Him. Again, i am not going to get into the back and forth details. As the president estatesed on numerous occasions, he did nothing wrong. The president did nothing wrong. And there are no charges against him. He did nothing wrong. There are no charges against him. The president has done nothing wrong. No charges against him. There is no collusion. Well, Rudy Giuliani told robert costa of Washington Post that he had spoken to the president about yesterdays events. This is rudy talk. Hard to believe. One source close to President Trump told john roberts of fox news, remember, the president cant be indicted. Seth waxon, barbara mcquade. Chris Matthews debates hot political issues with politicians, newsmakers and Washington leaders. Trump tweeted Michael Cohen pled guilty to two counts of Campaign Violations. During an interview with fox he seemed to confess to Campaign Violation while denying it. Did you learn about the payments . Later on, i knew. You have to understand ainsley, what he did, and they werent taken out of Campaign Finance. They came from me and i tweeted about it. I dont know if you know, but i tweeted about the payments. But they didnt come out of campaign. My first question when i heard about it, did they come out of the campaign. Because that could be a little dicey. And they didnt come out of the campaign and thats big. But thats its not even a Campaign Violation. Barbara, to get to the
president s defense. This is the idea that ultimately, a person who is rich can by all they want in Campaign Advertising and all they want. Thats how it works in our rockefeller system. But he is saying as long as i ultimately paid, if i was the ultimate payee, im not guilty of any serious crime. Is that right . He is wrong. Other Campaign Finance cases divide the world into Campaign Finance into expenditures and contributions. He is focussing on expenditures. The charges relate to contributions. And there are two charges, one that Michael Cohen exceeded the limit. No, there is no limit on the candidate spending how much they want to spend. But it was Michael Cohen there is no constitutional limit. Any candidate that spends all
they want can do that, right . But they have to disclose it is it is a der sall you wn your own campaign, that is their argument. You have to disclose who made the payment. And two, you look at motive and intent in a case like this. The intent was not as in the obama situation, a clerical error, this was an intent to mislead by hiding the nature of the payment. This is the kind of case that gets prosecuted. Robert, i get to defend this maybe there is a Paperwork Problem on the pass
through, but my money and it is legal. Its constitutional. Isnt that his argument now . That is the argument the challenge is what is Michael Cohens thinking here . That he can try to shrug this off legally, politically, as something that is not a Campaign Violation but face the challenge that cohen admitted in court, in Federal Court that he did commit a violation, he did break the law. Pled guilty. So that is the reality and here is the argument they make. If the president s lawyer admits the guilt of a felony, a couple of them, admits it was really a Campaign Expenditures and wasnt filed properly. They are going to mount a credibility war against cohen in the coming weeks. Giuliani says he is going to call on cohen to release all the
tapes to try to see if cohen said anything that goes against what he pled guilty to. What do you make, how guilty is it a Paperwork Issue or commit a serious felony here. The Campaign Finance law determines criminality at the moment of the contribution. So when Michael Cohen makes that contribution. You can basically up end all Campaign Finance law by saying my corporation did it or that was an overlimit. Dont you have to argue the intention there, that cohen was intending to pay for that money and not get the money from trump. He is saying that. He is admitting under oath. That it was his payment. And procured another payment. We knew from the tapes that he
knew about It Contemporaneously or before. Why was he having money paid from ami and having his lawyer pay it. Why did they set up a dummy comfortable. Robert what do you make of this . We went from home to work last night, all came home thinking this is a very, very bad day for the president. Two things happened. The guy who ran his campaign for many months looks like he is facing hard time and i dont have any particular animus to the guy but facing a large time. This guy is in serious, he is 69 yea 69years old. He may never get out. And then you have Michael Cohen who was close in with this president. Locked together in the biggest secrets of the world. Women, all kinds of payoffs, all personal stuff we have never
heard about. And now, this guy is facing, at least going to allenwood some place like that for a couple of years. What does the president feel for his own situation, does he have sifrpthy for this guy or what. The white house today, it is like the eye of the political hurricane. Trying to project calm. But surrounded by the hurricane. They put him on the phone with abe. Anything but a political war today. But they dont think inside of the white house that this is going to last. Giuliani calling from scotland. No evidence to back it up. A lot of confidence but not a lot of evidence that their confidence is going to play out. It is not like the compartments are flooding on the
titanic. It is just another day, is that what they look at it . I can get through a day so i can survive. They dont see it adding up. It is a different white house than it was a year ago. They are all gone. This is a general kelly, Kellyanne Conway white house. The president talking to giuliani. Different mindset. Not as political as charged as it was. Thank you. Jennifer rubin, seth waxman. It is a very short tape. These people are amazing, they are regimental in their defense. Rob reiner is coming up to
discuss what the democrats should do. First two congressional supporters have been indicted on corruption charge. And when in doubt, who does President Trump blame . Obama. About the end of the long, long legacy. This is hardball where the action is. As their spokesperson because apparently, im highly likable. See, they know its confusing. I literally have no idea what im getting, dennis quaid. Thats why theyre making it simple, man in cafe. And more affordable. Thank you, dennis quaid. Youre welcome. Thats a prop apple. Id tell you more, but i only have 30 seconds. So heres a dramatic shot of their tagline so youll remember it. Esurance. Its surprisingly painless. Less than 80 days to go, orourke might chose that gap. Four points now. The last time a democrat was elected to represent texas was lloyd benson. This reminds me of the movie the candidate with redford. With a plan. It includes preservision. Only Preservision Areds 2 has the exact nutrient formula recommended by the National Eye Institute to help reduce the risk of progression of moderate to advanced amd. Thats why i fight. Because its my vision. Preservision. Also, in a greattasting chewable. [ coughs ] [ screams ]
[ laughs ] whoa, whoa, whoa. Your one item would be the name your price tool . It helps people save on car insurance. Why wouldnt it save me . Why . What would you bring . A boat. Huh. This wifi is fast. I know i know i know i know when did brian move back in . Brians back . He doesnt get my room. Hes only going to be here for like a week. Like a month, tops. Oh boy. Wifi fast enough for the whole family is simple, easy, awesome. In many cultures, young men would stay with their families until their 40s. Michael cohen has now said in Federal Court that he committed a crime at the direction of President Trump himself. There are now only two things protecting the president from becoming an indicted coconspirator. The first is his elected four term as president. Elected republicans who stand by him for that reason. One2 punch for the president. The legal set backs that he suffered within minutes of each
other could open fissures among republicans on capitol hill. Today many republicans had only tepid condemnations. That he is are serious charges, they cant be ignored. Do you think this opens up the president to be indicted while sitting in office. No i dont. I dont think he can be indicted while sitting in office. Until we know all the facts. This is very, very unfortunate. It is very serious. I want to see this go through our judicial system. That is what is going to happen. It is not a good day for the president. An accusation that he did conspire for Campaign Finance laws. The only people that are coming out against the president
are those leaving the battlefield. Lets listen to them. I have been here 11 and a 1 2 years and this is, i dont think i have witnessed anything like i have witnessed over the last year and a 1 2. I think there is going to be other revelations that come up and i think we ought to let the process work. This is serious and i am not suggesting any outcome here, but this is serious. So far, Mitch Mcconnell hasnt spoken on the issue. House speaker paul ryans office spoke only in a statement. We ar wear of mr. Cohens guilty plea to these serious charges, we will need more information at this point. What more information. I am joined by democratic
senator. What is your party, is it rig under oath and said he directed me to break the Campaign Laws and secretly spend 130,150,000 130,000 and 150,000 to shut up his girlfriend. If this was braobama, it would unseemingly. You would have heard a little bit different message from republicans that you played. But those senators who Arent Retying did indicate it was a very serious issue. And i get back it the comment that you made in the previous segment with barbara. Is this a buckley b vallejo
issue . The president using his own money is markedly different than some of the other things that mule s mueller is investigating. I mean, cohen is going down with the ship. He said i did what the president Wanted Me Ton do. I did the payments. And he told me to do it. Totally agree with you. But i think what to lanny daviss point is the real issue here is what comes next. Politically what comes next is going to be more perilous than what happened yesterday with mr. Cohen. What happens if mr. Cohen said we had a lot of conversations with the hacking of the dnc and that information,
how we knew about it ahead of time and the president knew about it ahead of time which sounds like collusion. I totally agree with you. And that is why i think having an affair with two women and paying them off maybe not out of your pocket right away but reimbursing your lawyer after he did it, that is one issue. Im not sure that republicans read that evidence and say we should impeach the president over that. Frankly, im not sure democrats want to do that either. If they do, it is a double edged sword for them. If we talk about russian interference, russian collusion, that is where i think, if it gets into that territory, then you are going to start seeing a different discussion on capitol hill amongst republicans. Meanwhile, noting that democrats would demand a floor
bill on a bill retroactive protecting mueller. Number two, dic durbin said it is not what democrats said they would do. Is there a hard bake snr . Is there a person that steps up. Inconsistent with the laws and rule of law in the united states. Senator what do you think of your party . What is your party, should it be doing . What should the republicans be doing about what is emerging is a problem of criminality around the president. First thing is make sure the Mueller Investigation can go forward. How can you do that with the majority on the other side. Continue to put pressure on them to bring the bill up. After yesterdays events, they are going to feel that pressure in a different way. All right bipartisan. Mitch hasnt want to bring it
un, but i am not sure how long that is going to last. Second thing is we have to resume pressure in investigation. I will compliment Lindsey Graham who has done some good work. But a lot to do. Have somebody go out who both sides can trust and give us a quick report on what all of the relations are between russian financial interest and the trump organization. Isnt that what mueller is doing . No, for congressional purposes. We have our own right doing this. Do you have any doubt that this president would fire everybody in the Justice Department to save himself and his family. Do you think he would let them indict his kids. He is not going to be able to. Rod rosenstein has spread this
investigation into five different elements. You have to go into the Eastern District virginia. He has talked about it. Talked about getting rid of jeff sessions. He says he can take over the investigation. The president said i can take over this entire investigation if i want to. Me. He probably couldnt get into the Department Of Justice if he did that. Everybody fleeing. That is tweet nonsense i have to go back to the senator. Thank you for coming on tonight. Do you think your Republican Party which is marching in lock step for 90 right now in the rankandfile, the people out there. Do you think the senator and the members of the house, like ryan and mccarthy, do you think they will ever come out against this
president , no matter what is going on, ever . I dont think we have crossed the rubi con. If the russia stuff comes into play, then it is different. The president s press conference with vladimir putin, i have heard more members more bothered by that than previously what the president did. We have been tap dancing and trying to avoid land mines every single day. What we have now avoided is the Freedom Caucus attempt to impeach rosenstein. If you recall, when we left for recess in august, there was an attempt by the Freedom Caucus to put on the floor and force an impeachment vote. I dont think anyone has an appear at this time for that. And certainly, i am more centered than that. But no one at this point in time is going to say this is not a legitimate investigation. You said something. I have to ask you about this. I heard people that i respect on the Republican Party and Foreign Policy said Something Like that. Do you believe when you think about your colleagues and yourself, when you watch that display by the president where he seemed to take the sides with the russians and their values with the American Values right there on the stage, was that closest to impeachable you have seen in this president s behavior. I would say that is the most disturbing thing i have ever seen a president has participated in. Impeachment is a political process and you need the evidence in front of you and you need to evaluate it. Some of the things he intimates
and you saw it right there in the interview with the fox journalist. He repeats himself over and over again and then uses the word but and then says the same thing. It is a verbal gymnastics. He can say two Different Things in four sentences and you dont know which way he said it. Who knows who to believe. That is not how our country works and that i think is something at that a lot of republicans took issue with. That is exactly my assessment. And i have heard that from people. I respect at the very top of the republican Foreign Policy establishment, they consider that meeting and what he said afterwards a disaster. Thank you. Up next, lawmakers on capitol hill are wrestling with a new conundrum how to handle a new Supreme Court nominee. Should yesterdays event put the kibosh on the nomination . Majoris lowered their blood sugar and reached an a1c of less than seven and maintained it. Oh under seven . vo and you may lose weight. In the same oneyear study, adults lost on average up to 12 pounds. Oh up to 12 pounds . vo a twoyear study showed that ozempic® does not increase the risk of major cardiovascular events like heart attack, stroke, or death. Oh no increased risk . Ozempic® ozempic® should not be the first medicine for treating diabetes, or for people with Type 1 Diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. Do not share needles or pens. Dont reuse needles. Do not take ozempic® if you have a personal or Family History of medullary thyroid cancer, multiple Endocrine Neoplasia Syndrome type 2, or if you are allergic to ozempic®. Stop taking ozempic® and get medical help right away if you get a lump or swelling in your neck,
severe stomach pain, itching, rash, or trouble breathing. Serious side effects may happen, including pancreatitis. Tell your doctor if you have Diabetic Retinopathy or vision changes. Taking ozempic® with a sulfonylurea or insulin may increase the risk for low blood sugar. Common side effects are nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, sto