This last year the prop q with the tent ban would have been a good opportunity. The police are like they are to be offering housing. There is no housing. Right now people are asking officers, well, prop q went through, you are to give me a notice and an offer of services. That is not happening. There arent any services to offer. Yes, we need to look at the Bigger Picture and look for solutions. I have 30 seconds. We were looking with the library a while back, a couple years back, and we were advocating for social workers. Within the first year incidents decreased 50 percent. That speaks a lot. When you are going with the right solutions. The citations bottom line they dont work, it doesnt work. Thank you. President turman thank you. Any other Public Comment . Public comments is now closed. Item 7 Public Comment on all matters pertaining item 9 below including whether to hold item 9 in closed session. We are about to go into closed session and consider personnel and other litigation related items. Is there any comment about us going into closed session . Okay. Seeing none. Public comment is closed. Secretary kilshaw. Administrative code action. President turman we are to go into closed session to consider several items. I will entertain the appropriate motion. Moved and seconded. All in favor. Any opposed . Members of the public we thank you for joining us for the first part of the open session of the San FranciscoPolice Commission meeting. We we are back on the record in open session. You still have a quorum. Please call the next item. Item 10 discussion on item 9 held in closed section. I move not to disclose. President turman second. On the question arent we prohibited from disclosing this no matter if we want to or not. We have to make this motion. President turman moved and seconded all in favor. Any opposed . All right. Next item. Item 11 adjournment. President turman members of this commission tonight we close the book on the commission in 2017. We are concluding our calendar for the year and we will be back on january 10th. It has been a challenging year, it has been a hard year. But we accomplished much and there is still a lot to do. Lets work as productively together as we have been able to do in the past. I look forward to working with all of you in 2018. 2018 in one capacity or another. And i thank you for all of your time and attention to the commission and to the goal also of serving the people of the city and county of San Francisco. I want to thank you and the commissioner for your leadership. It is a difficult year. We do what we have to do. I want to thank you for your hard work. And we hope you get well. Thank the chief, too. All in favor of adjournment. Aye. I will make a motion to adjourn. Second. I vote no. I will go with the majority. President turman all in favor. Any opposed. Thank you. We will see you on january 10th. Left right halt i had a burning doorway to do the right thing and join the department such this we my brother applied and fortunately well here and this means a lot im home everyone night to study and we workout together and it is a blessing i have a brother to go home and fed off of one another were the twins but pretty much were not treated and individuals sometimes treated as a item if he did something wrong they use the word instead of you the it heroism were going our our separate ways and good morning our own individuals middle of steadfastly a twin all the it but inside of the district ive seen negative and positive things and with that made me want to be a Police Officer i want to give back and do public serve always a class president i dealt with everyone and served my class not only be humble enough to serve my class and pierce being a squad leader is a responsibility of maintaining my squad and being that voraciously person i need to step up to the challenge i believe during the 8 months i fulfilled any dude and after graduation just be a good officer to learn the skill and profession and give to the community to give the best to them and be a helpful hand thats the main thing and the new people coming into the did not know why youre doing it join the department for the right reason and do it to help the community and it is sharing youre time when you get into the department do is commented to the craft and enjoy it along the way enjoy it along the way i encourage you to talk about over with our families and talk 2 over with yourselves ultimately youll do the job and find a senseably reason for doing it after the hard work everyday for 8 months straight and finally it pays off and you know as honey honor and privilege not anyone can do this job i look forward to getting often the street and learning and hit the ground running it will be a surreal moment day one i thought months here but sat down me and my brother talked about it and were on the right track and stay focused and walking tloo across the stage is a huge honor ever wonder about programs the city it working think to make San Francisco the best place to work and will we bring shine to the programs and the people making them happen join us inside that edition of whats next sf sprech of Market Street between 6th is having a Cinderella Movement with the office of Economic Workforce Development is its fairy godmother Telegraph Hill engaged in the program and providing the reason to pass through the corridor and better reason to stay office of Economic Workforce Development work to support the economic vital of all of San Francisco we have 3 distinctions workforce and neighborhood investment i work in the tenderloin that has been the focus resulting in tax chgsz and 9 arts group totally around 2 hundred thousand square feet of office space as fits great as its moved forward it is some of the place businesses engaged for the people that have living there for a long time and people that are coming into to work in the the item you have before you companies and the Affordable Housing in general people want a safe and Clean Community they see did changed coming is excited for every. Oewd proits provides permits progress resulting in the growth of mid businesses hocking beggar has doubled in size. When we were just Getting Started we were a new Business People never saturday a Small Business owner and been in the bike industry a long needed help in finding at space and sxug the that is a oewd and others agencies were a huge helped walked us through the process we couldnt have done it without you this is sloped to be your grand boulevard if so typically a way to get one way to the other it is supposed to be a beautiful boulevard and fellowship it is started to look like that. We have one goal that was the night to the neighborhood while the bigger project of developments as underway and also to bring bring a sense of Community Back to the neighborhood. We wanted to use the says that a a gathering space for people to have experience whether watching movies or a yoga or coming to lecture. That sb caliber shift on the street is awarding walking down the street and seeing people sitting outside address this building has been vacate and seeing this change is inspiringing. Weve created a space where people walk in and have fun and it is great that as changed the neighborhood. Oewd is oak on aortas a driver for San Francisco. Weve got to 23ri7b9 market and sun setting piano and it was on the street weve seen companies we say used to have to accompanying come out and recruit now theyre coming to us. Today, we learned about the office of Economic Workforce Development and its effort to Foster Community and make the buyer Market Street corridor something that be proud of thanks to much for watching and tune in next time for good afternoon, everyone. A call to order of the meeting of the San FranciscoPublic Utilities commission for today, tuesday, december 12. Madame secretary, roll, please . [roll call] and we have a quorum. So, before we get started, today is actually a very sad day for the city and county of San Francisco and in honor of our late mayor, ed lee, id like to ask everyone to stand if we can observe a moment of silence in his honor. Thank you. Before we enter Public Comment, i wanted to send my condolences to many of you, especially harlan, i know you were close with mayor lee. If there is any day to wish for fake news, this was it. I think were all very stunned. So, i want to announce closed session items 25 to 31 will not be heard today. As were going to approve the minutes of november 14. Can i have a motion to approve those minutes . So vote. Second. Any discussion . Any Public Comment related to the minutes of november 14 . All in favor, do approve . Aye. Opposed . Ok. Approved. Id like to call forward Public Comment and i have two gentlemen here. First is peter jakemier for Public Comment. Good afternoon. First im really sorry about mayor lees untimely death. A real tragedy for the city. In reading the sfpucs week in review that ended on december 1, a couple of things jumped out at me. First was conditions at the reservoir. There were two significant storms this season. Approximately 32,000 acre feet of water available to the city. 4 of our annual average accumulation. So, that would mean the average annual accumulation is 815,000acre feet. Ill come back to that. Second was an item economic value of water in u. S. Metropolitan areas. And this is a study done by the Bay Area CouncilEconomic Institute. And this is the analysis builds on the Bay Area CouncilEconomic Institute report. The impacts have reduced the bay area water supply prepared in response to the Water Quality control plan. I looked that up and awas kind of shocked by the poor analysis that says the Bay Area CouncilEconomic Institute looked at the impacts of 30, 40 and 50 unimpaired flow requirement on the river would have on bay area water users under the 175 million gallon per day scenario. The draft s. E. D. Could lead to water supply shortfalls during dry years. Regional Water Supplies would be reduced to as low as 67 million gallons for day from 175 million gallons per day during dry year such as 1991, 1992. Im assuming they misquoted the sfpuc. Seasonerly you want to look into that. May made the same mistake that the bradle group has done, which is based rationing on demand versus supply. For example, if you make 265 a day and you only spend 175 a day, you put 90 in the bank. If you get a pay cut of 90 a day, that comes from your 265, not from your 175. So back to the sfpuc water available. It was 815,000 acre feet per year. 175 million gallons per day is the equivalent of 196,000 acre feet. 67 million gallons per day is the equivalent of 75,000 acre feet. So, the 67m. G. D. Figure they used, in storage, in the sfpuc has enough water in storage to last 16 years at 67 m. G. D. So that is a hard core design drought that theyre apparently planning for and in the march report they basically said the method used to estimate impact was [bell ringing] 2014 report which we commented on and found a lot of reports aen are disappointed that that didnt get changed. Thank you. Thank you. Next item, mr. Dave warner. Good afternoon. I came up here on cal train and we stopped between station for a minute at 12 00 noon to pay our respects to mayor lee. So im dave warner. Im concerned about the delta bay ecosystem. One of the many great things ed lee was known for was unification. What a great quality that is and dont we wish we had more of that in washington. So, one place where San Francisco has a lot of unification is in environmental issues. And 70 of San Franciscoians voted to protect themselvess to protect the bay dell tafm im sure you heard of this before. But it is an astounding number. Three out of four people voted if favor of taxing themselves for environmental issues. My point is, then you know the sfpuc opposes the state water boards plan. And you know the sfpuc has taken a minority view amongst scientists that the ecosystem can be protected by nonflow measures. And you know the sfpuc has been posing what i would say a false tradeoff thats either the water or the economy thats at stake. And to me there are many, many more options than that. So, my point is a request is id really ask you to ask the hard questions of your staff. Dont accept either or answers. Have rigorous debate that you fully understand the implication and judge whether or not it reflects the will of the people and it is also important to ask what is the will of the people . Sure they want water, but that answer is probably too simple. I go to my conclusion, which is my understanding is that for having a water supply, we are second to none and that is a really nice accomplish. Ment. But that is maybe only half the job. When 85 of our water comes from severely damaged ecosystem. So, that is the reasons that they ask these hard questions in our meeting of the will of the people. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other members of the public who wish to comment on items not on todays agenda . Ok. Next item, please. Item five is communications. Sorry. Communications. Communications . Yes. So you or me i dont have any questions. Any comments . No. Ok. Any Public Comment on communications . All right. Next agenda item. Item six is other commission business. Commissioners . Ok. Is there any Public Comment . All right then. Item seven is report of the general manager. All right. Thank you. Yeah, commissioners. This has definitely been a hard day for me. Ive been friends personal friends with the mayor ed lee for over 20 years. I worked with him when he was h. R. C. Director. I worked with him when he was the city purchaser. I worked for him when he was the director of public works and i worked with him when he was city administrator. He is very collateralize to the family. In fact, he was a groomsman in my wedding and so when i received the call, i was definitely in disbelief. I arrived shortly after his passing at the hospital and, you know, i helped the family out as best i could. And naomi is, you know, working with the family to figure out what their wishes are. It has been a rough year for me we some other folks passing away, including my mom in february. Needless to say i cant wait until this year is over. [chuckling] but other than that, lets talk about government and the government must continue and so the one thing i want to first topic is clean power s. F. , barbara hill. Thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners. I have quick updates on three clean power s. F. Topics, enrollment and service, contracting for our growth, and our legislative and regulatory activities. Our enrollment continues to go smoothly. We have successfully we are a successfully serving about 80,000 Customer Service sites today. Our opt out percentage is 3. 2 , so super low and our upgrade rate continues to exceed our optout ray. Its 4 for our customers now. That is a snapshot on who were serving today. Looking ahead are our next small enrollment will be january 2018. Were notifying customers now. Less than 1 of those customers who are receiving notice now have decided to opt out. We have 120 customers on the wait list now for our next enrollment in the spring. 56 of those customers are asking for super green service. So, if you are listening and want to enroll, go to cleanpowersf. Org enroll to be included in our next enrollment. In terms of our growth plans, we are contracting both for supply and for the bank credit facility. For suspect mraou, were testifily negotiating our final contracts with the short listed counterparties. Those contracts are for both new and existing Renewable Power and the energy to firm and shape it. And for our bank credit facility, the finance team is working to finalize the contract terms with j. P. Morgan for our bank credit facility. We will bring recommendations to the commission on both of those contracting efforts for a vote early in the new year. On legislative activities, consistent with your vote on november 14, i believe it was, an ordinance was introduced at the board requesting the board of supervisors provide a limited, delegated authority to the p. U. C. To enter into supply contracts to support completion of our program. The delegated authority would include annual expenditure limits and conditions that the Commission Imposed on the general manager. The item is scheduled to be heard this week tomorrow, i believe at a special meeting of the budget and finance committee so well be presenting there in support of that item. And regulatory activities. I just wanted to mention that our annual usual adjust tonight the exit fee, the pcia, will be delayed this year so there wont be a new pcia on january 1. It will be delayed for at least 30 days. The california Public Utilities commission has not provided a proposed decision on that. In time for it to be implemented january 1. So, we expect there will be a proposed decision issued soon. And that there would be a new pcia some time probably in january. So that was kind of an interesting wrinkle to the pcua issues. With that, im happy to answer any questions you may have. Thank you. May i ask a question . What was the reason for the postponement for pcia .