Sing about this item . Good afternoon budget and finance committee. [singing] when the lights go down in the city, and the sunshines on the budget bay, wont you may it better for the Youth Commission today. They really need your help. Wont you help them with college free, okay. The budget has magic you know the money has it and suddenly the school youth turns into gold filling up their lives with golden budget, coming their way today. City goal finger, the city with the midas touch and it has budget too. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else wish to comment on sing on item 23 . Okay, seeing none, Public Comment is closed. I will reopen Public Comment. My name is Jessica Williams and a youth advisory member for larkin street and work for transational age yulth for San Francisco. I attend San FranciscoState University and the only reason im able to attend this university is because i live in tay housing and one of the main reasons i live in tay housing is because i cant affords to live in San Francisco. With gentrification and all the things going on in San Francisco a lot of transitional age youth whether we are student or do vocational jobs, whether we are working diverse jobs we need spaces to live and are here and want to give voiz and rise the voices of lgbtq youth in San Francisco especially transitional age youth. I want you to consider everything the Youth Commission has done and appreciate the work and also want to emphasis if you can look over more in depth the Affordable Housing for transitional age youth because without it people like myself would be on the streets and just because i cant afford to live in San Francisco or live in San Francisco and attend San Francisco state doesnt mean people like me dont deserve to be here but there isnt space to be here now and you have a opportunity to create the space. There are radical orgners creating space and you can be a part of that movement as well. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else wish to comment . Okay. Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Thank you everybody for being here today. Colleagues can i entertain a motion to file 23 . Motion by supervisor tang and second by supervisor kim. Any other business in front of us . No, mr. Chair. Okay, thank you everyone, we are adjourned. [meeting adjourned] fair and th interest of having supervisors in the field will be time we may have an mc i casualty and one of the supervisors is dedicated to that he can have an example s d that is working on retaliation we have had one supervisor for the entire city. Thank you any Public Comment on this item . At this time seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Please call the next item item 3 approval of the minutes minutes from the regular meeting of april 13, 2016. Thank you, madam secretary just for my fellow commissioners before we vote on this item i have cared with our Commission Secretary and there were a couple of things in the minutes for our meeting in the mission that i would like to expand on page 4 under presentation item 7 presentation from the bureau of Fire Investigation i am suggesting we have a little bit more information about our fire marshall comments regarding the fires in the mission and how the numbers and type of fires compare to other district in the city not here and included so paragraph and visuals for that captain russel on page 5 go those are not changes but changes im proposing at this time. inaudible . Okay. Thank you that is for the april 27th meeting second. Seconded by commissioner hardeman all in favor signify by i. I. All right. April 27th and we have the minutes for april 13th signify by the if you say okay special meeting from may 13, 2016. So moved thank you please signify by the. I. All 3 minutes have been approved item 4 certifies and acknowledgment of appreciation for the mta who took swift action on a member of the public that experienced an emergency thank you dmilg id like to ask the captain up to the podium and while doing so i want to acknowledge captain oftentimes we dont hear enough of the great work of the colleagues no the city and the captain took the time to let us know i wouldnt have common about the great partners in the sfmta we appreciate youre adding to the agenda i thought since the captain was here and acknowledged and asked for the mta members youll describe that. inaudible . Perfect. Exactly. Id like to take the opportunity to commend the actions of sfmta on february 19, 2016, engine one responded to inaudible the call came in at 613 and a slower Response Time the quick actions by bystander cpr by folks were vitally no saifgs the patients life they assistant the patient and was not breathing through chest compressions got the candy and crew one was able to transfer thats a lot more sanitary than on scene an awful scene quite a period of time revealing the person definitely went above and beyond the call of duty and thank you to the officers for their action chief. Thank you, captain and thank you for taking the time to acknowledge the coworkers and colleagues at this time, id like to join you and acknowledge the great work of the mta and the supervisors is here meg in any if we can get the employees to come up. So ill read from here each of i are receiving a certificate of merited communication theyll be the same to for our service and quick actions to a patient from a partial Airway Obstruction on february 2016 your quick initiative contributed to the outcome for 9 and to sheryl, karen smith and allen i understand just pled our emt today at city college ill present this to you and alleging youll be speaking on behalf of the group so congratulations. clapping. sherman. Thank you. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you very much and id like to thank the Fire Department we did on february was i think a small inning with the Fire Department does all the time and i grew up in the city and born and raised and went to high school and a lot of my friends go to the Fire Department not realizing the sxoep that the Fire Department does for the city i started taking the emt work with all the work i started doing invested with some of the crews and really was in shock the amount of effort, the amount of work that is put in by the Fire Department to support the city of San Francisco and identify seen it amend when i was out there with the ambulance crews to see the miles. And the hope for the Fire Department sees for the whole city the heroes are with the Fire Department thank you thank you. clapping. thank you all very much please stay the commissioners would like to say a word or so to commissioner nakajo. Thank you madam president hopefully my microphone is on i just wanted to say a commissioner with this Fire Commission commission chief joanne hayeswhite and command staff and members im just really move forward by your action this thought in my mind im glad you were there that day if it was me i would need your help and for you to take the time to go ahead and work with us id like the description you talked about the screen you said a good term that term kind of lead me to the chaos that might have occurred if not for yourselves and chief joanne hayeswhite i appreciate your partnership with the city. Thank you so much for your services well thank you commissioner nakajo commissioner hardeman. Thank you, madam chair naturally i appreciate San Francisco appreciates the action for the duty youre not assigned to we were there in a pinch using your education and abilities to assist sounds like if without your actions the person would not to have survived so thank you very much congratulations and i agree with you entirely with our statement about you dont know much about the Fire Department until you get involved and as a commissioner we learn the same thing the duties and how people go about their business each day is remarkable and lucky to have this great Fire Department in San Francisco and back up from Services Like mta thank you very much. Thank you commissioner hardeman commissioner Vice President cleaveland. Id like to say thank you for your heroic actions. I, of course, would like to echo that and want to thank the captain for taking the time and recommend those accommodations so good luck to all of you and thank you, again very much for helping to save a life that day any Public Comment on this item . Anyone okay no thanks again madam secretary next item, please. Item 5 proposed legislation from the board of supervisors Public Safety and Neighborhood Services committee during the course and possible action. Whos presenting this item . Chief the department chief joanne hayeswhite ill just saying goodbye to the captain thank you very much this item will be given a general overview by the and fire marshall like him to approach the podium thank you, chief. Thank you, chief and commissioners good evening and chief dan Fire Marshalls Office for the supervisor campos legislation there are 3 areas and fire code that will be amended with that legislation ill identify those 3 areas and to the impact on our resources within the implementation of the proposal so the 3 areas that will impact will be smoke alarm requirement and fire alarm maintenance and fire upgrade the smoke alarm proposal will require the Building Owners with an annual notice to post that notice in common areas the building this notice this informational sheet fire safety sheet will be developed in in conjunction with the building inspection and post on the website and posted in 3 languages english, spanish and chinese and will require that the Building Owners to issue a hardcopy of that to each of their tenants annually and requires the Building Owner to post this in the common areas at one location on each floor of the location the impact will no major impact the times developed into and to have it translated this informational sheet and posted on the website that is something to absorb with the staff at this time and number two fire alarm Maintenance Requirements supervisor campos protective requires Building Owners to file every two years a statement of compliance a form that which is a form of annual fire alarm investigation testing is it certifies their fire alarms were tested that year per updates set to standards that form is submitted to right now as that reader to the Building Department but still in the works and maybe changed to the Fire Department depending on the resources we are that we can apply to this so every two years 9 years or more those Building Owners will submit on odd years and 8 unit will submit on even years the impact to the division will be receipt of more than 5 thousand forms annually with the potential to get the majority towards the end of the year will greatly overwhelm the staff and managerial staff thats our recommendation the time recommended for the database with the additional time to research when building with required to file with would take a considerable monument the proposal we dont know chomz have fire alarms and which ones does not all building are required to have fire alarms some are existing the best way to address that the annual be inspections well add a section of a firebox and inquiry that is one way to track for 9 units or more those buildings with 3 to 8 ill recommend Housing Department inspects those some kind of similar effort from the Housing Department theyll take time a year at least a year to gather all the data florida in the database and which ones have it and cho which building dont without that if you dont submit on our own we dont know if youre delinquent or not fire alarm upgrade to renovate, upgrade the existing fire alarms existing with seeping areas by july 1st, 2021, upon completion of 50 thousand or more so the initial impact will be that great on us because most are deadlines their inloaded the deadline what a e wait until the deadline and rush out to comply so with the fire Emergency Rooms there are 25 thousand Apartment Buildings how many have fire alarms we dont know an educated guess 78 thousand thats my educated guess what percentage are noncompliant roughly 50 percent so three or four thousand that require upgrades how that impacts us we have to get a designer and contractor to design a fire alarm submitted for approval through the plan section and receive the plans and get them approved and sent out to the field and test on the new fire alarm upgrades three or four thousand inspections each inspector doesnt one thousand inspections a year three or four inspectors in the field to address this well talk about realistically probably two plan receivers after 2021 after all compliance and submittals have come through it is up to date that load and requirement will drop off it will be taken care of and ill take any questions at this time. Thank you fire marshall all right. Are there any people in the greatly that would like to pack a Public Comment at this time all right. Public comment is closed. And go to any fellow commissioners gwen with Vice President commissioner Vice President cleaveland. Thank you madam president and thank you, chief fewer comments on this obviously in the preliminary stages of reviewing this legislation and youll have to probably get hard numbers to what the budgetary impacts to implement the legislation obviously a delta between the Apartment Buildings that have alarms and those that dont sea have alarms not working properly you have a big task thousands of the buildings that need to be inspected and do you have the resources to do that if youre saying you dont we need to make sure the supervisor understands and ask for additional budget funding for to do this very work this is proposed so thats my first question is wheres the money coming from and how much will it cost to do the job that the supervisor would like the Fire Department to do with regards to the residential fire inspections and get that money then we could implement this ordinance. Yes. Commissioner again, i will think that field intishgdz and thats 5 additional positions. What are the dollars. Id like refer to mark on that. Okay. The other thing worth noting were talking about fire alarms so the fire code drives fire code and the housing code were not part of that but a section that doesnt list in the fire code that alarm system and my question from the Housing Department what is an alarm system as opposed to a fire alarm system my understanding an alarm system which is not a fire a fire alarm is a control united i united with inputs and outputs and listed with the Fire Marshalls Office youll have systems that are hybrids or whatever you call them not falling there that definition of a fire alarm maybe and Burglar Alarm tied with the smoke alarm thats an fire alarm how do we address that those are questions well have to come to grips with and find solutions so it is going to be a complicated task obviously we have an issue we dont know exactly how many residential buildings have fire alarms and Smoke Detectors that will be a hercules attack to see in terms of the safety of the Residential Housing stock so to do that and do it right were going to need funding so certainly hope that. 25 thousand that we know of we got a list and comparing their list with our list total list of 25 thousand were comparing notes at this time but a survey of 25 thousand buildings ill agree that is challenging. I have a question in terms of the current annual inspectors the highrise building and residential inspection or not. In their one in the same were required to inspect all highrises in San Francisco where you have a highrises an rh2 that is considers that falls under having inspected the rh2 a two for one. A hundred is over what 7 stories and 75 feet we have roughly 6 hundred highrise and 33 in the the pipeline for inspection. Those improvements where annually inspected by the rest of the meddled family dwelling units dont get annually inspected. We do their falling under housing. I cant speak exactly to, you know, how up to date housing is what they do i can speak to fire. Housing will some of the data. Well, thats our next step we need to speak with housing. Is a task and i think the supervisor is right in saying that we need to know how safe or unsafe our reciprocal hornl it is a big task and big ask in order to g