Please silence all electronic devices. And can you please rise for the pledge of allegiance. America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Commissioner president loftus im not thank you, sergeant commissioner president loftus commissioner turman commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus commissioner mazzuco commissioner wong commissioner wong is in route and commissioner serlina have you a quorum and greg suhr the police chief and director the occ joyce hicks. Thank you sergeant id like to welcome everyone to the wednesday, may 4, 2016, Police Commission meeting i do have to start that meeting acknowledging the place were in as a city were here every once to do the work and there are still a lot of folks grieving and concerned and feeling like all the work were doing still isnt enough together is about continuing this work in actor and doing the work youll see the agenda from university of california, San Francisco to updates on collaborative reform to how were we keeping our streets save and the commission is doing the work and acknowledging there are a lot of folks still in pain and grieving and that for three and four no way just reaffirms why i do this service. Thank you lets go ahead and call line item. Commissioners for the record item 4a one the presentation of the First Quarter felt finding and recommendations n focusing is taken off the agenda. It is just the last report. Item one adoption of approval of the minutes minutes for april 6th and 20th of 2016. Colleagues you have in your packets minutes any correction to the minutes. Is there a motion . Second. Second. All in favor, say i. I. Public comment. Oh, any Public Comment on the minutes. Hernandez o hearing none, Public Comment is closed. That item passes southeast. Item 2 consent calendar receive and file action sfpd occ document protocol for 2016 a report from the occ that indicates compliance between the department and the occ the department i would note has done an excellent job in producing the documents any questions on this matter. Any Public Comment . Hearing none, Public Comment is closed. Another motion all in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That item passes sergeant, next line item. Item 3 Public Comment the public is welcome to address the commission on items not on tonights agenda but within the jurisdiction of the commission. Please direct your questions to the commission as a whole and not to individual commissioners or departments or occi personal. Two minutes. Okay please direct your questions to the commission as a whole and not to individual commissioners or departments or occi personal. Under Police Commission rules of order neither the Police Department, occi or commissioners are to respond to the questions Police Commission should enter into debates and please limit your comments to 3 minutes, please. 2 minutes. Thank you good evening and welcome. Commissioners ray hart for San Francisco open government. Two weeks ago when i was here he was pubically accused of violating the mayors policy on harassment either the president has not read those and didnt understand that is protected classes my comments didnt fall under this is nithsz or know and choose to federal and local accuse any in public on television of violating the mayors policy im owed an apology i didnt violate the mayors policy if i dont ill file a complaint under the sunshine ordinance for subpoena pressing Public Comment to pubically denigrated and undercut my standing as a member of the community and my right as a citizen to make Public Comment and inflame people against me i only said Something Like that that tilts on the bore which i read in dozens. Ill. Of literature. Im going to let you finish i want to hear everything you have to said. The same unique was used at me at the Library Commission and accused of violating the policy i didnt and end up in the estoppel with the Library Commission being heard on tape saying i know 12 people that could buyer him. So basically Public Comment in the city i have miff the mayor was found in violation of e racing his calendar i think was a great big deal. Part of any obligation to insure any comments made that could be often to a protected class and women are you make sure i indicate that is not the opinion of this commission so that anybody here an employer or member of the public feels weve infringed on their Voting Rights next item, please. Good afternoon commissioner president loftus and commissioners im former police compared a nature San Francisco born and raised and past the half century mark im here to say congratulations chief even this is difficult times to reiterate what i said Property Line and pubically said i watch colonel our the last 25 years and had the privilege of working with you in the Mission District i know how to much you care and watched you when you were the Commanding Office and gave gave the respective to our communities congratulate you 5 years have been difficult but i know we will see you complete your task as you had a job and will do that commissioners, i ask you utensil start to think outside the box understand that we all have those prerockets but now is one of the most difficult times in the history of the city and the Police Department the man that is sitting there with the stars cant do the job alone so you have prerequisites i understand that is like being in a little box but push against the sides and think outside the box never said i expect anyone to violate dlus but things you can do i wish you well and make sure this city whole and bring the trust and confidence in the Police Department. Thank you. Next speaker. Good evening ladies and gentlemen, and welcome. Good evening thank you for the smile and welcome peter yeah. I went to remind ive been here before the statement in the least of me was a reference to the animals and the School Systems and churches never teach the children that a long time people einstein and jesus and Martin Luther king and hundreds and hundreds of beacons because murder included the animals were in a nation full of turmoil in a city that is has turmoil is like a rose that is ready to bloom i stopped down and given they gave me a piece of my mind at the mission the protesters oh, it is about brown and black what go you know the corrupt people that maintain the power by the colored i said wake up i came down also to award chief suhr the captain cojack award for maintaining under adverse politics and tootsie role cops sent to the Mission Street soon and in regards to the stickerers i didnt hear of a fast people put on weight and drinking chocolate shakes. Everyone get two minutes at any rate well follow the rules youre next youre next go ahead finish. I really want to get a chance to hear from you and if you dont chanting . I dont get to hear from everyone. Hey guys i want to hear from etch of i want to hear from etch of you you want to hear from everyone we will adjourn and youll not get our time well adjourn and we will recess and youll not get your time do you want to talk to us do you want to talk to us two minutes no, no two minutes do you want to be heard. Do you want to be heard. And everyone gets two minutes even e everybody gets two minutes i want you guys help if you want to participate if you want to participate okay. Were in adjournment until we can do this not adjourn well take a recess and not to do the work were going to take a recess chanting we have an overflow room call the next line item. Shut up were attending a meeting well keep on going well resume Public Comment you cant hear me in our shouting people low resume Public Comment ill explain were going to make sure there is an overflow room we want to hear from everyone weve con it before hold on one second i want to make sure we hear from everybody sergeant an overflow room overflow room 416 is the overflow room and people can leave on this so many so i wanted to make sure we need to fix that thank you. So sergeant make sure the tv is on we want to make sure it is on hey i appreciate that we all need to keep your cool only so many seats not up to me not up to me. Okay. Guys. Listen up i got confirm the tv is on the room not up to me but the sheriff how many people can be about the room i want to hear from you not up to me. chanting it you want to lingo the overflow room or well have to have another recess and i dont get to hear from you. I want to hear if ever be two minutes at that time, you know how to goes. Two minutes at that time, and lets do it guys we can do this. chanting we can resume Public Comment they and then hear the congestion you can give up your seat and someone can come in give up our seat well make sure that people get to come in and take a seat thank you 4 15 4 15 all right. Sir youve given Public Comment. Oh, i am sorry you more time left. schant i dont get to hear from you. My request of the people that want to be heard we want to commend hear from you. chanting make sure we dont get to hear from anyone this is you can view Public Comment and give up your public seats thats the solution. chanting . How about lets do. Lets do. You guys want to be heard chanting . All right. Well come back to hear if everyone but we have to be able to hear from each speaker thank you lets try 24 one more time, sir. You have to continue to let those folks in okay. Firefighter chief suhr were in recess agawere in rw. Firefighte chief suhr well go first okay. Yeah. Okay. We commissioner president loftus were back in session thank you, everyone for your patience to be here to continue this work we were where we left off many general Public Comment well continue everybody gets two minutes ill welcome the next speaker. Good evening ladies and gentlemen, and welcome. Two minutes. Commissioners youve heard this before tasers are lethal weapons of torture in the face of corporate lies about the technical concussion device device that cant be repeated dpufrz repeated lies about tasers it operationally is fuel for the row nation theyve documented hundreds of people have been killed by tasers the Homeless Coalition presented to the Police Commission has evidence wherever a Police Department gets tasers that Police Department use of gun shootings increase dramatic and it is an circulation of violence in the Police Department a recent baltimore son in depth report which i gave you a copy officially for the record at the loose meeting and im going to quote from that you stated a first, this appeared in the march 16 a first Data Analysis of all tasers incidents in Maryland Police agencies are predominantly use those against suspects with no medal threat in hundreds of cases over a 3 year Period Police didnt follow widely accepted recommendations legal and policing experts worry about this is as increasing number of departments outfit for officers with stun guns a tasers used by Police Officers nine hundred and 4 times a day on average. Thank you, sir next speaker for general Public Comment good evening ms. Brown. Its been a long evening but as usual im here to or here to talk about my son Aubrey Abrakasa like to use the overhead any son Aubrey Abrakasa what was mshtd august 14, 2006, and let me make sure they got it i have something wrong with it does it its there. Oh. Thank you. Well start our time great. What happened to it was so big. Okay. Thats fine as i said before there is a 200 and 50,000 award issued by the Mayors Office for the to catch the perpetrators that murdered any son mothers day is coming sunday and im not feeling that good about it it will not be a mothers day for me i dont have any child my only son that should be bringing me some flowers i dont have that so im here still keeping his memory alive and case alive this is a cold case now as i said everyone knows who killed any son i bring up and carry the thing that was George Gascon he mentioned i know who killed my son the da knows who killed my son but nobody it doing anything about it these are the names theyre on my sons case and when George Gascon said he know,s who killed my son thomas han billion peculiar paris moffett and jason thomas and Anthony Hunter and Marcus Connor one is in jail i dont know if hes out i fight for my child but several unsolved homicides that is what im left with for mothers day my son laying on a generous and his moll mother standing over him 23 anyone asks me i want any son back thats what i want i know its not possible but thats what i want thank you ms. Brown if anyone has information about the murder of Aubrey Abrakasa an unanimous tip line 415 5754444 thank you and. Next speaker. General Public Comment. Good evening and welcome. Hello so its been a long time since i came to speak improvements you im nina parks born and raised in San Francisco and worked with you guys on any initiatives something im here to address the issue of the hunger sticker and the fact theres been no response probation officer get them on the agenda addressed some of the needs respect it is kind of hard to deny there is something very, very wrong structurally; right . Because even after we pass the general order that laid out the Community Values and partnerships 3 laid out training that laid out all those things we have more issue worse it started in the community that we even started to draft that the inning side station the dispatch and the officers that shot out the windows we were doing policing work so when the general orders like a meeting at the Caesar Chavez middle school and how were working towards that means training and communitybased training i came to educate the officer to to address the officers not only one responsible on one person with that note being put to bed and implemented you guys not having commerce at Balboa Park High School commissioner president loftus said the general orders say in their in enforcement by the Police Commission and there was no clarification i have it on video no clarification afterward for the community was left with so none knows what is what you dont say a consensus how we 130e7d to know who is supposed to hold a what of its the case none knows everyone has to go obviously we have a facility i didnt system no accountability what do we do. Two minutes. Everyone and everyone has two minutes. Okay. I hear you and if there the was a clarification ill talk about it im not beyond making a mistake ill followup on what that was and happy to clarify okay. Next speaker. Mr. Crew. Good evening and welcome. Thank you call your attention to first report ghirardelli principle on use of force this came out you should be proud San FranciscoPolice Department is is a significant notice principle 9 talks about the time and distance and not rush with force ill talked about that before on the table it says it requires officers to create distance and time to create a report were only a dogger to ourselves chief suhr is quoted talking about as a nobrainer easy to follow absolute rules and nobrainer said in d. C. A conference the chief Financial Officer executive and weve not had a situation where a person is only a danger to himself and 10 weeks later it happened the policy that was issued 4 times in 5 years a simple easy to follow nobrainer absolute rule was obviously not followed and ruled in a traechlg tragically loss of life the officers acted appropriately and said we need tasers ive been asking for transparency in the sense of speaking simple truth the way the chief did in washington, d. C. For the reports around the country a nobrainer easy to follow absolute rule what is said in d. C. To a group of Police Chiefs on a National Report needs to be said in San Francisco clapping. it is dangerous excuse me excuse me. It is dangerous for the confusion to remain out there officers read the newspapers they hear with the poa says ive been talking about the need for accountability we shouldnt be surprised those are happening. Ill save the discussion for the use of force policy. Next speaker. Any further general Public Comment. Good evening ladies and gentlemen, and welcome. Good evening and director hicks and chief suhr im barbara im a Police Officer accounta