Investigating the case urban design called out to the scene our occ volunteers being trained in bias we been talking about in the past year about accountability and the office of citizens complaints is the first line of accountability for the Police Department we need cases to be fully investigated we need them to be evaluated with the correct standard of evidence thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Seeing none, yeah. Sorry good evening. Good evening. I showed up awhile ago in front of the board of supervisors. Concerning Police Department i have said any opinion of the financial members of the alzheimers that i advise with any experience of life that the city will fire the department with new people theres a reason why at the level of not only of the shootings and everything weve seen my family lives there 5 generations but wish to bring more accountability that has been took place and the new chief to monthly meetings and weekly meetings and the monthly at the level of the adult management and the city should decide to keep the Police Department and the gentleman from los angeles ive on january 3rd i didnt know which one but pertains to how you guys conduct with the purpose of taking firearms from the population which people have right to have and in their locked cabinets in their garages and stay over there thirty years ill read the invoice it says invoice addressed to the city amount of personal distract on the undercover officer proclamation to the family that is involved gates and collectable items and books and things all 62,000 number it request and return of two firearms taken from our property and the garage located on that property on de harrow street in San Francisco from the locked cabinet they stayed for more than thirty years the sfpd didnt come officially to take the items and return those items to my husband after receiving them point number 3 requesting returns of documents items taken from the families home and the elements seized by the illegal operation from the Previous Year from the family against serious of items from the Fourth Amendment and taken eyes and ears and obamacare intrastate after the husband passed away thank you. Mbalthazar is there. Im sorry Public Comment is at the same time Deputy Director balthazar is there. Any more Public Comment . Hearing none, Public Comment is closed. Next line item please. Item 3 approval of the awards Committee Recommendation action. Ladies and gentlemen, i mean sorry colleagues in our packets are the recommendations that were presented to the Police Commission from the awards committee that was held on october 4th during that particular meeting there were awards recommended for this commission to award to two officers from give gold metals to the lifesavers award that list is before you we have conferred with the occ and no pending complaints or disciplinary hearing for any of the officers and also commissioner dejesus asked specifically if any of the officers were involved in my investigative progresses or charged with violations or disciplinary considerations sergeant killshaw has looked at that and ill give her time to respond. Thank you commissioner Vice President turman again as you stayed commissioner dejesus had questions went to 30 years me to work with the lieutenant at internal affairs so have the list of members that you are voting to confer the awards that on they did look through the list specifically looking for significant discipline cases against the officers and reported back to the commissioners bans the report the Commission Revised the list one member who is name was removed from the list your reviewing because that officer has one pending discipline case they Commission Level all of the other members on the list have no significant pending sorry discipline case and no discipline cases related to the event for which their in the mind. No significant what do you mean. Significant cases that will rise to the level of a commission charges. Did that mean they are disciplinary basis with the chief. I believe there were 6 of the officers on the list do have disciplinary cases that are open and assigned to investigators at the level of the internal affairs but they are all open and nothing has been referred to the chief at this point okay. Okay. At this point, i need to review well someone needs to review that list of items so my recommendation we carry item number 3. Any objections. That we. Carry it to another meeting to review that list is interest any objection. Sergeant were going to continue item number 3 the approval of the awards committee. I apologize captain. Okay. Take that off calendar. Because im taking that off calendar i dont believe were allowed to comment on it okay general Public Comment. Im sorry so the question because it was an item for discussion every item needs Public Comment if youve taken that before. Thank you so Public Comment on the approval of the awards recommendation. Okay. Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. General Public Comment . General Public Comment the public is welcome to address the commission on items not on tonights agenda but within the jurisdiction of the commission. The commission as a whole and not to individual commissioners or departments or occi personnel. Department, occi or commissioners are to respond to questions but may provide a brief response. Police commission should enter into debates and please limit your comments to 3 minutes, please. Hello, again. And happy new year it is another year and this year will make the 11th year august 14, 2006, of this year will be 11 years and here i am at the beginning of the year still asking for justice concerning my son Aubrey Abrakasa who was murdered august 14, 2006, to a semiautomatic gun thirty bullets left that gun to this day his case is not solved i talked with any inspector today and still havent heard what i want to hear his words an uproar in homicides lastly so those comments that took priority over my sons case but i thought that i was told that i had an investigator that was dealing with unsolved homicides to if thats the case why are other homicides taking part over my sons case and i was told that he was supposed to be on any sons case and now waiting to speak to the da im not sure and im confused and im tired of waiting i want justice for my child and im just bringing they know formal gavin newsom know i know who killed my son the police know who killed her son those are his words in the paper how could you not know something that being done and the lady that was here before us saying that case were solved whether in 1941 or how ever their not solved im left to deal with my sons case and left to have any son this is what i have to live with and deal with it if i look at it every year and week i want everyone else to know i dont want my sons memory and homicide to be forgotten a 17 yearold boy and, yes 10 years 11 years i city cry you guys and hurt and have grasped children and he was mother only son i cant let this go away so, yes im here and it is redundant but not just fight for any son but another homicides need to be solve help me solve my sons case of the perpetrators that done this. Thank you, chief is sergeant discipline i need detective spleen assigned to the cold case and. Brought back to cold cases sounds like hes talking about and literally getting in like that they only have so many prosecutors and involved in the Hunters Point so the number of prosecutors is 20 i dont know if there is a presentation hes trying to do or speak to the debut not getting in line for the presentation. It was my understanding he was just brought back from cold cases could you please have him recontact ms. Brown and explain to her what the process is right now so she clearly understand. Absolutely. Thank you. Any other Public Comment. Hearing none Public Comment is closed. Parking lot. Public comment on all matters closed session including Public Comment on votes whether to hold item 7 in closed session. Members of the public were about to go into closed session so we give you an opportunity to comment on the fact were about to do so is there any Public Comment hearing none Public Comment is closed. Item 6 vote on whether to hold item 87 in inclusion and the Attorney Client privilege. I move we hold the item in closed session. Second. Do you also move we assert the Attorney Client privilege. Commissioner Vice President turman back on the record we have quorum were back in open session so skeet kilshaw item 8 vote to disclose any or all session in the administrative code action. Move for nondisclosure. Second. Move forward by commissioner mazzucco and seconded by dr. Marshall is. All in favor, say i. Opposed . Unanimous thank you next line item. Item 9 adjournment action item. Commissioner mazzucco thank you. I move as we state earlier at the beginning we adjourn tonight in honor of memory of form San FranciscoPolice Officer dennis and form San Francisco da dennis cash man may he rest in peace. I second that. All in favor, say i. Thank you, were happy ne the commission will come to order and secretary will call the roll. [inaudible] singer, here. Chow, present. Chungsanchez. Approval of minutes of december 20, 2016. The minute are before you and motion for acceptance is in order. So moved. Is there is second, please . Secsd. Second. Any corrections to the minutes . Not seeing any all in favor say aye. Aye opposed. Item 3 is directors report. Director. Happy new year commissioners and those in the audience. A couple item, every year the Mayors Office asks for nomination for Good Government awards and we send one so this year we sent the [inaudible] move team and they were selected fl the Good Government award and so we are really proud of them. This recognizes outstanding leadership, creativity and kis tinction in San Francisco government and since the Program Inception more than hundred city and county employees receive the award. Individuals receive the award and glup award so happy to note all the good work that the team did to transition to the new hospital will be acknowledged and there will be a Award Ceremony across at city hall and let all the commissioners know whether that is. As we have the ceo ptd to give her part of that award. Shape up San Francisco was honored by the board of supervisors led by eric mar. They acknowledged decade of work to make healthy choices. This is a coalition of groups within the city San Francisco department of Public Health participates in. I want to give a update on a incident that happened on thursday. There was a shooting in front of 240 golden gate which is next door to tom ligal and it was two fatalities that happened there. Tom [inaudible] there werefore Staff Members outside of the clinic at the time. One of the Staff Members were grazed by a bullet. They were not injured at all, but small cut on their arm. Both roland and i went and talked to staff at night and went the next morning to the clinic. We also worked with the staff, had crisis counselors there. The staff shared with us their great concern of the safety of the neighborhood. We have a security person inside the clinic, but outside on golden gate there is a lot of drug activity. This happenedthis incident was a drug activ tee that happened. So, we immediately had bazal price a Security Director was in the middle 06 a security assessment of that location. We did know we would have to put a sheriff in that area, so we immediately put two sheriffs to do rotations on that street. I also had a conversation with the deputy chief of the police, we talk today the captain ofteneder loin station and the sheriff and the police are working together on trying to do a lot more rotation walks around in the clinic. Not inside the clinic but outside the clinic is basically where the staff felt so concerned. We are also will be allowing staff who are feeling unsafe to walk fromwe had a couple incidence they shared of walking from the bart to the clinic and from the clinic to the bart that we will also encourage staff if they like reimbursement for that small frip trip on uber if that will support their safety. Also, there will be escourts by the sheriff for those who park in the area. This was a unusual occurrence, i wanted the commissioners to know how we responded so the staff there felt that we responded in i think a quick fashion and we are very supportive of the actions we took and the leadership of primary care was involved and will do a lot of the follow up from our work on last week. I just wanted to inform the commissioners of that incident. Thank you. Commissionerwere there any Public Comments to the directors . Not received Public Comment requests for this item. Commissioners questions to the director or comments concerning the report . We of course again congratulate the team for having won this award. Shall i move on . If there are no further comments, then we will proceed to the next item. Item 4, general Public Comment. Not received requests. We can move to item 5 which is rart back from finance and Planning Committee from today. Commissioner chung. Good afternoon commissioners. The Planning Committee met before the Commission Meeting today and we have reviewed prop i request and also a contract report and two new contracts and we are recommending with the exceptions of one contract in the contract report that belongs to theu csf on the employment service, the rest we are recommending for the commission to approve and the reason for post poning theu csf contract is we felt we needed a little more data to understand the operation oaf the program and so we will revisit the approval for that in the next finance and Planning Committee meeting. Questions to commissioner chung concerning the finance and Planning Committee report . If not well proceed to the consent calendar. Ite 786 is consent calendar. As note d by commissioner chung for the contract reportu csf f contract is removed as you move forward to approve. Committee recommending is recommending approval. Any discussion for the consent calendar or anyone like to take any other item off . We are prepared for vote on the consental caener de. All in favor of the consent calendar please say aye. Aye. Opposed ken sent calendar is passed. Item 7 is the vision zero update and also a resolution. I believe commissioner chow would like to Say Something about that. As we receive the update on vision zero because the Strategic Plan is still in process and presented the resolution itself would be deferred until the presentation of the full Strategic Plan if that meets with the consent of the commission. I believe the date the resolution is presented is february 7, 2017. Okay. Please proceed. Thank you so much. Good afternoon. My name is megan were, the director of the plan of Health Equity and sustainability and cochair the Vision Zero Task force. Thank you so much for the opportunity to provide the update today. I also want to acknowledge cochair mar wroehunter of the Municipal Transportation Agency and a number of colleagues from dph imprieveolog privileged to work with on the initiative. I first wanted to just open summarizing our iftality data and vision zero so the goal is eliminate traffic fatalities in the city by 2024. This chart depicts the fatalities in San Francisco from 2005 to 2016 and i wanted to note the data is only through november of 2016. Um, the blue is People Killed while walking, green, biking and red in vehicles. Roont years we had approximately 30 people kimed on ourb streets. I want to note data is being finalized for 2016 and will issue a end of year report in the next couple weeks. We have a traffic fatality protocol we implement with the mta and pd ochb a monthly basis that draws from international and National Best practice to reconcile fatalities in the medical examiners aufs and please investigationism many are reported in the media, however, some of them are not and we also do include or exclude suicides and other particular circumstances. We look forward to issuing that report as soon as we can. Many people are interested and committed to having acprt data. While we dont have sth final numbers for this year we know we have lot more work with respect to vision zero. We have a lot going on with increase in population and constructio