Coal industry report toilets only going social and economic disadvantages among former mining communities it was commissioned by the coal fields regeneration trust Professor Steve full video led the research at the core issues about jobs and the economy but it's not just about how many jobs increasingly it's also about what kinds of jobs coalfields and you'll sure in the Midlands for example have been very successful attracting a lot of new warehousing jobs but many of these are not very well jobs with very good terms and conditions and average of 5 weapons related incidents it's a thing place in schools every day according to figures obtained by the Press Association the vast majority involve no ifs with the 1200 cases reported in England and Wales in the 2 and a half years in the Spanish government says the minorities trying to impose violence in Catalonia the more clashes between police and protesters who are angry at the jailing of that pro independence politicians the survival of news Casey has discipline and in limited failed to join hands and said they wanted to Mabel Garion fans suffer by thrashing the team on the pitch in the year a 2020 call it it's often racist abuse all the England players by home fans in Bulgaria is now investigating whether President Alexander's Shefrin says they're committed to eliminating the disease of racism in football and he's insisted thoughtful associations camel solve the issues align elsewhere Republic of Ireland Lost Tales to Switzerland in Geneva in the qualifier Lenny at the end Cassius go to hattrick as a Under 20 one's maintain the 100 percent winning record in Europe 2021 qualifying a.b. Austria 5 in cricket over 560 players have registered to be part of the men's draw for the new e.c.b. 100 competition Chris Gayle Steve Smith and David Warner are among those from outside the u.k. With England well Cup winners mock wood and Liam Plunkett. Also lining up a live stream of the dross available on the b.b.c. Website and app from 7 pm on Sunday evening and speeds gates at least Kristie will not compete until January health she posted on social media saying the past few years have been some of the most challenging and deflating of her life this is b.b.c. Radio 5 Live on digital b.b.c. Sal It's small space. In the north and east will continue to move east through Wednesday with many places rolling out later elsewhere sunny spells but with a few showers in the West today of 12 and 16 face things. Really. Anyone else. Please please keep us in. The Premier League is probably like this week a pleasing funny blights Premier League Sundays this is 5 I. Bought it on Am and f.m. Around the u.k. Are digital and on law and I'm rod shop were up all night well it's over relieved viewers for American cable t.v. Networks and people be shooting at on their phones go back to the Twitter of our shore simply playing video games for the pleasure of not seeing anyone who says when I am elected president of the United States trial candidates for the Democratic nomination appeared on stage in Ohio and tried to differentiate themselves one dominates of the time speaking more than anyone else one tried to moderate his soft image by aggressively critiquing opponents ideas one appealed for more unity leading some to conclude he's really positioning himself as a vice presidential pick one remained vigorous as if to reassure supporters were. For us how. The parents of Hi Don The teenager killed in a road crash involving an American diplomats wife and Northamptonshire in August I met President Trump the White House seems the president also wanted to introduce them to the woman in question on Soko us and of the Taishan which they pointed Lay declined they were also told I'm a sicko this will not be returning to the u.k. Shortly after that White House meeting I spoke to Rod Sego the spokesman for his mom and dad of 3 of them got on the train back to New York I asked Mr Siegel how the meeting came about we've been doing a number of television appearances over the last couple of days but this morning today. I got a message to say that. The White House wanted to reach out to us so we didn't really have any intention of. Of meeting today with President Trump but we we were encouraged to do so and so we we changed our plans and helped our other 1st train we couldn't travel down to Washington and could face to here to meet with him and. How is it we're just we're just we're just gathering our thoughts obviously if we walk away from it. To say that we. Are a bit taken aback by what's happened would be a gross understatement because. As we traveled away from it clear it was just because after 6 grieving parents and he was quite warm and very charming and extended his condolences Surely after we all sat down he said that he has this effect of us of extra. And it has got to be my fear that he was going to try to. Babblers said some way with something that would was going to suit him and you know which are your the reality is run which is where the parents are just not ready to make the sun close one day they would like to you know to have to go through therapy and it also has to be in a controlled environment where there are perhaps mediators chair at the surrounded also but you build up to perhaps a handshake or even a heard. Extraordinary rock for the person to sit down and look at these people say oh she's in the next room she'd like to see you. But I just can't quite believe what I've just come away from. I'm not sure what better any of the medical experts would say about the freezer party to just spring it on as it was that wasn't made clear to us this morning is that the president just wants to see you once you come up if you're available. If it's said to have Mrs suckle as I would have said no to the meeting. Just honestly right it's very difficult Syria. To predator to put it any better than that I mean quite quite quite extraordinary how. Did this meeting take. Well. I think I ended up at it cutting it short so I would sort of estimate brought the somewhere between China in 15 minutes. I'm guessing and once I saw the the route that we were going down not to have a discussion about taking such a bus back which we are always on the train right down we were quite excited and relaxed and once I saw what he was. I just wasn't going to let it happen so I think what he realized we were going to play a game. He created or to talk to us any further and hear a comment was made by actually a chap called Robert or Brian. As I understand is the head of national security when Charlotte said she all she wanted was Mrs cyclists to come back and he said in a quite understood why why she's not coming and that's what I thought well but you know we're not here for a fight we know the Americans are not going to have her come back willingly and that's what I said well that there's just not much point in carrying on but to her credit as we were walking out of Charlotte to turn around and speak to President job again and she'll still tell the story so but the words that are heard were that you're a parent if you're in the same things that are doing and he did say yes I will. And then he did order the words Let me see if I could push it from a different angle. Aaron Schock center and then we left and I think some of us saw the group as I walked away from that feeling that actually that was a step forward for those of us who are of course who study. Presidential Daily know that he's he has a tendency to say things but sometimes doesn't always follow through on on his promises. You know we as a group we need to reconsider. The exchange or views that I brought I just it's just it was just an extraordinary meeting. To start when when you when you saw him and when he said I've got Mrs sackless in the next room what did you think he was going to do to Jews and he was going to try and engineer some sort of kiss and make up meeting. Absolutely and when I look to my left and I saw at least 3 photographers 3 photographers in the room I attend dawned on me that what he was trying to do was just to pull stunts. Maybe I shouldn't be unfair about his bike but you know we know that sometimes he likes to do things the back him but was he going to bring these 2 people together and shake hands and her with him standing there and the photographers taking pictures and he could say to the world look at me art are wonderful about these 2 people back together again and don't worry about her going back to the u.k. To face the justice system it's all done and you know it's the other thing that was upsetting was they tried to prevent me from going into the room I was I was a shelter to one side by 2 or 3 other large element of a large pressed by cell and then I found myself in a completely different room to them and I got up and I said No I know what you're doing and I quickly found the. Again I convinced that if I had been in the room he simply would have probably sacristan and I you know he's good people maybe they were to have the wearer of a stand up to he's a large man I didn't appreciate the 6 the 3 and very bruising and you know I just you know just honestly Rod I sort of feel not deflated because I'm not surprised. That there were no further forward. She you know it was obvious there were to you've said there were 3 photographers in the room there were there were 2 bodyguard types Was there anyone who reminded you of a State Department lawyer or anybody representing the state of Ohio for Mr sackless works I said I didn't recognize anybody the only person that I recognized was Mick Mulvaney is the chief of staff. There's a Robert O'Brien there's you know it's not something I've tried to do it but it was subsequently told that he's the head of National. Security. So there I didn't recognize anybody from the State Department and. I guess you know ideally if we could have just had a frank exchange of views why do you think that she should not come back to u.k. We could have given our theories and you know maybe just agree to disagree but maybe reconvene that was not his intention quietly there or not letting her come back and. Maybe we were naive to think that other trade right and that maybe there was the possibility of. You know when you it's not every day but one gets a call to come down to the White House drop everything come down to the White House and maybe in the back of our minds we sort of felt or maybe they were somewhere but the broader with you say you know whether your listeners have seen it we mounted a incredibly successful p.r. Campaign out here it's a little orphan Harry his name seems to be everywhere and everybody is stopping at a lot of people stopping us and giving us support but I just wondered whether the court of public opinion had brought some pressure to bear on the administration and that she was going to go back. It's clear to us now that we're going to have to maintain the pressure through our through our campaign and. We're committed to do that we will do that as long as it takes and that we have got let you go but it's going to change her image. Not at all not at all it's only going to cause us to redouble our efforts and as we keep saying until she's back in the u.k. We are not going to stop fighting for Harry and make sure that we get justice for him we will not let his party trusting be and rain. Well I was a spokesman for the family of how they done ride Seeger who was charging at that point with Charlie Charles and Tim Dunn who will expect to hear from. Their trip to the United States goes on. While the debate took place tonight in Ohio between 12 contenders who all want to be the Democratic candidate for the Preston say of the United States really you say a debate between 12 people how did that work well here someone who actually sat through it that's John Nicholls political writer for The Nation Hello John Hello Rod It's good to be with you that it good to have you with us well how did it work coming 12 people on the stage horribly really yeah it was 6 years chaotic it was unfocused it was disorganized it was ill served by the moderators who. Seemed like every time the debate covered it to get maybe a little bit interesting for the candidates really start to go at each other the moderators jumped in civil war will have none of that. And so what what ended up and without a lot of talk about hears about this you know dismissed it there but it ended up with it wasn't a coherent arc. In this debate it went in that so many here at the direction I don't really blame the moderator so much when you have 12 candidates this is the largest number of candidates we've ever had on a stage. 12 candidates going at each other you know all with their different strategies and you're Twining to focus on it will fast. Numbers of various foreign policy opioid crisis health care you know who they are what Republicans they like you know use it so many different question it doesn't work it doesn't work what they ought to do is have debates that are focused on one major topic and the war and peace or climate crisis and then kind of keep circling back into that well it's not just just take the example you mentioned climate crisis was anything said about the climate crisis something we will I think here you go. Pretty big issue. And it's clearly mentioned now Tom Styer the American billionaire who's focused a lot of his energy and climate issues and you know I don't think it's unfair to him to say that he sort of bought his way into this debate he has spent a fortune in the last few months you know trying to move him as a presidential candidate trying to move his poll numbers up he's been very focused on climate change and when they got to him at a certain point he brought it up but instead of saying the moderator saying oh you don't want loud we really blew it there we should have brought this up sooner but as some of the other candidates about it to just sort of let it die was tired and moved on to something else. And that I guess that's the challenge I felt in this debate we sort of crashed into the reality of so many candidates. Going in so many different direction it frankly. You know I don't to some too negative because there it is and midst of it were dramatic moments and important moments and of course as you know Rod most people learn about debates not from sitting through 3 hours which is what it was today. But from the clips that you see our social media or on the new tumor or whatever give us the drama this is all full to do is do this to you but we don't have C.E.O.'s either so. Does somebody have a go or somebody else what was the drama oh yeah yeah there was a there were some dramatic moments clearly the fact that Elizabeth Warren has of merged as something of a front runner She's a very closely tied with Biden at the top of this race right now led a number of people to go after her including intriguingly and up Biden who isn't usually very gracious to the other candidates and at one point Biden was going out of saying he was the only person ever really accomplished anything he's listing all this stuff that had happened during the Obama administration when he was vice president a lot of people don't think that's particularly credible they think Obama paid them for that by. Both sides going down the list and as certain points. It was a corn kind of ups and says you know that he or she also did some stuff and he's like really very sharply said oh yeah you were good at your job. Or something that paraphrasing a little bit but it was quick to sell him but dismissive. Yes And so that was that may be the one that the more people take away than anything else but there were lots of other clashes there was a real back and forth on the issue of health care reform and it's interesting that people who judge who's a rising candidate in many of the primary and caucus states his poll numbers put him in a strong 4th place just behind Bernie Sanders he was definitely trying to make a name for himself here and so he very much went after lives before and Bernie Sanders for supporting a Medicare for all single payer health care plan and really pushed him and they pushed back so you had some questions on that but interesting Lee enough I would argue the most dramatic moment of the debate may well have been not a clash between 2 candidates but a candidate dealing with a reality that had to be dealt with and that was Bernie Sanders returning to age so why was he weeks after. Boy. I think that stance work at. Any came on very strong and intriguingly enough Here's the 3 hour debate you get a 78 year old guy 2 weeks after a heart attack he can't fill in the strongest moments in the last hour. Totally seem to be very much there and there was a fascinating moment where there was a discussion about the opioid crisis a huge issue United States. And a number of other candidates were talking about it they're doing fine they're saying important things and thoughtful things about how to handle it how to respond to the pharmaceutical companies and then the moderator or Erin Burnett was going to try to shift to a discussion about health care and clearly that was going to go to her centers and she sort of trying to shift it and Bernie Sanders says no I'm going to answer something related to that last discussion and Erin Burnett was saying then I know it's one of our senator I want to kind of get on to some of these other issues and Sanders was insistent and I know I really want to say something about that last discussion and and and and she mentioned something about health and he said My health is fine I'm feeling great but I just want to get into this other I want to get into some of these issues and the way he said it was so strong come frankly so good humored that the crowd laughed in applauded it Burnett herself smiled and said Ok go ahead and and he ripped into an answer tacking freighted really ripping into the pharmaceutical company. Describing executives and pharmaceutical companies as bad players and finishing off saying this is what on that or capitalism does to you and anyone into other companies and in abundance it. He kind of rips through all the corporate sector ending up with this message is this is why we need a political revolution and I have to tell you it had all the energy and the vibrance of what turned people on to him back in 2016 so he had a quite a remarkable moment there had a good and a good time let me then ask you John just finally if you're the Suppose for a minute that it wasn't just you know policy wonks and political junkies who are watching this for spores were people out there who were thinking about their their incomes that are innings their insurance policies their children's education their safety their children safety school did anybody did they articulate policies that are going to make ordinary working people's lives better I think they I think they did try and I have to say that people to judge who had a. Complex performance in this debate he was a times too aggressive seem to want to fight with the debate anybody you know whatever anybody said he had a couple different the lines. But there were many many points at which he sort of drew it back to some of those economic issues and some of those it is the real issues of people's lives Here's some of that as well I think if you are telling it as somebody who has not seen any of these candidates. Is there to you know somebody and see any of these candidates and you're just trying to hear what they had to say. I think a candidate we didn't mention much did very very well and that was kind of the Harris California senator she really had some stellar answers where she did kind of humanize the discussion and bring a lot of out of the issues a lot of concerns is so she did very well the challenge for her is that she's pretty far down in the polls at this point so I mean it's a qu