It Dan Gerstein News Today

Refuse to do that. please do not bother to call us up if you find an illegal alien in arizona because were too busy. that is an outrageous position, it will get slammed in the political debate because its common-sense people will just think it makes no sense and legally im not sure it will depend on the judges and the 9th circuit out there is very liberal, im not sure whether that position will stand up either. shannon: dan, what do we make of the two things that we hear, the federal government ...

Joining us now to talk about it dan gerstein who is a forbes columnist and former communications direct erbt for joe lieberman. fritz lowry. a fox news contributor. welcome, gentlemen. >> its going to be a short-lived victory in the sense that the politics are running the administration on this issue. there is a lot of sympathy for the arizona law. a lot of people -- people feel the immigration law is broken in this country. i think they will not gloat but buying time to try to find some kind of...

Law a couple years ago saying we can enforce at the place of employment, same claims, this preempts the scheme, you cant enforce this, the 9th circuit unanimously said yes you can. >> these are different circumstances. >> the states have a role in immigration enforcement. >> dan last word to you quickly. >> ill have rich have the final word on that. shannon: well work on our adjectives, thank you for coming in today. coming up next on studio b with sheppard smith. >> reporter: today well talk mo...