part of common axis. It allowed for having a sixinch curve be considered clear with it its our opinion that we dont thats not accessible to us to mount a sixinch curve to drive over sidewalk were pedestrians may be standing so we are stripping that out the old fire code. We actually consulted with state fire marshal on this as well and they were in agreement with us that they would not consider that clear with. Next item were asking for 5 foot clearance around cisterns access to the systems around fire hydrants. Right now it is three good im and 5 feet. Right now its 3 feet. We are increasing at 25 feet clearance around those hydrants and systems. Systems. Auxiliary water supply system you were putting those requirements into our fire code by now. They live under subdivision regulations and puc regulations. So we are bringing them into our fire code. Our Emergency Responder radio coverage, we are acknowledging nap 1221 as a standard for maintenance and installation. On accession standpipe was always step up the code as Jacob Belasco 2013 hose were required in all required exit stairs the new code for 2016 says all new interior stairs. So our concern was live in exterior stair thats required zero why would it not be required there. So we are still applying it to all required stairs. I just interior stairs. Then the next two items address integrity of the fire pump room in the water tanks. Basically you cannot run any utilities or anything in there does not serve the fire pump or those tanks. And has to do with f occupancies on port property. Those are manufacturing fabrication factories. Weve are going to require they be mdm. Clerk at all times regardless of the Square Footage giving a hazard on a port on piers. , or santo sliding doors. We are asking to you limit the application of this section and have it not apply to highrise buildings where those doors are installed in the means of egress. The reason for that is in a bar highrise buildings we are Holding Place with no tool full building evacuation. Usually we have for for several fire floor, too low and one of of your wheat relocatable to place and have our Fire Department operations and to be sliding door horizontally as were coming through with hose leads would make it negatively impacts operations. Just refers to class iii pipes for stages. Signage for fire escapes. Requirements for egress passages. And ill just close out here briefly with we are adopting 503 which is Fire Department access road with street measures etc. That is not adopted by the state bar marshals office. We are recommending to adopt at the local level. We also recommend to adopt appendix d section d105 two refers to arial apparatus with a width of 20 feet dependent on the height of the building etc. And appendix i which is it breaks down the Fire Protection systems noncompliant systems should basically describes when the system becomes noncompliant. What type of systems or whatit will describe all those areas where maintenance is required. Ill leave it at that. Answer any questions you may have. Thank you fire marshal. The legislative digest is very helpful. Because we have both. We have the entire sparrow and then we have the if this time if there is a member of the public that would like to excuse melike to speak on the new proposals for the fire code going to the board of supervisors, please come forward. I admonish anyone speaking to please, stick to this topic cured fire codes. Thank you. My name is sylvia johnson. The adoption of 503 and the section [inaudible] is one of fire codes that was [inaudible] for newer ways of establishing and as i was a nonsection 6 that we have different lines in that section because this is what it explains with the fire code that he just got done discussing. This is what i was talking about, the codes on the buildings again, there we have our answers that we need to be investigating because this is really our economic way of [inaudible] but to go along with our Climate Controls. Thank you. Seeing that no other members of the public that would like to speak at this time,excuse me Public Comment is closed. By fellow commissioners, do you have comments . Commissioner nakajo thank you. Chief did you say this adoption is a twoyear adoption . Three years thank you mdm. Pres. Thank you. You want to move this item . I have some questions thank you. Vp cleaveland thank you mdm. Pres. Thank you chief, for ushering us through the code cycle into the next iteration. Of the states fire code and adoption of the local level. I have a couple questions and one was doing with a sixinch curve sidewalk piece that were going to take out the were not going to use. Was there something were substituting here . That was added in ordinance during the 2013 cycle is strictly at the local level. Personally, this is before my time here. I dont understand the rationale why was put in there. Spoke with the field that suppression crews, operations etc. It just isnt practical to think would be mounting sixinch curb where people are standing. So i went as far as to reject to state Fire Marshals Office on this so maybe they can help provide insight. The purpose of this and they were in agreement with us that they would not consider that clear with i was just wondering whether this is something a product of the vision zero so to speak and that was that came in at the state level from the Division Zero i do not know have knowledge of that. Okay. Are we substitutingon the page 3 when you are dealing with theexcuse me, page 4. When youre doing without 2015 International Fire code street with good this has nothing to do with the curb issue, right . This is strictly street with correct. This is also probably been increasedhave you consulted on Division Zero are we in sync with them on this particular thing . Its a negotiation should we go case by case. We are all for our green with them when he to be retain access as well. I agree its been a challenge and one size does not fit all on this. To take this tool away from us though there may have zero input moving forward on any street designs and i think that would be a bad way to go i completely agree. As i mentioned at the last Commission Meeting, i dont agree with permanent closures of roads that dont allow access where Fire Department apparatus and fire trucks and engines. They have to get in there to protect property and lives so temporary closures may be given permanent closures, never. On page 3, dealing with the Emergency Responder video coverage systems. I know you are using nfpas 1221 standard but whether other standards that were considered . That is the only standard im aware that addresses their First Responder radio covers. It was never spelled out. I do not know if there were other systems out there for radio response that we might sort of considered as far as the standard itself . Right to my knowledge this is a. Was never spelled out before. Okay. Dealing with proposal fire code dates that supervisor campos introduced and was passed by the supportive supervisor requiring building owners provide tenants with annual smoke alarm information disclosures annual filing of fire alarm statement of compliance with the Fire Department urges to be posted on the website and establishing a posting enforcement and recordkeeping requirements, that is only residential b1 correct. Construction and maintenance of the integrity of the fire pump room ensuring the room is used solely for the fire pump in related to equipment. Has that been a problem . The path of least resume the weve had answers well you cannot put anything exit and closure bitty the same thing for life safety concerns. Seismic concern. If you look at that burst and that could impact life safety system. Is not ever been a problem locally, though . Not that i know. On the state level and so they put it into the code were simply adopting it or was that something were putting a this is something we are adding works are fine art tradition of the session and this was our request for plan check section to add this in error. You said the water tank clean required that are essential part of our Fire Suppression system of a highrise building. That is something that were adding is a new requirement or is that backspin and exist in the true source of water acquired. Quite often stunned by storage tank in a fire service. Again we want to keep that is independent and maintain integrity as much as possible. The few things that can affect it a better in the state code is not there. This is something were adding specifically for San Francisco highrise building yes. Continuing to given the code yes got it. In utah flood horizontal sliding doors not beingaccessible in the event of a fire or emergency in highrise buildings. This prohibition if you will in using horizontal sliding doors as egress dollars, will only affect new construction correct. Or will it affect remodeling it would affect remodeling. We are doing this on a casebycase good when i think he would never would be allowed to do that it was a negative part of an egress component meaning you have to open that were taught by the special doors, the most like a portable wall. That pulls back in. You dont even see it opens up upon smoke detection good to have to open and close these and make the rest through them in a highrise building which already has a greater challenge potential more hazards, greater hazards, we dont think thats reasonable. Thank you very much, cheap. A lot of hard work. I surely appreciate it. Mdm. Chairman, i would move to approve these amendment to the San Francisco fire code two 2016 cycle thank you. I think our chief of the department has some remarks . Is one of the fire marshal clarified next steps after this approval process here tonight to the best of my knowledge this is for some of actually gone through this. I understand its a threeyear cycle. These minutes are submitted from the chief to the commission it was the Commission Approves them send them to the board of supervisors. The board of supervisors has to vote on. I think thats a 30 day period the Public Comment. The board votes on it once its approved then it goes to sacramento could all this has to take place by january 1 2017 thank you. He concluded yes. So come achieve anything also no. These are good amendment thank you could commissioner hardeman thank you manager. Well quickly, fire marshal you been very busy. I appreciate the gravity in your report. And the length of document that we can research. After going through the grand jury and have these at the same time as youve had your hands full. We are very grateful for doing a good job. Thank you. I will second the motion commissioner nakajo screws thank you so much. Commissioners think is much for your comments as well. Fire marshal, again because of time and experience we go through this cycle during the requirements of that and i just want of knowledge chief, this is the first cycle for yourself within this kind of contract in june and your timeline definitions was very very good. So i just want to thank you for all the hard work as well as for your acknowledged supportive staff. Thank you very much thank you commissioner nakajo well done. As far marshal. Yes, i believe my remarks at that. Time being of the essence. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor say, aye [chorus of ayes] the motion passes unanimously. Thank you. Item 9 update on the restoration of battalion five. Good evening pres. Lincoln commissioners did Mark Gonzales ugly giving the presentation for the reactivation of battalion five. Welcome chief gonzales thank you. The reactivation as planned for the middle of january 2017. Battalion five was deactivated on may 25 2004 due to budget cuts at that time. Its going to be located station 21 was deactivated from that sin a sally and grove and brought it. Within the station five, station six, station 12 and 21 lead battalion five. Station 10 is located in the northern tip of battalion five is assigned to battalion four. The battalion five response area description covers the beat Western Addition called out, hayes valley and part of the inner sunset. Battalion five. Include our hazards such as uc and st. Marys hospital. University of San Franciscostadium and many victories of wooden construction. On this map disregard the 11 other with the presidio subject is where we currently have. Give nine battalions ashley battalion four and seven cover that area. But were battalion to, four, and seven and eight that is basically enveloped the area where battalion five used to be. In this slide uc battalion five. On the map there. It goes in the middle of battalion seven, four, 26 and eight. Itll be in division two. This is a closer look, i battalion five. Its boundaries. Runs along the includes the panhandle runs alonggolden gate park runs up to california in the north. And then and comes in some other part of the castro there as well. Just to give the public and yourself i know that you know most of this good some of the operational roles of the battalion chief and incidents. The time shes make sure the right moves are being made by First Responders that major incidents. The foundation is weighing correctly most incidents run smoothly. Battalion chiefs perform the role incident commanders at many incidents were division chief is not required. Battalion chief surcharge of fire attacks exposure building safety and other functions as a network in bars greater all on screen battalion shes a cisco unified commands were can cooperation with the police and other agencies in that instance where the cabin incident commander. Also a partial list of some administrative duties. Personnel apparatuses patients action tidbits and community meetings. They do investigations of nightclubs target hazards, homeless others, bart and highrises. Drills they do battalion drills. Every week. I then chose those extra extrication bills, etc. They bounce the districts in the morning make sure that the right number of firefighters at each station. They handle investigations handle by myself with the chief. A Mature Company officers disseminate departmental news to companies and many more tasks as well. Better not listen. I would just like to thank sincerely thank the Mayors Office for their support as well as the board of supervisors for the ad back to battalion five. This is really important. And also to thank president covington per your work advocated with as supervisors as well as the chief of the department. Our communications are reached or nader Olivia Scanlon does onto great credit for it a lot of things was essential in helping with this. Shes right there. She did a great job. Very happy this is that. As well [inaudible] 750 in my presentation at he questioned thank you chief gonzales. Are there any members of the public that would like to comment on the restoration of battalion five . Think we one person coming forward my name is sylvia johnson. [inaudible] thank you. Any other members of the public . Public comment is closed. Chief gonzales, before we go to each member of the commission, can you really put into context for us how important the restoration of the battalion five is . As you know, our cities. More challenging as far as traffic logging density, population growth,. We had 10 battalions and seven in the garman. I was activated in 2004 i thought this was always needed to come back. I believe that when other areas are more thoroughly expended like Treasure Island Hunters Point shipyard and Candlestick Point as well as. Under we need another battalion possibly two more batons good in the future. This is an essential get back. The battalion chiefs as i said added incidents multiple units are responding that they really do live the foundation for when the us achieve better and it matters oftentimes that these incidences especially fires were as you know it zero lot line a lot of wood construction, hills, whether, or we are challenges that these are good at the right moves are not made in the inception and apparatus placement is not done often times we can use to, three, four dollars. The battalion chief [inaudible] the right news on not being made the closer they are to the building ashley spent about their equidistant from everywhere in the battalion. They get there to make those corrections if needed. Often times me the difference between losing one building were confined to a room was in the building or losing multiple buildings. Thank you. By fellow commissioners, who would like to speak for . Vice president cleaveland thank you. I like to also just say how important it is for this battalion chief five position reactivated and id like to publicly thank the mayor and board of supervisors for authorizing but id also like to thank the chief of the department and Olivia Scanlon, tom oconnor local 798 and president covington. Are making it happen for making the case i guess is the best way to put it to the board of supervisors, to the budget and finance committee into the Mayors Office. That was important as our city grows and gets denser its more difficult to get to the fires to emergencies and so we need additional commands that. So delighted that it happened, to congratulate all the those that help make it happen the thank you mr. Vp. Commissioner nakajo thank you good i also want to echo sentiments of Vice President of this commission in terms of all the identification this is a 12 year lapse that weve had. For myself as lower talk about reactivation battalion five we indeed are talking about additional personnel, battalion chiefs that is that the main personnel that we are adding to this restoration to battalion five, chief . Yes, sir it will be three more actual spots for permanent battalion chiefs than this reactivation in the spots are they determined whos going to be the pcs in this battalion five . No. Can the advertisements the vacancies coming up the next month or so. Wendy went to state having this in actual operation . We anticipate it happened overly by generate 14th 2017 those three spots rotate the role. Is there a chief to this battalion chief or how does this operate . Epistemic, no. When they were deactivated i believe that a chief spot of i could be mistaken taken very much. Congratulations chief. Thank you commissioner nakajo. Commissioner hardeman yes real quickly, this is wonderful news. I was born that you see so i hate to see that without a battalion. I wait for that st. Marys for 40 years. I love soccer stuff in the universe of San Francisco our city namesake for university very important institutions. A lot of people. I bet you are real busy when the niners play that [inaudible] sunday afternoon was the bottles and the things find around full beer cans and people fighting so theres probably a lot of work for our department at that time. Anyway, thank you and good job everyone has had an opportunity to speak. Our chief of the department would like to add something thank you. Without a doubt a group effort. All the names that were mentioned to be thank and acknowledge and we do good work when were unified. I would personally like to knowledge because he did not mention himself, get the chief gonzales. As you know, my son was having surgery the latter part of the middle of june and i was off into the latter part of june and so for the final push chief gonzales was the executor that apartment. So that should be noted as work. I appreciate it. Thanks, chief thank you. I would like to thank everyone involved as well. There are many people who despaired that battalion five would ever return and so when word got out there was a lobbying effort on the part of the department for the restoration, people felt like i dont think thats core to work and they were ecstatic when the news did come down that, yes, we got it. It was an ad back but we are still much stronger together when we are presenting a case and i really do appreciate the effort on the part of everyone for this. Thank you for your thank you president covington thank you. Next up item 10 station 35 bp are 26 update on France Construction in progress. Welcome chief lombardi thank you president is a city for the presentation on the new fire station 35 and the work were planning for your 26. Before i started bring up the powerpoint i like to say that this is been a joint effort with other city Agencies Department of public works, or project managers here tonight and ill bring her up to answer any questions after the presentation. Ms. Gabrielle isand also the port has been a big partner in this and that was a port represent earlier but had a prior commitment and had to leave earlier. I just want to say also that its been a huge joint effort for both of these projects. We been talking getting new fire station 35 since before 2010 no finally its come to fruition. So first slide is just an old picture of the actual firehouses into either in the middle. Just a reminder of the fund until we have a easter bond 2014 400 million general Obligation Bond that the voters approved with the seven grading, 85 million about went to the neighborhood fire stations that so we get the majority of the funding for this project. Were were actually talk about his fire station 35 which is a pier 22 1 2 the red circle indicated there used to be a bigger 24 thats no longer there. Thats our project right there. We will be building out behind the current firehouse. This slide shows the first slide on the left shows are actual footprint right now. This slide in the middle the dotted line that will be going away. When the building out over the water youve got to give back and is holding of how much shadow over the water and stuff so all the dotted line will be going away and then the new project on the right will be the new projects or you can see the Old Firehouse will stay in the be a new project behind it. This slide is hard to read up on the board but it really shows our existing facility which is 6100 ft. 2. The new proposed facility which is seen thousand 800 ft. 2. What this is intended to show is that our old 100yearold facilities grossly undersized. Another example of the existing facility our assets are to fire boats one engine is currently staffed with the seven fulltime members on a 24seven basis and only six 100 ft. 2. Some of the issues are no changing facilities for firefighters. No separate men and womens bathrooms. There is one bathroom and one shower for the firehouse. The new station will be like i said 16,800 ft. 2. It will be able to accommodate 35 votes. It be able to accommodate water craft rescue craft. Jet skis. The dive boat but we heard earlier that we dont know where its going to go but this building will be able to accommodate it. We will still have the one fire engine out front and theres been a lot of talk is budget season about having a marine unit. This would be a facility that could accommodate that. So were planning for the future. Obviously, thats not been approved or anything but this building would be able to accommodate that if that came to fruition for us. Quick sketch of what the downstairs is anticipated to look like. One of the major things here is we would have a floating dock that we can operate on and off of the boats which we currently do not have the other thing is, we could get an ambulance into the middle of this world can unload bodies in recovery and work on them right now. You bring a body back on the boat and theres nowhere to work on patience and stuff. Click lands of the top floor. I kept this presentation the same commissioner nakajo zero presentation on at those Port Commissions why didnt want to shortage with everyone appears 30 familiar with our threepart houses. This next picture shows the mass sizing of the. This project is we dont program to say what we need but has not been designed. It will go out to architects and builders to actually come up with a design for us but this is the volumes are you can get a look at the Old Firehouse and then this new big square is the volume that werent his grading that we need to be. One of the things that was discussed with the port with dpw and would achieve a department is Sea Level Rise which is a big thing now being built around the embarcadero. So if we were to build this and was to be a fixed pier we would have to build it 7 feet higher from ground level that our current building. So slide before showed how big the building was going to be if they were level. If we build a fixed pier we have decided around the block 7 feet higher after ramp that went up at that degree and then the building would start and go up. So its not regular practice here in the bay area but around the world it is. To build floating piers and bills buildings on floating piers and so that dpw, with the port would achieve a department, and a lot of research on making this light of this really quick but a lot of research on what would be the best thing to do, the best option that came about is a steel pier. This slide would you all have just compared thanks begin to this deal floating. To a concrete footing speed. We figured the steel be there would be the best option for our Fire Department. Shows how the steel pier is designed. Of course, when you have a floating. Youre right about the comfort of the people working in there and living there. This is a picture of how theyre anticipating to keep the movement of it to a bare minimum. The pictures some examples of floating barges about the world actually. Theres a school up in alaska. There is actually present in new york that is out over the water on a barge. Then weve got an Office Building in Cleveland Ohio and a Ferry Terminal in australia just some examples where this construction is done. You have a regular building but its actually on a floating barge. Next slide shows some boathouses throughout the country. With our area its very limited space lies in San Francisco what we can and cant do. So these are just in different examples around the united states. This slide is very interesting because when you look at the original slide that i show you that showed her Old Firehouse versus this new building or barge were to put behind it looks kind of massive but if you take it along the waterfront this slide puts it in perspective. The first one would be the firehouse and our new firehouse behind it. The next one would be pier 26 which is tremendously bigger and dark gray shows what our new footprint is going to be. The pier 28 exploratory inaand the cruise ship terminal. So although our project looks big for us its not really a big project when it comes to building buildings and barges along the waterfront. One of the major challenges for doing any project along the waterfront is the agencies you have to go through. Theres 15 major agencies listed here but therell be a total over 20 agencies that work have to get approval from and some and everybody has their own interests and what their agency represents. So make the top. Make your plan to one agency in states permit new show to another agency and we want you to change that. So these projects anything along the water or over the water takes a tremendous amount of time to get the approvals for the project. To bring this to the next i would actually be the timeline. You can see the dotted red line is where we are at now and then were looking at being able to finally occupy this building at the end of 2020. The project we thought about since 2010. So it takes a while. Now that was it for station 35. The next thing on here is pier 20 secured what we have now is a brandnew fire boat that everybodys happy and excited about we have a dilapidated dock beyond our current firehouse. So were going to put a new obviously building and but the current one will not last until 2020s when you place to put our three fire boats now and while the construction is going on. So that will be pier 26. We are working with dpw and the port on that also. This overview shows our current firehouse and then the Straight Line on the left shows the edge of pier 26. We are going to rehabilitate goal side of pier 26 and get storage area inside. Speak the pier 26 you be able to be physically see that the backup firehouse or whether sarah sponsor can you walk over and we would respond from pier 26 but the current firefighters and staff would live the current firehouse. This is a footprint of the negotiations with the port. Were never 385 feet outside on the water which would accommodate all three of our fire boats. We would have deck space for one boats we could bring a forklift in and out and bring equipment in and out to the boat with inside storage for our shop and every thing else inside the port. This is that pier 26. This is currently with the edge of pier 26 loci. It has seen better days. Theres old wall rail tracks. The pylons are all one up so we will be rehabbing the whole side of this pier and building a platform over these Railroad Tracks so we can make it a working pier again. Last slide finally is the timeline for pier 26. Chief williams mentioned end of november. Thats actually theres a window when you can type piles in the bay. So that window at the lead opens november 1 and closes november 30 so we will have all the piles on by november 30. Only having a whole project on by the end of january. Meaning whole project meaning doing the concrete siding and evident at this point of the willing to take questions and also like to invite up our project manager only for this but for all of our projects in the neighborhood is gabrielle cirelli. Thank you very much chief lombardi. Ms. Cirelli did you have something you want to add or say at this time . Good evening commissioners they do so much for having the most happy to report on the easter bond and our progress. Im here to support chief lombardi and answer any questions you have. In the full technical detail. Thank you. At this time i would like to call up any member of the public would like to comment on chief lombardis presentation . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Ms. Johnson okay. This is about the new fire boat station and the fire boat berths sylvia johnson. I think that the plans he has to elegantly sparrow but some of the [inaudible]equipped [inaudible] we probably would have extra with lights that probably had not got through the computer yet because they probably did not [inaudible] certain [inaudible] that put on this [inaudible] and i think this [inaudible] in the process of not so we can give a better example thank you. Is there any of the member the public that would like to speak at this time . Public comment is closed. I will go to my fellow commissioners began with vp cleaveland thank you mdm. Chairman and thank you chief lombardi and your entire team putting this very impressive when together. Had a couple of questions. I know when you first decided to go with it floating station as opposed to a fixed pier type of traditional structure over the cost differentials for doing fixed versus floating . So i breezed over that page but page 13 in you are thing actually shows it. Thanks to peter as the steel pier was the exact same cost. We will look at estimated pics. 6. 4 million just for the pier with the steel floating pier is 6. 3. So very close in cost. The floating concrete pier is a . 69 estimate but if the first you know kind of feeling was we are saving money but its really not a monetary savings but when it comes to Sea Level Rise, its a much more practical build because like i said the base, the ground level of the fixed pier would have to be 7 feet higher than the current firehouse. The you would have a building that is 15 feet away that starts at 7 feet higher than the gross the square of the buildings can be taller already. It would justvenue of a steep ramp going up that. Now the ramp would adjust with the tide so it seems like a better idea there was a lot of research done. I think is probably a better idea. What kind of movement is expected on a floating fire station . How much is it going to move the spirit weve all kinds of weather out there on the bay however the key. Making our firefighters seasick . Thats an excellent question commissioner cleveland the premise for the design will be designed in detail by the forthcoming Design Build Team is theres a series of god piles in this case estimated six that piles holding the floating structure in place. There are certain designs for floating structures with the intent is for the vehicle to actually because it is a vehicle float away be able to move this presumably would stay fixed. Therefore the comfort criteria would be developed that the basic structure. On this slide 15, slide 15, gets into a little bit of our marine engineers usability study for the comfort criteria. The floating barge. The intent is that it be barely perceptible hues laypersons terms good there are a series of rollers against those god piles that motion moved the motion. Absorb the motion so that really is not very different from being in a conventional land strike. Thats the intent is not intended to feel like a boat. It can also mention this is not a detriment we like the league has been not cuttingedge. Or leadingedge is an example many floating piers in singapore, australia a lot of pleases with it uses biology. Its not unknown to armoring engineering communicate and also quickly like direct your attention to this slide would be designi believe its the one right before it. Slide 14. In the top left corner of that diagram, where it says still barge, you can see the presupposed structural system there and the corner where it is blue can you see those corner blue areas . Dozer buoyancy tanks. So thats part of the engineering there sealed tanks that help once they level the structure they would presumably be never moved again. So that would be helping to both absorb the motion and assure the structure is level. Underway specters to be a permanent position but can be floated away . It could be indeed it could be. Fire department we consider the apple station draft to be part of their firefighting asset and equipment. Technically speaking is a large piece of equipment. How did we get the staff as station 35 involves . Were they involved in the discussions at all . We actually have this presentation in dpw, the port went to station 35 my talk to the members talk to the captains invited the Union Executive board there and they give a very effective presentation i got the firehouse. He was thats why you dont have the seeking pots [laughing] those are gone. What will happen to the historic fire station 35 the historic fire station will stay there and we will still be using it. Engine 35 will not respond out of this or offer this part. Engine 35 would still respond out of the current firehouse. In conjunction we use the current firehouse and we will use the new parts. Okay. 2020 the opening day. What can we do to shave some time off that . Like i said what we do toget the zipper was going faster the construction period over the water is not the big issue. Is the approval period and like i said the port is very experienced in this. A lame forbes has given us or talk people to work with us and so i would anticipate it hopefully its a concert of schedule but we have everybody in the port has been cooperative it is a matter pushing this through to the different agencies. Ive got to tell you honestly, pier 26 the first part of this and that has come we were nervous about missing the window where you can drive piles that looks like evidence working out great. The port has been a great advocate for us on that very much appreciate hearing that. Im very excited. They set about getting pier 26 built and getting station 35 and its floating station 35 built. Thank you for all the hard work youve done you will continue to do into opening day 2020 thank you vp cleaveland. Commissioner tran nakajo chief lombardi, thank you so much for your patience and staying at this late hour. When i caught this at your presentation at the Port Commission are marked that this commission and chief will party the enormity of this project. Being a commissioner and the Fire Department [inaudible] i appreciate this preaching. I think with vp cleaveland youve dealt with the items that i needed some verification that the Sea Level Rise, on page 12, the reason why the floating pier on page 13, the examples on the steel barges, page 14. The example, 16 of barge supporting structures. My questions were weird is this done, who has done it, are we experimental here or are we creating something but again the verification of all these projects and other cities the timeline. The enormity for me is how large this is historical 35 there were so going to maintain that operation. Were going to build a new pier station behind 35 and were going to pier 26 for a temporary yes. Were going to pier 26 temporarily moving the boat. The whole crew would continue to save station 35 during the construction and then they would respond off of pier 26 and we are in negotiations with the port rainout working at mou and hopefully we would maintain one slip at pier 26 to store excess stuff because were making networking pier. We would return to it is suspected up pier so they can users of easily we want to keep our boat said her new dog but maybe keep one vote at pier 26. I appreciate that she. I appreciate you being a project manager and keeping oversight with this. Pier 26 is going to be quite a [inaudible] in itself. Now that i have the compression where the members or were 35 in terms of the truck, and that timeline would be an operational december january 2017. Am i correct with that yes. Its a quick timeline and yes you are correct. I think the actual contract date to be goes to fairbury fourth of 2017 but we were just look at the contractors estimate could use estimated finishing in the middle of january which would be great for us he was pier 26 and station 35 are closed to each other you can walk if we could pull up that picture page 22, slide 22, it looks a distance but its literally the next pier over the. You can walk to it within probably a minute were under a minute but they would have i could give her something we can have them drive there in under 30 seconds. So it will bethat was the closest option we had. It worked out that the port the allowed us to go there because other than that, we wouldve had to close the firehouse that we would have to move the firefighters temporarily somewhere else the boats somewhere else. It makes it real talk. To be able to stay at stations are not respond right out of their these votes need you just cant tie them up they need power need a lot of hookups. So this is the best option that could happen for us because it goes with us in the cooperation of the Port Commission and the acting chief marty talk like 10 different agencies were more than that in terms of this approval. This is again a major step within our development for future within the city and county of San Francisco. Im going to be very very anxious to see this at some point chief lombardi 10 commissioners go and view this 26 development absolutely. Could be worth viewing out to see how deteriorated us be. Is. Then see it again later once we do the work. I would like to do that as well. Again these pictures of the condition of 26 now again this is an ambitious timeline and i hope we can do it. Because it works within our program and our advancement with the new boat as well. Thank you very much chief lombardi thank you. Commissioner hardeman thank you. Very great graphics. Chief lombardi. I do like the one. Its hard on the screen for everyone on the audience to see but the one thats listed as the los angeles fire boathouse which is in san pedro that thats my favorite firehouse. For years at first went about 25 years ago. I went on a cruise which is just recently built there. That is just spectacular. Very nice. Then not too far from it they have one of the nicest maritime museums i ever subject so san pedro rate the money. Youve been around a few times for us and always feel confident when youre here because things move along good. He was thank you. I appreciate that i appreciate you being here. This is although fire boats and as you indicated in your graphics, the years of age of our fire boats there under 60s. Its not really the real problem the real problems they dont have the pumping capacity so we can say we can [inaudible] but as we all know if the delay the new fire boat was pumping capacity. Getting something that can handle him underwater that San Francisco feels they need in a crisis. So again i would say were moving along this project we have to think about another fire boats. Great. Just wonderful on feeling really good. This rule one my personal favorite things. And by commissioner cleaveland is worried about [inaudible] force amounti do an awful lot of boating. Every was singing to be a nice station some sort of disappointed. I sleep the best remote in the ocean with a little rock. Anyway thank you very much welcome to make common in response to your reference to the long beach and send to joe and other area bonuses in Southern California you have an Excellent Teamwork worked on this project. We have a really Excellent Team conducted with public works at one of those is a marine boat station architect whos been advising us on our design build criteria and she was actually involved in some of those boathouse project name is mary mcgrath. Shes in oakland california. So excellency just want to stress that. Thank you anything else to mr. Hardeman mdm. Chairman thank you. Excellent presentation. I cant wait to see it. Its going to be fabulous. A lot of innovation. I think people are going to be very excited to see it. The chief lombardi is right. From one peer to another is just a job. Its a quick jog. Thats it. That pier is only through gods grace it is not collapsed into the bay. It is like a toothpick now open up those rails. This is going to be very very good and i also like the boathouse that it looks a something out of thomas the tank engine like the boat is going to sleep in there. There was one question i had. On the list of approvals that were needed, i noticed i noted the absence of the event Fire Commission. So the capacity with which public works will continue to adopt with San Francisco Fire Commission in that advisory capacity. According to the mr. Go this action of contract action would need to approve soap under the list of approval actions is what we do not include either but certainly as my primary client as service out pleasure of the Fire Department happy to be here an update anytime you like. Thank you. So the approvals are coming from the people putting up the money the approvals are basically coming from the revelatory agencies that need to bless the project to allow us to move forward. The San Francisco voters have spoken with a bond funding in place. There is no contingency for funding. I know concerns over proper funding moving forward it just the act and sequencing of obtaining all those various rogatory approvals commissioner cleaveland was referencing an earlier and really the Critical Path goes through the sql process. That something that a Revelatory Affairs division of public works has a lot of experience with and a Regulatory Affairs director started working for quite some time with city planning. We believe major ceqa action is can be mitigated negative declaration which is preferable and thats wonderful step and that is the primary indication good we are hoping that will continue to be the case. There will directly impact the schedule in a positive way. To your point. One thing mma comments, one thing in a favor is by doing a floating pier theres a lot less Environmental Impact get we will need to dredge. Nor to drive all because good makes a lot of agencies really happy. Indeed it does as a longstanding former leader moment commissioner very familiar with sql and yes, you have to have all of your is dotted and ts crossed and new [inaudible] whatsoever. Thats good. I have one question one more question regarding it was construction. Dessert portion of this project is going to be offsite . Presumably, yes. This project will be bid as part of a design build contract solicitation of delivery method thats a delivery method thats used by her sister agencies quite a lot for example San Francisco International Airport uses that build back the prime of your public works is now using. It seems to be the perfect example the marriage of a designer and contractor by needing to be working together to affect the proper outcome that we want here. The ultimate team will be able to subcontract out to build what and where is on the thingy although stephen ordinances which include local hire, 30 of the needing to be San Francisco residents is work on the project also will be a local bid Business Enterprise presumably will be at war near the minimum goals set for most projects of 20 . Were waiting for cmds determination that because of the specialized nature of this project as emily could be lower because theres no local firms who can build the barges. As emily, yes, they parted it would be fabricated offsite could presumably delete it with a barge comes floating in to our site is either to the skype house and from there is a much conventional construction from backup. Good. There was one question i had and so as i suspected out of it would be offsite. Great. Thank you very very the much. Commissioner hardeman i feel to say Human Element of this the new firehouse, the way the conditions down there are starting to say the least and people do that because they love working with the fire boat. They set twice a lot with the amenities that are very very hard to live by. It would be nice for them some of the younger people in quite a few people avatar recently but younger people look forward to the new firehouse. He was here. Could there be commander when we have our work in session i have to extract from and to ask for more. Because the just a very modest in the request. They are really anyway wonderful time to work right good we are working session for three hours with him last week. Going with the design details and i will continue thank you. Again thank you so much for your presentation. Its very exciting project. Thank you for having a some happy to come back anytime i appreciate it. Mdm. Clerk item 11, agenda for next Fire Commission meeting on october 12, 2016. Thank you. Is there a member of the public that would like to come forward and give some suggestions for the agenda for october 12 . This is for agenda items only. Thank you. Sylvia johnson. Section 35 i would like to make an agenda for more with [inaudible] some improvements on 25 and 26 sections and building processes. Mostly for [inaudible] 23 to discuss that process. Processing to make more [inaudible] thank you. Seeing no windows want to speak on this item Public Comment is closed. I will go to my colleagues. Yes . I like to put the status of h23 on the agenda get a quick update on the process where it is in hr. I think that is an important thing we want to have that in a position created we one have that latter to advancement for emts in our department. I think its important that we take a good look at that as you were we are. Thank you. Any other items . Commissioners, no . The Vice President and i will consult with the chief of the department and other pertinent persons and present the agenda. Are there any other matters before us this evening . If not, i will entertain a motion to adjourn moved and seconded. All those in favor say, aye [chorus of ayes] thank you all very much. [gavel] [adjournment] [gavel] good morning and welcome to the San Francisco county Transportation Authority monthly meeting, im scott weiner the share of the authority, would you call the roll . Commissioner avalos . Present. Breed . Here. Campos . Absent. Coen . Present. Farrell . Ab scent. Kim. Here. Peskin present. Tang, present. Weiner present, commissioner yee . Yee is absent and we have the quorum. Okay, we will go to the chairs report, colleagues i would like to again by reporting that our transportation Charter Amendment revenue measure and proposed sales tax increase have been placed on the ballot as propation jand k. Each one requires a majority vote of the voters to pass during the summer, contra and santa clara also put on to sales tax on the ballot. In addition to barts regional bond measure is on the ballot and all three part counties, San Francisco, alamena and contra costa and the city of oakland, and ac transit are also going to the voters to approve local measures all of these measures are needed to be part of the streets and transit systems continue to require repair and vinestment and we cannot wait for the state and the federal government to take up the tabs, over 50 percent of the transportation investment or region through 2040, is provided by the local sources in the summer has increased over the years. That is because this approach is working. Counties like ours, especially delivered the voter Proof Projects small, to get them grant ready so that they can compete for and Leverage Private funds. To help the best use of the funds, our Transportation Authority is working in conjunction with the Planning Department and mta and other agency to develop the long range transit plans, including the subway vision, and the legislation and the call for such a plan, so the master plan, and to the board of supervisors passed last year, and i was pleased to see the out reach conducted for this study over the summer. And to hear about the response from the public on the question of where San Francisco should build the new rail lines. I am told that we received, 2500 responses across the city and region and i look forward to seeing the stud at the transpower Passion Committee on october, 17th as we plan the next big rail lines and we are glad to see them partnering with the agencies on the solution to reduce the crowding on the systems including the various, incentives and this pay lot program, the trip to a less busy time, such as before or after the morning peak rush hour, and about the passengers who do shift the travel times could earn the points with the fun online game, 16,000 sign ups and 29,000 in rewards, to providers were optimistic about this program and i thank you and that concludes my program remarks. Colleagues any comments in is there any Public Comment . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. We will move to item three, the executive directors reports. Good morning, commissioners. Executive director, chang is on a jury panel for the new bus terminal and so keep you postd on that. You sh you had have the executive directors reports in front of you. And i will highlight a few of the items that were not addressed by the chair already in the chairs remarks. But it seems like we have not met for a long time because of the recess and so some of this has already hit the nut papers and we have been covering it in committee one of the items in the newspaper was the legislature and the agreement on cap and trade and even though the revenues from the last auction have been way over anticipated one of the up sides of the more conservative approach to dulling out the revenue earlier is that there are some revenues from the previous proceeds that were sort of on goal and in the bank, 60 percent of the revenues have been going out to the programs like the transit inner city rail program that have been delighted to receive the new lrvs and there are several other related programs and this agreement distributes 900 million, in unallocated auction, prohe seeds and those go to the transit rail program and the state program and other programs. Which i will speak to you a little bit later. And the state legislative session is over. And the governor has until september 30th to sign or veto a bill that are on his desk. And we will go through those now, but i will say that the finance committee at its october 11th meeting will be getting sort of a session and a summary of where we are on the legislative advocacy for mark watts the sacramento representative and it mentioned one of the beneficiaries of the cap and trade is the state active Transportation Program and this funds particularly a lot of bicycle and pedestrian projects and the education and out reach and capitol improvements. Right now, there is an under way surge cycle of programming. And there are two at the state level, 120 million that is competitive distributed to the ap mri indications state wide and those results are anticipated next month. And at the regional level, the metropolitan agency has 20 million to dull out. This cycle is a little bit odd in that the funds will not be available for several years, knowledge next the fiscal year, 1920, which is challenging for sponsors but we are pleased to work with the Municipal Transportation Agency and the public works in submitting several projects including the gene va project, and the play streets pilot, and the safety, and the vision zero, and safer intersections and jefferson street, improvements phase two and so we will keep you posted if we are as successful in those applications. Plan bay area has been a big topic and i know that our representatives on the metropolitan transportation commission, appeared with several presentations on that plan, early in the month, the two regional agencies or at least the draft preferred scenario and this includes the land use vision for the distribution of housing and jobs within the region. And corresponding transportation investment tragedy and we just had an up date at the plans and Programs Committee and we expect to have one over the next couple of months as the region moves toward a planned adoption of the preferred scenario and i just summarized for those who did not watch the Committee Meeting that right now, it looks like we are doing pretty barn well in the transportation and Investment Strategy and i qualify that by saying, it looks like all of property jects that need to be in there for San Francisco in this up date are in there and it looks like we are getting the amount of regional funds that we asked for. And i am not being completely definitive because we are lacking the details, but it is looking promising and the land use and working with the Plan Department to make sure that the projections of the housing and jobs makes sense, and the housing looks reasonable, with the zoning on the job side and it looks like they have given us a little bit more and different places than we are anticipating and so we are working with mtc and the Planning Department to reconcile that and see if that will trigger any changes in the transportation and Investment Strategy one of the things that i do want to call out were raised by the commissioners in their mtc and the abag representatively is the rereg n reregional agencies about an evaluation and there is a whole bunch of target and metrics and unfortunately on two of the economy metrics the draft preferred were moving in the wrong direction, they were the percentage of income that the low income households spend on housing and transportation, and instead of Getting Better it is actually getting worse, and displacement risk is increased. And mtc did some analysis which indicates that most of the increase, the wrong direction increase and the metric atribable to the decade long deficit in helping supply, 12 percent is attributed to the housing issue and one percent to transportation, but i think that our commissioners and others, raise the questions as if the 2040, vision that we as a region want to bless, is there more that we can do with the transportation funds and the planned bay area and probably more importantly what else can we do beyond the plan bay area to address this . Nobody is happy with this out come, so we will keep you posted and working closely with the Planning Department, and the mta in particular on trying to come up with the recommendations. So moving a bit to your projects and as you may all recall, ta commissioners and the board of supervisors this summer, we approved a supply mental, and a cost increase for the cal train, program and that increased the local contribution from the three member counties, from 60 million to 80 Million Dollars each. And i would just call out for that item 8 today. We have annual indication of 3. 9 million of sales tax funds and that is San Francisco first piece toward that 20 million increase, and we are looking towards the Charter Amendment on novembers ballot to help to fund the 16. 1 delta with the last increase and cal train is now awarded the contracts for the design build of the infrastructure and the poles and the wiring and also for the electrified vehicles. So, related, the Planning Department has been leading quite a mouth full, the relatives and the boulevard feasible study, known as rab for short is looking at a number of things, it is looking at alternatives to the cal train, king rail yard and it could be down sized or relocated and the alternative alignments for the downtown, rail extension. It is looking at the possibility of taking down part of i280 and replacing with the boulevard and looking at associated land use changes and i know that there is a great deal of interest in this and it impacts a lot of the key projects from the cal train, to the downtown extension. And the Planning Department held the second Citizens Working Group and i think that it was last week, and we are planning another one this fall. There is anticipated third round of Public Meetings that will happen this fall where there should be more information on the final alternatives that are looked at, including the cost estimates that were not previously available, i know that this is a great interest and came up with the plans and Programs Committee and as soon as Public Information is available, we are planning on the information, and or we could come back to the board as a whole of this years discretion. And just a few more items i just want to congratulate the transit riders, the San Francisco Transit Riders Union and all who participated in transit week, which was held the week of september 12th, and the authority was proud to sponsor that event with the celebrated users who help to make life in San Francisco better for everybody by getting the cars off of road and increase decreasing the greenhouse emissions. And i know that tly y is excited to report that we have a lot of progress on the neighborhood transportation improvement program, the prop k, funded program and we will just a couple of quick highlights, we have the project completed in supervisor cohens district and this is dealing with the hair ball in other terms, and the bay shore and the avenue, intersection project. And this project includes a number of improvements from the plan for the entire area, and bicycle and pedestrian path, and the street scape and improvements and so forth, the good news is that the mta has the funding for the recommendations in the five year capitol plans and we will be working with them to try to find the rest of the funding. It looks like i will leave that one there. Commissioner camposs district, the alamene interchange, i will just call out, this is in with a lot of safety and improvements right near the boulevard, and the farmers market, and there are some great out reach opportunities this week, where we are presenting tomorrow night, the neighborhood, association on wednesday, and we are presenting to the tas, and the Citizen Advisory Committee and on october the eleventh we are presenting to the plans and Programs Committee and so you can get a look at what those are for that effort. We had earlier this month, an out reach activity on the lumbard street which we are doing in concert with commissioner ferrills office and i want to thank him and his staff to help on that project. The intent of that project is to find the ways to help with the increasing vehicle on the crooked part of lum. Bard street and they say that it is a great input received at the open house and we are working to develop a set of recommendations, for handling that. Switching gears, i wanted to thank our bay area air Quality Management district. Representatives, and i will draw a blank and i know that one of them is commissioner avalos. And the air district has the purview over the transportation funz, and these are on the fees and they go to j ekts that help to reduce the motor emission and it may sound like of geeky but it is super important, and the guidelines, previously have only allowed us to fund new bike lanes or paths and this really just disadvantages San Francisco, where we want to go and upgrade, infrastructure that we have had to make them more safe, and putting in the bike lanes or the cycle tracks that was previously ineligible and we are excited that the guidelines are now, recommending that that change be eligible and we thank, commissioner avalos for helping to get that through. Lastly, we have a couple of Ground Breaking ceremonies coming up on september, 29th at noon, in supervisor peskins district we have the broad way, china town Ground Breaking ceremony, the city of broad way, and powell streets and this is the 4th phase of the street scape and safety improvements that the ta has funded from a multiple of fun sources and we are very pleased to see that project getting going, and in supervisor yee and all of the district and that is right on the border we have the area of the Ribbon Cutting of the new unity plaza and the project and this helps to connect the new terminus for the stop and the city college and with a prop aa funded pedal connector and a new plaza that is up and under way. And lastly on the boulevard, we have seen the implementation of the various, bicycle and the pedestrian, improvements on the boulevard, and with more permanent things with the concretes to come out when the streets are paved in 2017, we are excited to see the whole generation of the projects and i will give out a shout for her and her staff for working with mta and your office to keep those things moving forward. Last two things are special shout out to the finance and administration, and to mike and the policy division to another clean audit. And the transportation funds for the clean air program, and then behind the scenes shout out, and we have a Branch Management data base called pour tal and this is how we track the invoices and the back engine that up loads to the Interactive Data base, where you can find the information on any of the projects i just spoke about, and anna has been working with the staff in the division to continue to make things a lot easier for us and for the sponsors to use and i will just note that you may have seen the changes in the allocation in the form in your packet and may not look like much, but what they have done is eliminate a lot of unnecessary fields, and stream lined and entry so that we are able to extract the data from the forms right into my street and into our data base, that will conclude my remarks and i am happy to answer the questions. Thank you, colleagues, noo he questions or comments on the executive directors report . Seeing none, is there any Public Comment . One item three, seeing none, we will close Public Comment. And this is an information item and we will move to item number four. Item four, approve the minutes of the july, 26, 20 is 6 meeting this is action. Are there any comments or questions or changes to the minutes . Seeing none, is there any Public Comment . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. And can you call the role . Four, avalos . Aye. Breed . Aye. Campos . Aye. Cohen. Aye. Farrell. Aye. Kim . Absent. Mar . Aye. Peskin. Aye. Tang. Aye. Commissioner weiner . Aye. Commissioner yee . Aye. Minutes are approved. Great. Before we go to item five i did neglect to thank sgtv for broadcasting todays meeting. And he with will know how go to item five. Approve the resolution urging the league of california cities to adopt and implement virgs zero strategies and initiatives for eliminating traffic deaths and see vooer injuries and to prioritize task safety throughout california, this is an action item. Okay. Any comments or questions or thoughts . Colleagues . Seeing none s there any Public Comment on item five . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. We will move to item 6. Same house same call . Excuse me, colleagues could we take item five, same house same call, without objection. Item six. Reappoint santiago lerma and appoint shannon wellsmongiovi to the citizens sad vicery complitties. Any questions or comments . None. Any comment on iks . Seeing none, closed. Colleagues could we take item six, the same house. The house has changed. Commissioner kim was absent for the vote on item five. Okay. Ten we then we will take a roll call on six. Avalos. Aye. Breed. Aye. Campos. Aye. Cohen. Aye. Farrell. Aye. Kim. Aye. Mar. Aye. Peskin. Aye. Tang. Aye. Weiner. Aye. Commissioner yee . Aye. The item is approved. Okay. Item number seven. Item seven, amend the prop k Strategic Plan and the guide wise, muni 5 year program, this is an action item. Colleagues are there any questions or comments on item 7 . Seeing none, is there any Public Comment on item seven . Seeing none, we will close the Public Comment. And the house is the same, colleagues, take item 7 the same house same call. Without objection, that will be the order. Item 8. Al kalt, 20,88,900 in prop k funds with conditions for 14 requests subject to the attached fiscal year cash flow distribution schedules this is an action item. Commissioner peskin. Thank you, chair weiner and colleagues, as i indicated in the committee i would respectfully like to suggest that we temporarily remove the 6. 774 Million Dollars for additional studies and design work on phase two of the transbay terminal project. Specifically would i raise in committee as somebody who served on the board years ago, when the tjpa was first created a project that we obviously want, and we have, but that has cost substantially more. I think that given what we heard from miss lumbardo that there are a number of studies ongoing, with the rab, and given the fact that this is going to require the condemnation of the Additional Properties given the uncertainty about the project and given the passenger of facility, and the charges, that may not be sustainable, i would like a little bit more time. To think about this to have a Public Policy conversation, about it. And quite frankly, when we go into phase two, we should go in with our eyes wide open, we should know what the alignment is going to be. And we should know whether or not downtown is going to be disrupted for years. Are there better ways of doing it than cut and cover . We should have that conversation before we get just a little bit pregnant. Because this is going to be the next ten million and the next 100 million and the next 200 million and so why dont we slow down and do a little bit of thinking about this . And wait for this process, and it is, and we are in the fall and this process is going to become much more definitive in the fall, and so i would subject to comment public like to make a motion that we reduce the 20. 88 Million Dollars by 6. 774 Million Dollars. And send the item back to the plans and Programs Committee for additional policy discussion and debate. I do not want to be in a situation where in a number of years we all regret this vote. Commissioner campos . Thank you. Mr. Chair, i have a number of questions about this item. And quite frankly one of the key questions is actually having a better grasp of what the oversight actually looks like. We have a long history of issues with this project. And at some point, the tjpa actually had problems with the county Transportation Authority providing oversight. And i am glad to hear that that is no longer the case. But i do think that as we are dealing with our own leading tower of pisa here in San Francisco, i think that we have a responsibility to make sure that we do everything that we can to make sure that Something Like this project is handled properly. And quite frankly, there are issues around some of the existing litigation that has been filed around mellineun sky scaper that raises questions about what the cta own liability could be. And so, i will support that motion. Supervisor kim . Or commissioner kim . Thank you, and i, i can support a continuance of this, this dollar amount and i am just curious how long we plan to place it on hold . So, and what the expectation would be in order to release the remaining 6 million specifically. Through the chair to commissioner peskin. Kim. I would like it to go to our next plans and Programs Committee. I would like to use that as an opportunity to hear from the mayors transportation advisor and have a more robust conversation about the alternatives, i would like to actually have a much more definitive briefing, whether we are interested in the embarcadaro, and we asked the questions of how many pieces of property will have to be condemned along 72nd street and there will also have ton property condemnations alounge townsend and that was all high level and vague and i would like to hear what the rab comes up, and lumbardo said that they will have more information this fall and we are now into the fall and so depending on the answers that we get in october, and maybe we could send it back to the full board in october, and hopefully we have a much more definitive set of answers by november. But no later than november. And i see that our Transbay Joint Power Authority staff is here. And so i just wanted to bring up either the director or our Government Relations liaison just to answer a few questions. And in terms of whether there is an agreement on bringing it to the committee and that there will be answers to what peskin has asked and any impact of the delay of the 6 million disbursement to tjpa. Good morning, i am the director with the transbay, Port Authority, and here to impress upon you, to pass this item and provide the needed funds for the tjpa moving in partnership, and very Close Partnership with the San Francisco Transportation Authority and the mtc into advancing the delivery of phase two. With wrour support, and it is fully funded and we are grateful for that and it is on track to be completed december, 2017, for the construction and shortly there after for the bus administrations and our focus at the tjpa has shifted to phase two and advanced stage two in collaboration with the region and to that extent, i presented to the board, the juj meeting this year, a road map to deliver phase two along with a funding plan and this is just basically a road map that allows us to advance, phase two and possibly be able to bring the trains to the Transit Center, late, 2025, and 26, and i shared that the road map with the sfjta and the mtc and i got their support to or their encouragement to move forward, is to take the design to 30 percent completing and that will allow to develop the bottoms up estimate for the construction and will allow us to also, determine the right away impacts, that will go long ways to answer supervisor peskins question, and we move to move the designs, 30 percent in order for us to be able to determine what properties are impacted and how are they impacted . And to how, impacted would you include, in the temporary construction, easements is it permanent, construction, easements or is it the property acquisition, and no condemnation, or the acquisition will take place as part of the money that we are asking for today, and it is to move the design forward so that we can fit the scope properly and he can come up with the bottom up estimate, and do an up to date, study to allow to us confirm, what you should except from the charges to the compliments or the funding plan and also to up date the program cost estimate and to do a Risk Assessment. And we need to do a Risk Assessment after the 30 percent design is completed and in order to identify the risk and provide, and fund the proper amount of program reserves. And so what we are asking today, is basically, advance the project, so that we can answer a lot of the questions that we brought at this committee, one thing that i would like to highlight, regarding supervisor camposs concerns, we fully intend to move forward to deliver this project. It is not one agency alone, it has to be with the region, to that extent, moving forward we will be working close, as we advance this project. I impress on you to move forward, and it is basically on life support for up to three years and we have not done much work. And our focus has been phase one, and phase one has a lot of difficulties that we have overcome and, if this money is not allocated this month, and i am afraid that the dtx you will be pulling the plug on the dtx because we have a lot of momentum Going Forward now, we have updated the mtc and updated the federal partners on how we can fund the project. And the loans to fully fund the dtx, and so, i think that if we are not able to move to 30 percent design, i am afraid that we are going to lose that momentum and lose the project. Question . Director, do you feel that you can come up with adequate responses to commissioner peskins questions at the next meeting . I will be more than happy to continue to meet with supervisor peskin and his staff, and a lot of his questions will be answered and i can see your supervisor peskin and the acquisition will take place before we come back here and that is where we show the funding and more appropriately, up date you on the status of the 30 percent, drawings and the impacts that it will have on the property. That is 30 percent, drawings . Yes, 30 percent design, this money is going to allow us to finish the 30 percent design and determine the impacts as far as the acquisition are concerned. I think that i dont, i may have misunderstand, commissioner kims question. But i think the question or my question is, by next month, will you have the answers to the questions that commissioner peskin is asking . You will have, you will have parts and we will be able to answer parts or portions of his questions, and some of his questions we kneed to finish the 30 percent design to answer the questions. Which of the money is helping to the funds . Yes, sir. I want to ask you, will you have the answers to commissioner peskins questions by next month . Without this money, i cannot. Okay. I cannot give you a cost estimate and i cannot give you the impact acquisition. Commissioner tang . Thank you, i think that, and i know that there are some troubles here i think that is what i was struggling with during the plans and programs meeting last week, which was, you know, i respectfully disagreed with trying to put the funding for the design, on reserve because i felt that we actually needed that money to be able to answer a lot of the questions that supervisor peskin and others have. And i will likely continue to support, so that we can get up to the 30 percent design today. Okay. Commissioner campos . Skept cal if we are on the same path, many of the people that were involved here are involved here before, and so that not very comforting. And they, the sure, the executive directors are out there, but you have some of the same players here. And i went out of my way with supervisor weiner, to advocate for this project at the mtc, and the city and county of San Francisco has put itself on the line, and i am really disturbed that there is such a fear in answering questions. And if hewe had actually taken time to do what we are doing here we would not be in this mess, and so i will be voting no, and quite frankly, unless the approach changes, i will make sure that at the mtc, my concerns are reflected because this is not a good thing for San Francisco. And it is not a good thing for the region. My. My response . I will give you a chance. Momentarily. And commissioner peskin . Thank you, chair weiner and colleagues, and lets examine this a little more closely. First of all, we are voted advanced the quarter of a billion dollars to bail the tjpa out. And as commissioner campos says there may be other liabilities that they are now facing. And there are a series of Unanswered Questions that dont require 6. 7 Million Dollars to answer, they require a level of transparency, and a level of honesty in answering some questions and having a real honest dialogue. About it. What are we doing getting 30 percent design drawings, when we have not deci this decided i this is the alignment and that is the cart before the horse and the whole relationship between the tjpa through the staff has always been to jam us. Wow, lets slow down a little bit. Lets have that conversation. And so that we do not end up in the same position that we are now, and the reason that phase two is not funded is because they borrowed from phase two to pay for the cost over runs of phase one, that is a fact. And look, if this thing has been dormant for the last two or three years, all of a sudden, one or two months of our discharging our duties is going to make some profound change . Hogwash. And for the record, when i asked miss change about this prior to the plans and Programs Committee, she said a month or two. No big deal. Enough of them jamming this dually elected body and i would make a motion to take that 6. 774 Million Dollars and send it back to the plans and Program Committee for the october meeting to be discussed. I thought that you already made that motion. It didnt get seconded. Seconded. And made by peskin and seconded by campos. After supervisor avalos, and breed i would like to hear from our staff. So commissioner avalos . Excellent. I would like to hear from the staff, a two month delay that that was not going to be ab is an issue. And then, also, contention that we are being jammed by the pjpa, and also has been a contention that we are not practicing the oversight, although, i think that this discussion is practicing our oversight, and could we have a. We have 6. 4, and is there a portion that we can enable, something to go forward but that we could actually make the project go forward, those are my questions. The great questions, thank you. And the chief deputy, director. And let me just take this not necessarily in order because i want to agree about the oversights. And i am one of the old timers who is here, with phase one of the project. And at that time, as i supervisors know who are around, we tried to do oversight, and but we are not permitted to do the oversights. And that has changed now and you will see attached to the allegation request, the oversight protocol that is a models off of what we used very successfully with the mta and the central subway and pretty much the same protocol that we are applying, to the project and i am more confident in the oversight, and tjpa is working with open arms and my understanding is that protocol will be offered to the Funding Partners and the mtc and the federal administration, and mta, and to the question about will we have answers. The question there, what portion of the funding for the over all project is actually coming from the Transportation Authority from the cta . Phase two of the project is a rail extension . I mean that it is pretty naul, right now, the total project is just under estimated 4 billion dollars. And we are talking about 6 billion here, at most prop k, maybe has if you accelerate all of the money, 12 million. Over all what would you say . At this point in time, there isnt much money committed to phase two. Thank you. So lets see, the other comments about will we have answers . Next month and what are the impacts of the delay, the fair questions and this really goes i think that your Comfort Level as a body and you they ever have all of the answers on the major capitol project of this size, when it is at this stage of the project, and we give the directors, that it is correct for the request for the funding to get all of the project elements including the elements like the bart underground 230 to the 30 percent design that will enable a grounds up cost estimate to be able to verify, the 3. 99 billion cost which mtc came up based on a useful but it was a shortened and a cost review. And in terms of delays, sure, you can delay, and it is not the end of the world. And i know that it isnt what the djpa wants but it is not stopping anything and i think that the question that commissioner kim asked is pointed what will be the marker for the Comfort Level for this body to decide to move forward . We may be able to get some answers, but in terms of the rail yard, and i was going to say that rab that the rab study and we are hoping to have the cost estimates in october, november, december, time frame, which covers all and i dont suspect that it will have a preferred alternative for the city and be aware that all should have more information. In terms of prohe vieding partial funding, so that if there are and i have been told that we are not going to be aible to have any answers unless we do the study and we cant do the study without the funding, so is there something that can be pro provided that will allow for that to happen and still hold, you know, the greater portion of the funding up . So that we can actually get a report back and release that based on what we hear . Yes, as a body that allocates the funds you will have the ability to let out just that amount of funding for the particular scope, but i am not sure, is what he would need to answer the questions raised by commissioner peskin and i did also ne glekt to say one thing, attached to the form is another special condition that acknowledges that there are these other studies out there like the rav and it gives this body the ability to stop, if you approved the allocation to stop the work at any time. If it picks a different alignment and to renegotiate the scope of work my understanding is that 85 percent of what is funded is stuff that would need to happen any way regardless of alignment. What specifically about that 900,000. So that the transbay authority, recently did a supply mental eir, which modified some elements that have been previously cleared and previously we were at 30 percent design and also, added some new elements and so it will give you two examples. And so, when we went through the cost of the mta, and you know that many of our east bay commissioners felt strongly about including the bart, and muni connector as part of the project scope. And that had not been part of the project scope, previously and so part of the fund sg to bring that project from basically close to zero, to 30 percent design, and there were other elements that were cleared before such as the underground station of fourth and king, that used to be under the yard, and to allow for the potential development of the yard, they have agreed to move the station under the townsend street and so that requires the redesign as well. There are elements like that, that you could if you wanted to dissect what is needed and what is not needed if the alignments were changed commissioner peskin . Well i will defer for a minute to campos. I have seen, this movie before, many times, and it is what the tjpa has done in the past, and consistently come to us with a parade of horribles if we dont approve this now, the world was going to come to an end. And you know, i always think that with these kinds of things you have to trust your gut. And my gut tells me that we are better off getting more information here, especially given that it is sort of a shifting target, what they are saying, today. As opposed to what they seem to have said in the committee. And by the way, if it, it was so critical that they needed to have this, vote in on today, they had a few days to actually get more information that they could have brought to this body today. And quite frankly, part of the problem that i have with this project is the attitude, right . Which is lets move forward, because the bulk of the work that is going to done, even if there is a different alignment, it is needed. And yeah, sure, we may lose, 15 percent, but, you know, 85 percent, is still going to happen regardless of what the alignment is. Well, 15 percent, is significant. And it is, and it is through, through the accumulation of 15 percent after 15 percent, after 15 percent that we get to where we are right now. The project that is a lot more expensive than was anticipated and in phase two that is not funded because some of the money that was going to go for it, had to be used for phase one. And so, i am sorry, but the tjpa is not in the strongest position here. To come and lecture us about the need to trust them, and to move forward. And for the county Transportation Authority, we have to do a better job. We have to do a better job of providing oversight here, and yes. The relative to the large amount of money that is being spent, is a small fraction, but it is still tax payer dollars. It is still money. That we have a responsibility a fiduciary duty to make sure that it is spent, properly. And if 6. 8 million is going to slow down this project of this magnitude, what does that say about where this project is headed . And how it is being handled . I am going to vote no on moving forward with this and support the motion. Commissioner breed . Thank you. And i appreciate supervisor camposs comments about this, when we discussed this item, in committee, and a number of questions were raised, we sent it to the full board, in support of it, with the expectation that many of those issues would be addressed. I did definitely appreciate the additional oversight from the ta for these particular funds. But i do think that there are a number of outstanding questions that still need to be addressed. And my Comfort Level with the tjpa is just not there. Unfortunately to trust that by issuing over 6 Million Dollars we will be able to answer questions that we need answered before wei actually issue the money. So i definitely will be voting to support the motion at this time and hope that a better job is done at communicating to this body in the future, and especially when a request of any magnitude whether it is one mill object, or 6 million, or 20 million, you know, there is just, the Comfort Level with this particular entity is just not there. From my perspective and so i do think that a lot more work needs to go into a request of this nature. To make sure that we are comfortable with issuing additional dollars and we are not just pouring money down a black hole. Thank you. Commissioner kim . Thank you, i am happy to support the continuance today of the 6 million, but i would like it if the ta staff could work with commissioner peskins office on coming up with a ligs of deliverables that we would expect. I think that my one concern is that i do think that it is not absolutely clear to me, all of the answers that we would like to have answered at the next plans and Programs Committee but i dont think that i think that it is good to have a greater discussion and i think that unfortunately tjpa is also caught in the middle in the sense that the city and other departments have been raising questions about an alignment that we have committed to, and we have completed the eir, and study for. And now there is a request by other entities for us to examine other alignments that might better work for downtown, extension and i am open to that process. And i think that if there is a better alignment, we should certainly study it. But i think, you know, tjpa has been committed to the original alignment, and i understand certainly, the reason why they are as it has been fully studied and it looks to be maybe the fastest way for us to complete the dtx, and that being said, i think that if we are going to put something under gro und that we should do it the right way even if it takes us a little bit of time to do that. I think that clearly that question is not going to get addressed by the next plans and Programs Committee, so i would like to get to a more reasonable set of expectations for the next plans and Programs Committee, i would like to move this money forward seeing that i do think that the 30 percent design process is important to many of the other questions. But now, i can support this and hopefully we can Work Together on getting to a better place at the next Committee Meeting. Thank you. I want to give tjpa a chance to respond to the conversation ha happened today. Actually i was clarify myself, my intention was not to jam this item at all to the board and my apologies, supervisor campos, that was not my intention. I used this what i was trying to say and i will say it again, is that we need this technical data in order to answer some of the questions, but given that, and there is no support for this item we will continue to work with the commissioner to make sure that their answers are or their questions are addressed before we move forward. I fully intend to move forward with stage two, different that stage one and i mentioned with the mtc and we signed an oversized agreement, access to our staff and data and we are going to move forward, to deliver this project and again, i reiterate a 4 billion will not be done or delivered by an agency alone and it has to have the help of one region. That is why we are reaching out to do that. Okay. So the petitioner peskin could i clarify, that the original motion was to send it back to the committee and you referred to it as a continuance, could you clarify what the motion is. The motion is out of the 20. 88 billion dollar item to remove the item in the first portion of that, allocation of prop k funds in the amount of 6. 774 million, and 400 dollars and send that portion back to the plans and Programs Committee for their october meeting. Thank you for clarifying it. And commissioner campos did second that motion. And i am not going to be supporting this motion. I have in the past obviously been critical of tjpa and some of the way that the projects have been handled and with that said, i also believe that it is critically important that we move phase two, forward. And even given the uncertainty around the alignment, and the vast majority of this money is irrespective of what alignment is chosen and so, to me, the downtown extension is important, and this is while, a 6 Million Dollars is certainly, it is a significant sum of money they are not asking for the moon they are asking for enough to keep the design process moving forward and to get the 30 percent, and i also will just note i, completely respect commissioner peskins view on this and not supporting the commercial paper item that was before us, earlier. This spring or summer and has the prospect on the city, and i respect that and i have a different perspective and i am concerned that what will happen, if it goes back to the committee, and i have a feeling that i am going to on the losing end of this vote, and i request that whatever that group is that is working with tjpa i would like my office to be a part of that as well. So with that, we will open this item up for Public Comment. Yeah, Public Comment, and you can have a seat, thank you. Please excuse me . All of item a . Please come forward, public xhe comment. Sorry i am late, i guessed that the missed the Committee Meeting and there are a number of my neighbors who lived on the street who are worried about a smaller part of this sitem and t is the plan to lower the traffic capacity on eddie and elis street and i guess what we are asking for is a similar kind of action and to hold up the money. And the study that was done at this action was based on was made in 2005 and it has been quite a bit of difference in it. You know, the capacity and everything else, and at that time. The problem is that if the people are, in one lane in either direction, there are about, somewhere between, is 800 and 200 people on the street. That would that this project would apply to. And they have a variety of needs, and the needs are met by light vehicles and small vehicles. And they have to be able to park, and many times there is double parking. And well, if there is only one lane in one direction that really clogged up the traffic and the road is in recent years it is very well used and you know, the history of the traffic pattern is that it when the price of gas went up in the recession, we had a very, we had an extreme drop in the amount of traffic on that street, but then, you know, starting in the last four or five years it has been creeping up and you know, many times and i think that it has to do with the traffic changes on the other side of Market Street as well. Many times there is bumper to bumper, and as the horns honking. And well, what we have, for the neighbors there and what they have there is they have the service vehicles, and the families that are always, dropping off the neighbors and they, and their kids sometimes. And the food bank and there is disabled, and there is emergency vehicles, and the Police Department is expanding. There is the 31 balboa which is if it locked and grid locked i dont know see that is going to increase that, there is a great amount of need on that street for the two lanes in one direction, from levenworth down to Market Street. As it we would like to ask you to you know, to hold up the funds or to have another study. Thank you very much. And is there any additional Public Comment on item 8 . If there is come forward. And if there is anyone else come forward if you are tiebl stand up. Good morning, commissioners my name is Rob Burmingham and i would also like to supPort Commissioner peskins request for a holding up of these funds. I am a stake holder. I own 5 parcels of property at the corner of second and howard street. And so i do care how the dtx is going to eventually, the route is going to take place. I agree with what you are saying, commissioner weiner but not at all cost and not as quickly as possible, by far and away, the most important thing of this project is that we get the route correct, and there is no question that it is going to happen. But, there is a rail road line, or a rail road yard, area which can be developed, there is two stadiums that could be served much better than the present alignment, and this idea that tjpa needs to quickly, move forward to the 30 percent design phase, is so strange. I am an, engineer by profession, and the idea is that they have to or else, the project is going to stop, even if we dont get funded even though we are doing the studies about the alignment is counter productive and it does not serve this body the most important thing for you to guys to focus on is getting this right. The transbay, and the Transit Center did not, did not make anyone here looks like stars, this project is about 1,000 times more complex and you need to get it right and get tg right, lets make sure that we get in the 30 percent, as quickly as possible and that just makes no sense. Take your time and get it right. Thank you. Is there any additional Public Comment on item 8 . If so, please come forward. Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. I just wanted to appreciate the Public Comment, and i appreciate mr. Berminghams comment and if these funds were on a particular alignment, i would be voting against them because that is up in the air and i completely agree that there may be a better alternative alignment, and that is why we are going through the process and i would also be fine if the votes were there to move this forward to slice off that 15 percent, and that 900,000 that is predicated on the alignment so that we are just moving forward the 85 percent, that is applied no matter what the alignment is. And but, again, it appears that i will be in the losing end of todays vote in any respect, so if i happened to prevail on the vote, i will be open to slicing off that 15 percent, and commissioner avalos . Just a request for the staff on what was brought up by mr. Duffy on the alignment or the traffic work oban ellis and eddie street and you mentioned that the work being done on this was based on a study in 2005 and that was work that i had helped with as a legislative aid. And for chris daily back, and way back when and in another lifetime. And so wondering, in response to his contention that there is old data that this is based on, i knew and i do know that there was talk of going from two to one lane and looking at their enclosures i am not seeing that in here. And so if you could just that is what he was referring to, but that is the right alignment, to have for those streets, given sort of the study that was done in 2005. Great, absolutely. And i will see if craig and mta wants to jump up to correct me. My read of this is that it is not reducing the number of traffic lanes but changing the streets from one way to two way, in order to achieve the vision zero goals to calm the traffic down, and well, the original study is old, we have been implementing it since then in pieces and so they have been keeping up to date on the traffic information. Great, thank you. Okay. Colleagues, seeing know other names on the roster, we will proceed to a vote on commissioner peskins motion to sever off the funds for dtx as he described and to send that portion of item 8 back to the plans and Programs Committee. And mr. Clerk, would you please call the role on that motion . All right, on the amendment to item eight, avalos. Aye. Breed. Aye. Campos. Aye. Cohen . Aye. Fer el . Aye. Aye. Kim . Aye. Mar . No. Peskin. Aye. Tang. No. Weiner. No. Commissioner yee . Yee is absent, and the amendment is approved. Okay, so that motion to amend and to send back to the plans and Programs Committee is approved. Okay, now we are passed this item, item 9, i am sorry, on the remainder, my apologies, and so, we now have the remaining funds, minus the dtx funds and could you please call the roll on that item . Avalos. Aye. Breed. Aye. Campos. Aye. Cohen. Absent. Farrell . Aye. Kim. Aye. Mar. Aye. Peskin. Aye. Tang. Aye. Weiner. Aye. Yee is absent. The underlying item is approved. Okay. Item number 9. Introduction of new items . Colleagues, are there any items for introduction . By seeing none is there any Public Comment on item nine . Relating to introduction . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. And this is an information item. Item ten . General Public Comment. Is there any general Public Comment. Please come forward. Yes. inaudible some people have shock abilities and they understand immediately upon having inaudible thank you. Next speaker . My name is duffy and just extending on the last item that i wrote up. I dont think that the city and, i dont think that the city is giving us a forum to explore the issues that are coming in the last several years, since this was first proposed. Obviously, it was not given to us today. So when do we discuss the trade offs and whether or not there is a better way to use this money for Pedestrian Safety . For example, mccallister and leven worth street that is where some of the work was done and part of this project and yet it is a very dangerous and very imperfect solution set. Is there any additional Public Comment . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Item number 11 . Adjournment. We are adjourned. Thank you. Im sherman and icon for the board of supervisors in district one the Richmond District im a lifetime resident lived there any whole life i attend San Francisco State University in addition to living in the district i work as a manager in the Richmond District on 20th and geary the reason he decided to run for the board of supervisors a few years ago i saw one of my neighbors hit by a tar car with no traffic signal it should have had a traffic signal and no traffic signal there today, we still have one dozen drshgsz on geary without a traffic signal i think that is irresponsible on behalf of our elected officials not to make safety a priority another issue in the district that i feel needs to be addressed is crime it has gotten oversee over the 40 years in the district you see more graffiti on the streets, we see litter on the sidewalk and items left on the curve maintenance for infrastructure as deratted our parks are not maintenance and roads and sidewalks what will i do as your supervisor i will reprioritize the issues weve discussed and make at translated a priority and make sure we have Traffic Signals on all blocks if the geary tunnel to ocean beach and timed so traffic can move across geary and pedestrian can cross the streets without aware of getting hit by a car and timed traffic signal lights in the corridors balboa park be fulsome, clemente and california street cleaning we want to go back 20 20 times a week i know that is a problem for people to move their cars this is not help the cleanliness and not a safe situation i want to increase streets cleaning a remove litter off the sidewalks as soon as possible i want to make sure that graffiti is removed off the street the graffiti that litters the neighborhood and spreads all over i want to working closely what other folks to get large items moved offer the sidewalk as soon as possible so we dont see that for days as a time for infrastructure i want to make sure we allocate the funds to have the funds necessary to replace the roads and sidewalks and park we do not need to spend infrastructure money to have bonds to be paying and a yearly basis and increase parking in the neighborhood by prioritizing parking and garages so that residents have places to park and businesses can encourage people if outside the district to hop here because we have parking i want to increase the distribution have distribution of krooirld waters through the the neighborhood to have kriernd water to water airing our trees and clean the trash cans and cars this allows us not to use precious drooeng water and especially because of drought over the last couple of years so i canned make you any specific promises all i can do to be fair to everybody in the district and alone listen to concerns and finds objectives of the people in the district i will working hard to make sure that the issues are taken care of and i will have a District Office in the neighborhood you dont see me only ones every 4 years but every week if you want fair and responsible government you want someone that will treat People Fairly and a clean and safe neighborhood i urge you to check this out when your deciding how want to represent you as youre next supervisor in our district thank you. Hello shalom my name is Ricky Greenberg thank you foe allowing me to introduce myself to you im new to politics but not new to serving the public i moved to San Francisco 15 years and brought experience im a proud husband and father all over the place now want to be youre next supervisor important the richmond and represent you at city hall i was born in new york and i learned to be are respect fell hard working and challenge my capacities scientific minded and in the arts and music im a team player and worked independently fast forward in any profession i learn a knowledge by helping people to come up with pa plan together and put that plan in motion the past 27 years ive helped over one thousand empires mom and pop and nonprofit startups release their dreams nationality and not english as a second language he myself speak four english, french and hebrew i traveled to many parts of the world put me at great Virginia Western Community college and have a worldly perspective seeing first hand ive earned a reputation of pragmatic and honest and afraid and have a realistic vision and stick to my promises and say im sorry when im wrong why do i want to be a periphery it is a natural presentation from Offering Services to the public and now a Public Servant ive been where arent by doing on excellent job over 27 years and give back to the community it here are 3 of the many issues to address making our city affordable this is an obvious goals that politicians mention but none has ill take real work to make that happen and keep costs down and salaries higher we cant control salaries ill fight to stop the rising costs and fight adding more and more takes and assessing products and i will fight higher operating costs for Small Businesses because those higher costs would be passed on to us making San Francisco not Affordable Housing i want to insure the best balance between Affordable Housing and all housing being built we cant build homes fast enough a force the barandgrills to blt build them with prices we can affordable ill work on Solutions Including building taller projects in the appropriate areas and tough over shortterm rentals adding to our housing shortage and Public Safety we are a society plagued with distractions not only taking personal responsibility for the use of social ability and texting while driving and walking but support of Law Enforcement in cracking on violators in kevin our city safe and gynecologists and pedestrians save im a strong supporter of spairt bike lanes i can be firm whether against the same thing policy and moreover we need to insure our Police Department is fully staffed for the richmond and for the fury cops walking the cadet we need them and in addition seriously address the Employment Practices of local startups and fight to stoppage gender for hiring of salaries by enforcing the laws we should be hired and paid equally the current board of supervisors is proposed laws and policies bans making a statement to be first in the nation to me id rather make sure the policies make sure and not just proposed so friends truly a pleasure to share this time please visit richie that will be an honor the responding needs richie and thank you shalom. Hello ill jonas candidate for district one nile slogan and bio my supervisor qualifications and my agenda first, id like to urge you to visit jonas for supervisor 2016. Com and my values and one hundred agenda items media slogan make San Francisco green, clean and great i believe that government should be efficient better city and introduce as much as possible to serve the resources for future generations my bio the Clean Technology with legal experience a San Francisco resident for thirty years and in the richmond for 20 i am married with commissioner moran and our goal with rainwater i own an electrical bicycle i built will myself i have judge pro tem 14 years as Vice President to the golden gate as telethon for side richmonds a long term active member in an organization my experience and interest is a Global Warming population lobbyist and public speaker and writer on energy and the environment and future technology a long time supporter im a lifetime registered independent and Practice Campaign or more and rough to accept Campaign Money my this of the law my lifelong environment of involvement that my many years of neighborhood a in numerous Neighborhood Organization my integrity by my unbelched reputation and refusal to lie and answering all questions as eventually act biden as possible and on the principles and not by political will my privilege are as follows the Community Sustainability founded on conservation planning for sound Economic Development and Community Safety which involves assuring all measures to prevent future and property crime and Resource Sustainability which requires conferring Natural Resources foyer future yagsz and wellbeing that is sharing all reasonable steps for health care and schools and levying that calls for insuring everyone full and equal opportunity and for employment and selfimprovement based on those privileges my political proprietors are personal responsibility and safety and Resource Management health and education and equal respect milestone my original and there are approximately, one hundred ideas environmental conservation, fiscal responsibility. Good Governance Health and family, homelessness housing, planning for the future, quality of life richmond specific ideas, safety, and transportation i recognitions i dont have the time to identify a perfect idea that are the embedded within a few minutes youll be able to scion any copy with action proposed for each item and the reason for item item you can read feasted check out the website ive enjoyed talking with i hope youll look at any website address have an agenda that will help make San Francisco lien, clean and green thanks very much. Im bryan larkin as in the street im once again running for the board of supervisors ive lived in the richmond since 1985 with my wife deb raised our daughter and attended Public Schools the majority to high school to third julian went to a the oldest ones graduate from the university of San Francisco and im on engineer by exercise and semi retired with chevron and more than 11 years with other company i started to seek employment in the 80s when i realized highway it would be awarding to work on Public Transit my main reason for running any advanced age is the same to bring unknown muni to the responding before i continue on the subway plan b a little bit about the board of supervisors the 11 members have representatives in the district and 5 probable progressive district and district one that is the swing district as such a lot of leverage from the muni rail we have not seen that i will be willing to work with the progressives and moderate to reach the goals but with achieving substantive improvements for the Richmond District back the muni retro the part of San Francisco is the only part that didnt have the metro rail serve the 50 thousand plus with the geary lines it takes someone like me that lives in the outer responding to get downtown to the bus from lafayette a long time speaking of long times by elect day im going to be an official Senior Citizen and will be an imempathetic voice people have their special challenges and agencies recognize that and provide support staffed by younger people that know about outlined age from reading something not the case with me, im living it more and more everyday im advocating this year the same things in 2008, but this time with more sense is urgency from the pressure to increase honoring housing density through the Affordable Housing and especially long corridors and geary boulevard i hear a crisis and get neurotic the first causality is arent and reason in 2008, on this stage forum i stated this is like desirable practices to live without the infrastructure and increased density can make it overcrowded along with better transportation and the other improvement in infrastructure underground or overhead illustrates half has this done and the richmond is not on the schedule there is little chance any of the improvements without the district one oldtime advocate indeed a champion i want to be that champion vote for me on november 8th ill take our second or third place but remember larkin like the street. Hello, im andy im a candidate for the board of supervisors in district one like most richmond neighbors and most san franciscans my own are tenants by far too many san franciscans were crushed by little scarcity weve been evicted twice in the 21st century by local homes two families one home just people trying to live in San Francisco pushing on each because not enough housing to go around im committed to project the housing and strengthen the tenants sustainability measures for everyone including Small Businesses and Public Institutions but we have to build more housing for more people at all affordability levels and create nor Affordable Housing for our neighbors but an you are not need tore teaches and Police Officers and bus drivers and nurses and cooks if you cant afford marketrate you need Affordable Housing that drives a huge crush and future san franciscan we need to work to relieve the housing crush to the bottom and the middle all san franciscans and first, we need to vigorously shape the Housing Project for a fair share and increase the neighborhood Users Community planning and health i think that geary boulevard can can get taller with the right transportation choices and solid infrastructure speaking of transportation im energeticly ready to have a muni system that people dont just tolerant muni but go out of their way to use it shape our streets so making a trip by bicycle is more convenient and comfortable than by car and causeandeffect is safe and pollutant and dignified and the Human Experience of wondering is protected and elevated as transportation advocate and the city starve ive made a career out in the Community Neighbors and advocates, institutions and businesses to shape a sustainable city save healthy streets are foundational i whorling endorse vision zero and support the focus on addressing and 4r50e789 serious related traffic injuries and death loss of a life to a hitandrun is unsurmountable and the shape and managing of the street is essential i love the city i love the business of running the city and helping to help it flourish and adopting and evolving for tomorrow and beyond im a proven and well regarded leader and accomplished explainer and listen Internal Revenue he go to work everyday to make the streets and neighborhoods more safe and more i partner with the people of all neighbors where empathy seeking a building consensus and passion im working on some of the citys busiest issues housing, save streets and sustainable infrastructure and more im well seasoned and broadly engaged in San Francisco and at all levels if outside city hall ive worked from inside city hall and spent years working with directors and staff the board of supervisors and their staffs the Mayors Office the sfpd and Community Groups and business groups and organizing get actual things done im already getting things done working with any neighbors and ready to step up ill be howard to have your full consideration had you cast our vote this fall. Fooimz a sam im running for the board of supervisors richmond. Im born and raised if hong kong and graduating if a high school my family moved to San Francisco i considered my education and graduated from uc berkley after working for several architectural firms i started my business in 1985 and returning for the board of supervisors i want to bring no nuisance leadership to city hall with no business experience in the city as a Small Business owner and a listens architect i see struggles of Small Business trying to starter their business and working hard parents struggling with their kids i also see the frustrations of young graduates and seeking a foot hold in the bay area city hall needs candidates that have will there ill be your advocate because im and licensed architect i have hands on know of signing and Building Code Building Code and did planning code and solve the housing crisis of the city as a resident of the richmond i feel that the west side is the forgotten side why former supervisors are claiming not squalling for a comprehensive planning study is an embarrassment when the Planning Department conducted the study in 2009 looking back at the impact of neighbors with the commercial zoning and the 20 years recommended Community Driven you updates control nothing was done im not going to allow that seven years has pads passed we need to take action the Richmond District is lucky that we have a valuable asset geary boulevard a wide street has a lot of potential to create housing but Infrastructure Improvements such power has to be in place the current sfmta plan for the business Rapid Transit is weak it fails to address the future housing growth and long term vision to have the underground that did west side will not be forgotten side if im elected i will be the immigrant that will represent the district our district is diverse with many long time residents and being an immigrant im sensitive to the needs of those residents are with limited english skills and make sure the issues effecting the city are communicated to the resident in their native language a member of the Bicycle Coalition were spending a lot of money on bike lanes and not addressed the need for secured parking throughout the city we need to encourage more secure parking and the only way that will be the only way that cycling will become angle alternative to driving with regards to building and Navigation Center in the richmond im opposed to it two key factors a mentally ill did moving the homeless to the Navigation Centers solve those problems where are they getting the drugs are we getting get rid of the drug dealers and future the lands for the Navigation Center is says and take a long time for neighborhoods my solution to have immediate heirs source that will bypass this process my solution is to create a vessel when you call a ship that already has cabins and bathrooms and kitchens in place this will be the real solution for providing shelter for the hopeless id like to have our vote im sam quan running for the richmond. High my name is marston im running for frifr in the responding district i was born in the responding and raising my three children i want them to live here right now i dont see that im running to seek family and keep working people in the city im with the Law Enforcement organizations firefighters and police and deputy sheriffs and proud to be enforced by fiance moss and District Attorney George Gascon and assessor recorder chiu, i have over 20 years of Public Services and for the last 10 years ive operated my business in San Francisco in strategy communicates and if you have any questions, well be happy to answer theming the affordability crisis is pushing out working people and widely agreement with the problem too many of us friends and neighbors are moving out of the city we love we need to talk about displacement and homelessness by protecting rentcontrolled units and build nor housing we have an Infrastructure Structure in the addressed specifically enough our budget is at a alltime high and doing better to invest in transportation and fixing potholes were spending a lot of money but need to generated nor solutions other than pollution evidence you find shattered gallows grace on the sidewalk we need to insure our Police Department is fully staffed and fined i feel that is an engagement of preview dialogue with the richmond Police Station my First Political mentor tom again and again said to me the first responsibility of a servant is to help the job of a supervisor is nonpartisan im not running as an activist too much city hall can be bogged down in a philosophical arguments it can get in the way even if nonpartisan such responding to constituent concerns around crime and parks and supporting our local Small Businesses i see government for people he started in the u. S. Capital working on labor, the environment and social justice and education had i returned to california i severed as Senior Advisor to the chief of staff in the office of gray davis then i worked on the president ial campaign senator john caring for a better california with successfully defeated stared anti labor and woman ballots 10 years ago he opened my Small Business in San Francisco running my business during the recession and raising three children with a challenge of a lifetime my business provides the needs to get my skids to school and creating jobs nor young people im running as Small Business owner and a working mom that bring the temperament needed to think about future generations and the direction of San Francisco our population is growing all over the place have a say and be that voice in settle we need sufficient housing to keep people in the responding and protect rent control the alternative is proven an environmental decrees for future generations im committed to running a good caption that, yes you can tackle those problems and, yes numerous responsibilities in the richmond yes, we can preserve that is special in the richmond that will make the right choices to this kind of and, yes we can have an rapid and effective respond from our resources im running as a leader that listens i hope youll join me hi my name is a over and over shall running for supervisor in district 11 our neighborhood have been treated as a forgotten part of the city your working families need a strong voice to represent them at city hall im that candidate as a parent of too Young Children and a long time neighborhood resident i believe i can be that voice im a trained city planner that believes that stes cities not involved are stagnated government must insure that all families are part of healthy evolution of ourselves we have a severe shortage of Affordable Housing and must do better in the private and government sector we have not seen any of the housing producing and relatively Strong Economy that helps to fund wonderful programs at the city and county level we must strive to make sure that all sectors are represent the single biggest on or about that sets me apart weve been doing the work on behalf of the district 11 ive been producing as candidate dont just us on what we say politicians like to make a lot of promises but what weve done this will tell you what kind of a leader im the only that fought the closure of hospital by serving on the Advisory Committee and led a revolt in 2008, that achieved improvements in balboa park and in the last seven years figure out four marijuana clubs more than any other residential neighborhood in San Francisco we have enough and access is not an issue currently im working to save the consortium a family serving daycare of 200 plus subsidized childcare and working with the nonprofit director to purchase the building once in office my top 3 priorities will be to as i stated before create nor Workforce Housing we have a sunshine ordnance of Affordable Housing, that can house working families my second priority to establish fully funded universal free care for all families in San Francisco question any is her that all sectors of our population are benls from a Strong Economy and that is where the chuch gap and finally make sure that we have a really strong commercial corridor and that our vacancies and empty storefronts are dealt with the highest vacancies in the city with that well increase our sales tax with more restaurants i thank you for your time and ask for your vote on november 8th please remember over and over shall if i he. Hello my name is june im a candidate for board of supervisors district 11 im asking for your vote because i am the most convicted candidate during 5 years worked for nonprofit organizations have the experience of collaborating with communitybased organizations in 2008, i began working for then california be Assembly Member tom ammiano as his district director he spent 6 years politically my skills to bring stockholders to address issues hung up with solutions for the common good and mobile at local and statewide as Assembly Member tom ammiano assistant i played a part in helping to Save City College california landmark antibullying bill that protects children bullied in california im currently the political director local 1025 and running for district 11 supervisor im commented to assure that under recommended communities have a vows in shelter in place the policies that impact them the Difference Community not San Francisco values have made our city a beacon they are stolen by the real estate speculators in the cities that haveized the cost of living in San Francisco to unbearable levels patrol car, immigrants, the lgbt community, our elderly and working people have that have been the backbone cannot afford to live here workers that are holding on live in fear theyll come home to eviction or no longer keep their homes theyve worked they are entire lives and want to share any journey i was born and raised from the Mission District my patterns were immigrants from mexico they met in the early 1960s at the restaurant any mom waltd tables and he worked for the Garbage Company they separated my movement raised me wheel working as domestic working and relying on public assistance after high school i studied at that particular time at kink of San Francisco while working at the nonprofit jobs during the day and blessed to get a sclirp at age 37 owe graduated any Life Experience and challenges of being raised by a single mom has driven me work as a Public Servant if you elect me to the board of supervisors my priorities will include creating incentives more Affordable Housing, especially for families fooekt unjust fevers supporting subdividing and prioritizing parks and open space, working for equitable sdwrks with residential Public Transportation in my district and free tuition for all san franciscans residents at city college, please joan the organizations that have endorsed me for the board of supervisors Transit Union local 155, American Federation of teachers 2123 the california nursing association, the united educators of San Francisco, the sierra club, the San Francisco Tenants Union staffed parent hood of Northern California Harvey Milk Club the International Brotherhood of electrical works local 6 and the National Union of Health Care Works and office of the San Francisco workers and the aclu and local 10 to one and local 2015 and the united works left local 483 thank you for your consideration. Handsome im sorry guz Anyone Running for district 11 im a School Teacher in Public Schools i teach owl i all projects and advocate for your children that have lack the health and lack of quality time together due to multiple jobs pr as a Community Advocate in district 11 i have that fined a Community Organization to address the needs of young people as a Community Advocate in San Francisco i reopened a closed Public School to address the needs of immigrant children and helped he families helping them with services and housing and jobs as an elected Union Official of teachers for seven years and elected delegates for educators owe supported resolutions and legislative billions for social just the district 11 is the largest number of children as other districts ill enhance the coalition are nonprofit and communitybased organizations and the city to allocate nor resources for our children when he talked to district 11 residents he hear one resident said we need a safe neighborhood a mom said he tried to help someone who was a victim only to have the gun pointed at me as youre next supervisor he want our citizens and nonprofit organizations to have dialogues to address safety and safe neighborhoods and to build trust 24 is how well help your neighborhoods your city and district 11 are aging the population will expand thirty percent of our population as a district 11 supervisory owe meet with many seniors and have the most profound respect i found seniors in district 11 some or inhabitant some can manage their homes some cant and some are commuters and are frustrated they cant afford the rent is as youre next supervisor a lot of mire Top Priorities to make sure that note neglected or solicited district 11 has their share of garbage and some residence of district 11 discard their garbage on the sidewalks as the next supervisor we want to come up with solutions the city has changed so much more cars and upscale common sense and parttime that displace as youre next supervisor he support qualified Affordable Housing for those who are in needs ive lived in San Francisco for 35 years my family lived in District Court 11 and my son graduated from Lowell High School and 25e7bdz the university of california, San Francisco i came to america with any family as an immigrant i studied. Working hard to be a natural citizen owe graduated in Illinois University in chicago in Multi Education and was awarded a scholarship last year elected to a union elected official and humblely ask you guzman to the board of supervisors he promise to serve district 11 with all my power and strength and humanity. Dear friends please image a San Francisco that you want to see that district 11 it is 679 to see the past we have to make this vision a reality for for those of you who dont know me, im here my family and i and kids and grandkids are raised here last year, he knocked it out of the park for the mayor of San Francisco and 10 thousand i remains runner up im here to ask for your vote to serve as your supervise in district 11 this represents excelsior, ocean view, i know side 0 and Outer Mission and others too along weve loudly investors and speculators to run this and control city hall the result a renewal uaw bull market tearing up the fabric of this city and displaced thousand of the san franciscans out of the city we now have families inth districts living in cars, sharing living rooms and garage spaces we work and live here is where we have the right to live here weve developed a platform to protect our families from unjust lectured evictions and produce more Affordable Housing for working families we will improve the health of those dealing with asthma in the district particularly in the Mission Terrace and satisfy the farm and deal with the flooding there support open space in the excelsior both on mission and geneva and make sure the development of the in line will support seniors and families at the same time make sure we can have a full Serve Grocery store in the neighborhood muni is an example i think of the health of district 11 because health is more than having access to medication or clinics it is being free and from anxiety by having a living wage enough money to buy food and pay for rents health is a clean part and save schools leak the great work and neighbors in action this is a pursued at the rec rec Centers Health is protecting our Small Businesses in the Outer Mission and dealing with the Noise Pollution of low underlying mr. Haneys plans education is not only for making it free but supporting teachers we need to find Affordable Housing to be teaching here as while as your supervisor i think continue to support the great afterschool programs we have last week the excelsior conceives project and in the Community Schools and the ymca programs on 0farrell we as a district have been away for far go long but making sure our families can flourish holding off on property tax on fixed incomes for people working that question, create with a new deal we are one of the last workingclass neighborhoods in the city completes draw the line for our families and Work Together to flourish in district health, education, and living wages job safety and vibrant Small Businesses the heart of the families in our district clean streets for Senior Citizens and children and working people secure Affordable Housing this is all part of liveability what i like to call a little bit of heaven in district 11 and people like minnie ward he fool in district 11 were the few weeks that can make a derivatives join me in this program thank you very [gavel] good rn