Dozens of judges, and not all of them end their careers after reaching the age of 65, many are allowed to work further by age and health, but they prefer to leave as soon as possible from the system with honors, and not be dismissed for violations, because judicial resignation is not just a pension, it is the continuation of immunity and huge lifetime Cash Payments from the state, all of which, after 20 years of service, should only be received by the virtuous servants of themis, those who did not take bribes, did not abuse his position and adhered to the norms of judicial ethics, and in fact , those whose integrity is questionable often try to escape to an honorable retirement in order to make it impossible to investigate their activities, not to pass qualification assessment and to keep all the privileges of honorable discharge, we continue to tell about the judges who, instead of being prosecuted, this year was sent to an honorable retirement by the supreme administrative court. In april , lyudmila harnyk, judge of the Northern Commercial court of appeal, resigned. She was one of the first judges to take the initial qualification assessment and failed. In 2016, the judge was unable to confirm her professional knowledge and ability to administer justice. Qualification the commission sent her for retraining to the National School of judges. Even then, the members of the commission had a lot of questions about garnyks fortune. In 2014, 3 million hryvnias appeared in the judges accounts. She was never able to explain their origin. At first she said that it was from the sale of the apartment, but it turned out that she sold the apartment a year later. At the next qualification assessment, the version changed. Everything is very transparent, everything is very simple, i worked for 20 years, further, even more, i worked as a lawyer in odessa, my son after after graduating from the academy, i also worked as a lawyer and after coming to kyiv, i also worked as a lawyer , i worked in a womens colony, i already have 40 years of experience, and as a lawyer, and by the way, a leading lawyer in odessa, what does leading mean . A good lawyer. It should be noted that lyudmila garnyk has worked as a judge since 2002, which means that in 2014 she simply could not earn millions while performing the work of a lawyer. The position of a judge prohibits working parttime. Lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away, in an elite coastal village. Sovin in odesa, her income that was only wages. We filmed and posted this house as it looks, there is a really nice estate near mine. After moving to kyiv, harnyk, who, judging by the declaration, had considerable savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized the office apartment. I received the same apartment on chervonozorin, as a judge, from the state, and then you privatized it, privatized it, and we still use it. Lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, during the qualification assessment, she shares her thoughts. We we will not even comment on it, we suggest you just listen. Arrived, a very interesting thought. And why did i write a scientific article, if there is a decision that has gained legal force, then it is a precedential decision. You are a candidate of sciences, so you are a 10th year student, americans, they are more , pitiful towards their own, farmers , their own, here are such singles, there everything is aimed at helping this person, somehow this is the same, to get out from this situation, in 2016 the Qualification Commission recognized the professional level. Handsome is not enough for administration of justice and sent to study. For almost five years, the judge was deprived of the right to work, until march 2021. However, all this time you and i, as taxpayers, continued to support an unprofessional judge. She received her high judicial salary every month. From 2016 to 2020, lyudmila garnyk simply received a salary. Not doing justice and because she still couldnt pass the qualification assessment, as a result she still passed it, her fortune did not decrease. Judge ludmila harnyk resigned on april 27 in 2023. She retained the title of judge, and at the expense of taxpayers, that is, you and i will receive a lifetime allowance from the state in the amount of 50 to 100 of her judicial salary. Salaries, and this is the judge of the Shevchenkiv District Court of the city of kyiv, lidia shchebunyaeva. She resigned on april 25 of this year. The servant of themis is known for freeing oleksandr medvyd, accused of kidnapping and torturing activists of the revolution of dignity, Ihor Lutsenko and yuriy verbitsy, from prison. The latter was brutally killed. January 22, 14th year. Body verbytsy was found in the forest 500 m from the hnidyn petrivske road. The investigation established that Oleksandr Medvid personally participated in the abduction of activists from oleksandrivska hospital, after which they were transported to the suburbs of kyiv, where they were abused and beaten. Lidia shchebunyaeva passed the verdict, in which she expressed her conviction that yury verbytskyi died not because of the torture of medvid and his company, but because of the fact that. in the winter forest, lidia shchebunyaeva has a rather long track record, but most of all, she is probably for became known, due to the fact that it justified, in fact, did not see the burden of severe consequences, the infliction of physical pain, the consequences and death of the journalist verbytsy, an activist during the revolution of dignity, this and many other things, unfortunately, did not become the reason for the Supreme Council of justice to at least suspend consideration of shchebonyaevas resignation, at the time of the announcement of medvidys sentence on april 23, the case had already been pending for several years, and the statute of limitations for prosecution for the crime had coincided, so even though medvidy was found guilty, he was released from punishment at the same time. Also lydia. Shchebunyaeva tried her colleague from the pechersk District Court of kyiv, the odious maidan judge, viktor kityuk. In 2020, she acquitted kytsyuk, because she did not see the nature of the crime in his actions. The systematicity of such decisions is followed by the judge of the maidan, viktor kytsyuk, at one time , she acquitted herself by considering cases of judicial decision administered by the constitutional court, by the way. Recognized as unconstitutional even in a preliminary composition, but then, even before that, she also did not see the composition of the crime in the adoption of the wellknown judicial decision judge kitsyuk, who is also, well, probably one of the most odious kyiv judges , who persecuted activists during the maidan for traveling to mezhygiya, lidiyueva was transferred to the District Court of kyiv in 2015. Since 2003, she has been a judge of the khartsy city court of donetsk oblast. The interview with the higher Qualification Commission, the servant of themis, was held in closed session and she confirmed her suitability for the position. Property declarations indicate that the main income of the shchebunyaeva family since 2014 was the judges salary. Judge owns an apartment. In the donetsk region, and the place of her actual residence was indicated as kyiv, although her declarations did not include any housing in the capital, even on the terms of use. It turns out that, once again, judges who are actually playing against the state of ukraine, who let murderers go free, who let go judges who made decisions at the behest of president yanukovychs administration, we now eat them, instead of them suffering a just punishment, we will pay a lifetime cash benefit, which can reach up to 1000 hryvnias and more, depending on how much judges earned at their last job. And another judge with a dubious reputation, who was dismissed by the Supreme Council of justice with life imprisonment, at our expense, is oleksiy bryntsev, a judge of the Economic Court of the Kharkiv Region. In 2016, he participated in the competition for the supreme court, but received a negative opinion from the Public Council of integrity. The candidate is connected to political forces. The candidate reported incomplete information in the declaration of family ties. Candidate and members of his family own a significant amount of immovable property, the legality of which origin raises reasonable doubts. The Public Integrity council found that bryntsev is a former partner of expeoples deputy stepan havrysh, who in 20045 represented the interests of Viktor Yanukovych in the supreme court. And bryntsevas exwife served as an assistant to yury ivanushchenko, a peoples deputy from the party of regions. In 200615, the judges father, vasyl bryntsev, was a judge of the constitutional court. In 2010, as a member of the panel of judges, he recognized the constitutional coup as legal, in as a result of which expresident Viktor Yanukovych usurped power in ukraine. One thing is certain children are not responsible for their parents. However , the connection with political forces, especially prorussian. By no means indicates the integrity of the judge. Bryntsev took ownership of land in the temporarily occupied crimea, several houses and apartments, and nonresidential premises. In 2019, the Public Council of virtue found that during the three years of the war, the judge had crossed the border with russia more than 20 times. Bryntsevs father and mother also made regular trips to the russian federation. Exactly, well, they cant not to know the russian Border Guards and other representatives of the russian Law Enforcement agencies, why they let them in, how they let this person in, how and for what they did, what they exchanged security guarantees for, if the judge rides back and forth, or to the occupied territory, or directly on the territory of the russian federation, then clearly there is some kind of agreement between this judge, or this judge and the russian federation, what a person who is a representative of the ukrainian state does on the territory of our enemy, who decides. Decision on behalf of ukraine. With all this according to the track record of the judge of the Economic Court of the Kharkiv Region oleksiy bryntsev resigned on march 21 of this year. So, as we can see, the honorable dismissal of the servants of themis is not always a positive and fair phenomenon. Of course, the fact that unscrupulous judges stop administering justice is not a bad thing. However, when they retire, they retain the title of judge. And, accordingly , immunity from Law Enforcement officers, because a judge , even in retirement, cannot be detained without the permission of the supreme administrative court. They can participate in the administration of the judicial system and receive lifelong Financial Support from the state, from uah 100,000 per month. Therefore , such an option as honorable resignation should not be available to judges with a dubious reputation. As of today , i have everything, you watched judicial control, im tetyana shustrova. If you want to report corrupt judges or illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to this email address. See you in exactly a week. Good bye. The usual time, the usual tv channel, the usual host, my name is yuriy fizer, its monday, 1 14 p. M. , which means that espresso is on the air the Program World during the war, during which i and my guests will discuss the most important things that happened in the world, obviously with reference to ukraine last week, well, at least we are trying to look into the week ahead in order to. Be, well, at least we are ready, today there are many topics, more than two guests, lets talk, but before that, i want to remind all those who watch us on the youtube network, please put yours in favorites and write comments, it is very important for us, we want hear your opinion besides that very important for the promotion, our tv channel, our program in the complex algorithm of youtube, the more likes , the more comments, the more people will have the opportunity to see, in particular, the world at war program, so please, a big request to you, like it, so lets move on to the first topic that i chose to talk about today, lets talk about, the summit, the nato defense ministers meeting in brussels last week , which i was at, i was there, i saw it, but with my first guest, the executive the director for the sake of Foreign Policy ukrainian prism, hennadiy maksak, i want to talk about the aftertaste, mr. Vitaliy, mr. Hennadiy, i congratulate you, glory to ukraine, madam, congratulations, glory to the heroes, thank you very much for joining. Well, as i said just now, i was there, i saw what was happening inside, but i want to talk to you about the aftertaste, we have already passed five days, that is, we know what we agreed on, what is the benefit for us, what we have as a result, and the benefit is, first, we see that the agreement that was on the level the villeneuve summit on the launch of the ukraine nato council, it is working, we see that different formats, that is, we are already trying to understand for ourselves how we can reach a higher level of cooperation between nato and ukraine in all directions, therefore, the more we hold meetings on at the level of ministers of defense, at the level of our ambassadors, at the level of the minister of legal affairs, which is also planned in november, the more we will understand what topics are common to both, to both partners, and here it is important that right now this treasure is being filled with certain resources , certain committees, i. E. Its structure is increasing and this is one of the points , the other is what was really discussed in the fields about the onetime meeting of the support group for ukraine, vidomystein, there are agreements, there is confirmation of previous agreements, for us this is possibly a plus, because we see that despite the fact that there is now an escalation, a conflict in the middle east, and a certain amount of attention is diverted, nevertheless, the political signals that we heard, they say that ukraine is on the radar of both nato and the European Union and a partner that is part of the coalition ramshtein, that is why we should not worry that this could be a sharp decline or the redirection of wasted resources, just as we should not , so let our enemies not hope for that either, and for sure, let them not hope, mr. Gennady, please tell me well, at least there in brussels they said that the visit of president Volodymyr Zelenskyi was important, eh, do you have any information about that, and why was he so unannounced and so. Unexpected, because half an hour before Volodymyr Zelenskyi arrived at the headquarters there are no apartments at all ukrainian journalists present did not know about this arrival, why was it so unannounced . Well, lets not forget that we are a country at war and these are security measures, remember when gensex toltor came to ukraine, few people knew about it either, when he visited the Defense Industry forum and had meetings with our leadership, so i think that there is still such a moment here, on the other hand, i think that it was a reaction, a quick reaction. From our side, from the ukrainian side to what is happening in the middle east, and the alignment of the clocks predicted that it was, lets say yes, a lastminute visit, although i will probably have less hope for it, because here again, preparation is needed, but the fact that it was unannounced, security, plus, again, a change in the geopolitical situation in the region, well, during the press conference , with the secretary of defense of the United States of america, lloyd austin, and the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff, the new chairman of this committee, charles, charles brown, just said that it was very important that Volodymyr Zelensky arrived, because we heard him not on video, but we heard him live about what ukraine needs and how we can help, and its great that he was there and held many meetings, you already said about this ukraine nato council, you mentioned the ukrainenato council, that is , it works, but it works in order to speed up our, increase our chances and speed up. The moment of joining the north atlantic alliance. In your opinion, according to your estimates, how much time do we still need for this, obviously we have to wait until the end of the war, after the end of the war, how long does it take and for what we need to pay the most attention in order to become a full member of the alliance. Lets go back a little to the Vilnius Summit and look at the various packages that were provided to ukraine, this is again financial aid, this is a comprehensive aid package that includes certain humanitarian aspects, reforms, and so on. It was also signed there or the foundations of the interoperability plan were laid there, and i think that is the clue that we need to Pay Attention to, so that when the war ends in our victory, and our partners, nato allies will understand this, then the questions regarding the internal unpreparedness of ukraine, they were minimal , that is, our compatibility with nato standards, perhaps with new standards that appear in ukraine and to which nato must also adapt, it is also necessary to have in mind, and we have to close this moment for you, so i think that precisely the council of ukraine, nato and our annual program, which will be reformatted, are also currently consulting on what it will look like, and should already be in november final options and recommendations from the members of the alliance so that they want, so it is precisely our internal track as the rnp, the external track as the ukraine nato council, this is exactly what we can say, and it is important, in addition to the internal track, that i said that we now see that, come on, the council is a