Peeps or Cadbury Creme Eggs: Easter’s ‘Godzilla vs. Kong’ Updated Apr 03, 7:00 AM; Posted Apr 03, 7:00 AM Do you go for Peeps or Cadbury during Easter season? Or neither? (Ben Flanagan / AL.com) Facebook Share Which is the best Easter candy? Peeps or Cadbury Creme Eggs? Neither? Can’t decide? It’s tough. Easter is right up there with the best seasonal candy offerings, with several we’d consider top dogs, er, bunnies (chicks?). For me, there’s a clear top five: Peeps, Cadbury Creme Eggs, Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs, jellybeans and the classic chocolate bunny. A recent study shows these five remain the top sellers, too, with Reese’s eggs on top, followed by jellybeans, Cadbury eggs, chocolate bunnies and Peeps.