living on welfare are the norm and are passed on to the next generation and he said now on the last fourth generation east. is a good this is i don't think it's purely an east german phenomenon but it is partly of course there are also regions in west germany that have been hit by industrial decline and where there's also structural poverty. we should also perhaps take into account the brain drain that eastern germany has experienced if you will was many of those who were skilled well educated who can and want to work who have seen the world in my generation have deserted the east they're no longer there is real models for those who are left behind living on welfare there's no one to encourage or motivate the rest to try to take a different route. and for different those who have stayed behind feel excluded that society has failed them is this not also