The National School of judges for retraining. Even then, the members of the commission had a lot of questions about garnyks fortune. In 2014, 3 million hryvnias appeared in the judges accounts. She was never able to explain their origin. At first she said that it was from the sale of an apartment, but it turned out that it was her apartment sold a year later. At the next qualifying assessment, the version changed. Everything is very transparent, everything is very simple. I worked for 20 years. Further, even more, i worked as a lawyer in odesa, my son also worked as a lawyer after graduating from the academy and after coming to kyiv also worked as a lawyer, i also worked in a womens colony, i already have 40 years of experience, both as a lawyer and a leading lawyer in odesa, what does leading mean . A good lawyer, we note that lyudmila garnyk has worked as a judge since 2002, which means that she can earn millions by performing she simply could not work as a lawyer in 2014. The position of a judge prohibits working parttime. Lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away in the elite coastal village of sauvignon in odesa. Her income was only a salary. We filmed and posted this house as it looks, there is a really nice estate near mine. After moving to kyiv, harnyk, who, judging by the declaration, had considerable savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized an Office Apartment more than 100 km away. I own the same apartment on chervonozorin received, as a judge, from the state. Then it was privatized, privatized, and we still use it. Lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, during the qualification assessment, she shares her thoughts. We will not even comment on it, we suggest you just listen. I came to a very interesting thought, and why did i write a scientific article. If there is a decision that has entered into legal force, then it is at. Solution, you are a candidate of sciences, so since the 10th year, americans, they are more, pitiful to their own, farmers to their own, here are such singles, there everything is aimed at in order to help this person, as it were, to get out of this situation, in 2000, the Qualification Commission recognized harnyks professional level as insufficient for Judicial Practice and sent him to study. For almost five years, the judge was deprived of the right to work until march 2021. However, all this time you and i, as taxpayers , continued to support a professionally unfit judge. She received her high judicial salary every month. Lyudmila garnyk from 2016 to 2002, one can say, simply received a salary, without carrying out justice, and therefore that she still could not pass the qualification assessment, as a result she passed everything, her fortune did not decrease, judge lyudmila harnyk resigned on april 27, 2023, retained the title of judge, and at the expense of taxpayers, that is, you and i will receive a lifetime allowance from state from 50 to 100 of her judicial salary. And this is lydia shchebunyaeva, judge of the Shevchenkiv District Court of the city of kyiv. She resigned on april 20. 5 this year. The servant of themis is known for freeing alexander from imprisonment medvidy accused of kidnapping and torturing activists of the revolution of dignity, Ihor Lutsenko and yuri verbytsy. The latter was brutally killed. On january 22, 2014, verbytskyis body was found in the forest 500 meters from the hnidyn petrivske road. The investigation established that oleksandr medvid. Who participated in the abduction of activists from oleksandrivska hospital, after which they were transported to the suburbs of kyiv, where they were molested and beaten. Lidia shchebunyaeva passed the verdict, in which she expressed her conviction that Yury Verbytsky did not die because of the torture of medvidy and his company, and because he froze in the winter forest. Lidia shchebunyaeva has quite a long track record, but the most, probably, she stood for because of the fact that she justified , in fact, did not see them, severe consequences, discrimination of inflicting physical pain, consequences and death, journalist verbytsy, activist during the revolution of dignity, this and many other things, unfortunately, did not become a reason for the Supreme Council of justice to at least suspend the consideration of the issue of resignation, at the time of the announcement of medvids sentence on april 23, the consideration of the case continued several years already, and the statutes of limitations for prosecution for the crime have coincided, so even though medvidy was found guilty, he was released from punishment at the same time. Lydia shchebunyaeva also tried her colleague from the pechersk District Court of kyiv, the odious maidan judge, viktor kityuk. In 2020, she acquitted kityuk, because she did not see the nature of the crime in his actions. The system of such decisions of the judge of the maidan Viktor Kytsyuk is being followed, she once justified, by considering cases of supervised judicial decision, which, by the way, the constitutional court, in its preliminary composition, recognized it as unconstitutional, but then, even before that, it also did not see the composition of the crime in the judicial decision made knowingly by judge kytsyuk, who is also, well, probably one of the most odious kyiv judges , who prosecuted activists during the maidan for a trip to mezhyhirya, lidiyubunyaeva was transferred to the Shevchenkiv District Court of kyiv in 2015, since 2003 she has been a judge of the khartsy city court of the donetsk region. The interview with the higher Qualification Commission was held by the servant of themis closed mode and confirmed compliance with the position held. Property declarations indicate that the main income of the shchebunyaeva family since 2014 was the judges salary. The judge owns an apartment in the donetsk region, and the place of her actual residence was indicated as kyiv, although any housing in the capital was not included in her declarations. Even on the terms of use. It turns out that there are judges who actually play against the state of ukraine, who let murderers go free, who let go judges who approved decision by the command of president yanukovychs administration , we will now, instead of them suffering a fair punishment, pay them a lifetime monetary benefit, which can reach uah 1,000 or more, depending on how much. They earned at their last place of work. And another judge with a dubious reputation, who was dismissed by the Supreme Council of justice with a life sentence at our expense, is oleksiy bryntsev, a judge of the Economic Court of the kharkiv region. In 2016, he participated in the competition for the supreme court, but won negative conclusion from the Public Council of virtue. The candidate is connected to political forces, the candidate reported incomplete information in the declaration of family ties. Candidates, members of his family own a significant amount of real estate, the legality of which causes reasonable doubt. The Public Integrity council found that bryntsev is a former partner of expeoples deputy stepan havrysh, who in 20045 represented the interests of Viktor Yanukovych in the supreme court. And bryntsevas exwife performed duties assistant to peoples deputy from the party of regions yury ivanushchenko. In 200615 , the father was a judge. Bryntsev was a judge of the constitutional court. In 2010, as part of a panel of judges, he recognized as legitimate the constitutional coup, as a result of which expresident Viktor Yanukovych usurped power in ukraine. One thing is certain children are not responsible for their parents. However, the connection with political forces, especially prorussian ones, in no way indicates the integrity of the judge. Bryntsev acquired land in the temporarily occupied crimea. Several houses and apartments and nonresidential rooms. In 2019 , the Public Integrity council found that during the three years of the war, the judge crossed the border with russia more than 20 times. Bryntsevs father and mother also made regular trips to the Russian Federation. This is for sure, well , the russian Border Guards and other representatives of the russian Law Enforcement agencies cannot fail to know why they let it go, how they let it go. This person, how and for what they exchanged security guarantees for, if the judge rides back and forth, or to the occupied territory, or directly to the territory of the Russian Federation, then clearly there is some kind of agreement between this judge, or this and the Russian Federation, as to what a person who is a representative of the ukrainian state, who makes decisions on behalf of ukraine, is doing on the territory of our enemy. With all this track record, the judge of the Economic Court of the kharkiv region, oleksiy bryntsev , on march 21. Retired last year. So, as we can see, the honorable dismissal of the servants of themis is not always a positive and fair phenomenon. Of course, the fact that unscrupulous judges stop administering justice is already not bad. However, when they retire, they retain the title of judge and, accordingly, immunity from Law Enforcement officers, because a judge cannot be detained even in retirement without the permission of the supreme administrative court. They can participate in the management of the judicial system and receive a lifetime allowance from the state of uah 100,000 per month. Therefore , such an option as honorable resignation should not be available to judges with a dubious reputation. Today i have everything. You watched judicial control. I am tatyana shustrova. If you want to report corrupt judges or illegal decision, write to me on facebook or to this email address, see you in exactly a week, all the best, malta ukraine on mego, in the summer malta created problems for us, will ukraine be able to show not only a result this time, but also a spectacular game. Find out on october 17. At 21 45 on meego. I flew, flew, and the cough stopped me. Cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly. We do inhalation. Lord hyal is an inhalant for cough. Lorde hyal is a direct way to expel phlegm. Oh, sprained the back or joints. Flamides. Flamidez gel quickly reduces inflammation and treats pain. For pain in the back and joints flamides. There are discounts on coldrex 20 in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. There are discounts. 1 1 3 in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. There are discounts on zest of 50 on any second package with a check at travel bam and savings pharmacies. No matter what ukrainians think about, no matter what they talk about, war still comes first. War and our victory, only on espresso. From monday to sunday completely different fields of activity a person sports, health, politics, the return of crimea, military analysis, nine presenters, journalists, experts, opinion leaders. In real time, it is more relevant events through the prism of war in authors projects on espresso. Hello, this is svoboda ranok, an informational project of radio svoboda. Top guests every day. This is the shipping district of kherson live. We are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut. We tell the main thing. On weekdays at 9 00. Espresso is the september leader among Ukrainian Information channels. We hold the championship for six months in a row. I congratulate you, dear viewers, its time to learn about the most important thing. According to measurement data, viewers choose the ukrainian view from espresso. Congratulations friends, mykola veresin, Vitaly Portnikov, good health to all. We thank the ukrainians for their trust. Espresso works for you. Mykola veresen, Vitaly Portnikov and the main topics of the week. If , god forbid, a truly Tactical Nuclear weapon is used against ukraine, it will definitely change the world. Stories, issues, analysis and personalities. John herbst, the former ambassador of the United States to ukraine, is waiting for us. Good afternoon, do you have a question . You will get answers, also interesting questions, it is worth analyzing, sportnikov veresen, every friday at 21 15 on espresso. Vasyl winters great ether. Two hours of airtime, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what the world is about, two hours to keep up with Economic News and sports news. Two hours in the company of loved ones. Presenters, presenters, many of whom have become like relatives , as well as distinguished guests of the studio, events of the day in two hours, vasyl zimas big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people, in the evening on espresso, see this week in the program collaborators, traitors of show business, who entertain the russian public for bloody rubles, all the agony, all the harassment fall on the shoulders of, well, ordinary people. But who sings in ukrainian for the russian generals . Everyone was told that i was an enemy. Greetings, this is the Collaborators Program and i, olena kononenko. Todays issue is about migratory birds of show business, those who chose rubles, the russian public and popularity in orkostan. An artist of ukrainian origin who lives and performs in russia, todorenko regina petrivna, 33, comes from odesa. Reginas career. Ukrainian Television Began in 2007, when she became the presenter of the golden ten program. It was then that the producer and singer nataliya mogolevska saw her and invited her to the casting of star factory2. Todorenkos takeoff on the project was so successful that mogalevska invited her to the real all group. Four beautiful singing girls gathered platforms, received music awards for the best songs and music videos and high fees. Next was the star factory super final. After finishing the program , regina decided to leave the ro group in 2012 and build a solo career. In 2014, she became the host of the successful ukrainian travel show orel and reshka, paired with kolya syarga. Meet the new hero. Near serg and regina. Todorenko, they can do everything, catch fire, catch fish with ease, as it turns out later, todorenko can just as easily betray her homeland, keep silent and sell herself, while her former colleague kolya serga will defend our country with a machine gun country, but we will come to that later, todarenko began conquering the russian scene in the 15th year, when she took part in a project in voice on the first channel, where tina karol sang the song nochenka. Thats how she flew from our stage to the russian stage. She will shoot halfnaked in the russian magazine maxim and release a song, in ukraine she will again host the new season of the orel and reshka program. Until, in 2018, she finally moved to rashka, where some projects were launched. She wrote songs, took part in various shows, in general she was shining a light and cutting down women, forgetting about her native ukraine, the show is called a bluff, so they decided to call odesa in 2019, todorenko decided to remind about herself to ukrainians, to cry on camera and press for pity, in an interview with the famous putin propagandist ksenia sobchak, she said that she is being harassed for not having a clear position, and she hopes. That one day the flags of ukraine and russia will hang side by side, just uh, both, that artists often become a stumbling block in such cases, and this is true, and as it were, all the fire, all the harassment falls on the shoulders of ordinary singers, who often do not understand this all. What acting, what tears, but we dont believe what they say. First. Of a fullscale war, regina, sitting in her bed, closed her eyes and decided to remain silent, to live as if no rockets were flying at her homeland, as if her hometown was not being shelled, and people were not dying there, many colleagues in the shop from ukraine tried to reach her, which was very surprising to regina, here is a post on her telegram channel, which has more than 115 subscribers, dated february 26, 2022. Today , my friend, my close friend from kyiv, called me personally and asked me to organize a flash mob of mothers so that mothers and pregnant women would go to rallies. I have tears in my eyes, i confusion, it hurts. And its scary because of whats happening, now im in touch with my relatives, im afraid that theyll turn off the internet. Todorenkos relatives were in odesa at that time, and while this traitor was looking for words to call a war a war, the armed forces of ukraine protected her family in ukraine, and the zaprodanka remained silent and continued to post pictures with clothes on instagram, asking if the audience was interested in looking at her wardrobe, while the ukrainians were hiding in shelters. When it became known. That todorenkos exboyfriend died in the butch of hell, which was organized by the russian army, to exhost, now a military man, kolya serga tried to reach her with a video message. On behalf of regina, i am addressing all neutral bloggers on the territory of the Russian Federation, this is a war, there are no polutanovs here, you are either against or for, and even after that the singer did not begin to condemn the aggressor country. On the day when the rashists fired rockets at her native odesa, todorenk. Entertained with celebrities who support the russian invasion, for the voiceover of a book of her own authorship, the traitorous singer thought of calling putinist artists, valeria and filippa kirkoroova. Recently, regina mentioned her hometown, wrote to her followers on instagram that she was going to odessa someday. Oh, youd better sit in the swamps, we in ukrainian odesa dont need the cream rot. I note that todorenko has come under. Sanctions of the National Security and Defense Council of ukraine. We very much hope that the entire civilized world will be closed to this traitor, and she will be included in the sanctions lists of all european states, so that even her nose cannot put forward a traitor. Used to be on the side of truth thats why she chose the Russian Federation for herself. These are the words of the once popular ukrainian singer taisia ​​povaly. I carried my heart. Once she sang in ukrainian for us, but now she sings in the kremlin for the enemy. Taiya mykolaivna povaliy, 58 years old, native of kyiv region. At the age of 19, she began her professional career as a singer. During the time of independence, she received recognition and Many National awards. In 1997, povaliy became peoples artist of ukraine, and in 1998 she was awarded the order of st. Nicholas the wonderworker. In honor of orders, glory for loyalty to the motherland and st. Anna from uoc of the moscow patriarchate, with a song for the will of the thai government. At first, she took an active part in yanukovychs election campaign, and in 2012 she was elected to the Verkhovna Rada from the party of regions. I believe in you, Viktor Fedorovych and your team, i know you as a person of faith, orthodox. I really want politics in our country to become moral. It is difficult to imagine what kind of lawmaking activity povali was engaged in in the Verkhovna Rada, what she could do there, apart from pathetically wearing branded handbags and imitating a reasonable facial expression. In september 2014 the artist visited the state duma of russia, after which the Main Investigative Department of the ministry of internal affairs opened criminal proceedings against her under the article on encroachment on the territorial integrity of ukraine. After the escape of yanukovych , she left politics and at first actively toured the swamps and complained that she was uncomfortable in ukraine. There were problems with emigration, and people flocked to the border, everyone was made to think that i am an enemy, i am in my own country, and i am not comfortable. To his native land. Country, native country, song country, and labor. When on february 24 rockets from russia flew at ukrainians, the traitor taya did not even stutter about the atrocities on her native land. She packed up all her things , her old mother, and moved to rashka forever, until she was called to sing for the russian generals on victory day, for those who gave orders to bombard her homeland, this traitor even dared to sing in ukrainian. Let the clean path and Green Meadows of the Nightingale Grove bloom on it. After this shameful howl povaliy began to openly support putler, she told the socalled kremlin media that putin is ridding the world of nazism, that russias attack on ukraine is salvation. Now this traitor lives in two countries russia and sunny spain, she has a house by the sea there. By the decision of the National Security council, sanctions were imposed against her for a period of 5 years, and the singer was deprived of the title of peoples artist of ukraine. Another year. We really hope that soon the collaborators Spanish House will be used by the armed forces of ukraine, her entry to the developed world will be closed forever. And this is another silent traitor, Christmas Tree ivantsis real name is elizaveta valdemarivna. She was born in uzhhorod at the age of 41. The singer took her first musical steps as part of the uzhhorod band b b, but always dreamed of a career in moscow. In 2004, elizaveta moved to russia, but at first glance she retained warm feelings for ukraine. Here, in an interview with the russian channel moscow 24 , he corrects the host when he puts the emphasis incorrectly. Can a ukrainian artist be a ukrainian artist because he is ukrainian . Ukrainian, excuse me, excuse me, for gods sake, ukrainian. The artist continued to tour two countries, and from 2010 to 12 years was a judge of the vocal show xfakttor. It was the Christmas Tree that gave. A ticket to a musical life for dmytro monatyk, an unknown singer at that time. The singer argued today, yes. But since the 14th year, when russia annexed crimea and seized part of donbas, yolka stopped talking about ukraine in interviews. The singer did not mention her ukrainian roots and asked interviewers not to ask her questions about the war. On the eve of february 24, the singer had time to give a concert in kyiv, and when it started. Massive russian offensive army, she suddenly lost the gift of speech. Not a word about the war, the death of thousands of ukrainians , the tragedy in buch, irpen and azovstal, the language was loosened only for russian wooden rubles. In the spring of 2022, this traitor performed in sochi, where she did not hesitate to perform a provence song, which mentions boryspil airport, which the russians began to attack in the first hours of the war. Today , despite the war in her native country, the singer continues to live and perform in russia, yolka has a large threestory house 500 km away from moscow. An Observation Deck on the territory, a swimming pool, a gym and a music studio, yolka never spoke about the war in ukraine and did not condemn the aggressor country russia, and silence is a sign of agreement. Soon our armed forces will liberate ukraine from the invaders, and i will say this to putins outlaws, all of you sad musicians should remember this. The occupiers should be held accountable for the concerts, even though you really liked the kremlin rubles and you were forever ashamed of the betrayal of ukraine. Join the creation of the Collaborators Program. Send information about kremlin sellers to us at facebook or on. Email, lets send them together to track the russian ship, see you in a week on espresso. On the air from washington, the program of the ukrainian voice of america chas and i maria prus, congratulations. The us continues to support israel in its efforts to protect its people, state secretary Anthony Blinken said. Now he is visiting telviv again, where he met with defense minister yoav gallant and Prime Minister binyamin netanyahu. Gallant stressed that it would be a long war, and the price of victory would be high. The white house said that us President Joe Biden received the latest information on the situation in israel from his National Security team. Israel continues. To a largescale ground operation to destroy hamas militants in the gaza strip. The un calls for immediate humanitarian aid to the civilians of gaza, who have found themselves there without food, water and medical supplies. At the parliamentary