When Antonio Gonzalez Jr. died in his home, about an hour south of Erie, the 14-year-old weighed 92 pounds and had two black eyes. His father had waited about 10 hours to call the police. It turns out, he had beaten and starved the boy. Social workers visited the Gonzalez family in the years before Antonio died. Police had as well, but his family slid through the system, despite the teenager’s thin frame and the squalid conditions in which they lived. He was enrolled in cyber school when he died, hidden from the view of anyone outside the family. On the final day of his life, he was hosed down by his father and left on a tarp, where he complained of not feeling well. His father threw a bucket of water on him and left him there.