Redefining formula retail use is proposed until november 19, 2015, i have no speaker cards any Public Comment on the two items proposed for continuance not seeing any, Public Comment is closed. Commissioner antonini before i hopeful for the continuance up wanted to note 1532 did we originally continue this. We continued it because of the late hour on the 17 to the first, the project sponsor is asking for one more week. That being said i propose to continue item one until october 8th and 10 to october 19th a thank you commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places under our to be routine and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. Item two case at jackson street conditional use authorization please note on september 17th after hearing the closing Public Comment it was an intent to disapprove and continue this matter item 3 on that concludes my report tool conditional use authorization there are no speaker cards. Any Public Comment on item the two items on the consent calendar not seeing any, smallpox. The second item on the consent calendar is not on the calendar i have here. Thats a miss print calendar new ones are being printed up missing a couple of pages and on jackson street took it off content we have to disapprove and see in the project manager is willing to move this was that the report. Yeah. Yeah. My second question on the content would be to disapprove the project. Okay. Was this the motion. Yeah. Motion to disapprove dot street and motion to approve portola avenue. Second. Thank you, commissioners on that motion to disapprove item 2. Commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you under commission matters adaptation of draft minutes of the joint hearing of september and the regular hearing of september 17th. Is there a motion . Move. Im sorry Public Comment on the draft minutes not seeing any, Public Comment is closed. So moved. On that motion to adopt the minutes commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously and places you on item 5 commissioner questions or comments. Commissioner hillis. So last week, we talked about the article in sf magazine commissioner moore and director ram brought it up ive not had a chance to read it but now i see interesting points brought up in the article i want to take issue with many of the comments commissioner moore brought up on the Planning Department staff i disagree with those comments especially the comments around staff i come to this commission from a unique prospective i worked with the commission 15 years before this commissions for 3 and had the privilege of working with the Planning Department staff i want to commend them on the work they do it is quite a feat what the staff does if i look at the last 3 years that ive been on the commission the issues weve tackled weve not gotten along but at the urging and is leadership of the staff inlaw units and major neighborhood in the central selma and increases the descended and shortterm rentals, the urban forestry and transit and formula retail and diverse those are huge issues you know have had constituents on both sides not winners e. R. Losing those are controversial projects that staff as weighed in and done a noble job i know from sitting on the citywide they dont often get the credit quote unquote the Ribbon Cutting theyre not the staff doing it i appreciate their efforts and thats not to say there are not still big issues certainly we hear that every week of affordability and gentrification but i think solutions will come the same way to the solution through important policy changes and debates and weve talked about them the small side acquisitions and increasing the revenues for affordability and the inclusionary percentages and reform i think we have looked to staff to help guide us and the board to them so i appreciate all your work and think were the ernest very of most Planning Department in the city. Commissioner richards. A couple of things in todays paper an article of the future of driving and whether youve had a chance to read it it in terms of i guess some of the projects we have coming brother us we have projects designed for the way we drive today but not the way driving will be tomorrow i want to make sure that lens is being looked at one of the projects with the director had additional requests for parking in todays world that mannered make sense i got from the gi f Team Information around the consensus when we have those cases theyre asking for the parking data i asked to to be forwarded that is information youll take on one project for that view but really interesting article in terms of the cars and people dont have a car anywhere thanks. Commissioner antonini. In regards to have the article in sf i read it it brings up a lot of interesting challenges for the city and the commission and the staff as mentioned in the various comments from all the constraints not just commissioner moore i would take exception in my own case i does not im completely independent i amount my mind on issues i always have i dont care which way opinion it. Commissioner johnson. Thanks very much im not going to appeal pile on the San Francisco magazine i agree with commissioner hillis well get to read articles and want to say and look at it more architecture and a lot of policy planning and forward thinking about the city we are with the commissions and ill get to the staff commissioners are all very professionally capable and work hard with the commission we bring something relevant to wasnt we do in terms of staff you guys are like one of the hardest working go groups allison park ive been on the Planning Department for one year but ive seen around the country what i observed is not as thoughtful and hardworking cities dont have the same issues you guys do a fantastic job i hope that the commissioners will be doing the same i wanted to say a couple of things commissioner richards brought up on interesting point to add on to what how were thinking about our infrastructure for cars today may not match what were see in the near future in an article city planning what is the biggest change that uber and share Ride Companies and the selfdrive Car Technology bring to the city what do you hope to be your impact he said i hope theres no such things as a a parking lot in a parking building so certainly i think we need to be more forward thinking about that as we look at it we have more projects in valencia street and others are that are looking at increased parking someone it is moving into a building in less than a generation we need to be thinking about in drop out active reuse for the infrastructure so for the next decade something after that not necessary well have all the empty spaces on the ground floor and late thing read an article in sunday times and cant pull it up in new york city they passed legislation to protect tenants against landowner that use necessary construction as a way to get tenants to move out in new york city theyre talking about the building inspection beginning to enforce the line up on the screen side of the room like rehab the common areas a rentcontrolled tenants will mount move out were not focusing on but highlighting where legislators in this case the new York City Council are thinking about those issues as a way to maintain Affordable Housing in the city and culture and diversity in their city last week we were talking about owner moveins and other ways to protect evictions as a safety get net it struck me as new york city is taking steps i thought that was interesting. You can add on to the selfdriving cars it is something commissioner johnson not to bring up a dialogue but comes back to what happens to garages, etc. Is it is interesting to have a Forum Discussion of leadership with cars and traffic to see where we can forecast ourselves in the next 10 to 15 years and picking up the San FranciscoMagazine Article i want to be respectful to any of us who have a right to share that is important in those leadership roles not to call out a department or starch especially public we have the privilege of representing the city and all aspects of the city ensue an opportunity to tammy take it you been u up with the director and staff hopefully in the future those things will, done privately and not calling people out i want to thank the staff it is a tough decade in San Francisco some call the best of time and some the worst i hope those comments are brought to light but bring everyone to fix the problems and not separate them. Commissioner moore. I want to acknowledge commissioner hillis for precisely summarizing the strength of the department and this stands exceptional not only in the city and country im one of the people that have the future to speak about the strengths in terms of urban design nationally and internationally and my praise didnt fall short im basically in participating for the next the last 10 years and it is my intent to continue to support and future urban design in this department as a colleague and supporter and do it as a concrete in the form appropriate to the role i hold as a Planning Commissioner my comments in a discussion about Public Interest values have been taken out of context from a long conversation about a subject matter that is looking back as the essence of the urban design plans created in the 70s and early 80s a look back in order to have a frame of conversation about architecture is it is difficult to frame it then. It was more than that there was no intent to hurt or slander anyone i reilly repeat my comments from last week the department and doak director and everyone has my support as this commission who works with a lot of energy and diligence to tackle the issues. Commissioner richards. One thing i forgot to mention couple of on commissioner president fongs comments on the best and worse decade if you have not watched the dock r documentary for San Francisco it is a sobering look at San Francisco today and what were faced with in terms of balancing the growth and keeping the city the soul of the city i recommend that on hbo thank you. Commissioners, if theres nothing further we wyoming can move on to department matters. Good afternoon, commissioners one announcement regarding a piece that is noted in our written directors report about the bayshore study involved that the mta and the office of Economic Workforce Development and ocii e occ a multiply or multiple study with san mateo the note around Visitacion Valley and the caltrain station and the at the end of the muni line to see if there are option for the Transit Service if area including the roefrj of the caltrans and not the extension of the muni like that to serve Visitacion Valley the shackling and no more than part find brisbane it is that kind of conjecture, if you will, in the south east side of the city for your and the Public Benefit an open house from 6 to 8 at the Visitacion Valley library this is at 201 leeland. Thank you that concludes my presentation. Commissioner moore can i ask director ram is that a possibility for you to start leadership in bringing mta and abag together it is obviously they have an ability to talk about their growth at the station you talked about last week the difficulties and merging all the desire to merger the large and smaller agencies that is a perfect subject to broaden the discussion including this. Sure by county excuse me. There are because it is by county there are multiple agencies involved including mtc and their staff and mta and the Transportation Authority and brisbane and a series of people at the table an important kind of multi agency effort. Commissioners, if theres nothing further well move on to the past event and board of supervisors no brotherhoods. Good afternoon, commissioners at t park Planning Department staff at the this last weeks Land Use Commission we heard the establishment of the citywide sustainability fee the Planning Commission heard this on september 10th and voted to removed approval at the land use they heard presentations by the staff and director ram and Public Comment they debated the plans in particular the feasibility of raising the percentage to 33 percent and requiring the fees to hospitals that require the master plan after the discussion there was a consensus those need more research so the commission continued the item at the full board the dagget street rerezoning of on open space passed its second reading and the inclusionary housing bought up by supervisor kim passed it First Reading and a appeal on the negative declaration for the disposal and hallway wood in the county it is an agreement between the city and ecology for the solid waste the results is the trusting truck trips in Alameda County can go to say h the hay wood road with the physical impacts of the truck route is 2 million longer and it is brought up bye bye the Orderly Growth Committee several of the public spoke and the investment of viable with the volume of waste some supervisors expressed the view any concerns the haywood landfill it was approved and at the end it was voted 11 to zero with the negative declaration and a motion by supervisor wiener and seconded by supervisor campos there were who introduction of note this week ago the first one the zimmermann extension on the mergers in the quatro special use sponsored by the supervisor campos and the interim prohibition on the mergers greater than 7 hundred and 9 grow square feet eased the quatro special use district and the Affordable HousingProgram Sports by the mayor was introduced it received a lot of press and that concludes my remarks thank you. And the board of appeals didnt meet but back in action if next week and the Historic Preservation commission doesnt meet that places the commission on number 8 the housing balancing report. Good afternoon commissioner president fong and commissions im teresa senior planner with the citywide policy Planning Section im here to introduce the housing balance report this is for your information no action required what is the housing balance report in april of this year, the board of supervisors approved ordinance 531 to add section 1013 to the planning code this new code directs the Planning Commission to report the balance two market rate housing and new Affordable Housing production the housing balance is the proposition of all new affordable units to the total number of the net new Housing Units over 10 year housing Balance Period this ordinance requires a bye annual ill be talking the the second report submitted last month it covers the quarter of 2005 to the Second Quarter of 2015 we submitted did first in july and the second in september and our schedule for a hearing before the board of supervisors as well what are the housing balance targets one stated goal of the ordinances to make sure that the data on Affordable Housing tathsd citywide within neighborhoods informs the approval process for the new Housing Development to remind the commissioners are 3 tacks each with its own monitoring and reporting requirements the Housing Element announced bit little state to be updated per day sets a goal of 28 thousand new unit built between 2015 and 2012 it is commonly called the area goals that stands for the Housing Needs allocation 87 percent should be available to lowerincome and other households with an annual report for the citys progress to the did depth of housing and Economy Development it is bans the production goals called the residential piecemeal dashboard prop c r prop k passed in 2014 set the goal this is the goal from the hours balance report will be aiming for mayor ed lee thirty thousand by 2020 set a goal of thirty thousand units the Mayors Office of housing and Community Development prepares a dashboard highlighting towards this goal what has been the 10 year historic Affordable Housing production trend . Affordable housing made up of thirty percent of net new units built in the last 10 years this is from quarter 3