The democrats blew it. They had a great, great chance. Well have to take a look. Dana Sarah Sanders followed up on fox news earlier. The president made multiple offers on daca. He wanted to see something get done. Democrats refused to put something on the table or work with the president to get anything done. They wanted these Daca Recipients as political pawns. The president wanted to make a deal. He made two incredibly generous offers that went far and above even what the Previous Administration had done on daca. Democrats still refused to make a deal. I think its because were getting close to an election. They dont want to see the president continue to win back like he has for the last year and a half. Dana jesse, i will go to first. There is a debate on who killed daca. I think the truth is it wasnt going to go anywhere before the midterm election. Everyone is going to try to utilize it for their advantage. Jesse exactly. The president offered a very generous proposal. Crying chuck denied it. President obama put forth daca. He knew it was unconstitutional. He had said he wasnt allowed to do it as president. Then he changed and did it. It was challenging the courts. It was about to get rejected, so the president says lets have Congress Deal with Immigration Law because thats the right place to deal with Immigration Law. He comes out and puts forth an arrangement which i thought was overly generous. 1. 8 million amnesty in exchange for wall funding. That was rejected. The president try to make it a broader solution and say okay lets put things that the american vote want on the table. Meritbased immigration system and doing away with the visa lottery and chain migration. 75 of the country believes that. That was rejected as well. Now we are in a situation where the democrats are going to campaign in the midterms that the republicans hate hispanics and the republicans will campaign as the democrats want illegal immigration and open borders. Will we will see which narrative wins. Dana dnc deputy chair Keith Ellison on what he thinks. Back when trump ended the daca program in september, i knew he wasnt going to do anything about it. He never had a plan for trying to fix daca and he turned down several bipartisan deals. This was always a game, a trick, he was never arguing in good faith. Dana the president did put a pretty generous plan on the table for going beyond the daca kids to say up to 8 million he would be willing to do amnesty. It couldnt get done. Is it fair to say that for the democrats this is an election issue thats better than solving the problem . Juan no. How i think the democrats would like to crow that they have solved the problem, and saved the dreamers. What you see is the proposal the president put forward didnt have the support of enough republican votes in the senate to get past her republicans didnt back what the president no he didnt. Dana he had 36. Juan he didnt have 52 republicans behind him. What struck me was how little relationship there is between what the president was tweeting and reality. He said there is a caravan of people from honduras, guatemala trying to make their way to the u. S. Border. To request asylum because they are fleeing from the crime and cast on there. The president says these people are trying to take advantage of the dreamers. They cant apply for dreamers status. There is no relationship. He makes it out if as if there is one. Jesse it is related. If you cross the border illegally as a migrant seeking asylum, you will get special treatment and they will consider you for amnesty. Juan no, they will consider you for asylum. Jesse amnesty or asylum, you still get to stay in that country. Juan theres a huge difference. In order to qualify for daca, you have to have been in the country, come in the country at a young age. Jesse there is no argument that not having a border wall and the daca situation still in play does attract illegal immigration. Dana kimberly, if you are being technical, these people, children being across the border by the parents. But its true there is a caravan. Comes around every year. This is the fifth year this group is trying to do this. They tried to deter them. You are not going to get asylum. You might be able to try to apply for it. Nikki haley was in honduras this past spring saying we want to help you solve the problem at the source but youre going to have to partner with us. Kimberly isnt it reasonable . Go to the source the problem and say we would like to partner with you, find a positive solution. Nevertheless, you cant flagrantly violate the law and expect a lot to show you consideration at expense to others who are come porting themselves in an appropriate matter following the legal guidelines. Nobody is trying to step on anybodys dreams or hopes or ability to get into this country. What people are against is illegal entry. The democrats missed a great opportunity to take advantage of the positioning. What he wanted to get the 25 billion for the enhanced border wall. Instead they went ahead and passed on it for political reasons which is a disservice to everyone. 80 of what they wanted. He was saying listen, we have to slow it down about this in terms of chain migration, the lottery system. Put some more specific standards and practices, little more structure to make sure the right people are getting in and its properly background vetted. Thats not an unreasonable request. Whats unreasonable is the obstructionists on both sides to be frank because people acted like Political Party pigs and they wanted everything they wanted on their plate without an ability or reason to compromise. This is what we have. The president didnt kill daca. I think the democrats killed it. People who were too entrenched in their own political beliefs and werent willing to compromise. Juan wait a second. Who killed daca . The president. Kimberly no, he did not. Dana sort of a tit for tat. Basically its not getting done before the election. Greg it is like murder on the orient express. They all killed daca. Okay, i ruined it for you. I love agatha christie. I believe this group who was helping the hunter and refugees were hired by trump. Here is a singular example that underlines the necessity for plan which is a wall with a door, which is what trump is talking about. Weaving in a group of Illegal Immigrants is not a plan. A wall with a door is a plan. This validates his concerns over a week border. Even mexico knows this is wrong. They deported tens of thousands of hondurans. Yet it is hey, come on through. Back to the point about daca, who killed daca. I think the democrats sacrifice the people they have used as pawns for so long just a score against donald trump. This trump deal wouldnt solve everything but they didnt want the solution unless it involved a humiliation of trump. Trump was giving 1. 6 million. Dana he was willing to go up to 8 million. Its not the first time the democrats have done this. 2007, that deal was on the tabl table. They blocked it then. Greg in business, if the deal gives you what you want, doesnt matter if you dont get along. You can get a deal with people you dont like. But in politics, there are no such rules. You can kill a deal and get rewarded for it because it rewards your side. There is no political consequences. Jesse to your point about the responsibility of both parties scuttling the deal, if you look at the republicans, a lot of those people in the pocket of big business, they want a certain amount of open borders because they want the cheap labor for the companies to come in. The democrats want open borders because it means more votes and more amnesty. Meanwhile, the middleclass American Workers are getting hosed. The body politic sufferers and our National Security suffers. You have no idea whos coming in the country. The honduras, the border with mexico, 500 miles. We are sending money to make sure they secure the border and root out the corruption and try to help the economy. Right now at such a disaster, it is spilling over. No matter what we spend, we are still getting in 2016, we stopped 200,000 Central AmericanIllegal Immigrants crossing through mexico into the United States. Thats a lot of people. Dana one of the reasons i look at the honduras trip nikki haley talk, there were several areas. One was combating drugs and gains. Drugs and gangs. Economic ties. But remember it was honduras and guatemala, two of the only countries that supported the president on his push to move the embassy from tel aviv to jerusalem. Juan i wanted to jump in and say jesse, we have hit a 47year low in terms of people crossing the border. U. N. President trump want to, i think, create elon musk rhetori rhetoric. Jesse juan. 300,000 they are catching. Juan the numbers, the percentages, this is a 47year low. Jesse trump fee as rhetoric. Juan the second thing is these people are coming seeking asylum. As dana was describing come of the situation in honduras, this is a humanitarian crisis. We as americans have created a system that allows people to apply for asylum. Greg you are absolutely right. People should apply. But just because they are closer to us isnt fair. Theres plenty of people who should be in front of them who happen not to be on our borders. I could go through them. We know where they are. I came up with an idea for a cnn town hall. Not for fox news but cnn. Why, when you talk about these things going on in the world, why is his Approval Rating still moving up . That is worth discussing. Why is it . Progress in north korea, because of immigration, because of being tough on china . Second amendment . Collusion theory dying. Is it terror, is it a stormy backlash. These variables exist. It kind of makes you think, he might be doing a pretty good jo good job. Juan do you know why his numbers dash record number. Greg i knew your head would explode. I think a lot of this has to do with people saying he is the president. We are patriots. Kimberly all of a sudden that happened . They woke up . Patriotism. 50 . Dana the gallup poll today had him at 39. I want to give juan a little cover. Greg the point i am trying to make is that everyone of these issues people are throwing out there has a rebound effect and thats whats happening. Americans are looking at this and they are looking at the assumptions trump makes witches im going to be tough on immigration, law and order. They like it. All these things are going on, collusion, stormy, they are creating a backlash and hes up at 50 . Dana basketball legend Charles Barkley is angry with President Trump and his supporters. Youre going to hear why next. , im allbusiness when i travel. Even when i travel. For leisure. So i go national, where i can choose any available upgrade in the aisle without starting any conversations or paying any upcharges. What can i say . Control suits me. Go national. Go like a pro. At ally, we offer lowcost trades and highyield savings. But if thats not enough, we offer innovative investing tools to prepare you for the future. Looks like you hooked it. And if thats not enough, well help your kid prepare for the future. Dont hook it kid. And if thats still not enough, well help your kids kid prepare for the future. Looks like he hooked it. Well do anything. Takes after his grandad. Seriously anything, to help you invest for the future. Ally. Do it right. Seriously anything, to help you invest for the future. We use our phones the same way these days. So why do we pay to have a phone connected when were already paying for internet . Shouldnt it all just be one thing . Thats why Xfinity Mobile comes with your internet. You can get up to 5 lines of talk and text included at no extra cost. So all you pay for is data. See how you could save 400 or more a year. Plus, for a limited time, get a 250 prepaid card when you buy any new samsung. Xfinity mobile. Its a new kind of network designed to save you money. Click, call, or visit an xfinity store today. Jesse every now and again turns barkley stopped into the new cycle with a tirade on President Trump. The former nba star says he has never been more angry and disgusted with the president because of his tweeting and staff changes. Barkley is unloading on his supporters too. Nobody ever wants to look in the mirror and say its my fault. I think he reached a demographic that wont look in the mirror that says my life sucks because of me. He came right after president obama, and there were some people who are like wow, weve got a black president. They are not happy with that. Jesse Charles Barkley is a basketball player. He played for the 76ers and the phoenix suns. That is the game where you shoot the ball. Dana got it. Jesse one of the biggest mistakes you can make when making political analysis, trust me, i know what im talking about. You never go after a candidates supporters. Kimberly did you learn a lot from that, dana . Dana i think life is too short to be mad at people who made a choice based on its not like we didnt litigate the 2016 campaign for two years leading up to it. People were clear eyed about the decision. They might have decided i cant vote for her. Im going to give him a shot. Why not . I try to listen to them, though. Because i feel the resentment. I hear it. I dont feel it personally. There is a resentment there that i think is unfortunately pulling people too far apart. Hillary clinton used that lesson when she said the word deplorable. She was denigrating the entire group of people. Its not helpful. Jesse greg, trump flipped 217 counties that went for obama in 2012. Does that all of a sudden weight people not racist . Greg it is an irrational comment for him to make. If barkley says something you hate, wait 5 minutes and he will Say Something you love. Even in that tirade, he actually said some things that were pretty good, about the russians, the stormy thing. He is he talked about looking in the mirror. He should look in the mirror because hes talking about himself. He is just like trump. Hes an opinionated trash talker. He has run into trouble in the past. He has considered entertaining a career in politics. He would be another trump. He is upset about trump tweeting . Charles wont keep his mouth shut if hes president. Charles is probably in the back of his head thinking, man, i could have done this. I have a pass but trump proved a pass doesnt matter. I could have been governor of a large state or ran for president , which may happen, charles. Jesse he is a very authentically authentic and likable guy. You dont think the russian thing is an issue . I do not. I think its probably true, but i am pretty sure in the election, state, local, nationa national, somebody can get some dirt on somebody if they wanted to. You think its a distraction . Its definitely a distraction. Weve spent the last year talking about russia every slow day. Now we have stormy. Now weve got another girl. I am sitting there saying, when are we going to help the people . Jesse juan, charles makes a good point. Juan i thought that was the best point he made. To me, the idea that you need to pay attention. He mentioned schools, puerto rico. The whole idea that even daca, he mentioned, we should do something to help the dreamers. I think on that level, lets really help people. Thats what he is saying, its the purpose of government. He things we are not doing that. I guess that means, since trumps president , trump isnt doing it. What struck me was when we are in the midst of culture wars on some level. Nobody goes to Charles Barkley for political expertise. He is endorsing doug jones in alabama. Has a guy who at one point thought about running for governor in alabama as a republican. I think people say well, its Charles Barkley, a celebrity. We like to hear what our celebrities think. Why we take it to heart as oh, boy, this is big news, i dont know. He is much more than a basketball player or former basketball player at this point. I think these may be the preeminent basketball analyst in the country. Not only does the nba but the ncaa, and hes very popular. I think it was interesting but i dont know that its of any big consequence. Jesse people like listening to sir charles, kimberly. He has always said interesting things about politics. Pretty in touch with the people. Juan he said a few things in there, like halloween candy. There is some in there, i love it. Candy corn. Peeps. And then theres that almond joy, mounds thing, i dont like that at all. He is like that. A bunch of good stuff and then a few things, maybe i will toss that out. I think is a thoughtful person the way comes across. He things about things and i agreed about the rush of collusion. Its been ridiculous. What he is saying about the trump supporters, that i dont like so much. A lot of people made choices. Making choices to go with President Trump on his agenda and reject that of the Democratic Party and Hillary Clinton and barack obama which was the establishment that was back in their Holding Court for a while. Jesse Holding Court . Well said. I had come of this protest isnt getting much coverage. A student walkout in support of the Second Amendment. Up next. Great, another dead end. Sarge, i just got a tip thatll crack this case wide open turns out the prints at the crime scene awwwww. Did Mcgruffy Wuffy get a tippy wippy . Im serious we gotta move fast before whos a good boy . Is him a good boy . Erg. Im just gonna go. Oh, you wanna go outside . You gotta go tinky poopoo . I already went, ok . In the bathroom as long as people talk babytalk to dogs, you can count on geico saving folks money. Fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance. We know that when youre tspending time with thelass grandkids. Music tech . Every minute counts. And you dont have time for a cracked windshield. Thats why at safelite, well show you exactly when well be there. With a replacement you can trust. All done sir. Grandpa looks great tech thanks for choosing safelite. Grandpa thank you child bye tech bye saving you time. So you can keep saving the world. Kids safelite repair, safelite replace essential for the cactus, but maybe not for people with rheumatoid arthrit